Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.38441

Classical Verifier Position Verification from Non-Local Games

Wen Yu Kon, Fatih Kaleoglu, Kaushik Chakraborty

quant-phSubmitted Sep 29, 2026• Announced Oct 1, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Secure position verification certifies that a remote prover occupies a claimed location, a task that is provably impossible with classical resources alone against colluding adversaries. Most existing quantum position verification schemes require transmitting quantum states between verifiers and provers, and the resulting photon loss makes long-distance verification impractical. Classical verifier position verification (CVPV) schemes with classical verifier-prover communication exist, but rely on complex quantum processes that generate certifiable randomness, placing them outside the reach of near-term hardware. Here we introduce a general compiler that maps any complete-support non-local game with the required quantum advantage into a multi-prover CVPV protocol. This addresses both limitations, with entirely classical verifier-prover communication and all quantum resources confined to shared entanglement and local measurements on the prover devices. Instantiating with the CHSH game enables near-term implementation on existing experimental platforms. We prove finite-size security in the quantum random oracle model for both simultaneous verification of multiple provers and verification of a single prover with multiple prover devices. Notably, security in the multi-prover setting is governed not by the certified randomness of the joint provers' outputs, but by certified blind local randomness that depends critically on the spatial arrangement of provers and verifiers.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether quantum position verification can use entirely classical verifier–prover communication without requiring complex quantum computation at the prover. It constructs a compiler from complete-support non-local games to protocols with multiple separated prover devices sharing entanglement and performing local measurements. Verifiers split challenges into shares, combine them through random-oracle hashes, and check both the game score and consistency of responses delivered within location-dependent deadlines. Finite-size soundness is proved in the quantum random oracle model against sequential adversaries with bounded oracle queries, allowing quantum memory across rounds. Security requires geometric conditions isolating each scored response from foreign inputs and forcing another response copy to be guessed without its generating system. The proof reduces spacetime attacks to non-local-game strategies, derives score–mismatch tradeoffs from multipartite blind local randomness, and applies concentration bounds. When adversaries may occupy all but one prover location, the score must exceed the optimum with one classical player; under stronger protected-region and geometric restrictions, exceeding the fully classical optimum suffices. For CHSH, both models admit the analytical bound $p_{\mathrm{mis}}\geq\frac{8}{9}(\omega-3/4)^2$, with tighter numerical SDP bounds. A GHZ-based attack shows that quantum advantage and global output randomness alone do not ensure security: the accessible side information depends on geometry. Complete-support modification or geometric changes can restore security in the discussed examples. No implementation is reported. The proofs idealize processing delays; quantitative security geometry, positional uncertainty, minimum device separation, and practical timing and transmission imperfections remain open.

Little sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsStrong assumptions

Central claim may not hold: The compiler samples independent uniform game inputs rather than the arbitrary joint distribution assumed in its theorems, and this change can eliminate a game's quantum advantage. The QROM soundness penalty incorrectly depends on hash output length instead of the length of an unrevealed challenge share. The near-term secure-implementation claim lacks a completed security analysis incorporating nonzero prover processing time.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Related papers

Practically secure quantum position verification

Siddhartha Das, George Siopsis

Abstract We discuss quantum position verification (QPV) protocols in which the verifiers create and send single-qubit states to the prover. QPV protocols using single-qubit states are known to be insecure against adversaries that share a small number of entangled qubits. We introduce QPV protocols that are practically secure: they only require single-qubit states from each of the verifiers, yet their security is broken if the adversaries sharing an impractically large number of entangled qubits employ teleportation-based attacks. These protocols are a modification of known QPV protocols in which we include a classical random oracle without altering the amount of quantum resources needed by the verifiers. We present a cheating strategy that requires a number of entangled qubits shared among the adversaries that grows exponentially with the size of the classical input of the random oracle.

arXiv:1711.03392•New Journal of Physics•Jun 1, 2021•11 citations

On the equivalence between classically verifiable position verification and certified randomness

Fatih Kaleoglu, Minzhao Liu, David Cui +4 more

Gate-based quantum computers can accelerate computational tasks beyond classical capabilities. Random circuit sampling is a task that has experimentally demonstrated algorithmic quantum advantage on near-term devices, but its practical utility has been limited. Recently, certified randomness generation based on random circuits was demonstrated on a trapped-ion quantum computer, advancing near-term applications. In this work, we connect single-device certified randomness to classically verifiable position verification, a classical communication primitive that avoids long-distance quantum communication challenges. We present a generic compiler that converts any such certified randomness protocol into a secure classically verifiable position verification scheme, extend it to multi-round protocols, and show its equivalence to a relaxed certified randomness variant. Our near-term instantiation based on random circuit sampling demonstrates classically verifiable position verification as a practical application for near-term devices. This article establishes a connection between single-device certified randomness and classically verifiable position verification. Through this connection, it shows that the latter can be implemented using noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices.

