Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.00844

Complexity study of the Hartle-Hawking state in JT gravity

Ritam Basu

hep-thgr-qcquant-phSubmitted Oct 1, 2026• Announced Oct 2, 2026• Revised Oct 8, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Oct 1, 2026v2 · Oct 8, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The Wigner function, in general, takes on negative values, and the amount of negativity in the Wigner function gives an operationally meaningful measure of the complexity of simulating the quantum state on a classical computer. In this paper, we study the growth of Wigner negativity of the Hartle-Hawking state of Jackiw-Teitelboim gravity under time evolution. We work in the gravitational length basis, at genus zero, and at high temperature, $β\ll 1$. Our main analytic result is simple: to leading order in $β$ the state is a Gaussian wavepacket of minimum uncertainty, sitting at rest at the turning point of the Liouville wall. Its Wigner function is therefore positive, and the negativity is $1+δ(β,t)$, where the correction $δ$ is smaller than any power of $β$. We show that $δ$ is an even function of time, so there is no linear growth at $t=0$, and that once the packet has reflected off the wall its leading-order evolution is a Clifford shear, which cannot change the negativity. We also numerically study the time evolution of the Wigner function and its negativity. We observe that $δ$ stays below $10^{-11}$ at $t=0$ and through the reflection, then rises slowly over a few tens of $β/π$, and then approaches a late-time value consistent with $δ_\infty(β) \simeq 0.08\, e^{-4.4/β}$ for $0.25 \le β\le 1$: the lower the temperature, the larger the late-time negativity. The exact survival amplitude $Z(β+it)/Z(β)$ fixes the spread complexity to order $t^4$, and it also fixes the seed-normalised Wigner diagnostic of our earlier work (arXiv:2607.04065, arXiv:2607.17346). We take this as evidence that the length basis is ideally suited for a dual, semi-classical description of the dynamics at genus zero. Beyond genus zero the length basis is overcomplete, and we make no statement about finite $e^{S_0}$.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether Hartle–Hawking dynamics in JT gravity remains nearly Wigner-positive in the gravitational length basis, using continuous-variable Wigner negativity $\mathcal N=\int dx\,dp\,|W|$ as a basis-dependent diagnostic. It studies genus-zero JT gravity at high temperature, $\beta\ll1$, where the length-space Hamiltonian is $H=p^2+4e^{-x}$. A saddle-point calculation gives a leading minimum-uncertainty Gaussian initially at rest at the Liouville-wall turning point, $x_*=2\log(2\beta/\pi)$, with position variance $2\beta/\pi^2$. After reflection, the leading packet undergoes a free symplectic shear, which preserves negativity. Time-reversal symmetry and differentiability imply that $\mathcal N(t)$ is even and has no linear term at the origin. The semiclassical expansion suggests $\mathcal N=1+\delta$ with $\delta$ smaller than any power of $\beta$. Numerical propagation for $0.25\le\beta\le1$ finds $\delta<10^{-11}$ initially and through the main reflection, followed by a slow rise consistent with $\delta_\infty\simeq0.08e^{-4.4/\beta}$. The exact survival amplitude also determines spread complexity through order $t^4$; a seed-normalised Wigner diagnostic grows predominantly because it divides by the decaying survival probability. The exponentially small negativity and its asymptotic freezing are not established by uniform error bounds; freezing is supported semiclassically and numerically. Low temperatures and late-time spread-complexity scaling remain untreated. At finite $e^{S_0}$, the length states are overcomplete and this continuum negativity is not defined, so no finite-entropy negativity prediction follows. No classical-simulation protocol or complexity guarantee is established.

