Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.40273

Exponential Quantum Advantage in Numbers-on-Forehead Communication

Haoyu Wang, Pei Wu, Guangxu Yang

cs.CCquant-phSubmitted Sep 30, 2026• Announced Oct 1, 2026• 0 citations• Revised Oct 5, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Sep 30, 2026v2 · Oct 5, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We give the first exponential quantum advantage in the general interactive three-party Numbers-on-Forehead (NOF) model for a decision problem. Previous separations hold only for restricted protocols like one-way communication for a relation. We construct an explicit partial Boolean function, the Interleaved Unitary Product problem, that requires only $O(\log n)$ NOF quantum communication but $\widetildeΩ(n^{1/32})$ randomized communication. This function builds on the two-party unitary product problem of Arunachalam, Girish, and Lifshitz (TQC 2024). The main technical obstacle is that discrepancy, the standard lower-bound method for NOF, also lower-bounds quantum communication. We instead develop a regularity-based argument for randomized NOF lower bounds, building on the approach of Kelley, Lovett, and Meka and adapting the regularity decomposition of Abboud, Fischer, Kelley, Lovett, and Meka (STOC 2024) to cylinder intersections. Combined with matrix-product estimates of Arunachalam, Girish, and Lifshitz, this yields our randomized lower bound.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether exponential quantum communication advantages persist when three players have overlapping inputs in the Numbers-on-Forehead (NOF) model, allowing unrestricted classical interaction. It establishes such a separation for an explicit partial Boolean function, with a quantum protocol using one clean qubit per run. The Interleaved Unitary Product problem encodes ten approximately unitary $m\times m$ matrices across three input blocks. Players distinguish whether the real normalized trace of their ordered product is at least $0.9$ or at most $0.1$. With $n$ bits per block and $m=\Theta(\sqrt{n/\log n})$, the quantum communication cost is $O(\log n)$, whereas every bounded-error randomized NOF protocol requires $\Omega((n/\log n)^{1/32})$ bits. The quantum protocol passes a controlled-unitary trace-estimation register between players, using a constant number of independent runs and no prior entanglement. It also works with disjoint, number-in-hand inputs. The classical lower bound compares independent Haar matrices with a globally correlated distribution whose product is identity; every individual player's view has identical marginals under both distributions. A regularity decomposition splits transcript cylinder intersections into sparse and pseudorandom pieces. Matrix-product estimates and grid-norm moment bounds then yield a corruption inequality, which survives finite-precision encoding and implies the communication lower bound. This avoids discrepancy methods, which also constrain quantum protocols. The separation concerns a promise decision problem and three players, rather than a total function or a general player count. The one-clean-qubit guarantee applies per run; constant-error amplification uses a constant number of runs.

Almost certainly largely AI-generatedAI use disclosed
GPT-5.6 Pro developed the proof of the grid-norm bound

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
27 pages. Minor editorial revisions

Related papers

Exponential Separation of Quantum and Classical One-Way Numbers-on-Forehead Communication

Guangxu Yang, Jiapeng Zhang

Numbers-on-Forehead (NOF) communication model is a central model in communication complexity. As a restricted variant, one-way NOF model is of particular interest. Establishing strong one-way NOF lower bounds would imply circuit lower bounds, resolve well-known problems in additive combinatorics, and yield wide-ranging applications in areas such as cryptography and distributed computing. However, proving strong lower bounds in one-way NOF communication remains highly challenging; many fundamental questions in one-way NOF communication remain wide open. One of the fundamental questions, proposed by Gavinsky and Pudlák (CCC 2008), is to establish an explicit exponential separation between quantum and classical one-way NOF communication. In this paper, we resolve this open problem by establishing the first exponential separation between quantum and randomized communication complexity in one-way NOF model. Specifically, we define a lifted variant of the Hidden Matching problem of Bar-Yossef, Jayram, and Kerenidis (STOC 2004) and show that it admits an ($O(\log n)$)-cost quantum protocol in the one-way NOF setting. By contrast, we prove that any $k$-party one-way randomized protocol for this problem requires communication $Ω(\frac{n^{1/3}}{2^{k/3}})$. Notably, our separation applies even to a generalization of $k$-player one-way communication, where the first player speaks once, and all other $k-1$ players can communicate freely.

