Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2011.14783 · New Journal of Physics

Many-body effects and quantum fluctuations for discrete time crystals in Bose–Einstein condensates

Jia Wang, Peter Hannaford, Bryan J. Dalton

Published Feb 26, 2021• 23 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract We present a fully comprehensive multi-mode quantum treatment based on the truncated Wigner approximation (TWA) to study many-body effects and effects of quantum fluctuations on the formation of a discrete time crystal (DTC) in a Bose–Einstein condensate (BEC) bouncing resonantly on a periodically driven atom mirror. Zero-range contact interactions between the bosonic atoms are assumed. Our theoretical approach avoids the restrictions both of mean-field theory, where all bosons are assumed to remain in a single mode, and of time-dependent Bogoliubov theory, which assumes boson depletion from the condensate mode is small. We show that the mean-field and time-dependent Bogoliubov approaches can be derived as approximations to the TWA treatment. Differing initial conditions, such as a finite temperature BEC, can also be treated. For realistic initial conditions corresponding to a harmonic trap condensate mode function, our TWA calculations performed for period-doubling agree broadly with recent mean-field calculations for times out to at least 2000 mirror oscillations, except at interaction strengths very close to the threshold value for DTC formation where the position probability density differs significantly from that determined from mean-field theory. For typical attractive interaction strengths above the threshold value for DTC formation and for the chosen trap and driving parameters, the TWA calculations indicate a quantum depletion due to quantum many-body fluctuations of less than about two atoms out of a total of 600 atoms at times corresponding to 2000 mirror oscillations, in agreement with time-dependent Bogoliubov theory calculations. On the other hand, for interaction strengths very close to the threshold value for DTC formation, the TWA calculations predict a large quantum depletion—as high as about 260 atoms out of 600. We also show that the mean energy per particle of the DTC does not increase significantly for times out to at least 2000 mirror oscillations and typically oscillates around an average value close to its initial value; so TWA theory predicts the absence of thermalisation. Finally, we find that the dynamical behaviour of our system is largely independent of whether the boson–boson interaction is attractive or repulsive, and that it is possible to create a stable DTC based on repulsive interactions.

DOI
10.1088/1367-2630/abea45

Related papers

Discrete time crystals in Bose-Einstein condensates and the symmetry-breaking edge in a simple two-mode theory

Jia Wang, Krzysztof Sacha, Peter Hannaford +1 more

Discrete time crystals (DTCs) refer to a novel many-body steady state that spontaneously breaks the discrete time-translational symmetry in a periodically driven quantum system. Here, we study DTCs in a Bose-Einstein condensate bouncing resonantly on an oscillating mirror, using a two-mode model derived from a standard quantum field theory. We investigate the validity of this model and apply it to study the long-time behavior of our system. A wide variety of initial states based on two Wannier modes are considered. We find that in previous studies the investigated phenomena in the evolution time window ($⪅2000$ driving periods) are actually ``short-time'' transient behavior though DTC formation signaled by the subharmonic responses is still shown if the interboson interaction is strong enough. After a much longer (about 20 times) evolution time, initial states with no ``long-range'' correlations relax to a steady state, where time-symmetry breaking can be unambiguously defined. Quantum revivals also eventually occur. This long-time behavior can be understood via the many-body Floquet quasieigenenergy spectrum of the two-mode model. A symmetry-breaking edge for DTC formation appears in the spectrum for strong enough interaction, where all quasieigenstates below the edge are symmetry breaking while those above the edge are symmetric. The late-time steady state's time-translational symmetry depends solely on whether the initial energy is above or below the symmetry-breaking edge. A phase diagram showing regions of symmetry-broken and symmetric phases for differing initial energies and interaction strengths is presented. We find that, according to this two-mode model, the discrete time crystal survives for times out to at least $250\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}000$ driving periods.

