Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.22199

Energetics of Fault-Tolerant Spin-Qubit Quantum Computation

João Santos, Jayshankar Nath, Marco Pezzutto, Valentin Savin, Tristan Meunier, Yasser Omar

quant-phSubmitted Oct 15, 2026• Announced Oct 16, 2026• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Semiconductor spin qubits offer a promising route to compact and scalable quantum computers, combining long coherence times in isotopically purified silicon with compatibility with semiconductor manufacturing. Beyond computational speedup, their energy efficiency is an important consideration for future large-scale systems. We evaluate the power and energy requirements of a Loss-DiVincenzo spin-qubit quantum computer by analyzing the Quantum Fourier Transform (QFT) and benchmarking it against the classical Fast Fourier Transform (FFT). We develop a detailed energy budget, identifying cryogenic cooling as the dominant baseline contribution before quantum error correction (QEC). The comparison between the QFT and the classical FFT reveals that, for any quantum workload operating under a polynomially bounded sampling regime, the crossover in energy consumption occurs at smaller problem sizes than the crossover in execution time. Thus, quantum computing can become energetically competitive before achieving a speedup in execution time. We then incorporate surface-code QEC and analyze the energy costs of QEC cycles, gate synthesis, and decoding. At scale, instrumentation and decoding become dominant contributions, while cryogenic cooling imposes a constraint on scalability. We show that optimizing the control-signal demultiplexing ratio can reduce the overall energy cost by approximately two orders of magnitude. For a system with about one million physical qubits, we estimate a power consumption of approximately 100 kW, at least one order of magnitude below that of today's highest-performance classical computing systems.

AI Summary

What sets the energy cost of fault-tolerant semiconductor spin-qubit computation, and how can control architecture reduce it? This paper constructs a system-level energy budget for Loss–DiVincenzo qubits, using the QFT as a workload and the classical FFT as a reference. It combines circuit decompositions and component-level power estimates with surface-code resource accounting, rotation synthesis, magic-state distillation, and a CPU-based MWPM decoding model. Without QEC, cryogenic baseline power of $5$–$10\,\mathrm{kW}$ dominates. With 1,024 shots, estimated QFT–FFT energy and runtime crossovers occur near 45 and 57 qubits, respectively. These compare different tasks: the FFT explicitly returns all coefficients, whereas the modeled QFT does not reconstruct the spectrum. With QEC, instrumentation and decoding become major costs. At fixed per-rotation synthesis tolerance $\epsilon=10^{-8}$, neglecting sufficiently small rotations changes the QFT gate-count scaling from quadratic to approximately linear beyond 27 logical qubits, with about $16{,}500q$ synthesized gates. Cryogenic control demultiplexing trades longer QEC cycles against fewer room-temperature channels. A modeled $1{:}500$ ratio extends cycles from $15$ to $25\,\mu\mathrm{s}$ and reduces total energy by up to roughly two orders of magnitude. Million-physical-qubit configurations are estimated to draw approximately $100\,\mathrm{kW}$, with cryoelectronic dissipation near a $700\,\mathrm{mW}$ cooling budget. The estimates depend on architecture, hardware and decoder assumptions, including a principal physical-error assumption of $p=10^{-4}$. Nontrivial input preparation, workload-dependent sampling, online calibration, and multiple cryostats are excluded. The crossovers are therefore benchmark comparisons, not demonstrations of quantum advantage.

