arXiv:2610.07254
The parliament of observers - Against the observable axiom of quantum mechanics
Markus Frembs, Andreas Döring
Abstract
The 'unreasonable effectiveness of mathematics in the natural sciences' may at times give the impression that natural science, especially modern theoretical physics, is all but a formal apparatus. However, a key challenge of physics remains to align everyday notions of experience -- be it directly or mediated through instruments of arbitrary sophistication -- with their mathematical formalisation. This applies in particular to quantum theory, arguably the most successful theory of physics ever invented. One of its core assumptions postulates: $Observables\ correspond\ with\ self-adjoint\ operators.$ Here, we argue that already this most basic premise about the quantum formalism falls apart under careful scrutiny, at least when understood for all observables at once. In other words, we challenge the role of the noncommutative algebra of bounded operators as an adequate formalisation of the 'algebra of observables', understood as (equivalence classes of) measurement procedures that admit a coherent empirical interpretation.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether the textbook identification of sharp observables with self-adjoint operators can faithfully represent measurement procedures whose descriptions and outcomes are consistently recorded and communicated across experimental contexts. It focuses on finite-dimensional systems and sharp measurements, setting aside POVMs, measurement dynamics, and state-dependent predictions. An experimental context is modelled as a measurable outcome space, with observables given by bounded real-valued functions. The paper introduces “classical coordinatisation”: context-wise outcome labels that agree wherever events are identified across contexts. It argues that coherent experimental recordkeeping requires this structure. For isomorphic contexts, such coordinatisation induces outcome bijections whose composition around every closed context cycle is the identity—a flatness condition. The observable–operator correspondence is required to preserve classical post-processing through functional calculus, $f\circ X\leftrightarrow f(a_X)$. This identifies contexts with commutative operator subalgebras and their events with projections. Using an existing context-connection reformulation of the Kochen–Specker theorem, the paper concludes that the required flat connections do not exist for the full matrix algebra in dimension $d\geq3$. Thus, the correspondence is incompatible with consistent recordability as defined here; finite Kochen–Specker configurations already suffice. The contribution is an operational and interpretive reading of an existing contextuality obstruction, rather than a new Kochen–Specker theorem. The paper explicitly leaves the mathematical operator formalism intact, suggests retaining additional contextual data, and does not provide a completed replacement framework. Its proposed consequences for quantum computation, probability, and reconstruction programmes remain open questions.
Central claim may not hold: The classical-coherence proposition incorrectly composes inverses of injections whose images need not coincide, so its claimed context connection need not exist. Quantum contexts satisfy the stated recordability definition by labeling elementary outcomes with their spectral projections, contradicting the theorem's assertion that this definition is incompatible with the observable–operator correspondence. Restricting every maximal context to the same d labels would introduce a stronger global coloring requirement, whose Kochen–Specker obstruction does not establish that quantum observables cannot be classically recorded or communicated.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 20 pages, 1 figure; comments welcome