arXiv:2610.00740
Negative quasiprobabilities redistribute (and complex ones reduce) the information in unabsorbed photons
Jonte R. Hance
Abstract
Negative Kirkwood--Dirac quasiprobabilities are credited with the quantum advantage of interaction-free measurement and postselected metrology. We test that claim on the task interaction-free measurement was designed for: learning about a sample letting it absorb as little light as possible. The Kirkwood--Dirac distribution of path and output gives the linear response to a weak sample: its real part responds to absorption, its imaginary part to a phase. For a pure single photon passing once through any interferometer, the Fisher information about transmittance per absorbed photon is the direct-transmission value minus a sum of squared imaginary parts: no interferometer or readout beats direct transmission. Negativity plays no role beyond concentrating information in weakly lit outputs. The imaginary parts of the Kirkwood-Dirac distribution depend on the output basis here, not on the sample, so a basis exists in which every term is real, which is optimal. A single photon gains information per absorbed photon only through a phase response, which for an optical line needs a thick or inhomogeneously broadened sample, or through many passes when absorptions go uncounted, as shown by a critically coupled resonator. For detecting a weak absorber, negativity gives a single-shot advantage that does not accumulate over multiple trials; advantage instead accumulates when there are outputs which are dark without the object, a case which needs no negativity.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether negative Kirkwood–Dirac (KD) quasiprobabilities improve interaction-free sensing when information is normalized by photons absorbed by the sample, rather than photons sent or retained. It distinguishes registered absorption events (known incident photon number) from unregistered losses (known mean flux and output counting). For a pure single photon encountering a non-dispersive absorber once, it derives the exact identity $F_{\mathrm{out}}(t)=P(a)/t-t^{-1}\sum_m[\operatorname{Im}\mathrm{KD}(a,m)]^2/P(m|t)$. Thus information per absorbed photon is at most $1/[t(1-t)]$ for unregistered losses, or $1/[t(1-t)^2]$ with absorption registered. Direct transmission attains both; every pure-input readout with real KD terms also does. Negativity can concentrate information in weak outputs but does not increase the attainable total. The proof decomposes amplitude derivatives into intensity and phase responses; extensions cover mixed inputs and simultaneous absorption estimation. Dispersion adds an attainable phase-information term. With unregistered losses, coherent multipass interference can improve dose efficiency: the analyzed Zeno chain reaches $0.932$ of the registered bound in the weak-loss limit, versus $0.648$ for repeated direct transmission; a resonant, critically coupled ring approaches unity for long wavepackets. Discrimination analysis using Chernoff bounds separates negativity-driven single-shot gains from accumulating dark-port gains; the optimal registered single-pass readout needs no negative KD term. Limitations include nonregular dark-port limits, sensitivity to visibility and detuning, and parameter-dependent optimal settings. Correlated multiphoton multipass probes, partial absorption registration, joint loss–phase estimation, and optimal finite-pass arrangements remain untreated.
Error found: The abstract incorrectly makes optical thickness or inhomogeneous broadening necessary for phase-based gain, although its own Lorentzian formulas give a strictly positive gain for every finite nonzero optical depth. The abstract overstates the disappearance of negativity-assisted repeated-test advantage and the necessity of exactly dark outputs, since sufficiently nearly dark outputs with nonzero absent-object probability can improve the exponent even for weak absorbers.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 17+10 pages, 6 figures