quant-pharXiv:2603.22795•Mar 25, 2026•1 citation

Randomized Lifting for One-Way Number-on-Forehead Communication

Chenyu Wang

We prove a lifting theorem from two-party public-coin one-way communication to multiparty public-coin one-way number-on-forehead (NOF) communication. For every fixed $k\ge2$ and prime $q>2k$, there is a generalized inner product gadget $\GIP_{q,r}^k:(\F_q^r)^k\to\F_q$ with $r=O_k(q/\log q)$ such that, for every partial Boolean function $f:D\to\bits$, where $D\subseteq\F_q\times\F_q$, \[ R_{1/3}^1(f)-O(1) \le R_{1/6}^{1,\NOF}\bigl(f\circ\GIP_{q,r}^k\bigr) \le R_{1/6}^1(f). \] Thus, composition with the gadget preserves one-way randomized communication complexity up to an additive constant and a change in the error parameter. The lower bound holds in the general one-way NOF model, where the last player sees the entire gadget input. This extends the deterministic one-way NOF lifting theorem of Yang and Zhang to randomized protocols, and extends the randomized lifting result of Wang and Wu from the conservative model to the general one-way NOF model. Our proof introduces a one-way cylinder partition bound that lower bounds public-coin one-way NOF communication complexity. We show that, for the lifted function, this bound is at least half the one-way partition bound of the outer function. The main technical step transfers a dual solution between the two bounds, using Möbius inversion and a discrepancy estimate for generalized inner product to control the loss. Combining this transfer with the characterization of two-party one-way randomized communication complexity by the one-way partition bound yields the lifting theorem.

arXiv:2609.32542•Sep 26, 2026•0 citations

Quantum versus Classical Separation in Simultaneous Number-on-Forehead Communication

Yang, Guangxu, Zhang, Jiapeng

Quantum versus classical separation plays a central role in understanding the advantages of quantum computation. In this paper, we present the first exponential separation between quantum and bounded-error randomized communication complexity in a variant of the Number-on-Forehead (NOF) model. Namely, the three-player Simultaneous Number-on-Forehead model. Specifically, we introduce the Gadgeted Hidden Matching Problem and show that it can be solved using only $O(\log n)$ simultaneous quantum communication. In contrast, any simultaneous randomized protocol requires $Ω(n^{1/16})$ communication. On the technical side, a key obstacle in separating quantum and classical communication in NOF models is that all known randomized NOF lower bound tools, such as the discrepancy method, typically apply to both randomized and quantum protocols. In this regard, our technique provides a new method for proving randomized lower bounds in the NOF setting and may be of independent interest beyond the separation result.

arXiv:2506.16804•Jun 20, 2025•1 citation

Characterizing Quantum Advantage for Generalizations of the Boolean Hidden Matching Problem

Mark Bun, Joao F. Doriguello, John Kallaugher +1 more

We study the one-way communication complexity of the $f$-Boolean Hidden Partition problem. Here, Alice is given an $n$-bit string and Bob is given $Ω(n)$ disjoint blocks of its indices together with a string of labels. Under the promise that the evaluations of $f$ on these blocks either agree with all of the labels or disagree with all of them, Bob must determine which is the case using a single message from Alice. This problem generalizes the Boolean Hidden Matching and Hidden Hypermatching problems, which capture the special case where $f$ is the parity function. We establish classical and quantum communication bounds for $f$-Boolean Hidden Partition in terms of the sign degree $d$ of $f$, proving a conjecture of Doriguello and Montanaro (TQC 2020). Their prior work gave logarithmic communication upper bounds for classical protocols when $d \le 1$ and quantum protocols when $d \le 2$, as well as polynomial lower bounds for certain structured functions with larger sign degree. We show that for every $f$ of sign degree $d \ge 2$, the randomized classical communication complexity of this problem is $Θ(n^{1-1/d})$ while its quantum communication complexity lies between $Ω(n^{1-2/d})$ and $\bO{n^{1-1/\lceil d/2 \rceil} \log n}$. This completely characterizes the functions $f$ admitting polynomial quantum advantage as those for which $d \ge 2$, with a new infinite family of exponential separations given by the case $d = 2$.

