Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.14778

Avoiding Defects within Heavy-Hexagon Architecture

Hansol Kim, Younghun Kwon

quant-phSubmitted Oct 10, 2026• Announced Oct 13, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

When implementing scalable fault-tolerant quantum computing using superconducting quantum processors, one of the critical challenges to overcome is the presence of defective qubits arising from fabrication and calibration imperfections. A defect on a specific qubit severely restricts the connectivity between adjacent qubits, disrupts stabilizer measurements, induces frequent detection events, and consequently inflates the logical error rate. To mitigate this issue, various strategies have been proposed, such as syndrome extraction circuits based on stabilizer folding and the construction of super-stabilizers via gauge operators. However, these methods have primarily been developed for architectures with relatively high connectivity of 3 to 4. Furthermore, experimental demonstrations showing an actual reduction in logical error rates in the presence of physical hardware defects have been lacking. In this work, we propose a defect-avoidance scheme tailored for the heavy-hexagon architecture, which features a lower connectivity of 2 to 3. While previous approaches required four measurement cycles to measure all gauge operators comprising a super-stabilizer, our proposed scheme completes all gauge measurements within only two cycles. We experimentally validate this approach on IBM quantum hardware by identifying physical defects and implementing the defect-avoidance circuits. As a result, avoiding the defect yields an approximately 10\% reduction in the logical error rate per cycle for both logical $X$ and $Z$ errors. These findings demonstrate that defects in superconducting hardware can be successfully handled even under the constrained connectivity of heavy-hexagon lattices, and that defect avoidance substantially reduces logical errors on real quantum hardware.

AI Summary

The paper addresses how to bypass defective qubits and couplers when implementing surface-code syndrome extraction on degree-$2$–$3$ heavy-hexagon hardware. It adapts stabilizer folding and gauge-based super-stabilizers, repurposing syndrome and bridge qubits so that all constituent gauge measurements fit into two measurement cycles rather than the four required by the compared folding-based schemes. Temporally staggered parity comparisons reconstruct the super-stabilizer outcomes. The accompanying rotated-surface-code layout requires $N=(5d^2+2d-5)/2$ physical qubits: 23, 65, and 127 for nominal distances 3, 5, and 7. Experiments on the 156-qubit IBM Boston processor compare circuits including a persistently poor data qubit against circuits bypassing it. Using calibration-derived noise models and minimum-weight perfect matching, distance-5 logical error rates per cycle decrease from 0.0578 to 0.0508 for $Z$ errors and from 0.1188 to 0.1069 for $X$ errors, reductions of 12.1% and 10.0%. At distance 7, the corresponding reductions are 8.1% and 6.7%. Nearby detector-event probabilities decrease from approximately 0.5 to 0.4. The layout has hook-error propagation along one logical direction, reducing its effective circuit distance to $\lceil d/2\rceil$. Circuit-level depolarizing-noise simulations show threshold behavior, but the hardware experiments show no logical-error suppression with increasing distance. Defect avoidance adds gauge-measurement overhead and can worsen performance when calibration improves. Multiple nonoverlapping defects are considered; overlapping super-stabilizers are outside scope. Experimental validation focuses on a naturally occurring data-qubit defect rather than all proposed defect types.

Little sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsMissing comparison

Error found: The reported per-cycle improvements use a stationary logical-flip inversion without testing its assumptions or separating preparation/readout offsets, so they establish improvements in the chosen estimator rather than independently isolated cycle-error probabilities. The paper provides no uncertainty analysis for its logical-error reductions despite a nonlinear estimator that strongly amplifies sampling uncertainty when cumulative logical errors approach one half.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Related papers