Little sign of AI-generated textIncrementalStrong assumptions

Central claim may not hold: The abstract claims an analytic beyond-all-orders bound on Wigner negativity, but the paper provides only a nonuniform Gaussian expansion without controlling the integrated negative tails needed for that bound. The printed late-time fit 0.08 exp(-4.4/β) misses two reported values by approximately 17% and 11%, contrary to the body's claim of agreement within 7%.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
19 pages, 1 figure, 1 table

Related papers

Wigner negativity, random matrices and gravity

Ritam Basu, Pratyusha Chowdhury, Anirban Ganguly +3 more

A bstract Given a choice of an ordered, orthonormal basis for a D -dimensional Hilbert space, one can define a discrete version of the Wigner function — a quasi-probability distribution which represents any quantum state as a real, normalized function on a discrete phase space. The Wigner function, in general, takes on negative values, and the amount of negativity in the Wigner function gives an operationally meaningful measure of the complexity of simulating the quantum state on a classical computer. Further, Wigner negativity also gives a lower bound on an entropic measure of spread complexity. In this paper, we study the growth of Wigner negativity for a generic initial state under time evolution with chaotic Hamiltonians. In [1], a perturbative argument was given to show that the Krylov basis minimizes the early time growth of Wigner negativity in the large- D limit. Using tools from random matrix theory, here we show that for a generic choice of basis, the Wigner negativity for a classical initial state becomes exponentially large in an O (1) amount of time evolution. On the other hand, we show that in the Krylov basis the negativity grows at most as a power law, and becomes exponentially large only at exponential times. We take this as evidence that the Krylov basis is ideally suited for a dual, semi-classical effective description of chaotic quantum dynamics for large- D at sub-exponential times. For the Gaussian unitary ensemble, this effective description is the q → 0 limit of q -deformed JT gravity.

arXiv:2506.02110•Journal of High Energy Physics•Jan 16, 2026•11 citations

Complexity growth and the Krylov-Wigner function

Ritam Basu, Anirban Ganguly, Souparna Nath +1 more

A bstract For any state in a D -dimensional Hilbert space with a choice of basis, one can define a discrete version of the Wigner function — a quasi-probability distribution which represents the state on a discrete phase space. The Wigner function can, in general, take on negative values, and the amount of negativity in the Wigner function has an operational meaning as a resource for quantum computation. In this note, we study the growth of Wigner negativity for a generic initial state under time evolution with chaotic Hamiltonians. We introduce the Krylov-Wigner function, i.e., the Wigner function defined with respect to the Krylov basis (with appropriate phases), and show that this choice of basis minimizes the early time growth of Wigner negativity in the large D limit. We take this as evidence that the Krylov basis (with appropriate phases) is ideally suited for a dual, semi-classical description of chaotic quantum dynamics at large D . We also numerically study the time evolution of the Krylov-Wigner function and its negativity in random matrix theory for an initial pure state. We observe that the negativity broadly shows three phases: it rises gradually for a time of $$ O\left(\sqrt{D}\right) $$ O D , then hits a sharp ramp and finally saturates close to its upper bound of $$ \sqrt{D} $$ D .

arXiv:2402.13694•Journal of High Energy Physics•May 23, 2024•31 citations

The Normalised Wigner Negativity Rate as a Second-Moment Probe of Infall in AdS$_3$

Ritam Basu

In spread complexity, the growth rate of the average position of a time-evolved state along its Krylov chain recovers the proper radial momentum of an infalling particle in AdS. It is, however, a measure of the first moment only, irrespective of the spread of the wavepacket away from its classical trajectory. The rate of a normalized Krylov-Wigner negativity can be proposed as a diagnostic of the second moment of the boundary state that captures this spreading. Starting with the seed-normalized Krylov-Wigner distribution, that is, the Wigner transform of the descendant cloud with the decaying return amplitude divided out, we obtain an analytic Bessel form in the macroscopic limit and compute its total negativity explicitly. Retaining the Bessel variable all the way through, we find that the negativity goes as $\sinh^{4Δ}(πt/β)$. But the raw normalized-state negativity saturates to an $O(1)$ constant, well below the $O(\sqrt{D})$ bound. Using the exact negative binomial statistics of the Krylov chain, the normalized negativity is at late times a fixed power of the second moment of the Krylov wavepacket, $\mathcal{N}(t)\propto[\mathrm{Var}(\hat{N}_{\mathrm{Krylov}})]^Δ$, for every $Δ>1/2$. The relation linearizes precisely at $Δ=1$. In this regime via the momentum dictionary of Caputa et al. (arXiv:2410.23334), the rate becomes the product of the proper radial position and momentum, $\mathcal{R}\propto\mathcal{C}\,P_ρ$, which we interpret as the rate of the tidal stretch of nearby geodesics falling into the horizon. We also comment briefly on a speculative direction for future research, in particular the interpretation of the transverse string size operator in terms of the Krylov number operator through the common $\mathrm{SU}(1,1)$ discrete series.