Little sign of AI-generated textStrong assumptionsMissing comparisonOverclaimsPossible error

Central claim may not hold: The abstract's universal energy-before-runtime crossover claim omits the relative-power or cost-ratio condition that Section V explicitly requires. The reported QFT–FFT crossovers compare different computational tasks and therefore do not establish an energy advantage for an equivalent task. The stated cable loads and 700 mW cooling budget imply a static-load capacity of approximately 1.09 million physical qubits, contradicting the claimed 20,000–30,000-qubit limit derived from those quantities.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
Keywords: Quantum Computation, Energetics, Spin-qubits, Semiconductors, Quantum Error Correction, Fault-Tolerant, Benchmarking

Related papers

Energy and power scaling in quantum computers based on rotated surface codes with silicon flip-flop qubits

Marco De Michielis, Elena Ferraro

Abstract Scalable solutions are essential to achieving the long-term goal of building a fault-tolerant quantum computer and energy-power consumption are fundamental limiting factors for this target. Among the available types of silicon qubits, this work focuses on Flip-Flop (FF) qubits. Energy consumption and power requirements are estimated for a square array of qubits that hosts the logical qubit. The logical qubit is implemented using the rotated Surface Code (SC) for Quantum Error Correction (QEC). By using a universal set of quantum gates, the energy usage, time and power requirements for a SC cycle are estimated based on noise level, code distance and control levels. These estimates are used to provide insights into the main scaling-up challenges for quantum computer development. This is achieved by extending a thermal model that includes energy contributions from both the cryogenic components (such as the qubit array, the cryogenic control electronics, and the cryostat) and the room temperature (RT) section (RT electronics and heat dissipation systems). The maximum numbers of physical and logical qubits are provided, as well as power consumption across the different temperature sections.

EPJ Quantum Technology•Jun 2, 2025•3 citations

Unveiling Energetic Advantage in Superconducting Cat-Qubits Quantum Computation

Pedro Ramos, Marco Pezzutto, Yasser Omar

Quantum computers are emerging as a promising new technology due to their ability to solve complex problems that exceed the capabilities of classical systems in terms of time. Among various implementations, superconducting qubits have become the leading technology due to their scalability and compatibility with quantum error correction mechanisms. Although time has traditionally been the primary focus, energetic efficiency is becoming an increasingly important consideration, especially with the possibility of a quantum energetic advantage. In this article, the energy consumption of the Semiclassical Quantum Fourier Transform was analyzed on a superconducting quantum computing platform based on cat qubits. Quantum error correction mechanisms were studied and considered in the energy estimations. The results show how the energy consumption scales with the number of qubits and how the most relevant parameters required for qubit stabilization, gate implementation, and error correction codes contribute to the overall energy usage. An optimization method was developed to tune these parameters with the goal of minimizing energy consumption while maintaining qubit fidelities above a given threshold. Additionally, a comparative study with state-of-the-art classical computers indicates a potential quantum energetic advantage for systems with more than 26 qubits, assuming cryogenic systems operating at Carnot efficiency, with this energetic advantage arising before any computational advantage. This behavior persists even when realistic cryogenic systems and control electronics are taken into account.

quant-pharXiv:2605.19854•May 20, 2026•2 citations

Energetics of Rydberg-atom Quantum Computing

Óscar Alves, Marco Pezzutto, Yasser Omar

While extensive research over the past decades has been dedicated to developing scalable quantum computers, the question of their energetic performance has only gained attention more recently, but its importance is now recognized. In fact, quantum computers can only be a viable alternative if their energy cost scales favorably, and some research has shown that there is even a potential quantum energy advantage. In parallel, Rydberg atoms have recently emerged as one of the most promising platforms to implement a large-scale quantum computer. This work aims at contributing first steps to understand the energy efficiency of this platform, by investigating the energy consumption of the different elements of a Rydberg atom quantum computer. First, an experimental implementation of the Quantum Phase Estimation algorithm is analyzed, and an estimation of the energetic cost of executing it is calculated. Then, we derive an estimate of how the energy cost of performing the Quantum Fourier Transform scales with the number of qubits in the Rydberg platform. This analysis facilitates a comparison of the energy consumption of different elements within a Rydberg atom quantum computer, from the preparation of the atoms to the execution of the algorithm, and the measurement of the final state, enabling the evaluation of the energy expenditure of the Rydberg platform and the identification of potential improvements. Finally, we use the Quantum Fourier Transform as an energetic benchmark, comparing the scaling we obtained to that of the execution of the Discrete Fourier Transform in two state-of-the-art classical supercomputers. This comparison indicates that, in an ideal error-free scenario, a quantum energy advantage is achieved in the Rydberg platform for the Fourier Transform, in a regime where classical algorithms are still faster.