LUCI on IBM Hardware: Error Suppression with Almost Half Syndrome Density

Younghun Kim, Spiro Gicev, Martin Sevior +1 more

Long-lived logical qubits are essential for fault-tolerant quantum computation. However, the practical performance of traditional error correction protocols relies on performing specific syndrome circuits, causing vulnerability to hardware defects and imposing rigid connectivity constraints. Recent theoretical findings have proposed that flexible subroutine circuits within the LUCI framework can maintain space-time distance in the presence of isolated or broken components, albeit at the expense of temporal distance. However, these approaches have solely targeted defect avoidance and have not yet been demonstrated to suppress errors with reduced temporal distances on physical hardware. In this work, we propose a reset-free scenario for the LUCI framework and experimentally benchmark it on IBM quantum hardware. By asymmetrically scaling the $X$ or $Z$ distance, we compare our reset-free approach against the standard surface code and successfully demonstrate error suppression ratios for targeted logical Pauli errors. Remarkably, despite a nearly halved syndrome density in time, which requires two subroutine rounds for full syndrome extraction, the LUCI framework remains competitive with the rotated surface code implementation. In the LUCI framework, we observe error suppression of $1.75(10)$ for logical $X$ errors and $1.93(12)$ for logical $Z$ errors, whereas the standard approach yields $ 1.58(13)$ and $2.44(7)$, respectively. These results demonstrate that dynamic codes outperform standard methods by avoiding highly noisy components, even without physical defects, while preserving logical boundaries. Our findings challenge the conventional dependency on static fault-tolerant architectures by verifying the feasibility and efficacy of the LUCI framework on physical hardware and pave the way for hybrid, hardware-compatible code designs in quantum computing.

quant-pharXiv:2607.01887•Jul 3, 2026•4 citations

Quantum computer error structure probed by quantum error correction syndrome measurements

Spiro Gicev, Lloyd C. L. Hollenberg, Muhammad Usman

With quantum devices rapidly approaching qualities and scales needed for fault tolerance, the validity of simplified error models underpinning the study of quantum error correction needs to be experimentally evaluated. In this work, we have assessed the performance of IBM superconducting quantum computer devices implementing heavy-hexagon code syndrome measurements with circuit sizes up to 23 qubits, against the error assumptions underpinning code threshold calculations. Circuit operator change rate statistics in the presence of depolarizing and biased noise were modeled using analytic functions of error model parameters. Data from 16 repeated syndrome measurement cycles were found to be inconsistent with a uniform depolarizing noise model, with slightly improved fits found with biased and inhomogeneous noise models. Spatial-temporal correlations investigated via Z stabilizer measurements revealed significant temporal correlation in detection events. These results highlight the nontrivial structure that may be present in the noise of quantum error correction circuits, revealed by operator measurement statistics, and support the development of noise-tailored codes and decoders to adapt. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2310.12448•Physical Review Research•Dec 9, 2024•15 citations

Realizing Error Suppression in Partially Fault-Tolerant Quantum Simulations with IBM Quantum Computers

Henry Froland, Dorota M. Grabowska, Sebastian Grieninger +8 more

Quantum error-detecting codes offer a near-term path for improving the performance of quantum simulations on noisy hardware. Using IBM's superconducting quantum computer ibm_boston, we show that partially fault-tolerant encoded quantum simulations of the Ising model in 1+1D and 2+1D outperform their unencoded counterparts in estimating local observables. To represent 42 logical qubits on the heavy-hex quantum processor, 21 blocks of the [[4, 2, 2]] Iceberg code and up to 136 physical qubits are used. By pairing fault-tolerant syndrome extraction with non-fault-tolerant logical operations, this scheme preserves many of the benefits of error detection while avoiding the overhead typically required for a fully fault-tolerant logical gate set. The encoding's square logical connectivity, together with the freedom to place logical qubits within each block, enables simulations of a 2D spatial lattice with lower circuit depth than the unencoded implementation requires. We introduce Observable-Ranked Postselection, a selective-filtering technique based on syndrome correlations that recovers reliable results without the prohibitive shot loss of full syndrome postselection. Under the cumulative effect of device errors, this encoding improves local-observable accuracy over the unencoded baseline by 2-6% at intermediate times in 1+1D simulations, growing with circuit depth to over 200% in 2+1D at the latest times studied.

quant-pharXiv:2607.24947•Jul 29, 2026•4 citations

Demonstrating multi-round subsystem quantum error correction using matching and maximum likelihood decoders

Neereja Sundaresan, Theodore J. Yoder, Young‐Seok Kim +7 more

Quantum error correction offers a promising path for performing high fidelity quantum computations. Although fully fault-tolerant executions of algorithms remain unrealized, recent improvements in control electronics and quantum hardware enable increasingly advanced demonstrations of the necessary operations for error correction. Here, we perform quantum error correction on superconducting qubits connected in a heavy-hexagon lattice. We encode a logical qubit with distance three and perform several rounds of fault-tolerant syndrome measurements that allow for the correction of any single fault in the circuitry. Using real-time feedback, we reset syndrome and flag qubits conditionally after each syndrome extraction cycle. We report decoder dependent logical error, with average logical error per syndrome measurement in Z(X)-basis of ~0.040 (~0.088) and ~0.037 (~0.087) for matching and maximum likelihood decoders, respectively, on leakage post-selected data.