hep-thCross-listedarXiv:2607.04065•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jul 7, 2026•3 citations

Complexity growth of operators in the SYK model and in JT gravity

Shao-Kai Jian, Brian G. Swingle, Zhuo-Yu Xian

Abstract The concepts of operator size and computational complexity play important roles in the study of quantum chaos and holographic duality because they help characterize the structure of time-evolving Heisenberg operators. It is particularly important to understand how these microscopically defined measures of complexity are related to notions of complexity defined in terms of a dual holographic geometry, such as complexity-volume (CV) duality. Here we study partially entangled thermal states in the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model and their dual description in terms of operators inserted in the interior of a black hole in Jackiw-Teitelboim (JT) gravity. We compare a microscopic definition of complexity in the SYK model known as K-complexity to calculations using CV duality in JT gravity and find that both quantities show an exponential-to-linear growth behavior. We also calculate the growth of operator size under time evolution and find connections between size and complexity. While the notion of operator size saturates at the scrambling time, our study suggests that complexity, which is well defined in both quantum systems and gravity theories, can serve as a useful measure of operator evolution at both early and late times.

arXiv:2008.12274•Journal of High Energy Physics•Mar 1, 2021•140 citations

Negative energies and the breakdown of bulk geometry

John Preskill, Mykhaylo Usatyuk, Shreya Vardhan

One central question in quantum gravity is to understand how and why predictions from semiclassical gravity can break down in regimes with low spacetime curvature. One diagnostic of such a breakdown is that states which are orthonormal at the semiclassical level can receive large corrections to their inner products from quantum fluctuations. We study this effect by examining inner products in pure 2D JT gravity. Previous work showed that black hole states with long interiors exhibit a breakdown at length scales of order $e^{S_0}$, where $S_0$ is a parameter analogous to $1/G_N$ in higher dimensions. This breakdown is caused by the discreteness of the spectrum of the dual boundary random matrix theory. We show that the full sum over quantum fluctuations indicates a more dramatic breakdown at parametrically shorter lengths of order $e^{S_0/3}$. In the dual boundary description, these corrections arise from negative energy states appearing in rare members of the random matrix ensemble. These results demonstrate that non-perturbative effects can invalidate the semiclassical description at much smaller length scales than previously expected, providing a new mechanism for the breakdown of effective gravitational theories.

hep-thCross-listedarXiv:2603.25782•Mar 30, 2026

Wigner negativity in Krylov space and emergent semiclassicality

Vijay Balasubramanian, Paweł Caputa, Onkar Parrikar +1 more

We propose that the Krylov basis gives a semiclassical representation of dynamics in general large-$N$, complex, many-body systems. As a probe of this semiclassicality, we study the growth of Wigner negativity -- a measure of the complexity of classical simulation -- under time evolution in Krylov space in several solvable models. We begin with 2d CFTs, initially in either the vacuum or the thermofield double state on a line excited by a primary operator. In both cases, Wigner negativity remains an $O(1)$ constant and does not grow at late times, indicating approximately classical dynamics in the Krylov basis. We then study random matrix theory with the maximally entangled state between two copies as the initial state. For general one-cut matrix models, we argue that Wigner negativity in the Krylov basis grows as $t^{1/2}$ at large $O(1)$ times but does not scale with the Hilbert space dimension, thus indicating semiclassical dynamics in Krylov space. Finally, in the double-scaled SYK model, we find an approximately classical phase (constant negativity) at early times and a semiclassical phase ($t^{1/2}$ growth) at late times. In all these examples, Wigner negativity either remains constant or grows slowly, demonstrating emergent semiclassicality of dynamics in Krylov space.

