Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.39918

Verifiable quantum advantage based on polynomials with planted structures

Markus Bläser, Michael Gullans, Dominik Hangleiter, Yuxuan Liu, Youming Qiao

quant-phcs.CCcs.CRcs.DSSubmitted Sep 30, 2026• Announced Oct 1, 2026• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A central question in the theory of quantum advantage is whether there are quantum advantage protocols with similar resource requirements as random circuit sampling that are also verifiable just from the classical outputs of the quantum computation. Here, we develop the idea of simulation secrets for verifiable advantage. A verifier can use a simulation secret to evaluate a cross-entropy test faster than it would take a classical adversary to pass the test. We instantiate this idea using IQP circuits described by cubic polynomials with planted independent spaces. These correspond to the largest independent set in the orbit of a polynomial under the general linear group and yield a low-rank stabilizer decomposition of the corresponding state. We conjecture that large independent spaces are invisible to a computationally bounded adversary, and therefore they cannot exploit them to pass the protocol. A second conjecture regards the fine-grained complexity of producing samples that pass the cross-entropy test for uniformly random polynomials. Under these conjectures, our scheme results in a polynomial gap between the verification time and the time a classical adversary would need to pass the protocol---both are exponential. It has a potential application to generating classically certifiable randomness, since the output distributions have high min-entropy. We estimate that the planted polynomial scheme is implementable using 100 logical qubits at logical error rates around $10^{-6}$.

AI Summary

Can sampling-based quantum advantage be verified from classical outputs without verification costing as much as classical spoofing? This paper proposes “simulation secrets”: hidden circuit structure that accelerates probability evaluation for XEB verification. Its construction uses cubic Boolean-polynomial IQP circuits with a planted $h$-dimensional independent space, on which the polynomial restricts to degree at most two, hidden by a random invertible linear transformation. Knowing the space permits exact amplitude computation in $O(n^3 2^{n-h})$ time and polynomial space, by summing quadratic-polynomial gaps over complementary variables. Under two fine-grained conjectures—sub-$2^n$ indistinguishability of planted and uniform polynomials for $h\le(1/2-\epsilon)n$, and polynomial-space hardness of achieving XEB at time below $2^{\kappa n}$ for some $\kappa>1/2$—verification takes $\widetilde O(2^{cn})$ while classical spoofing requires $\Omega(2^{\kappa n})$, with $1/2<c<\kappa$. The average ideal XEB is $2+o(1)$; acceptance uses threshold $1$. Supporting results include NP-completeness of finding sufficiently large independent spaces, via slice-rank reductions, and a rank-profile attack recovering planted spaces in $\widetilde O(2^{n-h})$ time when $h\ge(1/2+\epsilon)n$. Moment calculations establish sample-efficient completeness and high output min-entropy. Both verification and the conjectured classical attack cost remain exponential; the gap is polynomial and assumes polynomial-space adversaries. Security rests on new conjectures, not worst-case hardness alone. Certified randomness is treated only through a conditional single-round Shannon-entropy bound without adversarial side information; full security is deferred. Estimated implementation requirements are around 100 logical qubits and logical error rates near $10^{-6}$.

No sign of AI-generated textAI use disclosedStrong assumptionsOverclaims
We used generative AI of various generations for assistance in proving lemmas, checking technical correctness, and for feedback on earlier versions of the draft.

Central claim may not hold: The abstract's verification-versus-adversary time-gap claim omits the polynomial-space restriction required by its hardness conjecture and main theorem. The estimate of implementation with 100 logical qubits at logical error rates around 10^-6 is not supported by a resource or noise analysis connecting those parameters to successful XEB verification.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
44 pages, 1 figure. Comments welcome

Related papers

Peaked quantum advantage using error correction

Abhinav Deshpande, Bill Fefferman, Soumik Ghosh +2 more

A key issue of current quantum advantage experiments is that their verification requires a full classical simulation of the ideal computation. This limits the regime in which the experiments can be verified to precisely the regime in which they are also simulatable. An important outstanding question is therefore to find quantum advantage schemes that are also classically verifiable. We make progress on this question by designing a new quantum advantage proposal--Hidden Code Sampling--whose output distribution is conditionally peaked. These peaks enable verification in far less time than it takes for full simulation. At the same time, we show that exactly sampling from the output distribution is classically hard unless the polynomial hierarchy collapses, and we propose a plausible conjecture regarding average-case hardness. Our scheme is based on ideas from quantum error correction. The required quantum computations are closely related to quantum fault-tolerant circuits and can potentially be implemented transversally. Our proposal may thus give rise to a next generation of quantum advantage experiments en route to full quantum fault tolerance.