arXiv:2106.02219•Physical Review A•Nov 29, 2021•11 citations

Creating big time crystals with ultracold atoms

Krzysztof Giergiel, Tien Tran, Ali Zaheer +4 more

Abstract We investigate the size of discrete time crystals s (ratio of response period to driving period) that can be created for a Bose–Einstein condensate (BEC) bouncing resonantly on an oscillating mirror. We find that time crystals can be created with sizes in the range s ≈ 20–100 and that such big time crystals are easier to realize experimentally than a period-doubling (s=2) time crystal because they require either a larger drop height or a smaller number of bounces on the mirror. We also investigate the effects of having a realistic soft Gaussian potential mirror for the bouncing BEC, such as that produced by a repulsive light-sheet, which is found to make the experiment easier to implement than a hard-wall potential mirror. Finally, we discuss the choice of atomic system for creating time crystals based on a bouncing BEC and present an experimental protocol for realizing big time crystals. Such big time crystals provide a flexible platform for investigating a broad range of non-trivial condensed matter phenomena in the time domain.

arXiv:2004.00755•New Journal of Physics•Jul 8, 2020•55 citations

Fate of Discrete Time Crystals in Finite-Size Cavity QED Systems

Haimi Nguyen, David R. Reichman

It has been shown that Discrete Time Crystal (DTC) behavior may arise in the periodically driven, open Dicke model in the thermodynamic limit ($N \rightarrow \infty$). In this work, we demonstrate that finite $N$ non-mean-field fluctuations in this model can lead to decay rates and amplitudes of transient DTCs that display a non-trivial non-monotonic behavior with an increasing number of atoms. We show that the second-order cumulant expansion fails to capture the finite-size dynamics, while a stochastic version of the Truncated Wigner Approximation (TWA) is remarkably accurate, particularly in the large atom ensemble limit. Using the TWA and the Monte Carlo Wave Function (MCWF) approach, we identify three distinct dynamical regimes of transient DTC behavior in the finite-size Dicke model. We outline the mechanism behind the non-monotonic finite size dynamical decay of DTC order and discuss the implications for experiments performed on finite-sized atomic assemblies.

quant-pharXiv:2610.27589•Oct 21, 2026•0 citations

Condensed matter physics in big discrete time crystals

Peter Hannaford, Krzysztof Sacha

Abstract We review the application of discrete time crystals created in a Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) of ultracold atoms bouncing resonantly on an oscillating atom mirror to the investigation of condensed matter phenomena in the time dimension. Such a bouncing BEC system can exhibit dramatic breaking of time-translation symmetry, allowing the creation of discrete time crystals having up to about 100 temporal lattice sites and suitable for hosting a broad range of temporal condensed matter phenomena. We first consider single-particle condensed matter phenomena in the time dimension which include Anderson localization due to temporal disorder, topological time crystals, and quasi-crystal structures in time. We then discuss many-body temporal condensed matter phenomena including Mott insulator phases in time, many-body localization in time, many-body topological time crystals and time crystals having long-range exotic interactions. We also discuss the construction of two (or three) dimensional time lattices, involving the bouncing of a BEC between two (or three) orthogonal oscillating mirrors and between two oscillating mirrors oriented at 45∘. The latter configuration supports a versatile Möbius strip geometry which can host a variety of two-dimensional time lattices including a honeycomb time lattice and a Lieb square time lattice. Finally, we discuss the construction of a six-dimensional time-space lattice based on periodically driven BECs trapped in a three-dimensional optical lattice.

arXiv:2202.05544•AAPPS bulletin•May 1, 2022•24 citations

Phase diagram and optimal control for n-tupling discrete time crystal

Arkadiusz Kuroś, Rick Mukherjee, Weronika Golletz +4 more

Abstract A remarkable consequence of spontaneously breaking the time translational symmetry in a system, is the emergence of time crystals. In periodically driven systems, discrete time crystals (DTC) can be realized which have a periodicity that is n times the driving period. However, all of the experimental observations have been performed for period-doubling and period-tripling DTC. Novel physics can arise by simulating many-body physics in the time domain, which would require a genuine realisation of the n-tupling DTC. A system of ultra-cold bosonic atoms bouncing resonantly on an oscillating mirror is one of the models that can realise large period DTC. The preparation of DTC demands control in creating the initial distribution of the ultra-cold bosonic atoms along with the mirror frequency. In this work, we demonstrate that such DTC is robust against perturbations to the initial distribution of atoms. We show how Bayesian methods can be used to enhance control in the preparation of the initial state as well as to efficiently calculate the phase diagram for such a model. Moreover, we examine the stability of DTCs by analyzing quantum many-body fluctuations and show that they do not reveal signatures of heating.