arXiv:2607.01351•Jul 1, 2026•3 citations
The Wigner function, in general, takes on negative values, and the amount of negativity in the Wigner function gives an operationally meaningful measure of the complexity of simulating the quantum state on a classical computer. In this paper, we study the growth of Wigner negativity of the Hartle-Hawking state of Jackiw-Teitelboim gravity under time evolution. We work in the gravitational length basis, at genus zero, and at high temperature, β≪1β\ll 1β≪1. Our main analytic result is simple: to leading order in βββ the state is a Gaussian wavepacket of minimum uncertainty, sitting at rest at the turning point of the Liouville wall. Its Wigner function is therefore positive, and the negativity is 1+δ(β,t)1+δ(β,t)1+δ(β,t), where the correction δδδ is smaller than any power of βββ. We show that δδδ is an even function of time, so there is no linear growth at t=0t=0t=0, and that once the packet has reflected off the wall its leading-order evolution is a Clifford shear, which cannot change the negativity. We also numerically study the time evolution of the Wigner function and its negativity. We observe that δδδ stays below 10−1110^{-11}10−11 at t=0t=0t=0 and through the reflection, then rises slowly over a few tens of β/πβ/πβ/π, and then approaches a late-time value consistent with δ∞(β)≃0.08 e−4.4/βδ_\infty(β) \simeq 0.08\, e^{-4.4/β}δ∞​(β)≃0.08e−4.4/β for 0.25≤β≤10.25 \le β\le 10.25≤β≤1: the lower the temperature, the larger the late-time negativity. The exact survival amplitude Z(β+it)/Z(β)Z(β+it)/Z(β)Z(β+it)/Z(β) fixes the spread complexity to order t4t^4t4, and it also fixes the seed-normalised Wigner diagnostic of our earlier work (arXiv:2607.04065, arXiv:2607.17346). We take this as evidence that the length basis is ideally suited for a dual, semi-classical description of the dynamics at genus zero. Beyond genus zero the length basis is overcomplete, and we make no statement about finite eS0e^{S_0}eS0​.
The paper asks whether Hartle–Hawking dynamics in JT gravity remains nearly Wigner-positive in the gravitational length basis, using continuous-variable Wigner negativity N=∫dx dp ∣W∣\mathcal N=\int dx\,dp\,|W|N=∫dxdp∣W∣ as a basis-dependent diagnostic. It studies genus-zero JT gravity at high temperature, β≪1\beta\ll1β≪1, where the length-space Hamiltonian is H=p2+4e−xH=p^2+4e^{-x}H=p2+4e−x.
A saddle-point calculation gives a leading minimum-uncertainty Gaussian initially at rest at the Liouville-wall turning point, x∗=2log⁡(2β/π)x_*=2\log(2\beta/\pi)x∗​=2log(2β/π), with position variance 2β/π22\beta/\pi^22β/π2. After reflection, the leading packet undergoes a free symplectic shear, which preserves negativity. Time-reversal symmetry and differentiability imply that N(t)\mathcal N(t)N(t) is even and has no linear term at the origin. The semiclassical expansion suggests N=1+δ\mathcal N=1+\deltaN=1+δ with δ\deltaδ smaller than any power of β\betaβ. Numerical propagation for 0.25≤β≤10.25\le\beta\le10.25≤β≤1 finds δ<10−11\delta<10^{-11}δ<10−11 initially and through the main reflection, followed by a slow rise consistent with δ∞≃0.08e−4.4/β\delta_\infty\simeq0.08e^{-4.4/\beta}δ∞​≃0.08e−4.4/β. The exact survival amplitude also determines spread complexity through order t4t^4t4; a seed-normalised Wigner diagnostic grows predominantly because it divides by the decaying survival probability.
The exponentially small negativity and its asymptotic freezing are not established by uniform error bounds; freezing is supported semiclassically and numerically. Low temperatures and late-time spread-complexity scaling remain untreated. At finite eS0e^{S_0}eS0​, the length states are overcomplete and this continuum negativity is not defined, so no finite-entropy negativity prediction follows. No classical-simulation protocol or complexity guarantee is established.