•Oct 6, 2025•0 citations

Instantaneous Quantum Polynomial-Time Sampling and Verifiable Quantum Advantage: Stabilizer Scheme and Classical Security

Michael J. Bremner, Bin Cheng, Zhengfeng Ji

Sampling problems demonstrating beyond classical computing power with noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices have been experimentally realized. In those realizations, however, our trust that the quantum devices faithfully solve the claimed sampling problems is usually limited to simulations of smaller-scale instances and is, therefore, indirect. The problem of verifiable quantum advantage aims to resolve this critical issue and provides us with greater confidence in a claimed advantage. Instantaneous quantum polynomial-time (IQP) sampling has been proposed to achieve beyond classical capabilities with a verifiable scheme based on quadratic-residue codes (QRC). Unfortunately, this verification scheme was recently broken by an attack proposed by Kahanamoku-Meyer. In this work, we revive IQP-based verifiable quantum advantage by making two major contributions. Firstly, we introduce a family of IQP sampling protocols called the , which builds on results linking IQP circuits, the stabilizer formalism, coding theory, and an efficient characterization of IQP-circuit correlation functions. This construction extends the scope of existing IQP-based schemes while maintaining their simplicity and verifiability. Secondly, we introduce the (HSC) problem as a well-defined mathematical challenge that underlies the stabilizer scheme. To assess classical security, we explore a class of attacks based on secret extraction, including Kahanamoku-Meyer’s attack as a special case. We provide evidence of the security of the stabilizer scheme, assuming the hardness of the HSC problem. We also point out that the vulnerability observed in the original QRC scheme is primarily attributed to inappropriate parameter choices, which can be naturally rectified with proper parameter settings.

arXiv:2308.07152•PRX Quantum•Apr 22, 2025•12 citations

Classically simulating intermediate-scale instantaneous quantum polynomial circuits through a random graph approach

Julien Codsi, John van de Wetering

Quantum advantage is a demonstration of a computation by a quantum computer that cannot be performed by the best classical computer in a reasonable time. A well-studied approach to demonstrating this on near-term quantum computers is to use random circuit sampling. It has been suggested that a good candidate for demonstrating quantum advantage with random circuit sampling is to use instantaneous quantum polynomial (IQP) circuits. These are quantum circuits where the unitary it implements is diagonal. In this paper, we introduce improved techniques for exactly classically simulating random IQP circuits. We find a simple algorithm to calculate an amplitude of an $n$-qubit IQP circuit with dense random two-qubit interactions in time $O(\frac{{log}^{2}n}{n}{2}^{n})$, which for sparse circuits (where each qubit interacts with $O(logn)$ other qubits) runs in $o({2}^{n}/\mathrm{poly}(n))$ for any given polynomial. Using a more complicated stabilizer decomposition approach we improve the algorithm for dense circuits to $O(\frac{{(logn)}^{4\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\beta}}}{{n}^{2\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\beta}}}{2}^{n})$ where $\ensuremath{\beta}\ensuremath{\approx}0.396$. We further discuss how our techniques also lead to improved simulation times for IQP circuits on restricted architectures. We benchmarked our main algorithm and found that we can simulate up to 50-qubit circuits in a couple of minutes on a laptop, with 68-qubit sparse circuits taking a couple of hours. We estimate dense 70-qubit circuits are in range for large computing clusters.

arXiv:2212.08609•Physical Review A•Jan 14, 2025•21 citations

Forging quantum data: classically defeating an IQP-based quantum test

Gregory D. Kahanamoku–Meyer

Recently, quantum computing experiments have for the first time exceeded the capability of classical computers to perform certain computations – a milestone termed "quantum computational advantage." However, verifying the output of the quantum device in these experiments required extremely large classical computations. An exciting next step for demonstrating quantum capability would be to implement tests of quantum computational advantage with efficient classical verification, such that larger system sizes can be tested and verified. One of the first proposals for an efficiently-verifiable test of quantumness consists of hiding a secret classical bitstring inside a circuit of the class IQP, in such a way that samples from the circuit's output distribution are correlated with the secret. The classical hardness of this protocol has been supported by evidence that directly simulating IQP circuits is hard, but the security of the protocol against other (non-simulating) classical attacks has remained an open question. In this work we demonstrate that the protocol is not secure against classical forgery. We describe a classical algorithm that can not only convince the verifier that the (classical) prover is quantum, but can in fact can extract the secret key underlying a given protocol instance. Furthermore, we show that the key extraction algorithm is efficient in practice for problem sizes of hundreds of qubits. Finally, we provide an implementation of the algorithm, and give the secret vector underlying the "\$25 challenge" posted online by the authors of the original paper.

