Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.18553

On the Increase of Boltzmann Entropy in Closed Macroscopic Quantum Systems

Cedric Igelspacher, Roderich Tumulka

quant-phSubmitted Oct 13, 2026• Announced Oct 14, 2026• 0 citations• Revised Oct 26, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Oct 13, 2026v2 · Oct 26, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider a closed macroscopic quantum system in a pure state $ψ$ evolving unitarily with Hamiltonian $H$ in a finite-dimensional Hilbert space $\mathscr{H}$. Following von Neumann, we assume a decomposition of $\mathscr{H}$ into mutually orthogonal subspaces $\mathscr{H}_ν$, where each $ν$ represents a macro state, and $\mathscr{H}_ν$ contains the pure states compatible with $ν$. We define the quantum Boltzmann entropy for a macro state $ν$ as $S_\mathrm{qB}(ν) = k_{\mathrm{B}} \log \dim \mathscr{H}_ν$, where $k_\mathrm{B}$ is the Boltzmann constant. Goldstein et al. [http://arxiv.org/abs/1903.11870] have suggested, as a version of the second law of thermodynamics, that $S_\mathrm{qB}$ predominantly increases with time for realistic macroscopic systems. Here, we discuss precise versions of this statement and confirm them for several simple models of $H$ and $\mathscr{H}_ν$.

AI Summary

The paper asks how to formulate entropy increase for a closed quantum system in a pure state, using quantum Boltzmann entropy $S_{\mathrm{qB}}(\nu)=k_{\mathrm B}\log d_\nu$ for orthogonal macrospaces of dimensions $d_\nu$. Since unitary evolution generally produces superpositions of macrostates, it proposes two criteria: a weak second law requiring macrostate probabilities to move approximately toward higher entropy in stochastic order, and a strong second law requiring probability currents to flow predominantly from smaller to larger macrospaces. The strong criterion implies the weak one; violations are quantified by cumulative backward versus forward probability transport. Three toy-model settings are examined. For a small macrospace with uniformly random orientation, its occupation is approximated by the squared Fourier transform of the density of states. A theorem gives sufficient positivity and convexity conditions on that density for monotonic decay, including truncated power laws with exponent at least three. For GUE and Wigner Hamiltonians, existing random-matrix estimates yield explicit Bessel-function formulas for occupations and currents, with arbitrarily small pointwise errors at times $0<t\ll D^{1/7}$. These formulas suggest cumulative backward transport below approximately $2.5\%$ when an equilibrium macrospace dominates. Previously established results for a three-macrospace block-band model imply approximately monotonic relaxation without ultrafast thermalization. The random-orientation and Wigner models have physically unrealistic ultrafast relaxation. The $2.5\%$ conclusion is not established rigorously: simultaneous-in-time and accumulated-error control remain unresolved. Conditions guaranteeing either criterion for realistic macroscopic Hamiltonians are left open.

No sign of AI-generated textIncrementalStrong assumptions

Error found: The Wigner-model cumulative-current conclusion is not established by the supplied fixed-time estimates without additional integration and macro-state-count control, as the appendix itself acknowledges. The stated 2.5% cumulative-violation bound neglects transitions into macro spaces smaller than the initial one and needs a stronger quantitative equilibrium-dominance assumption. Example 1 incorrectly extends its continuum approximation to times below an assumed exp(D) recurrence scale, although an allowed equally spaced spectrum recurs exactly at time 2πD.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
14 pages, 3 figures; v2: Theorem 1 added