arXiv:2203.07205•Nature Communications•May 18, 2023•141 citations

Error correction on an array of superconducting qubits with defective components

Julien M. Drouet, Xanda C. Kolesnikow, Campbell K. McLauchlan +6 more

A solid-state quantum-computing architecture will require the fabrication of arrays of many coupled qubits. It is inevitable that this process will produce qubits and couplers with varying performance, with some components underperforming due to imperfect fabrication. Quantum error-correction requires high-performing components and hence these defects must be dealt with, either by adapting the code to exclude the defects, or by informing the decoder to accommodate defects in post-processing. Here we implement and compare strategies to operate distance-5 surface codes on a quantum processor consisting of a square-lattice array of 120 superconducting qubits. We demonstrate a dramatic reduction in the probability of a logical error in a memory experiment by excluding underperforming components, compared with both a standard approach of ignoring defects, and a defect-aware decoding approach. We observe up to 2.8X improvement in logical errors per round when excluding defects compared with the standard defect-ignorant approach (1.62% compared to 4.49%). In contrast, defect-aware decoding gives only modest gains. Defects are also expected to be particularly harmful for measurement-based logical operations. Using a stability experiment we show that excluding defects resurrects measurement-based logic gate performance, observing a 6.3% per-round suppression of failure rate when excluding defects, compared to zero suppression otherwise. Furthermore, we show a further substantial decrease in logical errors when using leakage post-selection in combination with our defect exclusion strategies, resulting in a distance-5 code outperforming the best distance-3 in one basis. Our experiments therefore give a proof-of-principle demonstration of the essential utility of defect exclusion methods in the scale-up of solid-state quantum computing approaches.

quant-pharXiv:2607.12118•Jul 15, 2026•10 citations

Error-Corrected Memory and Logic on a Heavy-Hex Superconducting-Qubit Processor

Campbell K. McLauchlan, Georgia M. Nixon, Julien M. Drouet +7 more

Large quantum computations require high-fidelity error-corrected memory and fault-tolerant logical operations. To achieve these with superconducting circuits, quantum processors will need many components operating with low error rates. In practice, fabrication of monolithic superconducting devices produces unavoidable heterogeneity in component performance, which the quantum computer must accommodate. We implement strategies to operate a large dynamic compass code on an array of 156 superconducting qubits arranged on a heavy-hexagonal lattice, making use of the entire monolithic quantum processor and redesigning our measurement schedule to exclude underperforming components. We demonstrate improvements of up to $35\%$ in logical error probabilities for a memory experiment by using a noise-informed decoder combined with strategies to exclude the worst-performing qubits and couplers, along with post-selecting on shots with a low probability of leakage errors. In addition to these memory results, we also observe performance gains of up to $56\%$ when these strategies are applied to measurement-based logic, demonstrated by stability experiments. We furthermore demonstrate high-fidelity fault-tolerant logic through lattice surgery. Through pre-selection filtering techniques, we can obtain Bell fidelities above $77\%$, and further logical gap post-selection using exclusive decoding increases these fidelities to above $97\%$. Our experiments demonstrate that high performance can be maintained in key elements of fault-tolerant quantum memory and logic when working on monolithic superconducting quantum processors with underperforming components, by using a suite of noise-informed quantum error correction strategies.