arXiv:1912.05547•Quantum•Sep 11, 2023•23 citations

On verifiable quantum advantage with peaked circuit sampling

Scott Aaronson, Yuxuan Zhang

Over a decade after its proposal, the idea of using quantum computers to sample hard distributions has remained a key path to demonstrating quantum advantage. Yet a severe drawback remains: verification seems to require classical computation exponential in the system size, $n$. As an attempt to overcome this difficulty, we propose a new candidate for quantum advantage experiments with otherwise random "peaked circuits", i.e., quantum circuits whose outputs have high concentrations on a computational basis state. Naturally, the heavy output string can be used for classical verification. In this work, we analytically and numerically study an explicit model of peaked circuits, in which $τ_r$ layers of uniformly random gates are augmented by $τ_p$ layers of gates that are optimized to maximize peakedness. We show that getting $1/\text{poly}(n)$ peakedness from such circuits requires $τ_{p} = Ω((τ_r/n)^{0.19})$ with overwhelming probability. However, we also give numerical evidence that nontrivial peakedness is possible in this model -- decaying exponentially with the number of qubits, but more than can be explained by any approximation where the output of a random quantum circuit is treated as a Haar-random state. This suggests that these peaked circuits have the potential for future verifiable quantum advantage experiments. Our work raises numerous open questions about random peaked circuits, including how to generate them efficiently, and whether they can be distinguished from fully random circuits in classical polynomial time.

arXiv:2404.14493•Apr 22, 2024•38 citations

Classical Verification of Quantum Advantage via Clifford Obfuscation

Bin Yan

Demonstrating quantum advantage in a manner that can be independently verified by classical means remains one of the most pressing open problems in quantum computing. Here we propose a new heuristic approach for constructing quantum circuits that are hard to classically simulate yet whose output distributions can be efficiently verified classically. Our approach is based on Clifford circuit obfuscation. This obfuscation scheme hides the Clifford structure and injects a controlled and rapidly growing non-stabilizer resources that resist known classical attack strategies including reverse engineering and direct simulation. Our protocol is heuristic but is supported by both numerical and theoretical evidence. This work provides a new avenue toward classically verifiable quantum advantage that avoids the stringent implementation requirements of known approaches.