quant-pharXiv:2610.06789•Oct 6, 2026•0 citations

Randomized and Quantum Lifting for One-Way Conservative NOF Model

Haoyu Wang, Pei Wu

We consider lifting theorems that transfer lower bounds for two-party communication problems to multiparty communication problems. In particular, following the deterministic Number-on-Forehead (NOF) lifting framework of Yang and Zhang, we study randomized and quantum one-way NOF lifting for composed problems F(z,𝐱) = f(z,G(𝐱)). We work in a one-way NOF model in which only the last player’s view is restricted. The other players have their usual NOF views and communicate as usual, but the last player sees only the gadget output G(𝐱), not the gadget input 𝐱. This kind of restricted-view has appeared in the NOF literature under the name conservative model. Our main contribution is a pair of lifting theorems for this model. In the randomized setting, we show that lifting follows when each preimage G^{-1}(v), the set of gadget inputs with output v, looks pseudorandom to large cylinder intersections. In the quantum setting, we prove an analogous theorem. Equivalently, conservative protocols for F(z,𝐱) = f(z,G(𝐱)) can be converted into two-party one-way protocols for f(z,v) with comparable cost, and the error loss controlled by the corresponding pseudorandomness parameters. Thus, this restriction isolates a setting in which both randomized and quantum one-way NOF lifting can be proved by a direct simulation argument. We prove the required pseudorandomness properties for the generalized inner product gadget over finite fields, using the multiparty character-sum bounds of Yang and Zhang, and for random gadgets, which give non-explicit lifting. As applications, Boolean Hidden Matching yields a randomized-versus-quantum separation in the conservative NOF model, and lifting INDEX gives randomized and quantum conservative NOF lower bounds for O(log n) players.

Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Lower Bounds on Quantum Multiparty Communication Complexity

Troy Lee, Gideon Schechtman, Adi Shraibman

A major open question in communication complexity is if randomized and quantum communication are polynomially related for all total functions. So far, no gap larger than a power of two is known, despite significant efforts. We examine this question in the number-on-the-forehead model of multiparty communication complexity. We show that essentially all lower bounds known on randomized complexity in this model also hold for quantum communication. This includes bounds of size Omega(n/2k) for the k-party complexity of explicit functions, bounds for the generalized inner product function, and recent work on the multiparty complexity of disjointness. To the best of our knowledge, these are the first lower bounds of any kind on quantum communication in the general number-on-the-forehead model. We show this result in the following way. In the two-party case, there is a lower bound on quantum communication complexity in terms of a norm gamma2, which is known to subsume nearly all other techniques in the literature. For randomized complexity there is another natural bound in terms of a different norm mu which is also one of the strongest techniques available. A deep theorem in functional analysis, Grothendieck's inequality, implies that gamma2and mu are equivalent up to a constant factor. This connection is one of the major obstacles to showing a larger gap between randomized and quantum communication complexity in the two-party case. The lower bound technique in terms of the norm mu was recently extended to the multiparty number-on-the-forehead model. Here we show how the gamma2norm can be also extended to lower bound quantum multiparty complexity. Surprisingly, even in this general setting the two lower bounds, on quantum and classical communication, are still very closely related. This implies that separating quantum and classical communication in this setting will require the development of new techniques. The relation between these extensions of mu and gamma2is proved by a multi-dimensional version of Grothendieck's inequality.