quant-pharXiv:2601.03141•Jan 7, 2026•3 citations

Optimal operating temperature for industry-compatible silicon spin quantum computing: colder is not necessarily better

Paul Steinacker, Amanda E. Seedhouse, Nard Dumoulin Stuyck +22 more

Silicon spin qubits are a leading candidate for large-scale quantum computing owing to their compatibility with semiconductor manufacturing. However, scaling to useful fault-tolerant processors will likely generate thermal loads that exceed the cooling power available at millikelvin temperatures. Raising the operating temperature eases cooling requirements but reduces gate fidelity, increasing the overhead of quantum error correction. Identifying the operating temperature that minimizes total power consumption is therefore a key challenge for commercially viable quantum computers. Here, we use gate set tomography to benchmark two-qubit silicon chips fabricated in both industrial and academic environments over a range of temperatures. Elevated temperatures substantially shorten coherence times and increase gate and state-preparation-and-measurement infidelities. Based on these measurements, we develop a general power model for silicon quantum computers that combines cryogenic cooling requirements with error-correction overheads. We show that a finite optimal operating temperature exists and is strongly influenced by a crossover temperature near 1 K in current devices, above which gate fidelity degrades rapidly. These results connect device-level fidelity limitations to system-level power requirements, providing design guidelines for large-scale silicon quantum computers.

quant-pharXiv:2607.11846•Jul 14, 2026•2 citations

Thermodynamic and Informational Bottlenecks of Scalable Fault-Tolerant Quantum Computation

QNFO

The promise of fault-tolerant quantum computation rests on its ability to solve certain intractable problems exponentially faster than classical computers. However, this theoretical promise is challenged by a cascade of interconnected physical bottlenecks, where the act of scaling quantum resources to suppress errors creates insurmountable thermal and classical processing loads. This paper develops an integrated thermal equilibrium model that quantitatively links physical gate fidelity, quantum error correction (QEC) overhead, and cryogenic cooling capacity to determine the viability of a large-scale system. Through numerical analysis of a system designed to execute Shor’s algorithm, the model demonstrates that even under optimistic technological assumptions, the required physical resources—in terms of qubit count, cooling power, and classical decoding speed—remain orders of magnitude beyond plausible near-term capabilities. The findings indicate that the primary barrier to scalable quantum computation is not a single engineering challenge but a systemic, multi-physics resource gap, where the polynomial scaling of classical support systems fails to keep pace with the exponential demands of the quantum core. This suggests that progress requires a holistic co-design of algorithms, hardware, and control systems rather than isolated improvements in qubit count alone.

•Dec 16, 2025•0 citations

A Lower Bound on Energy Cost per Logical-Qubit Operation in Surface-Code Quantum Error Correction