quant-pharXiv:2608.15963•Aug 18, 2026•1 citation
A central question in the theory of quantum advantage is whether there are quantum advantage protocols with similar resource requirements as random circuit sampling that are also verifiable just from the classical outputs of the quantum computation. Here, we develop the idea of simulation secrets for verifiable advantage. A verifier can use a simulation secret to evaluate a cross-entropy test faster than it would take a classical adversary to pass the test. We instantiate this idea using IQP circuits described by cubic polynomials with planted independent spaces. These correspond to the largest independent set in the orbit of a polynomial under the general linear group and yield a low-rank stabilizer decomposition of the corresponding state. We conjecture that large independent spaces are invisible to a computationally bounded adversary, and therefore they cannot exploit them to pass the protocol. A second conjecture regards the fine-grained complexity of producing samples that pass the cross-entropy test for uniformly random polynomials. Under these conjectures, our scheme results in a polynomial gap between the verification time and the time a classical adversary would need to pass the protocol---both are exponential. It has a potential application to generating classically certifiable randomness, since the output distributions have high min-entropy. We estimate that the planted polynomial scheme is implementable using 100 logical qubits at logical error rates around 10−610^{-6}10−6.
Can sampling-based quantum advantage be verified from classical outputs without verification costing as much as classical spoofing? This paper proposes “simulation secrets”: hidden circuit structure that accelerates probability evaluation for XEB verification. Its construction uses cubic Boolean-polynomial IQP circuits with a planted hhh-dimensional independent space, on which the polynomial restricts to degree at most two, hidden by a random invertible linear transformation.
Knowing the space permits exact amplitude computation in O(n32n−h)O(n^3 2^{n-h})O(n32n−h) time and polynomial space, by summing quadratic-polynomial gaps over complementary variables. Under two fine-grained conjectures—sub-2n2^n2n indistinguishability of planted and uniform polynomials for h≤(1/2−ϵ)nh\le(1/2-\epsilon)nh≤(1/2−ϵ)n, and polynomial-space hardness of achieving XEB at time below 2κn2^{\kappa n}2κn for some κ>1/2\kappa>1/2κ>1/2—verification takes O~(2cn)\widetilde O(2^{cn})O(2cn) while classical spoofing requires Ω(2κn)\Omega(2^{\kappa n})Ω(2κn), with 1/2<c<κ1/2<c<\kappa1/2<c<κ. The average ideal XEB is 2+o(1)2+o(1)2+o(1); acceptance uses threshold 111.
Supporting results include NP-completeness of finding sufficiently large independent spaces, via slice-rank reductions, and a rank-profile attack recovering planted spaces in O~(2n−h)\widetilde O(2^{n-h})O(2n−h) time when h≥(1/2+ϵ)nh\ge(1/2+\epsilon)nh≥(1/2+ϵ)n. Moment calculations establish sample-efficient completeness and high output min-entropy.
Both verification and the conjectured classical attack cost remain exponential; the gap is polynomial and assumes polynomial-space adversaries. Security rests on new conjectures, not worst-case hardness alone. Certified randomness is treated only through a conditional single-round Shannon-entropy bound without adversarial side information; full security is deferred. Estimated implementation requirements are around 100 logical qubits and logical error rates near 10−610^{-6}10−6.
A key issue of current quantum advantage experiments is that their verification requires a full classical simulation of the ideal computation. This limits the regime in which the experiments can be verified to precisely the regime in which they are also simulatable. An important outstanding question is therefore to find quantum advantage schemes that are also classically verifiable. We make progress on this question by designing a new quantum advantage proposal--Hidden Code Sampling--whose output distribution is conditionally peaked. These peaks enable verification in far less time than it takes for full simulation. At the same time, we show that exactly sampling from the output distribution is classically hard unless the polynomial hierarchy collapses, and we propose a plausible conjecture regarding average-case hardness. Our scheme is based on ideas from quantum error correction. The required quantum computations are closely related to quantum fault-tolerant circuits and can potentially be implemented transversally. Our proposal may thus give rise to a next generation of quantum advantage experiments en route to full quantum fault tolerance.
Sampling problems demonstrating beyond classical computing power with noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices have been experimentally realized. In those realizations, however, our trust that the quantum devices faithfully solve the claimed sampling problems is usually limited to simulations of smaller-scale instances and is, therefore, indirect. The problem of verifiable quantum advantage aims to resolve this critical issue and provides us with greater confidence in a claimed advantage. Instantaneous quantum polynomial-time (IQP) sampling has been proposed to achieve beyond classical capabilities with a verifiable scheme based on quadratic-residue codes (QRC). Unfortunately, this verification scheme was recently broken by an attack proposed by Kahanamoku-Meyer. In this work, we revive IQP-based verifiable quantum advantage by making two major contributions. Firstly, we introduce a family of IQP sampling protocols called the , which builds on results linking IQP circuits, the stabilizer formalism, coding theory, and an efficient characterization of IQP-circuit correlation functions. This construction extends the scope of existing IQP-based schemes while maintaining their simplicity and verifiability. Secondly, we introduce the (HSC) problem as a well-defined mathematical challenge that underlies the stabilizer scheme. To assess classical security, we explore a class of attacks based on secret extraction, including Kahanamoku-Meyer’s attack as a special case. We provide evidence of the security of the stabilizer scheme, assuming the hardness of the HSC problem. We also point out that the vulnerability observed in the original QRC scheme is primarily attributed to inappropriate parameter choices, which can be naturally rectified with proper parameter settings.
