Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.27098

A group theoretic calculation of multi-invariants of some stabilizer states

Bartlomiej Czech, Yichen Feng, Jonathan Harper, Xin-Xiang Ju

hep-thquant-phSubmitted Oct 19, 2026• Announced Oct 21, 2026• 2 citations• Revised Oct 21, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Oct 19, 2026v2 · Oct 21, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study multi-invariants---a multi-partite generalization of Renyi entropies---of simple stabilizer states, for an arbitrary replica symmetry group. We develop a group theoretic technique for evaluating such invariants, which operates on the replica group and involves counting intersections among its cosets. Our techniques streamline the calculations of multi-invariants for graph states with two GHZ-like nodes and for certain generalizations thereof. The methodology developed here is most suitable when the quantum state is simple but flexibility over the replica group is desired.

AI Summary

The paper asks how to evaluate multipartite local-unitary invariants defined by contracting multiple copies of a pure state and its conjugate, while allowing flexibility in the replica symmetry group. It studies GHZ states and “core-2” stabilizer states: two repetition-encoded qubits coupled by a controlled-$Z$ gate, including the four-qubit cluster state. For connected GHZ contractions using $s$ ket copies, the invariant is $d^{1-s}$. For core-2 states, contractions are recast as signed colorings of a replica tessellation. Binary labels are constant on cosets of two subgroups $\hat H_1,\hat H_2$ of the extended replica group $\hat G$. Defining $A$ by the parity of coset-intersection sizes reduces the coloring sum to a bilinear sum over $\mathbb F_2$, giving $\mathcal E=2^{-2s+[\hat G:\hat H_1]+[\hat G:\hat H_2]-\operatorname{rank}_{\mathbb F_2}A}$. Group quotients simplify the rank calculation. For the four-qubit cluster state, the resulting Rényi multi-entropy is $S_n^{(4)}=(2+n^{-2})\log 2$, with the stated canonical continuation giving $3\log 2$ as $n\to1$. More generally, core-2 states with block sizes $p,q\ge2$ give $(p+q-1)\log 2$ in that limit. A twelve-replica, genus-two contraction evaluates to $2^{-15}$ for the cluster state and $2^{-14}$ after swapping two parties. The method assumes a free, transitive replica-group action and exploits sparse wavefunctions with a single bilinear phase. Its stated scope is therefore narrow in states, although flexible in replica groups; broader stabilizer-state calculations and possible extensions to symmetry-protected topological states are left to separate or future work.

Little sign of AI-generated textIncrementalStrong assumptionsPossible error

Central claim may not hold: The claimed arbitrary-replica-group scope relies on a freely acting ket–bra reflection extension that need not exist for contraction patterns satisfying the paper’s stated regularity assumptions. The displayed equality between merged-party and standard finer-party Rényi multi-entropies is contradicted by the paper’s core-2_{2+2} state, whose merged and unmerged values are respectively 2 log 2 and (2+1/n²) log 2.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
28 pages, 11 figures. v2: references updated

Related papers

Multi-invariants in stabilizer states

Sriram Akella, Abhijit Gadde, Jay Pandey

Multipartite entanglement is a natural generalization of bipartite entanglement, but is relatively poorly understood. In this paper, we develop tools to calculate a class of multipartite entanglement measures - known as multi-invariants - for stabilizer states. We give an efficient numerical algorithm that computes multi-invariants for stabilizer states. For tripartite stabilizer states, we also obtain an explicit formula for any multi-invariant using the GHZ-extraction theorem. We then present a counting argument that calculates any Coxeter multi-invariant of a q-partite stabilizer state. We conjecture a closed form expression for the same. We uncover hints of an interesting connection between multi-invariants, stabilizer states and topology. We show how our formulas are further simplified for a restricted class of stabilizer states that appear as ground states of interesting models like the toric code and the X-cube model.

quant-pharXiv:2601.16258•Jan 26, 2026•6 citations

Rényi Multi-entropy for Stabilizer States: A Finite Field Gauss Sum Problem

Bartłomiej Czech, Yichen Feng, Jonathan Harper +2 more

Rényi multi-entropy probes multi-partite structure beyond bipartite spectra, but its behavior in general quantum states and the entanglement structure it captures remain poorly understood. We develop a finite field Gauss sum framework for calculating it in stabilizer states. Within this framework, the replica contraction reduces to a quadratic Gauss sum if and only if the state is locally unitarily equivalent to a stabilizer state. We obtain analytic expressions for the Rényi multi-entropy of all tree graph states and large families of loop graph states. In contrast to their flat bipartite Rényi spectra, stabilizer states generically have nonflat Rényi multi-entropy spectra.