IEEE Conference on Computational Complexity (CCC)•Jul 1, 2009•22 citations
We give the first exponential quantum advantage in the general interactive three-party Numbers-on-Forehead (NOF) model for a decision problem. Previous separations hold only for restricted protocols like one-way communication for a relation. We construct an explicit partial Boolean function, the Interleaved Unitary Product problem, that requires only O(log⁡n)O(\log n)O(logn) NOF quantum communication but Ω~(n1/32)\widetildeΩ(n^{1/32})Ω(n1/32) randomized communication. This function builds on the two-party unitary product problem of Arunachalam, Girish, and Lifshitz (TQC 2024).
The main technical obstacle is that discrepancy, the standard lower-bound method for NOF, also lower-bounds quantum communication. We instead develop a regularity-based argument for randomized NOF lower bounds, building on the approach of Kelley, Lovett, and Meka and adapting the regularity decomposition of Abboud, Fischer, Kelley, Lovett, and Meka (STOC 2024) to cylinder intersections. Combined with matrix-product estimates of Arunachalam, Girish, and Lifshitz, this yields our randomized lower bound.
The paper asks whether exponential quantum communication advantages persist when three players have overlapping inputs in the Numbers-on-Forehead (NOF) model, allowing unrestricted classical interaction. It establishes such a separation for an explicit partial Boolean function, with a quantum protocol using one clean qubit per run.
The Interleaved Unitary Product problem encodes ten approximately unitary m×mm\times mm×m matrices across three input blocks. Players distinguish whether the real normalized trace of their ordered product is at least 0.90.90.9 or at most 0.10.10.1. With nnn bits per block and m=Θ(n/log⁡n)m=\Theta(\sqrt{n/\log n})m=Θ(n/logn​), the quantum communication cost is O(log⁡n)O(\log n)O(logn), whereas every bounded-error randomized NOF protocol requires Ω((n/log⁡n)1/32)\Omega((n/\log n)^{1/32})Ω((n/logn)1/32) bits. The quantum protocol passes a controlled-unitary trace-estimation register between players, using a constant number of independent runs and no prior entanglement. It also works with disjoint, number-in-hand inputs.
The classical lower bound compares independent Haar matrices with a globally correlated distribution whose product is identity; every individual player's view has identical marginals under both distributions. A regularity decomposition splits transcript cylinder intersections into sparse and pseudorandom pieces. Matrix-product estimates and grid-norm moment bounds then yield a corruption inequality, which survives finite-precision encoding and implies the communication lower bound. This avoids discrepancy methods, which also constrain quantum protocols.
The separation concerns a promise decision problem and three players, rather than a total function or a general player count. The one-clean-qubit guarantee applies per run; constant-error amplification uses a constant number of runs.
Numbers-on-Forehead (NOF) communication model is a central model in communication complexity. As a restricted variant, one-way NOF model is of particular interest. Establishing strong one-way NOF lower bounds would imply circuit lower bounds, resolve well-known problems in additive combinatorics, and yield wide-ranging applications in areas such as cryptography and distributed computing. However, proving strong lower bounds in one-way NOF communication remains highly challenging; many fundamental questions in one-way NOF communication remain wide open. One of the fundamental questions, proposed by Gavinsky and Pudlák (CCC 2008), is to establish an explicit exponential separation between quantum and classical one-way NOF communication. In this paper, we resolve this open problem by establishing the first exponential separation between quantum and randomized communication complexity in one-way NOF model. Specifically, we define a lifted variant of the Hidden Matching problem of Bar-Yossef, Jayram, and Kerenidis (STOC 2004) and show that it admits an (O(log⁡n)O(\log n)O(logn))-cost quantum protocol in the one-way NOF setting. By contrast, we prove that any kkk-party one-way randomized protocol for this problem requires communication Ω(n1/32k/3)Ω(\frac{n^{1/3}}{2^{k/3}})Ω(2k/3n1/3​). Notably, our separation applies even to a generalization of kkk-player one-way communication, where the first player speaks once, and all other k−1k-1k−1 players can communicate freely.
We prove a lifting theorem from two-party public-coin one-way communication to multiparty public-coin one-way number-on-forehead (NOF) communication. For every fixed k≥2k\ge2k≥2 and prime q>2kq>2kq>2k, there is a generalized inner product gadget $\GIP_{q,r}^k:(\F_q^r)^k\to\F_q$ with r=Ok(q/log⁡q)r=O_k(q/\log q)r=Ok​(q/logq) such that, for every partial Boolean function $f:D\to\bits$, where $D\subseteq\F_q\times\F_q$, \[ R_{1/3}^1(f)-O(1) \le R_{1/6}^{1,\NOF}\bigl(f\circ\GIP_{q,r}^k\bigr) \le R_{1/6}^1(f). \] Thus, composition with the gadget preserves one-way randomized communication complexity up to an additive constant and a change in the error parameter. The lower bound holds in the general one-way NOF model, where the last player sees the entire gadget input. This extends the deterministic one-way NOF lifting theorem of Yang and Zhang to randomized protocols, and extends the randomized lifting result of Wang and Wu from the conservative model to the general one-way NOF model. Our proof introduces a one-way cylinder partition bound that lower bounds public-coin one-way NOF communication complexity. We show that, for the lifted function, this bound is at least half the one-way partition bound of the outer function. The main technical step transfers a dual solution between the two bounds, using Möbius inversion and a discrepancy estimate for generalized inner product to control the loss. Combining this transfer with the characterization of two-party one-way randomized communication complexity by the one-way partition bound yields the lifting theorem.