arXiv:2410.03982•Nature Communications•Apr 15, 2026•7 citations

Quantum Position Verification with Remote Untrusted Devices

Gautam A. Kavuri, Yanbao Zhang, Abigail R. Gookin +16 more

Position information underpins many modern technologies, from navigation and timing to authentication and critical infrastructure. However, classical methods of proving that information originates from a particular position are vulnerable to spoofing. This limitation can be overcome with quantum technologies but current protocols rely on trust in quantum hardware that can be undermined, or require quantum computers and bounds on adversarial computation. Nevertheless, there has been significant interest in experimental demonstrations, and aspects of these protocols have been implemented. Here we introduce and experimentally demonstrate the Bell-test quantum position verification protocol for device-independent quantum position verification that guarantees security with only observed correlations from a loophole-free Bell test across a quantum network. We experimentally implement a version of this device-independent protocol against adversaries who, before each trial, are weakly entangled. Our demonstration achieves a one-dimensional localization 2.47(2) times smaller than the best, necessarily non-remote, classical localization protocol. Compared to classical protocols with identical latencies, the localization volume is 4.53(5) times smaller, and represents a certifiable quantum advantage. The general Bell-test protocol is loss tolerant and secure against adversaries with significant quantum resources. This work allows digital security to be anchored to physically trusted locations, enabling new position-based authentication protocols for applications such as financial transactions, legal agreements, and securing critical infrastructure.

quant-pharXiv:2601.16892•Jan 26, 2026•11 citations

Efficient multi-basis quantum position verification secure against generalized adversaries

Wen Yu Kon, Ignatius William Primaatmaja, Kaushik Chakraborty +1 more

Abstract Quantum position verification (QPV) enables multiple verifiers to certify a prover’s location using quantum communication and physical assumptions. With experimental demonstrations of QPV becoming increasingly feasible, enhancing the practicality and security of QPV protocols is more important than ever. In this work, we make three key contributions toward this goal. First, we introduce a robust QPV protocol in which the verifier’s state preparation is independent of channel loss, improving reliability in real-world conditions. Second, we refine existing security analysis techniques to bolster protocol resilience against experimental imperfections. Third, we identify and address some implicit assumptions present in existing security analyses, providing a framework to eliminate such assumptions. Additionally, as an example of QPV application beyond location verification, we illustrate how QPV can be leveraged for authenticating classical communication in quantum key distribution.

arXiv:2506.03549•npj Quantum Information•Oct 31, 2026•4 citations

Secure positioning and non-local correlations

Nadeem, Muhammad

Recently, the problem of secure position-verification has been extensively analyzed in a formal notion where distant verifiers send encrypted challenge along with the decryption information to the prover. However, currently it is known that all the existing position-verification scheme are insecure and secure positioning is impossible. We propose here a different notion for position-verification where distant verifiers determine the actions of the prover through non-local correlations generated by local measurements at the provers site. The proposed scheme guarantees secure positioning even if the verifiers do not have any pre-shared data with the prover, position is the only credential of the prover. Our proposed scheme is secure in general and evades known quantum attacks based on instantaneous non-local computations in particular. The scheme enables verifiers to identify dishonest provers with very high probability , where n is the number of entangled pairs used.

arXiv:1406.3013•Jun 11, 2014•7 citations

How To Track Qubits Through Space and Time (Or: Sailing in a Quantum Boat)

