Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.37133

Stability of isometries of quantum states

Sam Looi

math.FAmath-phquant-phSubmitted Sep 29, 2026• Announced Sep 30, 2026• Revised Oct 13, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Sep 29, 2026v2 · Oct 13, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We prove dimension-independent Hyers--Ulam stability for surjective approximate isometries of the positive trace-class cone in both the trace and Bures metrics. Here $\varepsilon\geq0$ is a uniform upper bound on the additive error in preserving distances. Such an approximate isometry is uniformly approximated by a Wigner symmetry (a unitary or antiunitary conjugation), with error at most $9\varepsilon/2$ in the trace metric and $2\sqrt2\varepsilon$ in the Bures metric, even if it does not fix zero. For maps fixing zero, the trace bound improves to $3\varepsilon$ even under the hypothesis of $δ$-surjectivity, independently of $δ$. In infinite dimensions, we construct spectrum-preserving homeomorphisms of the full state space, including mixed states, whose distortions tend to zero in both metrics but which stay a fixed uniform distance from every Wigner symmetry. For state spaces, stability holds in each fixed finite dimension with a dimension-dependent modulus tending to zero as $\varepsilon\to0$, but no such modulus can be chosen independently of dimension.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether maps that approximately preserve all trace or Bures distances must be uniformly close to a Wigner symmetry, $A\mapsto UAU^*$ with $U$ unitary or antiunitary. It studies both the positive trace-class cone and the normalized state space, without assuming linearity, affinity, or continuity. On the cone, every surjective additive $\varepsilon$-isometry is uniformly approximated by a Wigner symmetry within $9\varepsilon/2$ in trace norm or $2\sqrt2\varepsilon$ in Bures distance, independently of dimension. For maps fixing zero, the trace bound improves to $3\varepsilon$; both zero-fixing bounds also hold under $\delta$-surjectivity for any finite $\delta$, without dependence on $\delta$. The trace result resolves a previously posed infinite-dimensional stability question. The Bures proof constructs an exact isometry by taking limits of rescaled maps, then controls the approximation through asymptotic distance comparisons along rays and a fidelity-profile estimate. The trace proof combines an existing uniform operator-norm approximation with a new dimension-independent upgrade to trace-norm control of differences, using complementary-support probes and asymptotic trace-distance formulas. For normalized states, spectrum-preserving homeomorphisms extend logarithmic-spiral examples from pure to mixed states. Their distortions vanish while their uniform distances from every Wigner symmetry remain at least $1$ in trace norm and $\sqrt{2-\sqrt3}$ in Bures distance. Thus stability fails in infinite dimension and cannot be dimension-uniform. Fixed finite dimensions admit a vanishing stability modulus by compactness, but no quantitative rate or linear bound is established. Cone stability requires a range assumption; optimal cone constants are not determined.

Little sign of AI-generated text

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
43 pages. Comments welcome. v2: Removed the surjectivity assumption from finite-dimensional state-space stability; showed that the state-space bijections are spectrum-preserving homeomorphisms; proved uniqueness of the approximating Wigner symmetry on the cone and extended Bures stability to approximately surjective maps fixing zero

Related papers

Nonexpansive and noncontractive mappings on the set of quantum pure states

Michiya Mori, Peter Šemrl

Wigner’s theorem characterizes isometries of the set of all rank one projections on a Hilbert space. In metric geometry, nonexpansive maps and noncontractive maps are well-studied generalizations of isometries. We show that under certain conditions Wigner symmetries can be characterized as nonexpansive or noncontractive maps on the set of all projections of rank one. The assumptions required for such characterizations are injectivity or surjectivity and they differ in the finite and the infinite-dimensional case. Motivated by a recently obtained optimal version of Uhlhorn’s generalization of Wigner’s theorem, we also give a description of nonexpansive maps which satisfy a condition that is much weaker than surjectivity. Such maps do not need to be Wigner symmetries. The optimality of all presented results is shown by counterexamples.

arXiv:2305.05123•Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh Section A Mathematics•Jan 17, 2024•0 citations

Bures Contractive Channels on Operator Algebras

Douglas Farenick, Mizanur Rahaman

In a unital C*-algebra with a faithful trace functional $τ$, the set $D_τ(A)$ of positive $ρ\in A$ of trace τ(ρ)=1 is an algebraic analogue of the space of density matrices (the set of all positive matrices of a fixed dimension of unit trace). Motivated by the literature concerning the metric properties of the space of density matrices, the present paper studies the density space $D_τ(A)$ in terms of the Bures metric. Linear maps on A that map $D_τ(A)$ back into itself are positive and trace preserving, hence, they may be viewed as an algebraic analogue of a quantum channel, which are studied intensely in the literature on quantum computing and quantum information theory. The main results in this paper are: (i) to establish that the Bures metric is indeed a metric, (ii) to prove that channels induce nonexpansive maps of the density space $D_τ(A)$, (iii) to introduce and study channels on A that are locally contractive maps (which we call Bures contractions) on the metric space $D_τ(A)$, and (iv) to analyse Bures contractions from the point of view of the Frobenius theory of cone preserving linear maps. Although the focus is on unital C*-algebras, an important class of examples is furnished by finite von Neumann algebras. Indeed, several of the C*-algebra results are established by first proving them for finite von Neumann algebras and then proving them for C*-algebras by embedding a C*-algebra A into its enveloping von Neumann algebra $A^{**}$.

arXiv:1704.00376•Apr 2, 2017•9 citations

Are almost-symmetries almost linear?