Rowan Brad Quni-Gudzinas

Surface-code quantum error correction (QEC) is pivotal for fault-tolerant quantum computing, but its energy efficiency remains underexplored. This work derives a practical lower bound on the energy cost per logical-qubit operation, accounting for gate-fidelity decay's impact on code distance and physical-qubit overhead. By modeling the energy consumption of gate operations and error correction, we express the total cost as $ E = (E_g N_g + E_c N_c)/N_l $, where $ E_g $, $ E_c $, $ N_g $, $ N_c $, and $ N_l $ represent gate and physical-qubit energy costs, gate counts, physical-qubit counts, and logical qubit counts, respectively. Gate-fidelity decay increases the required code distance $ d $, scaling $ N_c $ and thus $ E $. We propose normalizing computational cost in joules per logical-qubit operation (JPCUB), isolating logical work from error-correction overhead. Quantitative predictions for $ E_g $, $ E_c $, and $ N_c $ remain [to verify], but the functional dependence on $ d $ and gate fidelities is established. This framework informs energy-efficient QEC design and benchmarks. ## 1. Introduction Surface codes enable fault-tolerant quantum computation by encoding logical qubits in a 2D lattice of physical qubits, correcting errors through syndrome measurements. However, the energy cost per logical operation—critical for scalability—remains poorly quantified. While theoretical foundations exist (Raussendorf & Terhal, 2006; Kitaev, 2003), prior work focuses on error-correction thresholds rather than energy efficiency. Here, we address this gap by deriving a lower bound on energy cost, considering how gate-fidelity decay necessitates larger code distances $ d $, increasing physical-qubit overhead $ N_c $. This analysis connects to the joules-per-compute (JPCUB) benchmark, advocating for energy normalization per logical qubit to disentangle computational work from error-correction costs. ## 2. Background Surface codes encode logical qubits using a 2D grid of