quant-pharXiv:2610.11658•Oct 9, 2026•1 citation
When implementing scalable fault-tolerant quantum computing using superconducting quantum processors, one of the critical challenges to overcome is the presence of defective qubits arising from fabrication and calibration imperfections. A defect on a specific qubit severely restricts the connectivity between adjacent qubits, disrupts stabilizer measurements, induces frequent detection events, and consequently inflates the logical error rate. To mitigate this issue, various strategies have been proposed, such as syndrome extraction circuits based on stabilizer folding and the construction of super-stabilizers via gauge operators. However, these methods have primarily been developed for architectures with relatively high connectivity of 3 to 4. Furthermore, experimental demonstrations showing an actual reduction in logical error rates in the presence of physical hardware defects have been lacking. In this work, we propose a defect-avoidance scheme tailored for the heavy-hexagon architecture, which features a lower connectivity of 2 to 3. While previous approaches required four measurement cycles to measure all gauge operators comprising a super-stabilizer, our proposed scheme completes all gauge measurements within only two cycles. We experimentally validate this approach on IBM quantum hardware by identifying physical defects and implementing the defect-avoidance circuits. As a result, avoiding the defect yields an approximately 10% reduction in the logical error rate per cycle for both logical XXX and ZZZ errors. These findings demonstrate that defects in superconducting hardware can be successfully handled even under the constrained connectivity of heavy-hexagon lattices, and that defect avoidance substantially reduces logical errors on real quantum hardware.
The paper addresses how to bypass defective qubits and couplers when implementing surface-code syndrome extraction on degree-222–333 heavy-hexagon hardware. It adapts stabilizer folding and gauge-based super-stabilizers, repurposing syndrome and bridge qubits so that all constituent gauge measurements fit into two measurement cycles rather than the four required by the compared folding-based schemes. Temporally staggered parity comparisons reconstruct the super-stabilizer outcomes.
The accompanying rotated-surface-code layout requires N=(5d2+2d−5)/2N=(5d^2+2d-5)/2N=(5d2+2d−5)/2 physical qubits: 23, 65, and 127 for nominal distances 3, 5, and 7. Experiments on the 156-qubit IBM Boston processor compare circuits including a persistently poor data qubit against circuits bypassing it. Using calibration-derived noise models and minimum-weight perfect matching, distance-5 logical error rates per cycle decrease from 0.0578 to 0.0508 for ZZZ errors and from 0.1188 to 0.1069 for XXX errors, reductions of 12.1% and 10.0%. At distance 7, the corresponding reductions are 8.1% and 6.7%. Nearby detector-event probabilities decrease from approximately 0.5 to 0.4.
The layout has hook-error propagation along one logical direction, reducing its effective circuit distance to ⌈d/2⌉\lceil d/2\rceil⌈d/2⌉. Circuit-level depolarizing-noise simulations show threshold behavior, but the hardware experiments show no logical-error suppression with increasing distance. Defect avoidance adds gauge-measurement overhead and can worsen performance when calibration improves. Multiple nonoverlapping defects are considered; overlapping super-stabilizers are outside scope. Experimental validation focuses on a naturally occurring data-qubit defect rather than all proposed defect types.
Long-lived logical qubits are essential for fault-tolerant quantum computation. However, the practical performance of traditional error correction protocols relies on performing specific syndrome circuits, causing vulnerability to hardware defects and imposing rigid connectivity constraints. Recent theoretical findings have proposed that flexible subroutine circuits within the LUCI framework can maintain space-time distance in the presence of isolated or broken components, albeit at the expense of temporal distance. However, these approaches have solely targeted defect avoidance and have not yet been demonstrated to suppress errors with reduced temporal distances on physical hardware. In this work, we propose a reset-free scenario for the LUCI framework and experimentally benchmark it on IBM quantum hardware. By asymmetrically scaling the XXX or ZZZ distance, we compare our reset-free approach against the standard surface code and successfully demonstrate error suppression ratios for targeted logical Pauli errors. Remarkably, despite a nearly halved syndrome density in time, which requires two subroutine rounds for full syndrome extraction, the LUCI framework remains competitive with the rotated surface code implementation. In the LUCI framework, we observe error suppression of 1.75(10)1.75(10)1.75(10) for logical XXX errors and 1.93(12)1.93(12)1.93(12) for logical ZZZ errors, whereas the standard approach yields $ 1.58(13)$ and 2.44(7)2.44(7)2.44(7), respectively. These results demonstrate that dynamic codes outperform standard methods by avoiding highly noisy components, even without physical defects, while preserving logical boundaries. Our findings challenge the conventional dependency on static fault-tolerant architectures by verifying the feasibility and efficacy of the LUCI framework on physical hardware and pave the way for hybrid, hardware-compatible code designs in quantum computing.