Quantum versus classical separation plays a central role in understanding the advantages of quantum computation. In this paper, we present the first exponential separation between quantum and bounded-error randomized communication complexity in a variant of the Number-on-Forehead (NOF) model. Namely, the three-player Simultaneous Number-on-Forehead model. Specifically, we introduce the Gadgeted Hidden Matching Problem and show that it can be solved using only O(log⁡n)O(\log n)O(logn) simultaneous quantum communication. In contrast, any simultaneous randomized protocol requires Ω(n1/16)Ω(n^{1/16})Ω(n1/16) communication. On the technical side, a key obstacle in separating quantum and classical communication in NOF models is that all known randomized NOF lower bound tools, such as the discrepancy method, typically apply to both randomized and quantum protocols. In this regard, our technique provides a new method for proving randomized lower bounds in the NOF setting and may be of independent interest beyond the separation result.
We study the one-way communication complexity of the fff-Boolean Hidden Partition problem. Here, Alice is given an nnn-bit string and Bob is given Ω(n)Ω(n)Ω(n) disjoint blocks of its indices together with a string of labels. Under the promise that the evaluations of fff on these blocks either agree with all of the labels or disagree with all of them, Bob must determine which is the case using a single message from Alice. This problem generalizes the Boolean Hidden Matching and Hidden Hypermatching problems, which capture the special case where fff is the parity function. We establish classical and quantum communication bounds for fff-Boolean Hidden Partition in terms of the sign degree ddd of fff, proving a conjecture of Doriguello and Montanaro (TQC 2020). Their prior work gave logarithmic communication upper bounds for classical protocols when d≤1d \le 1d≤1 and quantum protocols when d≤2d \le 2d≤2, as well as polynomial lower bounds for certain structured functions with larger sign degree. We show that for every fff of sign degree d≥2d \ge 2d≥2, the randomized classical communication complexity of this problem is Θ(n1−1/d)Θ(n^{1-1/d})Θ(n1−1/d) while its quantum communication complexity lies between Ω(n1−2/d)Ω(n^{1-2/d})Ω(n1−2/d) and $\bO{n^{1-1/\lceil d/2 \rceil} \log n}$. This completely characterizes the functions fff admitting polynomial quantum advantage as those for which d≥2d \ge 2d≥2, with a new infinite family of exponential separations given by the case d=2d = 2d=2.
We consider lifting theorems that transfer lower bounds for two-party communication problems to multiparty communication problems. In particular, following the deterministic Number-on-Forehead (NOF) lifting framework of Yang and Zhang, we study randomized and quantum one-way NOF lifting for composed problems F(z,𝐱) = f(z,G(𝐱)). We work in a one-way NOF model in which only the last player’s view is restricted. The other players have their usual NOF views and communicate as usual, but the last player sees only the gadget output G(𝐱), not the gadget input 𝐱. This kind of restricted-view has appeared in the NOF literature under the name conservative model. Our main contribution is a pair of lifting theorems for this model. In the randomized setting, we show that lifting follows when each preimage G^{-1}(v), the set of gadget inputs with output v, looks pseudorandom to large cylinder intersections. In the quantum setting, we prove an analogous theorem. Equivalently, conservative protocols for F(z,𝐱) = f(z,G(𝐱)) can be converted into two-party one-way protocols for f(z,v) with comparable cost, and the error loss controlled by the corresponding pseudorandomness parameters. Thus, this restriction isolates a setting in which both randomized and quantum one-way NOF lifting can be proved by a direct simulation argument. We prove the required pseudorandomness properties for the generalized inner product gadget over finite fields, using the multiparty character-sum bounds of Yang and Zhang, and for random gadgets, which give non-explicit lifting. As applications, Boolean Hidden Matching yields a randomized-versus-quantum separation in the conservative NOF model, and lifting INDEX gives randomized and quantum conservative NOF lower bounds for O(log n) players.
A major open question in communication complexity is if randomized and quantum communication are polynomially related for all total functions. So far, no gap larger than a power of two is known, despite significant efforts. We examine this question in the number-on-the-forehead model of multiparty communication complexity. We show that essentially all lower bounds known on randomized complexity in this model also hold for quantum communication. This includes bounds of size Omega(n/2k) for the k-party complexity of explicit functions, bounds for the generalized inner product function, and recent work on the multiparty complexity of disjointness. To the best of our knowledge, these are the first lower bounds of any kind on quantum communication in the general number-on-the-forehead model. We show this result in the following way. In the two-party case, there is a lower bound on quantum communication complexity in terms of a norm gamma2, which is known to subsume nearly all other techniques in the literature. For randomized complexity there is another natural bound in terms of a different norm mu which is also one of the strongest techniques available. A deep theorem in functional analysis, Grothendieck's inequality, implies that gamma2and mu are equivalent up to a constant factor. This connection is one of the major obstacles to showing a larger gap between randomized and quantum communication complexity in the two-party case. The lower bound technique in terms of the norm mu was recently extended to the multiparty number-on-the-forehead model. Here we show how the gamma2norm can be also extended to lower bound quantum multiparty complexity. Surprisingly, even in this general setting the two lower bounds, on quantum and classical communication, are still very closely related. This implies that separating quantum and classical communication in this setting will require the development of new techniques. The relation between these extensions of mu and gamma2is proved by a multi-dimensional version of Grothendieck's inequality.