arXiv:2609.36113
Collectivity limits quantum entanglement
Donghoon Kim, Tomotaka Kuwahara
Abstract
Understanding what limits many-body quantum entanglement is a central problem in physics. Spatial locality has long provided a fundamental mechanism: correlations between a region and its complement must be mediated through a small spatial interface, thereby constraining their entanglement. Here we show that universal constraints on entanglement can persist even when interactions are strongly nonlocal, through collectivity: many weak interactions generate fluctuations controlled by their square-summed, rather than total, strength. We establish this mechanism rigorously for generic gapped Hamiltonians with Kac-normalized power-law interactions $r^{-α}$ on a $D$-dimensional lattice. For arbitrary bipartitions, we prove that the ground-state entanglement scales at most logarithmically with system size for $α<D/2$ and subextensively for $D/2<α<D$, due to suppressed collective fluctuations around individual sites. For spatially regular bipartitions with codimension-one boundaries, we use a renormalization-group construction to extend this suppression to larger length scales, yielding polylogarithmic scaling for $D/2 < α< (D+1) / 2$ and parametrically stronger subvolume bounds for $(D+1)/2<α<D$. We also establish the corresponding optimality results: for arbitrary bipartitions, the logarithmic scaling for $α<D/2$ is optimal and $α=D/2$ marks the optimal threshold for universal logarithmic bounds, while for regular bipartitions the threshold at $α=(D+1)/2$ is likewise optimal for universal polylogarithmic bounds when $D\ge2$. Together, these results reveal collectivity as a fundamental mechanism for constraining many-body entanglement alongside spatial locality.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether gapped ground-state entanglement can be constrained without spatial locality. It considers two-body Hamiltonians on a $D$-dimensional lattice with $n$ fixed-dimensional sites, bounded on-site terms, and interactions satisfying $\|h_{ij}\|\le J\mu_{ij}n^{-(1-\alpha/D)}r_{ij}^{-\alpha}$ for $0\le\alpha<D$, where $\mu_{ij}$ permits a fixed nearest-neighborhood enhancement. A unique ground state and system-size-independent spectral gap are assumed; no translation or permutation symmetry is required. For arbitrary bipartitions, the entropy bounds are $O(\log n)$ for $\alpha<D/2$, $O((\log n)^2)$ at $\alpha=D/2$, and $O(n^{(2\alpha-D)/D}\log n)$ above it. The below- and above-threshold scalings are matched by constructions. For regular codimension-one cuts, the bounds improve to polylogarithmic scaling for $D/2<\alpha<(D+1)/2$, $O_\varepsilon(n^\varepsilon)$ at $\alpha=(D+1)/2<D$, and $O_\varepsilon(n^{(2\alpha-D-1)/(D-1)+\varepsilon})$ above it. For $D\ge2$, uniformly gapped examples exhibit polynomial entropy arbitrarily close above the second threshold, ruling out extending universal polylogarithmic bounds into any right neighborhood. The proof combines a gap–variance inequality controlled by square-summed coupling strengths with local reflections, bounding the subleading one-site Schmidt weight. Subadditivity yields the arbitrary-cut bounds. Regular-cut bounds use iterative low-deviation block truncations, gap preservation, dimension-independent square-sum interaction estimates, and multiscale entropy reconstruction. The regular-cut exponent above the second threshold is not established as optimal, and scaling at that threshold remains unresolved. The results require Kac normalization, two-body interactions, and a unique uniformly gapped ground state; extensions to other interaction profiles or nonground states remain open.
Error found: The abstract omits the essential unique-ground-state assumption: gapped Hamiltonians with extensive free ground-space degrees of freedom satisfy the interaction bounds yet admit volume-law-entangled ground states, so the advertised universal bounds require the qualifications stated in the body.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 15 pages, 3 figures; 95 pages Supplementary Material