A bstract Given a choice of an ordered, orthonormal basis for a D -dimensional Hilbert space, one can define a discrete version of the Wigner function — a quasi-probability distribution which represents any quantum state as a real, normalized function on a discrete phase space. The Wigner function, in general, takes on negative values, and the amount of negativity in the Wigner function gives an operationally meaningful measure of the complexity of simulating the quantum state on a classical computer. Further, Wigner negativity also gives a lower bound on an entropic measure of spread complexity. In this paper, we study the growth of Wigner negativity for a generic initial state under time evolution with chaotic Hamiltonians. In [1], a perturbative argument was given to show that the Krylov basis minimizes the early time growth of Wigner negativity in the large- D limit. Using tools from random matrix theory, here we show that for a generic choice of basis, the Wigner negativity for a classical initial state becomes exponentially large in an O (1) amount of time evolution. On the other hand, we show that in the Krylov basis the negativity grows at most as a power law, and becomes exponentially large only at exponential times. We take this as evidence that the Krylov basis is ideally suited for a dual, semi-classical effective description of chaotic quantum dynamics for large- D at sub-exponential times. For the Gaussian unitary ensemble, this effective description is the q → 0 limit of q -deformed JT gravity.
A bstract For any state in a D -dimensional Hilbert space with a choice of basis, one can define a discrete version of the Wigner function — a quasi-probability distribution which represents the state on a discrete phase space. The Wigner function can, in general, take on negative values, and the amount of negativity in the Wigner function has an operational meaning as a resource for quantum computation. In this note, we study the growth of Wigner negativity for a generic initial state under time evolution with chaotic Hamiltonians. We introduce the Krylov-Wigner function, i.e., the Wigner function defined with respect to the Krylov basis (with appropriate phases), and show that this choice of basis minimizes the early time growth of Wigner negativity in the large D limit. We take this as evidence that the Krylov basis (with appropriate phases) is ideally suited for a dual, semi-classical description of chaotic quantum dynamics at large D . We also numerically study the time evolution of the Krylov-Wigner function and its negativity in random matrix theory for an initial pure state. We observe that the negativity broadly shows three phases: it rises gradually for a time of O(D) O\left(\sqrt{D}\right) O(D​) O D , then hits a sharp ramp and finally saturates close to its upper bound of D \sqrt{D} D​ D .
The Normalised Wigner Negativity Rate as a Second-Moment Probe of Infall in AdS3_33​
In spread complexity, the growth rate of the average position of a time-evolved state along its Krylov chain recovers the proper radial momentum of an infalling particle in AdS. It is, however, a measure of the first moment only, irrespective of the spread of the wavepacket away from its classical trajectory. The rate of a normalized Krylov-Wigner negativity can be proposed as a diagnostic of the second moment of the boundary state that captures this spreading. Starting with the seed-normalized Krylov-Wigner distribution, that is, the Wigner transform of the descendant cloud with the decaying return amplitude divided out, we obtain an analytic Bessel form in the macroscopic limit and compute its total negativity explicitly. Retaining the Bessel variable all the way through, we find that the negativity goes as sinh⁡4Δ(πt/β)\sinh^{4Δ}(πt/β)sinh4Δ(πt/β). But the raw normalized-state negativity saturates to an O(1)O(1)O(1) constant, well below the O(D)O(\sqrt{D})O(D​) bound. Using the exact negative binomial statistics of the Krylov chain, the normalized negativity is at late times a fixed power of the second moment of the Krylov wavepacket, N(t)∝[Var(N^Krylov)]Δ\mathcal{N}(t)\propto[\mathrm{Var}(\hat{N}_{\mathrm{Krylov}})]^ΔN(t)∝[Var(N^Krylov​)]Δ, for every Δ>1/2Δ>1/2Δ>1/2. The relation linearizes precisely at Δ=1Δ=1Δ=1. In this regime via the momentum dictionary of Caputa et al. (arXiv:2410.23334), the rate becomes the product of the proper radial position and momentum, R∝C Pρ\mathcal{R}\propto\mathcal{C}\,P_ρR∝CPρ​, which we interpret as the rate of the tidal stretch of nearby geodesics falling into the horizon. We also comment briefly on a speculative direction for future research, in particular the interpretation of the transverse string size operator in terms of the Krylov number operator through the common SU(1,1)\mathrm{SU}(1,1)SU(1,1) discrete series.