arXiv:2004.14982•New Journal of Physics•Aug 18, 2020•37 citations

Classical and quantum dynamics of pulsating instability in a Bose-Einstein condensate in an optical lattice

Uttam Shrestha

We study the dynamics of a Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) in a one dimensional optical lattice in the limit of weak atom-atom interactions. Numerically we find that a BEC may develop a pulsating instability in which atoms nearly periodically collect themselves into a pulse and subsequently disperse back into the initial homogeneous state. A qualitative explanation of the quasi-periodic behavior is given by drawing an analogy with a double-well system. In an extension we introduce quantum effects approximately within Truncated Wigner Approximation (TWA). In pure classical mean field theory the condensate shows an undamped pulsating instability, whereas we have observed a damping in the oscillation when we average over many stochastic realizations.

arXiv:0810.4199•Oct 23, 2008•0 citations
Abstract We present a fully comprehensive multi-mode quantum treatment based on the truncated Wigner approximation (TWA) to study many-body effects and effects of quantum fluctuations on the formation of a discrete time crystal (DTC) in a Bose–Einstein condensate (BEC) bouncing resonantly on a periodically driven atom mirror. Zero-range contact interactions between the bosonic atoms are assumed. Our theoretical approach avoids the restrictions both of mean-field theory, where all bosons are assumed to remain in a single mode, and of time-dependent Bogoliubov theory, which assumes boson depletion from the condensate mode is small. We show that the mean-field and time-dependent Bogoliubov approaches can be derived as approximations to the TWA treatment. Differing initial conditions, such as a finite temperature BEC, can also be treated. For realistic initial conditions corresponding to a harmonic trap condensate mode function, our TWA calculations performed for period-doubling agree broadly with recent mean-field calculations for times out to at least 2000 mirror oscillations, except at interaction strengths very close to the threshold value for DTC formation where the position probability density differs significantly from that determined from mean-field theory. For typical attractive interaction strengths above the threshold value for DTC formation and for the chosen trap and driving parameters, the TWA calculations indicate a quantum depletion due to quantum many-body fluctuations of less than about two atoms out of a total of 600 atoms at times corresponding to 2000 mirror oscillations, in agreement with time-dependent Bogoliubov theory calculations. On the other hand, for interaction strengths very close to the threshold value for DTC formation, the TWA calculations predict a large quantum depletion—as high as about 260 atoms out of 600. We also show that the mean energy per particle of the DTC does not increase significantly for times out to at least 2000 mirror oscillations and typically oscillates around an average value close to its initial value; so TWA theory predicts the absence of thermalisation. Finally, we find that the dynamical behaviour of our system is largely independent of whether the boson–boson interaction is attractive or repulsive, and that it is possible to create a stable DTC based on repulsive interactions.
Discrete time crystals (DTCs) refer to a novel many-body steady state that spontaneously breaks the discrete time-translational symmetry in a periodically driven quantum system. Here, we study DTCs in a Bose-Einstein condensate bouncing resonantly on an oscillating mirror, using a two-mode model derived from a standard quantum field theory. We investigate the validity of this model and apply it to study the long-time behavior of our system. A wide variety of initial states based on two Wannier modes are considered. We find that in previous studies the investigated phenomena in the evolution time window (⪅2000⪅2000⪅2000 driving periods) are actually ``short-time'' transient behavior though DTC formation signaled by the subharmonic responses is still shown if the interboson interaction is strong enough. After a much longer (about 20 times) evolution time, initial states with no ``long-range'' correlations relax to a steady state, where time-symmetry breaking can be unambiguously defined. Quantum revivals also eventually occur. This long-time behavior can be understood via the many-body Floquet quasieigenenergy spectrum of the two-mode model. A symmetry-breaking edge for DTC formation appears in the spectrum for strong enough interaction, where all quasieigenstates below the edge are symmetry breaking while those above the edge are symmetric. The late-time steady state's time-translational symmetry depends solely on whether the initial energy is above or below the symmetry-breaking edge. A phase diagram showing regions of symmetry-broken and symmetric phases for differing initial energies and interaction strengths is presented. We find that, according to this two-mode model, the discrete time crystal survives for times out to at least 250000250\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}000250000 driving periods.