James Bartusek, Zikuan Huang, Leo Orshansky +1 more

While quantum position verification aims to certify a prover's location using quantum information, existing security definitions only guarantee that part of the successful adversarial party is in the claimed location. This leaves open the possibility that a distributed team of adversaries can jointly simulate a prover in a way that defeats the intended meaning of `being at a location' in position-based cryptography. We introduce stronger notions of position verification that we call quantum localization, which requires that there is a specified, unclonable state at the verified spacetime point-and that this state can be found nowhere else. We show that quantum localization leads naturally to a meaningful notion of trajectory verification, in which quantum information is verifiably tracked through space and time. We construct quantum localization and trajectory verification protocols using quantum anchor states, which generalize coset states from unclonable cryptography. The security of our schemes is proven in the classical oracle (i.e. ideal obfuscation) model, which can be heuristically instantiated in the plain model using post-quantum indistinguishability obfuscation. We also introduce and instantiate the concept of functionality localization, which guarantees that the adversary has the ability to compute a secret function at the verified spacetime point, and this function cannot be computed anywhere else. This raises the intriguing possibility of localizing computational capabilities in space and time. More broadly, we believe our notions of quantum localization and subsequent feasibility results provide stronger foundations for position-based cryptography. At a conceptual level, our results also explore the tight link between two fundamental notions in physics-location and information-thus serving as a natural foundation for cryptographic capabilities tied to physical spacetime.