arXiv:2610.26814•Oct 19, 2026•3 citations

Rényi multi-entropy of graph states and the $n -> 1$ limit

Sriram Akella, Abhijit Gadde

Rényi multi-entropy extends the Rényi entropy to pure states of more than two parties. It is defined by a replica contraction at integer replica number $n$, and the multi-entropy is its $n\to1$ limit. In holography this limit is conjectured to compute the area of a minimal soap-film web in the bulk. Understanding multi-entropy for general states, however, is harder. Unlike the bipartite case, the replica contraction is not a moment of a density matrix, and the continuation to $n=1$ has to be found by other means. We study this problem for qubit graph states. We show that at every odd $n$ the contraction equals $2^{-k/2}$, where $k$ is a sum of ranks of matrices over a finite field, one row and one column per qubit. We define a class of graphs that we call collision-controlled, for which the rank sum is a polynomial in $n$. This class includes graphs without even cycles and all complete bipartite graphs. The natural polynomial $n \to 1$ continuation is a finite sum over partitions of the parties. While the Rényi multi-entropy is non-increasing under single-qubit Pauli measurements at every odd integer $n>1$, the continuation to $n=1$ is not. A $Z$ measurement on one qubit of an odd ring with $2r + 1 \geq 7$ qubits raises it from $(r+1)\log 2$ to $(2r-1) \log 2$. Thus the continuation is not an entanglement monotone.

quant-pharXiv:2610.27080•Oct 21, 2026•1 citation

Genuine multientropy, dihedral invariants, and Lifshitz theory

Clément Berthière, Paul Gaudin

Multi-invariants are local-unitary invariants of state replicas introduced as potential probes of multipartite entanglement and correlations in quantum many-body systems. In this paper, we investigate two multi-invariants for tripartite pure states, namely multientropy and dihedral invariant. We compute the (genuine) multientropy for Lifshitz ground states and obtain its analytical continuation to noninteger values of Rényi index. We show that the genuine multientropy can be expressed in terms of mutual information and logarithmic negativity, a relation that also holds for stabilizer states. For general tripartite pure states, we demonstrate that dihedral invariants are related to Rényi reflected entropies. In particular, we show that the dihedral permutations of replicas are equivalent to the reflected construction, or alternatively to the realignment of density matrices.

arXiv:2509.00593•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jan 14, 2026•9 citations

Multi-invariants and bulk replica symmetry

Abhijit Gadde, Jonathan Harper, Vineeth Krishna

A bstract In this paper, we analyze the question of replica symmetry in the bulk for multi-partite entanglement measures in the vacuum state of two dimensional holographic CFTs. We first define a class of multi-partite local unitary invariants, multi-invariants , with a given replica symmetry that acts freely and transitively on the replicas. We look for a subclass of measures such that the dual bulk geometry also preserves replica symmetry. We obtain the most general solution to this problem if we require the bulk to preserve replica symmetry for general configurations of the regions. Orbifolding the bulk solution with the replica symmetry gives us a bulk geometry with a network of conical singularities. Our approach makes it clear that there are infinitely many infinitely large families of multi-invariants such that each family evaluates identically on the holographic state. Geometrically, these are equalities involving volumes of handlebodies, possibly of different genus, at particular points in the moduli space. In certain cases, we check our bulk computation with an explicit calculation in CFT. Finally we comment on the generalization to higher dimension.