Abstract We investigate the size of discrete time crystals s (ratio of response period to driving period) that can be created for a Bose–Einstein condensate (BEC) bouncing resonantly on an oscillating mirror. We find that time crystals can be created with sizes in the range s ≈ 20–100 and that such big time crystals are easier to realize experimentally than a period-doubling (s=2) time crystal because they require either a larger drop height or a smaller number of bounces on the mirror. We also investigate the effects of having a realistic soft Gaussian potential mirror for the bouncing BEC, such as that produced by a repulsive light-sheet, which is found to make the experiment easier to implement than a hard-wall potential mirror. Finally, we discuss the choice of atomic system for creating time crystals based on a bouncing BEC and present an experimental protocol for realizing big time crystals. Such big time crystals provide a flexible platform for investigating a broad range of non-trivial condensed matter phenomena in the time domain.
It has been shown that Discrete Time Crystal (DTC) behavior may arise in the periodically driven, open Dicke model in the thermodynamic limit (N→∞N \rightarrow \inftyN→∞). In this work, we demonstrate that finite NNN non-mean-field fluctuations in this model can lead to decay rates and amplitudes of transient DTCs that display a non-trivial non-monotonic behavior with an increasing number of atoms. We show that the second-order cumulant expansion fails to capture the finite-size dynamics, while a stochastic version of the Truncated Wigner Approximation (TWA) is remarkably accurate, particularly in the large atom ensemble limit. Using the TWA and the Monte Carlo Wave Function (MCWF) approach, we identify three distinct dynamical regimes of transient DTC behavior in the finite-size Dicke model. We outline the mechanism behind the non-monotonic finite size dynamical decay of DTC order and discuss the implications for experiments performed on finite-sized atomic assemblies.
Abstract We review the application of discrete time crystals created in a Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) of ultracold atoms bouncing resonantly on an oscillating atom mirror to the investigation of condensed matter phenomena in the time dimension. Such a bouncing BEC system can exhibit dramatic breaking of time-translation symmetry, allowing the creation of discrete time crystals having up to about 100 temporal lattice sites and suitable for hosting a broad range of temporal condensed matter phenomena. We first consider single-particle condensed matter phenomena in the time dimension which include Anderson localization due to temporal disorder, topological time crystals, and quasi-crystal structures in time. We then discuss many-body temporal condensed matter phenomena including Mott insulator phases in time, many-body localization in time, many-body topological time crystals and time crystals having long-range exotic interactions. We also discuss the construction of two (or three) dimensional time lattices, involving the bouncing of a BEC between two (or three) orthogonal oscillating mirrors and between two oscillating mirrors oriented at 45∘. The latter configuration supports a versatile Möbius strip geometry which can host a variety of two-dimensional time lattices including a honeycomb time lattice and a Lieb square time lattice. Finally, we discuss the construction of a six-dimensional time-space lattice based on periodically driven BECs trapped in a three-dimensional optical lattice.
Abstract A remarkable consequence of spontaneously breaking the time translational symmetry in a system, is the emergence of time crystals. In periodically driven systems, discrete time crystals (DTC) can be realized which have a periodicity that is n times the driving period. However, all of the experimental observations have been performed for period-doubling and period-tripling DTC. Novel physics can arise by simulating many-body physics in the time domain, which would require a genuine realisation of the n-tupling DTC. A system of ultra-cold bosonic atoms bouncing resonantly on an oscillating mirror is one of the models that can realise large period DTC. The preparation of DTC demands control in creating the initial distribution of the ultra-cold bosonic atoms along with the mirror frequency. In this work, we demonstrate that such DTC is robust against perturbations to the initial distribution of atoms. We show how Bayesian methods can be used to enhance control in the preparation of the initial state as well as to efficiently calculate the phase diagram for such a model. Moreover, we examine the stability of DTCs by analyzing quantum many-body fluctuations and show that they do not reveal signatures of heating.
We study the dynamics of a Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) in a one dimensional optical lattice in the limit of weak atom-atom interactions. Numerically we find that a BEC may develop a pulsating instability in which atoms nearly periodically collect themselves into a pulse and subsequently disperse back into the initial homogeneous state. A qualitative explanation of the quasi-periodic behavior is given by drawing an analogy with a double-well system. In an extension we introduce quantum effects approximately within Truncated Wigner Approximation (TWA). In pure classical mean field theory the condensate shows an undamped pulsating instability, whereas we have observed a damping in the oscillation when we average over many stochastic realizations.