With quantum devices rapidly approaching qualities and scales needed for fault tolerance, the validity of simplified error models underpinning the study of quantum error correction needs to be experimentally evaluated. In this work, we have assessed the performance of IBM superconducting quantum computer devices implementing heavy-hexagon code syndrome measurements with circuit sizes up to 23 qubits, against the error assumptions underpinning code threshold calculations. Circuit operator change rate statistics in the presence of depolarizing and biased noise were modeled using analytic functions of error model parameters. Data from 16 repeated syndrome measurement cycles were found to be inconsistent with a uniform depolarizing noise model, with slightly improved fits found with biased and inhomogeneous noise models. Spatial-temporal correlations investigated via Z stabilizer measurements revealed significant temporal correlation in detection events. These results highlight the nontrivial structure that may be present in the noise of quantum error correction circuits, revealed by operator measurement statistics, and support the development of noise-tailored codes and decoders to adapt. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Quantum error-detecting codes offer a near-term path for improving the performance of quantum simulations on noisy hardware. Using IBM's superconducting quantum computer ibm_boston, we show that partially fault-tolerant encoded quantum simulations of the Ising model in 1+1D and 2+1D outperform their unencoded counterparts in estimating local observables. To represent 42 logical qubits on the heavy-hex quantum processor, 21 blocks of the [[4, 2, 2]] Iceberg code and up to 136 physical qubits are used. By pairing fault-tolerant syndrome extraction with non-fault-tolerant logical operations, this scheme preserves many of the benefits of error detection while avoiding the overhead typically required for a fully fault-tolerant logical gate set. The encoding's square logical connectivity, together with the freedom to place logical qubits within each block, enables simulations of a 2D spatial lattice with lower circuit depth than the unencoded implementation requires. We introduce Observable-Ranked Postselection, a selective-filtering technique based on syndrome correlations that recovers reliable results without the prohibitive shot loss of full syndrome postselection. Under the cumulative effect of device errors, this encoding improves local-observable accuracy over the unencoded baseline by 2-6% at intermediate times in 1+1D simulations, growing with circuit depth to over 200% in 2+1D at the latest times studied.
Quantum error correction offers a promising path for performing high fidelity quantum computations. Although fully fault-tolerant executions of algorithms remain unrealized, recent improvements in control electronics and quantum hardware enable increasingly advanced demonstrations of the necessary operations for error correction. Here, we perform quantum error correction on superconducting qubits connected in a heavy-hexagon lattice. We encode a logical qubit with distance three and perform several rounds of fault-tolerant syndrome measurements that allow for the correction of any single fault in the circuitry. Using real-time feedback, we reset syndrome and flag qubits conditionally after each syndrome extraction cycle. We report decoder dependent logical error, with average logical error per syndrome measurement in Z(X)-basis of ~0.040 (~0.088) and ~0.037 (~0.087) for matching and maximum likelihood decoders, respectively, on leakage post-selected data.
A solid-state quantum-computing architecture will require the fabrication of arrays of many coupled qubits. It is inevitable that this process will produce qubits and couplers with varying performance, with some components underperforming due to imperfect fabrication. Quantum error-correction requires high-performing components and hence these defects must be dealt with, either by adapting the code to exclude the defects, or by informing the decoder to accommodate defects in post-processing. Here we implement and compare strategies to operate distance-5 surface codes on a quantum processor consisting of a square-lattice array of 120 superconducting qubits. We demonstrate a dramatic reduction in the probability of a logical error in a memory experiment by excluding underperforming components, compared with both a standard approach of ignoring defects, and a defect-aware decoding approach. We observe up to 2.8X improvement in logical errors per round when excluding defects compared with the standard defect-ignorant approach (1.62% compared to 4.49%). In contrast, defect-aware decoding gives only modest gains. Defects are also expected to be particularly harmful for measurement-based logical operations. Using a stability experiment we show that excluding defects resurrects measurement-based logic gate performance, observing a 6.3% per-round suppression of failure rate when excluding defects, compared to zero suppression otherwise. Furthermore, we show a further substantial decrease in logical errors when using leakage post-selection in combination with our defect exclusion strategies, resulting in a distance-5 code outperforming the best distance-3 in one basis. Our experiments therefore give a proof-of-principle demonstration of the essential utility of defect exclusion methods in the scale-up of solid-state quantum computing approaches.
Large quantum computations require high-fidelity error-corrected memory and fault-tolerant logical operations. To achieve these with superconducting circuits, quantum processors will need many components operating with low error rates. In practice, fabrication of monolithic superconducting devices produces unavoidable heterogeneity in component performance, which the quantum computer must accommodate. We implement strategies to operate a large dynamic compass code on an array of 156 superconducting qubits arranged on a heavy-hexagonal lattice, making use of the entire monolithic quantum processor and redesigning our measurement schedule to exclude underperforming components. We demonstrate improvements of up to 35%35\%35% in logical error probabilities for a memory experiment by using a noise-informed decoder combined with strategies to exclude the worst-performing qubits and couplers, along with post-selecting on shots with a low probability of leakage errors. In addition to these memory results, we also observe performance gains of up to 56%56\%56% when these strategies are applied to measurement-based logic, demonstrated by stability experiments. We furthermore demonstrate high-fidelity fault-tolerant logic through lattice surgery. Through pre-selection filtering techniques, we can obtain Bell fidelities above 77%77\%77%, and further logical gap post-selection using exclusive decoding increases these fidelities to above 97%97\%97%. Our experiments demonstrate that high performance can be maintained in key elements of fault-tolerant quantum memory and logic when working on monolithic superconducting quantum processors with underperforming components, by using a suite of noise-informed quantum error correction strategies.