arXiv:2411.00935•Journal of High Energy Physics•Jun 12, 2025•31 citations

GHZ extraction yield for multipartite stabilizer states

Sergey B. Bravyi, David A. Fattal, Daniel Gottesman

Let ∣Ψ⟩ be an arbitrary stabilizer state distributed between three remote parties, such that each party holds several qubits. Let S be a stabilizer group of ∣Ψ⟩. We show that ∣Ψ⟩ can be converted by local unitaries into a collection of singlets, GHZ states, and local one-qubit states. The numbers of singlets and GHZs are determined by dimensions of certain subgroups of S. For an arbitrary number of parties m we find a formula for the maximal number of m-partite GHZ states that can be extracted from ∣Ψ⟩ by local unitaries. A connection with earlier introduced measures of multipartite correlations is made. An example of an undecomposable four-party stabilizer state with more than one qubit per party is given. These results are derived from a general theoretical framework that allows one to study interconversion of multipartite stabilizer states by local Clifford group operators. As a simple application, we study three-party entanglement in two-dimensional lattice models that can be exactly solved by the stabilizer formalism.

arXiv:quant-ph/0504208•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jun 1, 2006•74 citations
We study multi-invariants---a multi-partite generalization of Renyi entropies---of simple stabilizer states, for an arbitrary replica symmetry group. We develop a group theoretic technique for evaluating such invariants, which operates on the replica group and involves counting intersections among its cosets. Our techniques streamline the calculations of multi-invariants for graph states with two GHZ-like nodes and for certain generalizations thereof. The methodology developed here is most suitable when the quantum state is simple but flexibility over the replica group is desired.
The paper asks how to evaluate multipartite local-unitary invariants defined by contracting multiple copies of a pure state and its conjugate, while allowing flexibility in the replica symmetry group. It studies GHZ states and “core-2” stabilizer states: two repetition-encoded qubits coupled by a controlled-ZZZ gate, including the four-qubit cluster state.
For connected GHZ contractions using sss ket copies, the invariant is d1−sd^{1-s}d1−s. For core-2 states, contractions are recast as signed colorings of a replica tessellation. Binary labels are constant on cosets of two subgroups H^1,H^2\hat H_1,\hat H_2H^1​,H^2​ of the extended replica group G^\hat GG^. Defining AAA by the parity of coset-intersection sizes reduces the coloring sum to a bilinear sum over F2\mathbb F_2F2​, giving E=2−2s+[G^:H^1]+[G^:H^2]−rank⁡F2A\mathcal E=2^{-2s+[\hat G:\hat H_1]+[\hat G:\hat H_2]-\operatorname{rank}_{\mathbb F_2}A}E=2−2s+[G^:H^1​]+[G^:H^2​]−rankF2​​A. Group quotients simplify the rank calculation.
For the four-qubit cluster state, the resulting Rényi multi-entropy is Sn(4)=(2+n−2)log⁡2S_n^{(4)}=(2+n^{-2})\log 2Sn(4)​=(2+n−2)log2, with the stated canonical continuation giving 3log⁡23\log 23log2 as n→1n\to1n→1. More generally, core-2 states with block sizes p,q≥2p,q\ge2p,q≥2 give (p+q−1)log⁡2(p+q-1)\log 2(p+q−1)log2 in that limit. A twelve-replica, genus-two contraction evaluates to 2−152^{-15}2−15 for the cluster state and 2−142^{-14}2−14 after swapping two parties.
The method assumes a free, transitive replica-group action and exploits sparse wavefunctions with a single bilinear phase. Its stated scope is therefore narrow in states, although flexible in replica groups; broader stabilizer-state calculations and possible extensions to symmetry-protected topological states are left to separate or future work.
Multipartite entanglement is a natural generalization of bipartite entanglement, but is relatively poorly understood. In this paper, we develop tools to calculate a class of multipartite entanglement measures - known as multi-invariants - for stabilizer states. We give an efficient numerical algorithm that computes multi-invariants for stabilizer states. For tripartite stabilizer states, we also obtain an explicit formula for any multi-invariant using the GHZ-extraction theorem. We then present a counting argument that calculates any Coxeter multi-invariant of a q-partite stabilizer state. We conjecture a closed form expression for the same. We uncover hints of an interesting connection between multi-invariants, stabilizer states and topology. We show how our formulas are further simplified for a restricted class of stabilizer states that appear as ground states of interesting models like the toric code and the X-cube model.