quant-pharXiv:2605.30732•Jun 1, 2026•2 citations
Secure position verification certifies that a remote prover occupies a claimed location, a task that is provably impossible with classical resources alone against colluding adversaries. Most existing quantum position verification schemes require transmitting quantum states between verifiers and provers, and the resulting photon loss makes long-distance verification impractical. Classical verifier position verification (CVPV) schemes with classical verifier-prover communication exist, but rely on complex quantum processes that generate certifiable randomness, placing them outside the reach of near-term hardware. Here we introduce a general compiler that maps any complete-support non-local game with the required quantum advantage into a multi-prover CVPV protocol. This addresses both limitations, with entirely classical verifier-prover communication and all quantum resources confined to shared entanglement and local measurements on the prover devices. Instantiating with the CHSH game enables near-term implementation on existing experimental platforms. We prove finite-size security in the quantum random oracle model for both simultaneous verification of multiple provers and verification of a single prover with multiple prover devices. Notably, security in the multi-prover setting is governed not by the certified randomness of the joint provers' outputs, but by certified blind local randomness that depends critically on the spatial arrangement of provers and verifiers.
The paper asks whether quantum position verification can use entirely classical verifier–prover communication without requiring complex quantum computation at the prover. It constructs a compiler from complete-support non-local games to protocols with multiple separated prover devices sharing entanglement and performing local measurements. Verifiers split challenges into shares, combine them through random-oracle hashes, and check both the game score and consistency of responses delivered within location-dependent deadlines.
Finite-size soundness is proved in the quantum random oracle model against sequential adversaries with bounded oracle queries, allowing quantum memory across rounds. Security requires geometric conditions isolating each scored response from foreign inputs and forcing another response copy to be guessed without its generating system. The proof reduces spacetime attacks to non-local-game strategies, derives score–mismatch tradeoffs from multipartite blind local randomness, and applies concentration bounds. When adversaries may occupy all but one prover location, the score must exceed the optimum with one classical player; under stronger protected-region and geometric restrictions, exceeding the fully classical optimum suffices. For CHSH, both models admit the analytical bound pmis≥89(ω−3/4)2p_{\mathrm{mis}}\geq\frac{8}{9}(\omega-3/4)^2pmis​≥98​(ω−3/4)2, with tighter numerical SDP bounds.
A GHZ-based attack shows that quantum advantage and global output randomness alone do not ensure security: the accessible side information depends on geometry. Complete-support modification or geometric changes can restore security in the discussed examples. No implementation is reported. The proofs idealize processing delays; quantitative security geometry, positional uncertainty, minimum device separation, and practical timing and transmission imperfections remain open.
Abstract We discuss quantum position verification (QPV) protocols in which the verifiers create and send single-qubit states to the prover. QPV protocols using single-qubit states are known to be insecure against adversaries that share a small number of entangled qubits. We introduce QPV protocols that are practically secure: they only require single-qubit states from each of the verifiers, yet their security is broken if the adversaries sharing an impractically large number of entangled qubits employ teleportation-based attacks. These protocols are a modification of known QPV protocols in which we include a classical random oracle without altering the amount of quantum resources needed by the verifiers. We present a cheating strategy that requires a number of entangled qubits shared among the adversaries that grows exponentially with the size of the classical input of the random oracle.
Gate-based quantum computers can accelerate computational tasks beyond classical capabilities. Random circuit sampling is a task that has experimentally demonstrated algorithmic quantum advantage on near-term devices, but its practical utility has been limited. Recently, certified randomness generation based on random circuits was demonstrated on a trapped-ion quantum computer, advancing near-term applications. In this work, we connect single-device certified randomness to classically verifiable position verification, a classical communication primitive that avoids long-distance quantum communication challenges. We present a generic compiler that converts any such certified randomness protocol into a secure classically verifiable position verification scheme, extend it to multi-round protocols, and show its equivalence to a relaxed certified randomness variant. Our near-term instantiation based on random circuit sampling demonstrates classically verifiable position verification as a practical application for near-term devices. This article establishes a connection between single-device certified randomness and classically verifiable position verification. Through this connection, it shows that the latter can be implemented using noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices.
Position information underpins many modern technologies, from navigation and timing to authentication and critical infrastructure. However, classical methods of proving that information originates from a particular position are vulnerable to spoofing. This limitation can be overcome with quantum technologies but current protocols rely on trust in quantum hardware that can be undermined, or require quantum computers and bounds on adversarial computation. Nevertheless, there has been significant interest in experimental demonstrations, and aspects of these protocols have been implemented. Here we introduce and experimentally demonstrate the Bell-test quantum position verification protocol for device-independent quantum position verification that guarantees security with only observed correlations from a loophole-free Bell test across a quantum network. We experimentally implement a version of this device-independent protocol against adversaries who, before each trial, are weakly entangled. Our demonstration achieves a one-dimensional localization 2.47(2) times smaller than the best, necessarily non-remote, classical localization protocol. Compared to classical protocols with identical latencies, the localization volume is 4.53(5) times smaller, and represents a certifiable quantum advantage. The general Bell-test protocol is loss tolerant and secure against adversaries with significant quantum resources. This work allows digital security to be anchored to physically trusted locations, enabling new position-based authentication protocols for applications such as financial transactions, legal agreements, and securing critical infrastructure.
Abstract Quantum position verification (QPV) enables multiple verifiers to certify a prover’s location using quantum communication and physical assumptions. With experimental demonstrations of QPV becoming increasingly feasible, enhancing the practicality and security of QPV protocols is more important than ever. In this work, we make three key contributions toward this goal. First, we introduce a robust QPV protocol in which the verifier’s state preparation is independent of channel loss, improving reliability in real-world conditions. Second, we refine existing security analysis techniques to bolster protocol resilience against experimental imperfections. Third, we identify and address some implicit assumptions present in existing security analyses, providing a framework to eliminate such assumptions. Additionally, as an example of QPV application beyond location verification, we illustrate how QPV can be leveraged for authenticating classical communication in quantum key distribution.
Recently, the problem of secure position-verification has been extensively analyzed in a formal notion where distant verifiers send encrypted challenge along with the decryption information to the prover. However, currently it is known that all the existing position-verification scheme are insecure and secure positioning is impossible. We propose here a different notion for position-verification where distant verifiers determine the actions of the prover through non-local correlations generated by local measurements at the provers site. The proposed scheme guarantees secure positioning even if the verifiers do not have any pre-shared data with the prover, position is the only credential of the prover. Our proposed scheme is secure in general and evades known quantum attacks based on instantaneous non-local computations in particular. The scheme enables verifiers to identify dishonest provers with very high probability , where n is the number of entangled pairs used.
While quantum position verification aims to certify a prover's location using quantum information, existing security definitions only guarantee that part of the successful adversarial party is in the claimed location. This leaves open the possibility that a distributed team of adversaries can jointly simulate a prover in a way that defeats the intended meaning of `being at a location' in position-based cryptography. We introduce stronger notions of position verification that we call quantum localization, which requires that there is a specified, unclonable state at the verified spacetime point-and that this state can be found nowhere else. We show that quantum localization leads naturally to a meaningful notion of trajectory verification, in which quantum information is verifiably tracked through space and time. We construct quantum localization and trajectory verification protocols using quantum anchor states, which generalize coset states from unclonable cryptography. The security of our schemes is proven in the classical oracle (i.e. ideal obfuscation) model, which can be heuristically instantiated in the plain model using post-quantum indistinguishability obfuscation. We also introduce and instantiate the concept of functionality localization, which guarantees that the adversary has the ability to compute a secret function at the verified spacetime point, and this function cannot be computed anywhere else. This raises the intriguing possibility of localizing computational capabilities in space and time. More broadly, we believe our notions of quantum localization and subsequent feasibility results provide stronger foundations for position-based cryptography. At a conceptual level, our results also explore the tight link between two fundamental notions in physics-location and information-thus serving as a natural foundation for cryptographic capabilities tied to physical spacetime.