Related papers

Approach to thermal equilibrium of macroscopic quantum systems

Sheldon Goldstein, Joel L. Lebowitz, Christian Mastrodonato +2 more

We consider an isolated macroscopic quantum system. Let $\mathcal{H}$ be a microcanonical ``energy shell,'' i.e., a subspace of the system's Hilbert space spanned by the (finitely) many energy eigenstates with energies between $E$ and $E+\ensuremath{\delta}E$. The thermal equilibrium macrostate at energy $E$ corresponds to a subspace ${\mathcal{H}}_{eq}$ of $\mathcal{H}$ such that $\text{dim}\text{ }{\mathcal{H}}_{eq}/\text{dim}\text{ }\mathcal{H}$ is close to 1. We say that a system with state vector $\ensuremath{\psi}∊\mathcal{H}$ is in thermal equilibrium if $\ensuremath{\psi}$ is ``close'' to ${\mathcal{H}}_{eq}$. We show that for ``typical'' Hamiltonians with given eigenvalues, all initial state vectors ${\ensuremath{\psi}}_{0}$ evolve in such a way that ${\ensuremath{\psi}}_{t}$ is in thermal equilibrium for most times $t$. This result is closely related to von Neumann's quantum ergodic theorem of 1929.

arXiv:0911.1724•Physical Review E•Jan 7, 2010•157 citations

Time Evolution of Typical Pure States from a Macroscopic Hilbert Subspace

Stefan Teufel, Roderich Tumulka, Cornelia Vogel

Abstract We consider a macroscopic quantum system with unitarily evolving pure state $$\psi _t\in \mathcal {H}$$ ψ t ∈ H and take it for granted that different macro states correspond to mutually orthogonal, high-dimensional subspaces $$\mathcal {H}_\nu $$ H ν (macro spaces) of $$\mathcal {H}$$ H . Let $$P_\nu $$ P ν denote the projection to $$\mathcal {H}_\nu $$ H ν . We prove two facts about the evolution of the superposition weights $$\Vert P_\nu \psi _t\Vert ^2$$ ‖ P ν ψ t ‖ 2 : First, given any $$T>0$$ T > 0 , for most initial states $$\psi _0$$ ψ 0 from any particular macro space $$\mathcal {H}_\mu $$ H μ (possibly far from thermal equilibrium), the curve $$t\mapsto \Vert P_\nu \psi _t\Vert ^2$$ t ↦ ‖ P ν ψ t ‖ 2 is approximately the same (i.e., nearly independent of $$\psi _0$$ ψ 0 ) on the time interval [0, T]. And second, for most $$\psi _0$$ ψ 0 from $$\mathcal {H}_\mu $$ H μ and most $$t\in [0,\infty )$$ t ∈ [ 0 , ∞ ) , $$\Vert P_\nu \psi _t\Vert ^2$$ ‖ P ν ψ t ‖ 2 is close to a value $$M_{\mu \nu }$$ M μ ν that is independent of both t and $$\psi _0$$ ψ 0 . The first is an instance of the phenomenon of dynamical typicality observed by Bartsch, Gemmer, and Reimann, and the second modifies, extends, and in a way simplifies the concept, introduced by von Neumann, now known as normal typicality.

arXiv:2210.10018•Journal of Statistical Physics•Feb 22, 2023•13 citations

Entropies of Quantum Operators

Craig S. Lent

For a quantum state undergoing unitary Schrodinger time evolution, the von Neumann entropy is constant. Yet the second law of thermodynamics, and our experience, show that entropy increases with time. Ingarden introduced the quantum operator entropy, which is the Shannon entropy of the probability distribution for the eigenvalues of a Hermitian operator. These entropies characterize the missing information about a particular observable inherent in the quantum state itself. The von Neumann entropy is the quantum operator entropy for the case when the operator is the density matrix. We examine pure state unitary evolution in a simple model system comprised of a set of highly-interconnected topologically disordered states and a time-independent Hamiltonian. An initially confined state is subject to free expansion into available states. The time development is completely reversible with no loss of quantum information and no course graining is applied. The positional entropy increases in time in a way that is consistent with both the classical statistical mechanical entropy and the second law.