Javier Cuesta, Michael M. Wolf

It d-pends. Wigner’s symmetry theorem implies that transformations that preserve transition probabilities of pure quantum states are linear maps on the level of density operators. We investigate the stability of this implication. On the one hand, we show that any transformation that preserves transition probabilities up to an additive ε in a separable Hilbert space admits a weak linear approximation, i.e., one relative to any fixed observable. This implies the existence of a linear approximation that is 4εd–close in Hilbert-Schmidt norm, with d the Hilbert space dimension. On the other hand, we prove that a linear approximation that is close in norm and independent of d does not exist in general. To this end, we provide a lower bound that depends logarithmically on d.

arXiv:1812.10019•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Aug 1, 2019•3 citations

Quantum Wasserstein isometries of the nnn-qubit state space: a Wigner-type result

Gergely Bunth, Eszter Szabó, Dániel Virosztek

We determine the isometry group of the $n$-qubit state space with respect to the quantum Wasserstein distance induced by the so-called symmetric transport cost for all $n \in \mathbb{N}.$ It turns out that the isometries are precisely the Wigner symmetries, that is, the unitary or anti-unitary conjugations.

math-phCross-listedarXiv:2602.08628•Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society•Feb 10, 2026•2 citations

Isometries of quantum states

Lajos Moln r, Werner Timmermann

This paper treats the isometries of metric spaces of quantum states. In fact, we consider two metrics on the set of all quantum states, namely the Bures metric and that which comes from the trace-norm. We describe all the corresponding (nonlinear) isometries and also present similar results concerning the space of all (non-normalized) density operators.

arXiv:math/0211221•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Dec 12, 2002•29 citations

Beyond Wigner: Non-Invertible Symmetries Preserve Probabilities

Thomas Bartsch, Yuhan Gai, Sakura Schafer-Nameki

In recent years, the traditional notion of symmetry in quantum theory was expanded to so-called generalised or categorical symmetries, which, unlike ordinary group symmetries, may be non-invertible. This appears to be at odds with Wigner's theorem, which requires quantum symmetries to be implemented by (anti)unitary -- and hence invertible -- operators in order to preserve probabilities. We resolve this puzzle for (higher) fusion category symmetries $\mathcal{C}$ by proposing that, instead of acting by unitary operators on a fixed Hilbert space, symmetry defects in $\mathcal{C}$ act as isometries between distinct Hilbert spaces constructed from twisted sectors. As a result, we find that non-invertible symmetries naturally act as trace-preserving quantum channels. Crucially, our construction relies on the symmetry category $\mathcal{C}$ being unitary. We illustrate our proposal through several examples that include Tambara-Yamagami, Fibonacci, and Yang-Lee as well as higher categorical symmetries.

