arXiv:2610.07172
Pauli Flat Quantum States Mimicking Maximal Magic
Paweł Cieśliński
Abstract
Quantum magic is a necessary resource for fault-tolerant quantum computing, capturing the departure of quantum states from the classically simulable stabiliser set. Motivated by its role in quantum information processing, we investigate the correlation structure of states that maximize the Rényi stabiliser entropies, focusing on the T-type and Hoggar states. Inspired by their distinctive properties, we explore the notion of Pauli flat states, defined as N-qubit states whose expectation values on all Pauli strings are equal in absolute value. These states reproduce the correlation structure of highly magical states, which could also be interpreted as a mixed variant of Pauli covariant N-qubit symmetric informationally complete (SIC) Weyl-Heisenberg fiducial states, while not necessarily possessing nontrivial quantum magic. We investigate their existence and possible constructions, including examples both inside and outside of the stabiliser polytope. To identify the latter, we examine a magic witness tailored to the introduced family of states. Finally, we discuss their entanglement and Bell nonlocality, providing a broader characterization of their quantum properties. For completeness, we find pure states with a relaxed condition on the Pauli expectations, which forces unequal elements to zero, and discuss their non-stabiliserness. Our results offer a new perspective on the relation between quantum magic and Pauli correlation structures. They hold relevance to geometrical approaches to quantum mechanics, entanglement and magic detection, as well as estimation tasks.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether mixed states can reproduce the uniform Pauli-correlation magnitudes of maximally magical pure states without necessarily possessing magic. It defines $N$-qubit Pauli-flat states by $|\operatorname{Tr}(\rho P)|=\gamma$ for every nonidentity Pauli string. Pure examples exist only for $N=1,3$, corresponding to T-type and Hoggar states. A Cauchy–Schwarz positivity bound establishes mixed-state existence for every $N$ and every sign pattern when $\gamma\leq[(4^N-1)(2^N-1)]^{-1/2}$. A sign-matched Pauli-sum witness certifies nonstabiliserness whenever $\gamma>1/(2^N+1)$; the paper relates this criterion to existing stabiliser-norm witnesses. An explicit two-qubit family is physical up to $\gamma=1/3$ and certified magical for $\gamma>1/5$. Its endpoint is locally Clifford-equivalent to a Hoggar-state reduction, is entangled, and has maximal CHSH value $4\sqrt{2}/3<2$. Numerical searches over sign patterns, with positivity optimization, find four- and five-qubit examples with $\gamma\approx0.06731,0.02927$ and purities $0.1347,0.0586$. The witness certifies magic only for the four-qubit example; failure for five qubits does not establish stabiliser membership. Partial-transpose tests detect entanglement in both. The four-qubit example violates no tested two- or three-setting Bell inequality using Pauli measurements. A separate numerical search allowing zero Pauli expectations gives pure four- and five-qubit states with respectively 135 and 496 equal-magnitude nonzero expectations. Optimality of the mixed-state constructions is not established. General constructions with certified magic, fuller entanglement and nonlocality characterizations, and applications to tomography, estimation, or magic distillation remain open.
AI tools were used for language checking and text formatting (ChatGPT, Grammarly), code optimisation (ChatGPT, Claude), and technical proofreading after the manuscript's completion (ChatGPT).
Error found: The paper treats failure of its sufficient magic witness as proof of absent magic, although neither the five-qubit example nor the stated below-threshold families are thereby certified to belong to the stabiliser polytope. The relaxed-spectrum search objective has minimisers independent of its target parameter and does not enforce the claimed spectrum, while the accompanying purity-based parameter formula is inverted. The reported PPTMixer test does not justify the conclusion that the five-qubit example lacks genuine multipartite entanglement, because failure to detect that resource does not certify biseparability.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- AI statement added + small language changes. 6 pages + appendix