•Jan 25, 2019•0 citations

Quantum operator entropies under unitary evolution

Craig S. Lent

For a quantum state undergoing unitary Schrödinger time evolution, the von Neumann entropy is constant. Yet the second law of thermodynamics, and our experience, show that entropy increases with time. Ingarden introduced the quantum operator entropy, which is the Shannon entropy of the probability distribution for the eigenvalues of a Hermitian operator [R. S. Ingarden, Quantum information theory, Rep. Math. Phys. 10, 43 (1976)RMHPBE0034-487710.1016/0034-4877(76)90005-7]. These entropies characterize the missing information about a particular observable inherent in the quantum state itself. The von Neumann entropy is the quantum operator entropy for the case when the operator is the density matrix. We examine pure state unitary evolution in a simple model system composed of a set of highly interconnected topologically disordered states and a time-independent Hamiltonian. An initially confined state is subject to free expansion into available states. The time development is completely reversible with no loss of quantum information and no course graining is applied. The positional entropy increases in time in a way that is consistent with both the classical statistical mechanical entropy and the second law.

arXiv:1901.08956•Physical review. E•Jul 2, 2019•19 citations

Boltzmann entropy for quantum field systems

Kyo Yoshida

A way to construct Boltzmann entropy, i.e., the entropy as a function of a microscopic pure state, for quantum field systems is proposed. Operators that shift the field in wave-vector space are used in the construction. By employing an assumption that some terms emerging due to the shift are negligible in the thermodynamic limit, it is shown that, for almost all states in the ensemble of pure states corresponding to a thermodynamic state, the value of the proposed Boltzmann entropy coincides with that of the thermodynamic entropy for the thermodynamic state. For general self-interacting fields, the Boltzmann entropy evolves with time under Hamiltonian dynamics, so that it is capable of characterizing the thermalization of isolated quantum field systems.

arXiv:1909.00961•Physical Review A•Mar 16, 2020•2 citations

A quantum approach to thermodynamics

Jochen Gemmer B

Since the days of Boltzmann the foundation of thermodynamics has been subject to an ongoing discussion. Various problems like the precise definition of entropy, the origin of the second law, etc. have always been issues. For a long time the discussion has not been in the center of interest, for statistical physics work extremely well from a practical point of view. But now, as research deals with single small objects like molecules or atoms, the question arises whether or not thermodynamics are applicable to them, which leads back to the old question of the foundation of thermodynamics. We examine whether thermodynamics can be viewed as emerging from Schrödinger-type quantum dynamics. Therefore we partially transfer concepts of thermodynamical behavior in Gamma-space to the Hilbertspace of compound systems. Central roles play the local Von Neumann entropy of a system and the inevitability of entanglement with its environment, causing it to increase.