quant-pharXiv:2602.07110•Feb 10, 2026•8 citations
We prove dimension-independent Hyers--Ulam stability for surjective approximate isometries of the positive trace-class cone in both the trace and Bures metrics. Here ε≥0\varepsilon\geq0ε≥0 is a uniform upper bound on the additive error in preserving distances. Such an approximate isometry is uniformly approximated by a Wigner symmetry (a unitary or antiunitary conjugation), with error at most 9ε/29\varepsilon/29ε/2 in the trace metric and 22ε2\sqrt2\varepsilon22​ε in the Bures metric, even if it does not fix zero. For maps fixing zero, the trace bound improves to 3ε3\varepsilon3ε even under the hypothesis of δδδ-surjectivity, independently of δδδ. In infinite dimensions, we construct spectrum-preserving homeomorphisms of the full state space, including mixed states, whose distortions tend to zero in both metrics but which stay a fixed uniform distance from every Wigner symmetry. For state spaces, stability holds in each fixed finite dimension with a dimension-dependent modulus tending to zero as ε→0\varepsilon\to0ε→0, but no such modulus can be chosen independently of dimension.
The paper asks whether maps that approximately preserve all trace or Bures distances must be uniformly close to a Wigner symmetry, A↦UAU∗A\mapsto UAU^*A↦UAU∗ with UUU unitary or antiunitary. It studies both the positive trace-class cone and the normalized state space, without assuming linearity, affinity, or continuity.
On the cone, every surjective additive ε\varepsilonε-isometry is uniformly approximated by a Wigner symmetry within 9ε/29\varepsilon/29ε/2 in trace norm or 22ε2\sqrt2\varepsilon22​ε in Bures distance, independently of dimension. For maps fixing zero, the trace bound improves to 3ε3\varepsilon3ε; both zero-fixing bounds also hold under δ\deltaδ-surjectivity for any finite δ\deltaδ, without dependence on δ\deltaδ. The trace result resolves a previously posed infinite-dimensional stability question.
The Bures proof constructs an exact isometry by taking limits of rescaled maps, then controls the approximation through asymptotic distance comparisons along rays and a fidelity-profile estimate. The trace proof combines an existing uniform operator-norm approximation with a new dimension-independent upgrade to trace-norm control of differences, using complementary-support probes and asymptotic trace-distance formulas.
For normalized states, spectrum-preserving homeomorphisms extend logarithmic-spiral examples from pure to mixed states. Their distortions vanish while their uniform distances from every Wigner symmetry remain at least 111 in trace norm and 2−3\sqrt{2-\sqrt3}2−3​​ in Bures distance. Thus stability fails in infinite dimension and cannot be dimension-uniform. Fixed finite dimensions admit a vanishing stability modulus by compactness, but no quantitative rate or linear bound is established. Cone stability requires a range assumption; optimal cone constants are not determined.
Wigner’s theorem characterizes isometries of the set of all rank one projections on a Hilbert space. In metric geometry, nonexpansive maps and noncontractive maps are well-studied generalizations of isometries. We show that under certain conditions Wigner symmetries can be characterized as nonexpansive or noncontractive maps on the set of all projections of rank one. The assumptions required for such characterizations are injectivity or surjectivity and they differ in the finite and the infinite-dimensional case. Motivated by a recently obtained optimal version of Uhlhorn’s generalization of Wigner’s theorem, we also give a description of nonexpansive maps which satisfy a condition that is much weaker than surjectivity. Such maps do not need to be Wigner symmetries. The optimality of all presented results is shown by counterexamples.
In a unital C*-algebra with a faithful trace functional τττ, the set Dτ(A)D_τ(A)Dτ​(A) of positive ρ∈Aρ\in Aρ∈A of trace τ(ρ)=1 is an algebraic analogue of the space of density matrices (the set of all positive matrices of a fixed dimension of unit trace). Motivated by the literature concerning the metric properties of the space of density matrices, the present paper studies the density space Dτ(A)D_τ(A)Dτ​(A) in terms of the Bures metric. Linear maps on A that map Dτ(A)D_τ(A)Dτ​(A) back into itself are positive and trace preserving, hence, they may be viewed as an algebraic analogue of a quantum channel, which are studied intensely in the literature on quantum computing and quantum information theory. The main results in this paper are: (i) to establish that the Bures metric is indeed a metric, (ii) to prove that channels induce nonexpansive maps of the density space Dτ(A)D_τ(A)Dτ​(A), (iii) to introduce and study channels on A that are locally contractive maps (which we call Bures contractions) on the metric space Dτ(A)D_τ(A)Dτ​(A), and (iv) to analyse Bures contractions from the point of view of the Frobenius theory of cone preserving linear maps. Although the focus is on unital C*-algebras, an important class of examples is furnished by finite von Neumann algebras. Indeed, several of the C*-algebra results are established by first proving them for finite von Neumann algebras and then proving them for C*-algebras by embedding a C*-algebra A into its enveloping von Neumann algebra A∗∗A^{**}A∗∗.
It d-pends. Wigner’s symmetry theorem implies that transformations that preserve transition probabilities of pure quantum states are linear maps on the level of density operators. We investigate the stability of this implication. On the one hand, we show that any transformation that preserves transition probabilities up to an additive ε in a separable Hilbert space admits a weak linear approximation, i.e., one relative to any fixed observable. This implies the existence of a linear approximation that is 4εd–close in Hilbert-Schmidt norm, with d the Hilbert space dimension. On the other hand, we prove that a linear approximation that is close in norm and independent of d does not exist in general. To this end, we provide a lower bound that depends logarithmically on d.
We determine the isometry group of the nnn-qubit state space with respect to the quantum Wasserstein distance induced by the so-called symmetric transport cost for all n∈N.n \in \mathbb{N}.n∈N. It turns out that the isometries are precisely the Wigner symmetries, that is, the unitary or anti-unitary conjugations.
In recent years, the traditional notion of symmetry in quantum theory was expanded to so-called generalised or categorical symmetries, which, unlike ordinary group symmetries, may be non-invertible. This appears to be at odds with Wigner's theorem, which requires quantum symmetries to be implemented by (anti)unitary -- and hence invertible -- operators in order to preserve probabilities. We resolve this puzzle for (higher) fusion category symmetries C\mathcal{C}C by proposing that, instead of acting by unitary operators on a fixed Hilbert space, symmetry defects in C\mathcal{C}C act as isometries between distinct Hilbert spaces constructed from twisted sectors. As a result, we find that non-invertible symmetries naturally act as trace-preserving quantum channels. Crucially, our construction relies on the symmetry category C\mathcal{C}C being unitary. We illustrate our proposal through several examples that include Tambara-Yamagami, Fibonacci, and Yang-Lee as well as higher categorical symmetries.