arXiv:2610.09845
Redundant Records of the Past: Unifying Quantum Darwinism and Decoherent Histories
Philipp Strasberg
Abstract
There exist two different paradigms for records in isolated quantum systems: decoherent histories (which determines which past events leave formal records) and quantum Darwinism (which determines which current events get redundantly recorded). Neither one implies the other, and connections between the two are scarcely investigated. We unify quantum Darwinism and decoherent histories based on the insight that only redundant records about past events matter. The resulting framework of past redundancy encompasses quantum Darwinism when applied to events at the current time, and it implies the probability sum rule or decoherence of histories. The Bhattacharyya coefficient (or fidelity) plays an important role to establish this connection. Importantly, various examples show that past redundancy is a more widespread phenomenon than the fine-tuned models necessary for quantum Darwinism suggest. We thus arrive at a richer picture in which redundancy can be caused by mechanisms different from quantum Darwinism (such as macroevents or cascade structures), which emphasizes that redundancy is necessary but not sufficient for objectivity, and which, overall, allows to realistically investigate the question: how generic is redundancy in nature?
AI Summary
Quantum Darwinism (QD) characterizes redundant information about a system’s current state, whereas decoherent histories characterizes records of past events without requiring local accessibility or redundancy. This paper formulates “past redundancy” to connect these approaches: present environmental fragments, measured using specified local projectors, encode past events through a classical mutual-information plateau $I_C(X:R_F)\approx H(X)$ for fragments much smaller than the environment. The framework permits correlated records, multiple past events, and event projectors not tied to a distinguished system. In the equal-time, globally pure setting, a classical plateau implies the usual quantum-mutual-information plateau; the converse need not hold. Information-theoretic bounds connect the conditional entropy $H(X|R_F)$ to pairwise Bhattacharyya coefficients $B_F(x,x')$. These coefficients also bound violations of the probability sum rule: for any extended fragment $\overline F\supset F$, $\Delta_F\le\frac12\sum_{x\ne x'}\sqrt{p(x)p(x')}B_{\overline F}(x,x')$. The derivations use hypothesis-testing bounds, Fano’s inequality, and triangle/Cauchy–Schwarz inequalities. For multiple events, distinguishable record distributions also bound overlaps between history states. A reset circuit, a damped oscillator initially in a coherent-state superposition, and a simulated lossy-cavity QND measurement illustrate records persisting after correlations with the current system disappear. These examples do not establish genericity: redundancy remains qualitatively defined, product initial states are used, and persistence assumes no subsequent record-erasing interactions. Approximate probability consistency does not guarantee decoherence of every normalized, record-conditioned history; stronger conditional distinguishability is needed. Practical accessibility and stability of measurements remain unresolved, so redundancy alone is not identified with objectivity.
I consulted AI for specific technical questions related to information theory, quantum state discrimination and numerical implementations. In particular, most credit for the proof in Appendix~\ref{sec:app:proofs} goes to AI.
Error found: The Sandwich theorem's printed lower bound is false because the Bhattacharyya coefficient must be squared inside the square root, although correcting it preserves the qualitative entropy–overlap connection. Conditional independence of measured record probabilities does not imply the asserted branching form, because unmeasured configuration-dependent phases can entangle the conditional environmental states. The coherent-state redundancy plots use fragment-optimal Helstrom measurements without establishing the fixed local-projector implementation required by the paper's definition. For the specified initial two-photon cavity state, the final expected photon number is 2 exp(-5), not exp(-5) as reported.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- Improved clarity and a new result (redundancy implies classicality). One more page. Comments from v1 still apply