•Jan 1, 2003•2 citations
We consider a closed macroscopic quantum system in a pure state ψψψ evolving unitarily with Hamiltonian HHH in a finite-dimensional Hilbert space H\mathscr{H}H. Following von Neumann, we assume a decomposition of H\mathscr{H}H into mutually orthogonal subspaces Hν\mathscr{H}_νHν​, where each ννν represents a macro state, and Hν\mathscr{H}_νHν​ contains the pure states compatible with ννν. We define the quantum Boltzmann entropy for a macro state ννν as SqB(ν)=kBlog⁡dim⁡HνS_\mathrm{qB}(ν) = k_{\mathrm{B}} \log \dim \mathscr{H}_νSqB​(ν)=kB​logdimHν​, where kBk_\mathrm{B}kB​ is the Boltzmann constant. Goldstein et al. [http://arxiv.org/abs/1903.11870] have suggested, as a version of the second law of thermodynamics, that SqBS_\mathrm{qB}SqB​ predominantly increases with time for realistic macroscopic systems. Here, we discuss precise versions of this statement and confirm them for several simple models of HHH and Hν\mathscr{H}_νHν​.
The paper asks how to formulate entropy increase for a closed quantum system in a pure state, using quantum Boltzmann entropy SqB(ν)=kBlog⁡dνS_{\mathrm{qB}}(\nu)=k_{\mathrm B}\log d_\nuSqB​(ν)=kB​logdν​ for orthogonal macrospaces of dimensions dνd_\nudν​. Since unitary evolution generally produces superpositions of macrostates, it proposes two criteria: a weak second law requiring macrostate probabilities to move approximately toward higher entropy in stochastic order, and a strong second law requiring probability currents to flow predominantly from smaller to larger macrospaces. The strong criterion implies the weak one; violations are quantified by cumulative backward versus forward probability transport.
Three toy-model settings are examined. For a small macrospace with uniformly random orientation, its occupation is approximated by the squared Fourier transform of the density of states. A theorem gives sufficient positivity and convexity conditions on that density for monotonic decay, including truncated power laws with exponent at least three. For GUE and Wigner Hamiltonians, existing random-matrix estimates yield explicit Bessel-function formulas for occupations and currents, with arbitrarily small pointwise errors at times 0<t≪D1/70<t\ll D^{1/7}0<t≪D1/7. These formulas suggest cumulative backward transport below approximately 2.5%2.5\%2.5% when an equilibrium macrospace dominates. Previously established results for a three-macrospace block-band model imply approximately monotonic relaxation without ultrafast thermalization.
The random-orientation and Wigner models have physically unrealistic ultrafast relaxation. The 2.5%2.5\%2.5% conclusion is not established rigorously: simultaneous-in-time and accumulated-error control remain unresolved. Conditions guaranteeing either criterion for realistic macroscopic Hamiltonians are left open.
We consider an isolated macroscopic quantum system. Let H\mathcal{H}H be a microcanonical ``energy shell,'' i.e., a subspace of the system's Hilbert space spanned by the (finitely) many energy eigenstates with energies between EEE and $E+\ensuremath{\delta}E$. The thermal equilibrium macrostate at energy EEE corresponds to a subspace Heq{\mathcal{H}}_{eq}Heq​ of H\mathcal{H}H such that dim Heq/dim H\text{dim}\text{ }{\mathcal{H}}_{eq}/\text{dim}\text{ }\mathcal{H}dim Heq​/dim H is close to 1. We say that a system with state vector $\ensuremath{\psi}∊\mathcal{H}$ is in thermal equilibrium if $\ensuremath{\psi}$ is ``close'' to Heq{\mathcal{H}}_{eq}Heq​. We show that for ``typical'' Hamiltonians with given eigenvalues, all initial state vectors ${\ensuremath{\psi}}_{0}$ evolve in such a way that ${\ensuremath{\psi}}_{t}$ is in thermal equilibrium for most times ttt. This result is closely related to von Neumann's quantum ergodic theorem of 1929.
Abstract We consider a macroscopic quantum system with unitarily evolving pure state ψt∈H\psi _t\in \mathcal {H}ψt​∈H ψ t ∈ H and take it for granted that different macro states correspond to mutually orthogonal, high-dimensional subspaces Hν\mathcal {H}_\nu Hν​ H ν (macro spaces) of H\mathcal {H}H H . Let PνP_\nu Pν​ P ν denote the projection to Hν\mathcal {H}_\nu Hν​ H ν . We prove two facts about the evolution of the superposition weights ∥Pνψt∥2\Vert P_\nu \psi _t\Vert ^2∥Pν​ψt​∥2 ‖ P ν ψ t ‖ 2 : First, given any T>0T>0T>0 T > 0 , for most initial states ψ0\psi _0ψ0​ ψ 0 from any particular macro space Hμ\mathcal {H}_\mu Hμ​ H μ (possibly far from thermal equilibrium), the curve t↦∥Pνψt∥2t\mapsto \Vert P_\nu \psi _t\Vert ^2t↦∥Pν​ψt​∥2 t ↦ ‖ P ν ψ t ‖ 2 is approximately the same (i.e., nearly independent of ψ0\psi _0ψ0​ ψ 0 ) on the time interval [0, T]. And second, for most ψ0\psi _0ψ0​ ψ 0 from Hμ\mathcal {H}_\mu Hμ​ H μ and most t∈[0,∞)t\in [0,\infty )t∈[0,∞) t ∈ [ 0 , ∞ ) , ∥Pνψt∥2\Vert P_\nu \psi _t\Vert ^2∥Pν​ψt​∥2 ‖ P ν ψ t ‖ 2 is close to a value MμνM_{\mu \nu }Mμν​ M μ ν that is independent of both t and ψ0\psi _0ψ0​ ψ 0 . The first is an instance of the phenomenon of dynamical typicality observed by Bartsch, Gemmer, and Reimann, and the second modifies, extends, and in a way simplifies the concept, introduced by von Neumann, now known as normal typicality.