Abstract The concepts of operator size and computational complexity play important roles in the study of quantum chaos and holographic duality because they help characterize the structure of time-evolving Heisenberg operators. It is particularly important to understand how these microscopically defined measures of complexity are related to notions of complexity defined in terms of a dual holographic geometry, such as complexity-volume (CV) duality. Here we study partially entangled thermal states in the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model and their dual description in terms of operators inserted in the interior of a black hole in Jackiw-Teitelboim (JT) gravity. We compare a microscopic definition of complexity in the SYK model known as K-complexity to calculations using CV duality in JT gravity and find that both quantities show an exponential-to-linear growth behavior. We also calculate the growth of operator size under time evolution and find connections between size and complexity. While the notion of operator size saturates at the scrambling time, our study suggests that complexity, which is well defined in both quantum systems and gravity theories, can serve as a useful measure of operator evolution at both early and late times.
One central question in quantum gravity is to understand how and why predictions from semiclassical gravity can break down in regimes with low spacetime curvature. One diagnostic of such a breakdown is that states which are orthonormal at the semiclassical level can receive large corrections to their inner products from quantum fluctuations. We study this effect by examining inner products in pure 2D JT gravity. Previous work showed that black hole states with long interiors exhibit a breakdown at length scales of order eS0e^{S_0}eS0​, where S0S_0S0​ is a parameter analogous to 1/GN1/G_N1/GN​ in higher dimensions. This breakdown is caused by the discreteness of the spectrum of the dual boundary random matrix theory. We show that the full sum over quantum fluctuations indicates a more dramatic breakdown at parametrically shorter lengths of order eS0/3e^{S_0/3}eS0​/3. In the dual boundary description, these corrections arise from negative energy states appearing in rare members of the random matrix ensemble. These results demonstrate that non-perturbative effects can invalidate the semiclassical description at much smaller length scales than previously expected, providing a new mechanism for the breakdown of effective gravitational theories.
We propose that the Krylov basis gives a semiclassical representation of dynamics in general large-NNN, complex, many-body systems. As a probe of this semiclassicality, we study the growth of Wigner negativity -- a measure of the complexity of classical simulation -- under time evolution in Krylov space in several solvable models. We begin with 2d CFTs, initially in either the vacuum or the thermofield double state on a line excited by a primary operator. In both cases, Wigner negativity remains an O(1)O(1)O(1) constant and does not grow at late times, indicating approximately classical dynamics in the Krylov basis. We then study random matrix theory with the maximally entangled state between two copies as the initial state. For general one-cut matrix models, we argue that Wigner negativity in the Krylov basis grows as t1/2t^{1/2}t1/2 at large O(1)O(1)O(1) times but does not scale with the Hilbert space dimension, thus indicating semiclassical dynamics in Krylov space. Finally, in the double-scaled SYK model, we find an approximately classical phase (constant negativity) at early times and a semiclassical phase (t1/2t^{1/2}t1/2 growth) at late times. In all these examples, Wigner negativity either remains constant or grows slowly, demonstrating emergent semiclassicality of dynamics in Krylov space.