•Sep 3, 2026•0 citations
Semiconductor spin qubits offer a promising route to compact and scalable quantum computers, combining long coherence times in isotopically purified silicon with compatibility with semiconductor manufacturing. Beyond computational speedup, their energy efficiency is an important consideration for future large-scale systems. We evaluate the power and energy requirements of a Loss-DiVincenzo spin-qubit quantum computer by analyzing the Quantum Fourier Transform (QFT) and benchmarking it against the classical Fast Fourier Transform (FFT). We develop a detailed energy budget, identifying cryogenic cooling as the dominant baseline contribution before quantum error correction (QEC). The comparison between the QFT and the classical FFT reveals that, for any quantum workload operating under a polynomially bounded sampling regime, the crossover in energy consumption occurs at smaller problem sizes than the crossover in execution time. Thus, quantum computing can become energetically competitive before achieving a speedup in execution time. We then incorporate surface-code QEC and analyze the energy costs of QEC cycles, gate synthesis, and decoding. At scale, instrumentation and decoding become dominant contributions, while cryogenic cooling imposes a constraint on scalability. We show that optimizing the control-signal demultiplexing ratio can reduce the overall energy cost by approximately two orders of magnitude. For a system with about one million physical qubits, we estimate a power consumption of approximately 100 kW, at least one order of magnitude below that of today's highest-performance classical computing systems.
What sets the energy cost of fault-tolerant semiconductor spin-qubit computation, and how can control architecture reduce it? This paper constructs a system-level energy budget for Loss–DiVincenzo qubits, using the QFT as a workload and the classical FFT as a reference. It combines circuit decompositions and component-level power estimates with surface-code resource accounting, rotation synthesis, magic-state distillation, and a CPU-based MWPM decoding model.
Without QEC, cryogenic baseline power of 555–10 kW10\,\mathrm{kW}10kW dominates. With 1,024 shots, estimated QFT–FFT energy and runtime crossovers occur near 45 and 57 qubits, respectively. These compare different tasks: the FFT explicitly returns all coefficients, whereas the modeled QFT does not reconstruct the spectrum. With QEC, instrumentation and decoding become major costs. At fixed per-rotation synthesis tolerance ϵ=10−8\epsilon=10^{-8}ϵ=10−8, neglecting sufficiently small rotations changes the QFT gate-count scaling from quadratic to approximately linear beyond 27 logical qubits, with about 16,500q16{,}500q16,500q synthesized gates.
Cryogenic control demultiplexing trades longer QEC cycles against fewer room-temperature channels. A modeled 1:5001{:}5001:500 ratio extends cycles from 151515 to 25 μs25\,\mu\mathrm{s}25μs and reduces total energy by up to roughly two orders of magnitude. Million-physical-qubit configurations are estimated to draw approximately 100 kW100\,\mathrm{kW}100kW, with cryoelectronic dissipation near a 700 mW700\,\mathrm{mW}700mW cooling budget.
The estimates depend on architecture, hardware and decoder assumptions, including a principal physical-error assumption of p=10−4p=10^{-4}p=10−4. Nontrivial input preparation, workload-dependent sampling, online calibration, and multiple cryostats are excluded. The crossovers are therefore benchmark comparisons, not demonstrations of quantum advantage.
Abstract Scalable solutions are essential to achieving the long-term goal of building a fault-tolerant quantum computer and energy-power consumption are fundamental limiting factors for this target. Among the available types of silicon qubits, this work focuses on Flip-Flop (FF) qubits. Energy consumption and power requirements are estimated for a square array of qubits that hosts the logical qubit. The logical qubit is implemented using the rotated Surface Code (SC) for Quantum Error Correction (QEC). By using a universal set of quantum gates, the energy usage, time and power requirements for a SC cycle are estimated based on noise level, code distance and control levels. These estimates are used to provide insights into the main scaling-up challenges for quantum computer development. This is achieved by extending a thermal model that includes energy contributions from both the cryogenic components (such as the qubit array, the cryogenic control electronics, and the cryostat) and the room temperature (RT) section (RT electronics and heat dissipation systems). The maximum numbers of physical and logical qubits are provided, as well as power consumption across the different temperature sections.
Quantum computers are emerging as a promising new technology due to their ability to solve complex problems that exceed the capabilities of classical systems in terms of time. Among various implementations, superconducting qubits have become the leading technology due to their scalability and compatibility with quantum error correction mechanisms. Although time has traditionally been the primary focus, energetic efficiency is becoming an increasingly important consideration, especially with the possibility of a quantum energetic advantage. In this article, the energy consumption of the Semiclassical Quantum Fourier Transform was analyzed on a superconducting quantum computing platform based on cat qubits. Quantum error correction mechanisms were studied and considered in the energy estimations. The results show how the energy consumption scales with the number of qubits and how the most relevant parameters required for qubit stabilization, gate implementation, and error correction codes contribute to the overall energy usage. An optimization method was developed to tune these parameters with the goal of minimizing energy consumption while maintaining qubit fidelities above a given threshold. Additionally, a comparative study with state-of-the-art classical computers indicates a potential quantum energetic advantage for systems with more than 26 qubits, assuming cryogenic systems operating at Carnot efficiency, with this energetic advantage arising before any computational advantage. This behavior persists even when realistic cryogenic systems and control electronics are taken into account.