For a quantum state undergoing unitary Schrodinger time evolution, the von Neumann entropy is constant. Yet the second law of thermodynamics, and our experience, show that entropy increases with time. Ingarden introduced the quantum operator entropy, which is the Shannon entropy of the probability distribution for the eigenvalues of a Hermitian operator. These entropies characterize the missing information about a particular observable inherent in the quantum state itself. The von Neumann entropy is the quantum operator entropy for the case when the operator is the density matrix. We examine pure state unitary evolution in a simple model system comprised of a set of highly-interconnected topologically disordered states and a time-independent Hamiltonian. An initially confined state is subject to free expansion into available states. The time development is completely reversible with no loss of quantum information and no course graining is applied. The positional entropy increases in time in a way that is consistent with both the classical statistical mechanical entropy and the second law.
For a quantum state undergoing unitary Schrödinger time evolution, the von Neumann entropy is constant. Yet the second law of thermodynamics, and our experience, show that entropy increases with time. Ingarden introduced the quantum operator entropy, which is the Shannon entropy of the probability distribution for the eigenvalues of a Hermitian operator [R. S. Ingarden, Quantum information theory, Rep. Math. Phys. 10, 43 (1976)RMHPBE0034-487710.1016/0034-4877(76)90005-7]. These entropies characterize the missing information about a particular observable inherent in the quantum state itself. The von Neumann entropy is the quantum operator entropy for the case when the operator is the density matrix. We examine pure state unitary evolution in a simple model system composed of a set of highly interconnected topologically disordered states and a time-independent Hamiltonian. An initially confined state is subject to free expansion into available states. The time development is completely reversible with no loss of quantum information and no course graining is applied. The positional entropy increases in time in a way that is consistent with both the classical statistical mechanical entropy and the second law.
A way to construct Boltzmann entropy, i.e., the entropy as a function of a microscopic pure state, for quantum field systems is proposed. Operators that shift the field in wave-vector space are used in the construction. By employing an assumption that some terms emerging due to the shift are negligible in the thermodynamic limit, it is shown that, for almost all states in the ensemble of pure states corresponding to a thermodynamic state, the value of the proposed Boltzmann entropy coincides with that of the thermodynamic entropy for the thermodynamic state. For general self-interacting fields, the Boltzmann entropy evolves with time under Hamiltonian dynamics, so that it is capable of characterizing the thermalization of isolated quantum field systems.
Since the days of Boltzmann the foundation of thermodynamics has been subject to an ongoing discussion. Various problems like the precise definition of entropy, the origin of the second law, etc. have always been issues. For a long time the discussion has not been in the center of interest, for statistical physics work extremely well from a practical point of view. But now, as research deals with single small objects like molecules or atoms, the question arises whether or not thermodynamics are applicable to them, which leads back to the old question of the foundation of thermodynamics. We examine whether thermodynamics can be viewed as emerging from Schrödinger-type quantum dynamics. Therefore we partially transfer concepts of thermodynamical behavior in Gamma-space to the Hilbertspace of compound systems. Central roles play the local Von Neumann entropy of a system and the inevitability of entanglement with its environment, causing it to increase.