Rényi multi-entropy probes multi-partite structure beyond bipartite spectra, but its behavior in general quantum states and the entanglement structure it captures remain poorly understood. We develop a finite field Gauss sum framework for calculating it in stabilizer states. Within this framework, the replica contraction reduces to a quadratic Gauss sum if and only if the state is locally unitarily equivalent to a stabilizer state. We obtain analytic expressions for the Rényi multi-entropy of all tree graph states and large families of loop graph states. In contrast to their flat bipartite Rényi spectra, stabilizer states generically have nonflat Rényi multi-entropy spectra.
Rényi multi-entropy of graph states and the n−>1n -> 1n−>1 limit
Rényi multi-entropy extends the Rényi entropy to pure states of more than two parties. It is defined by a replica contraction at integer replica number nnn, and the multi-entropy is its n→1n\to1n→1 limit. In holography this limit is conjectured to compute the area of a minimal soap-film web in the bulk. Understanding multi-entropy for general states, however, is harder. Unlike the bipartite case, the replica contraction is not a moment of a density matrix, and the continuation to n=1n=1n=1 has to be found by other means. We study this problem for qubit graph states. We show that at every odd nnn the contraction equals 2−k/22^{-k/2}2−k/2, where kkk is a sum of ranks of matrices over a finite field, one row and one column per qubit. We define a class of graphs that we call collision-controlled, for which the rank sum is a polynomial in nnn. This class includes graphs without even cycles and all complete bipartite graphs. The natural polynomial n→1n \to 1n→1 continuation is a finite sum over partitions of the parties. While the Rényi multi-entropy is non-increasing under single-qubit Pauli measurements at every odd integer n>1n>1n>1, the continuation to n=1n=1n=1 is not. A ZZZ measurement on one qubit of an odd ring with 2r+1≥72r + 1 \geq 72r+1≥7 qubits raises it from (r+1)log⁡2(r+1)\log 2(r+1)log2 to (2r−1)log⁡2(2r-1) \log 2(2r−1)log2. Thus the continuation is not an entanglement monotone.
Multi-invariants are local-unitary invariants of state replicas introduced as potential probes of multipartite entanglement and correlations in quantum many-body systems. In this paper, we investigate two multi-invariants for tripartite pure states, namely multientropy and dihedral invariant. We compute the (genuine) multientropy for Lifshitz ground states and obtain its analytical continuation to noninteger values of Rényi index. We show that the genuine multientropy can be expressed in terms of mutual information and logarithmic negativity, a relation that also holds for stabilizer states. For general tripartite pure states, we demonstrate that dihedral invariants are related to Rényi reflected entropies. In particular, we show that the dihedral permutations of replicas are equivalent to the reflected construction, or alternatively to the realignment of density matrices.
A bstract In this paper, we analyze the question of replica symmetry in the bulk for multi-partite entanglement measures in the vacuum state of two dimensional holographic CFTs. We first define a class of multi-partite local unitary invariants, multi-invariants , with a given replica symmetry that acts freely and transitively on the replicas. We look for a subclass of measures such that the dual bulk geometry also preserves replica symmetry. We obtain the most general solution to this problem if we require the bulk to preserve replica symmetry for general configurations of the regions. Orbifolding the bulk solution with the replica symmetry gives us a bulk geometry with a network of conical singularities. Our approach makes it clear that there are infinitely many infinitely large families of multi-invariants such that each family evaluates identically on the holographic state. Geometrically, these are equalities involving volumes of handlebodies, possibly of different genus, at particular points in the moduli space. In certain cases, we check our bulk computation with an explicit calculation in CFT. Finally we comment on the generalization to higher dimension.
Let ∣Ψ⟩ be an arbitrary stabilizer state distributed between three remote parties, such that each party holds several qubits. Let S be a stabilizer group of ∣Ψ⟩. We show that ∣Ψ⟩ can be converted by local unitaries into a collection of singlets, GHZ states, and local one-qubit states. The numbers of singlets and GHZs are determined by dimensions of certain subgroups of S. For an arbitrary number of parties m we find a formula for the maximal number of m-partite GHZ states that can be extracted from ∣Ψ⟩ by local unitaries. A connection with earlier introduced measures of multipartite correlations is made. An example of an undecomposable four-party stabilizer state with more than one qubit per party is given. These results are derived from a general theoretical framework that allows one to study interconversion of multipartite stabilizer states by local Clifford group operators. As a simple application, we study three-party entanglement in two-dimensional lattice models that can be exactly solved by the stabilizer formalism.