While extensive research over the past decades has been dedicated to developing scalable quantum computers, the question of their energetic performance has only gained attention more recently, but its importance is now recognized. In fact, quantum computers can only be a viable alternative if their energy cost scales favorably, and some research has shown that there is even a potential quantum energy advantage. In parallel, Rydberg atoms have recently emerged as one of the most promising platforms to implement a large-scale quantum computer. This work aims at contributing first steps to understand the energy efficiency of this platform, by investigating the energy consumption of the different elements of a Rydberg atom quantum computer. First, an experimental implementation of the Quantum Phase Estimation algorithm is analyzed, and an estimation of the energetic cost of executing it is calculated. Then, we derive an estimate of how the energy cost of performing the Quantum Fourier Transform scales with the number of qubits in the Rydberg platform. This analysis facilitates a comparison of the energy consumption of different elements within a Rydberg atom quantum computer, from the preparation of the atoms to the execution of the algorithm, and the measurement of the final state, enabling the evaluation of the energy expenditure of the Rydberg platform and the identification of potential improvements. Finally, we use the Quantum Fourier Transform as an energetic benchmark, comparing the scaling we obtained to that of the execution of the Discrete Fourier Transform in two state-of-the-art classical supercomputers. This comparison indicates that, in an ideal error-free scenario, a quantum energy advantage is achieved in the Rydberg platform for the Fourier Transform, in a regime where classical algorithms are still faster.
Silicon spin qubits are a leading candidate for large-scale quantum computing owing to their compatibility with semiconductor manufacturing. However, scaling to useful fault-tolerant processors will likely generate thermal loads that exceed the cooling power available at millikelvin temperatures. Raising the operating temperature eases cooling requirements but reduces gate fidelity, increasing the overhead of quantum error correction. Identifying the operating temperature that minimizes total power consumption is therefore a key challenge for commercially viable quantum computers. Here, we use gate set tomography to benchmark two-qubit silicon chips fabricated in both industrial and academic environments over a range of temperatures. Elevated temperatures substantially shorten coherence times and increase gate and state-preparation-and-measurement infidelities. Based on these measurements, we develop a general power model for silicon quantum computers that combines cryogenic cooling requirements with error-correction overheads. We show that a finite optimal operating temperature exists and is strongly influenced by a crossover temperature near 1 K in current devices, above which gate fidelity degrades rapidly. These results connect device-level fidelity limitations to system-level power requirements, providing design guidelines for large-scale silicon quantum computers.
The promise of fault-tolerant quantum computation rests on its ability to solve certain intractable problems exponentially faster than classical computers. However, this theoretical promise is challenged by a cascade of interconnected physical bottlenecks, where the act of scaling quantum resources to suppress errors creates insurmountable thermal and classical processing loads. This paper develops an integrated thermal equilibrium model that quantitatively links physical gate fidelity, quantum error correction (QEC) overhead, and cryogenic cooling capacity to determine the viability of a large-scale system. Through numerical analysis of a system designed to execute Shor’s algorithm, the model demonstrates that even under optimistic technological assumptions, the required physical resources—in terms of qubit count, cooling power, and classical decoding speed—remain orders of magnitude beyond plausible near-term capabilities. The findings indicate that the primary barrier to scalable quantum computation is not a single engineering challenge but a systemic, multi-physics resource gap, where the polynomial scaling of classical support systems fails to keep pace with the exponential demands of the quantum core. This suggests that progress requires a holistic co-design of algorithms, hardware, and control systems rather than isolated improvements in qubit count alone.
Surface-code quantum error correction (QEC) is pivotal for fault-tolerant quantum computing, but its energy efficiency remains underexplored. This work derives a practical lower bound on the energy cost per logical-qubit operation, accounting for gate-fidelity decay's impact on code distance and physical-qubit overhead. By modeling the energy consumption of gate operations and error correction, we express the total cost as $ E = (E_g N_g + E_c N_c)/N_l $, where $ E_g $, $ E_c $, $ N_g $, $ N_c $, and $ N_l $ represent gate and physical-qubit energy costs, gate counts, physical-qubit counts, and logical qubit counts, respectively. Gate-fidelity decay increases the required code distance $ d $, scaling $ N_c $ and thus $ E $. We propose normalizing computational cost in joules per logical-qubit operation (JPCUB), isolating logical work from error-correction overhead. Quantitative predictions for $ E_g $, $ E_c $, and $ N_c $ remain [to verify], but the functional dependence on $ d $ and gate fidelities is established. This framework informs energy-efficient QEC design and benchmarks. ## 1. Introduction Surface codes enable fault-tolerant quantum computation by encoding logical qubits in a 2D lattice of physical qubits, correcting errors through syndrome measurements. However, the energy cost per logical operation—critical for scalability—remains poorly quantified. While theoretical foundations exist (Raussendorf & Terhal, 2006; Kitaev, 2003), prior work focuses on error-correction thresholds rather than energy efficiency. Here, we address this gap by deriving a lower bound on energy cost, considering how gate-fidelity decay necessitates larger code distances $ d $, increasing physical-qubit overhead $ N_c $. This analysis connects to the joules-per-compute (JPCUB) benchmark, advocating for energy normalization per logical qubit to disentangle computational work from error-correction costs. ## 2. Background Surface codes encode logical qubits using a 2D grid of