arXiv:2610.18816
On the coincidence of discrete and continuous definitions of Entanglement of Formation
Haobo Ma, Maksim E. Shirokov, Wenlin Zhang
Abstract
It is proved that every Borel ensemble of pure states on a separable bipartite Hilbert space with finite average entanglement admits a countable ensemble with the same barycenter and arbitrarily small additional average entanglement. Consequently, the discrete and continuous versions of the Entanglement of Formation coincide on the whole space of states of infinite-dimensional bipartite quantum system (with infinite values allowed). The main idea of the proof (realized with the AI-assistance) is the lifting a Borel ensemble of pure bipartite states to a Borel probability measure on the unit sphere in the space of Hilbert--Schmidt operators followed by dividing the support of this measure into appropriate cells and replacing each cell by its conditional barycenter. The resulting countable ensemble is obtained by a recursive construction.
AI Summary
In infinite-dimensional bipartite systems, entanglement of formation (EoF) can be defined by minimizing average pure-state entanglement over countable ensembles or over arbitrary Borel ensembles. The paper proves that these definitions coincide for every state on a tensor product of separable Hilbert spaces, including infinite values. Previously, equality was established when at least one marginal entropy was finite. The main result is an exact-barycenter discretization theorem: any Borel pure-state ensemble with barycenter $\rho$ and finite average entanglement $c_\mu$ admits a countable pure-state ensemble with the same barycenter and average entanglement at most $c_\mu+5\eta/(4-\eta)$, for every $0<\eta<1$. Taking $\eta\to0$ establishes equality of the two infima without marginal-entropy assumptions. The proof lifts pure states to unit Hilbert–Schmidt amplitude operators and partitions them into countably many cells using a convex spectral functional that controls entropy. Conditional amplitude means yield pure output atoms; a covariance identity represents the positive remainder through amplitude differences. Each extraction reduces residual trace by a factor at most $\eta/4$ and bounds residual entanglement cost by $\eta/2$ times the incoming mass. Iteration preserves the barycenter exactly in the trace-norm limit. Consequences include lower semicontinuity and generalized LOCC monotonicity of discrete EoF, and its vanishing on every separable state. Equality does not imply attainment by a countable ensemble: countably nondecomposable separable states provide nonattainment examples. Output atoms need not belong to the original ensemble’s support, and the method does not establish an analogous theorem for general lower-semicontinuous costs.
The AI agents assisted with literature search, symbolic and numerical computations, drafting and checking proof details, and Lean formalization attempts.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 14 pages, preliminary vesion, any comments are welcome