arXiv:2610.03694
An operational characterization of finite-dimensional quantum theory
Lionel J. Dmello, Xiangling Xu, Marc-Olivier Renou, David Gross
Abstract
A key goal in the foundations of quantum mechanics is to identify operational constraints characterizing physical theories. Bell inequalities do so for classical probability theory, while Tsirelson's bound provides a first step for quantum mechanics. Here, we address the dual question: Can one certify that all correlations predicted by quantum theory are actually realizable? In this work, we construct a finite number of two-body correlations such that the only probabilistic theory that (1) realizes them, and (2) does so in a way that is stable under iterated teleportation, is quantum theory. For $n$ quantum systems of dimension $d$ each, Condition (1) can be verified using $\operatorname{poly}(d,n)$ measurement settings. Condition (2) may be understood as a hierarchy of tests, one for each number $N$ of teleportation steps. There is thus a sense in which finite-dimensional quantum theory can be self-tested. In particular, one can certify the existence of Bell inequality violations larger than any that have been directly observed.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether operational observations can certify that all finite-dimensional quantum states and effects are realizable, rather than merely exclude superquantum correlations. It proposes entanglement-swapping experiments in the general probabilistic theory (GPT) framework, supplemented by an infinite hierarchy testing stability under repeated teleportation. For a qubit, the basic experiment uses three parties: the endpoints each have three binary measurement settings, and the central party has three four-outcome settings. Target correlations encode two rotations generating a dense subgroup of $SO(3)$. Tests at level $N$ check these correlations through $N$ swapping steps, with at most one nontrivial central setting. Passing every level forces swapping outcomes to have probabilities $4^{-N}$. Compact-semigroup methods, Haar averaging, and positivity of representation characters identify a four-dimensional effective sector; within it, teleportation maps reproduce the encoded rotations and their compositions. The resulting effective theory has the qubit’s local state and effect spaces, with bipartite states generated by products and maximally entangled states. Even when the largest directly tested CHSH value is only $2(\cos\theta+\sin\theta)>2$, the theory must permit $2\sqrt{2}$. The construction extends to $n$ qudits using Weyl corrections and two-system unitary generators, with $\operatorname{poly}(d,n)$ measurement settings for the generator tests. Additional orthogonality tests and a de Finetti argument address non-IID preparations. The characterization concerns the effective GPT generated by accessible experimental objects, not unreachable sectors. Its principal stated limitation is the requirement to pass every level of an unbounded hierarchy; finite truncation remains open.
Central claim may not hold: The abstract's uniqueness statement is broader than the body's characterization of a projected effective GPT, which leaves inaccessible sectors of the parent theory unconstrained. Removing IID requires an additional hierarchy of orthogonality tests with a separate second-moment condition, beyond the original teleportation-correlation condition. The compactness proof assumes closed state cones that the GPT definition does not require, leaving the use of compact semigroups and realizable limiting states unjustified without an additional assumption or argument. Twirling an arbitrary inner product does not uniquely normalize the character basis, although explicitly choosing an invariant inner product that makes the basis orthonormal repairs this local error.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 17 pages, 7 figures; v2: Added funding information, cleaned up the introduction and conclusion sections, fixed some typos