Quantum advantage is a demonstration of a computation by a quantum computer that cannot be performed by the best classical computer in a reasonable time. A well-studied approach to demonstrating this on near-term quantum computers is to use random circuit sampling. It has been suggested that a good candidate for demonstrating quantum advantage with random circuit sampling is to use instantaneous quantum polynomial (IQP) circuits. These are quantum circuits where the unitary it implements is diagonal. In this paper, we introduce improved techniques for exactly classically simulating random IQP circuits. We find a simple algorithm to calculate an amplitude of an nnn-qubit IQP circuit with dense random two-qubit interactions in time O(log2nn2n)O(\frac{{log}^{2}n}{n}{2}^{n})O(nlog2n​2n), which for sparse circuits (where each qubit interacts with O(logn)O(logn)O(logn) other qubits) runs in o(2n/poly(n))o({2}^{n}/\mathrm{poly}(n))o(2n/poly(n)) for any given polynomial. Using a more complicated stabilizer decomposition approach we improve the algorithm for dense circuits to $O(\frac{{(logn)}^{4\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\beta}}}{{n}^{2\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\beta}}}{2}^{n})$ where $\ensuremath{\beta}\ensuremath{\approx}0.396$. We further discuss how our techniques also lead to improved simulation times for IQP circuits on restricted architectures. We benchmarked our main algorithm and found that we can simulate up to 50-qubit circuits in a couple of minutes on a laptop, with 68-qubit sparse circuits taking a couple of hours. We estimate dense 70-qubit circuits are in range for large computing clusters.
Recently, quantum computing experiments have for the first time exceeded the capability of classical computers to perform certain computations – a milestone termed "quantum computational advantage." However, verifying the output of the quantum device in these experiments required extremely large classical computations. An exciting next step for demonstrating quantum capability would be to implement tests of quantum computational advantage with efficient classical verification, such that larger system sizes can be tested and verified. One of the first proposals for an efficiently-verifiable test of quantumness consists of hiding a secret classical bitstring inside a circuit of the class IQP, in such a way that samples from the circuit's output distribution are correlated with the secret. The classical hardness of this protocol has been supported by evidence that directly simulating IQP circuits is hard, but the security of the protocol against other (non-simulating) classical attacks has remained an open question. In this work we demonstrate that the protocol is not secure against classical forgery. We describe a classical algorithm that can not only convince the verifier that the (classical) prover is quantum, but can in fact can extract the secret key underlying a given protocol instance. Furthermore, we show that the key extraction algorithm is efficient in practice for problem sizes of hundreds of qubits. Finally, we provide an implementation of the algorithm, and give the secret vector underlying the "$25 challenge" posted online by the authors of the original paper.
Over a decade after its proposal, the idea of using quantum computers to sample hard distributions has remained a key path to demonstrating quantum advantage. Yet a severe drawback remains: verification seems to require classical computation exponential in the system size, nnn. As an attempt to overcome this difficulty, we propose a new candidate for quantum advantage experiments with otherwise random "peaked circuits", i.e., quantum circuits whose outputs have high concentrations on a computational basis state. Naturally, the heavy output string can be used for classical verification. In this work, we analytically and numerically study an explicit model of peaked circuits, in which τrτ_rτr​ layers of uniformly random gates are augmented by τpτ_pτp​ layers of gates that are optimized to maximize peakedness. We show that getting 1/poly(n)1/\text{poly}(n)1/poly(n) peakedness from such circuits requires τp=Ω((τr/n)0.19)τ_{p} = Ω((τ_r/n)^{0.19})τp​=Ω((τr​/n)0.19) with overwhelming probability. However, we also give numerical evidence that nontrivial peakedness is possible in this model -- decaying exponentially with the number of qubits, but more than can be explained by any approximation where the output of a random quantum circuit is treated as a Haar-random state. This suggests that these peaked circuits have the potential for future verifiable quantum advantage experiments. Our work raises numerous open questions about random peaked circuits, including how to generate them efficiently, and whether they can be distinguished from fully random circuits in classical polynomial time.
Demonstrating quantum advantage in a manner that can be independently verified by classical means remains one of the most pressing open problems in quantum computing. Here we propose a new heuristic approach for constructing quantum circuits that are hard to classically simulate yet whose output distributions can be efficiently verified classically. Our approach is based on Clifford circuit obfuscation. This obfuscation scheme hides the Clifford structure and injects a controlled and rapidly growing non-stabilizer resources that resist known classical attack strategies including reverse engineering and direct simulation. Our protocol is heuristic but is supported by both numerical and theoretical evidence. This work provides a new avenue toward classically verifiable quantum advantage that avoids the stringent implementation requirements of known approaches.