Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.36008

Entanglement spectrum and magic in higher-dimensional free fermionic systems

Beatrice Magni, Daniele Iannotti, Riccardo Travaglino

quant-phcond-mat.stat-mechSubmitted Sep 28, 2026• Announced Sep 30, 2026• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study fermionic non-local magic in higher-dimensional free-fermion systems through the lens of the entanglement spectrum. For translationally invariant Gaussian states in strip geometries, dimensional reduction maps the problem to independent lower-dimensional momentum sectors, leading in two dimensions to a multiplicative logarithmic violation of the boundary law analogous to Gioev-Klich-Widom scaling. We further show that the second Rényi fermionic non-local magic is bounded by the capacity of entanglement and introduce an entanglement-temperature deformation that probes the low-energy structure of the entanglement Hamiltonian. Applied to the matter-Majorana sector of the Kitaev model, this response is exponentially suppressed in the Abelian phase and algebraic in the non-Abelian phase, where its ratio with the capacity approaches a universal constant. Out of equilibrium, we extend the quasi-particle description to fermionic non-local magic in higher-dimensional quenches and show that random Gaussian circuits exhibit diffusive spreading in two spatial dimensions.

AI Summary

The paper asks how fermionic non-local magic (FNL)—stabilizer Rényi entropy minimized over bipartition-local Gaussian unitaries—is controlled by the entanglement spectrum in higher-dimensional free-fermion systems. It uses the existing additive covariance-spectrum formula to study equilibrium scaling, entanglement-temperature response, and dynamics. For translation-invariant strips, transverse Fourier transformation gives an exact decomposition into one-dimensional momentum sectors. A finite density of critical sectors produces $M_\alpha^{\mathrm{FNL}}\sim L_y\log\ell$ in two dimensions. Fisher–Hartwig asymptotics yield explicit coefficients and subleading terms for square-lattice hopping, checked numerically. A pointwise comparison of spectral kernels establishes $M_2^{\mathrm{FNL}}\leq C_E$, where $C_E$ is the capacity of entanglement. Introducing $\rho_A(T_E)\propto\rho_A^{1/T_E}$ resolves low-energy entanglement modes. In the Kitaev model’s Gaussian matter-Majorana sector, FNL scales as $L_y\sqrt{T_E}e^{-\Delta_E/T_E}$ for a gapped band with a quadratic minimum, versus $L_yT_E$ for linear gapless branches. For the latter, $M_2^{\mathrm{FNL}}/C_E\to(6/\pi^2)[\pi^2/4-\log^2(2+\sqrt3)]$. These results follow from spectral-kernel asymptotics and numerical spectra. For quadratic quenches, a quasiparticle formula reproduces numerical FNL dynamics. Random Gaussian circuits show $L_y\sqrt t$ growth numerically, consistent with an analytical diffusion equation for averaged Majorana weight; this does not establish the FNL growth law analytically. The analysis largely assumes strip geometries and pure Gaussian states. The Kitaev quantity is not generally the physical spin-state non-local magic; claims about unrestricted local-unitary minimization remain conjectural. Low-temperature continuum scaling also requires sufficiently large boundary length.

Little sign of AI-generated textIncrementalOverclaims

Error found: The random-circuit analytical argument does not establish M_2^{FNL}∝L_y√t, although the paper reports numerical evidence for that growth law. The statement that the capacity-of-entanglement upper bound is uniformly tighter than the existing entropy bounds is false, as a single covariance singular value λ=0.99 demonstrates. The critical-coefficient formulas mix natural-log and base-two conventions, producing values differing by a factor of 1/ln 2 without consistently distinguishing their use.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
10 figures, comments are welcome

Related papers

Non-Local Magic Resources for Fermionic Gaussian States

Daniele Iannotti, Beatrice Magni, Riccardo Cioli +2 more

Entanglement and magic are fundamental resources that capture the complexity of quantum many-body systems. Non-local magic isolates the irreducible nonstabilizerness intrinsically tied to entanglement. However, evaluating this quantity generally requires a prohibitive minimization over the full Hilbert space, making it computationally inaccessible beyond a few qubits. Here, we overcome this bottleneck by establishing a closed-form expression for the non-local stabilizer entropies of fermionic Gaussian states over local Gaussian unitaries, which we prove at Rényi index $α=2$ for arbitrary subsystem size, and which can be evaluated in polynomial time directly from the eigenvalues of the reduced Majorana covariance matrix. We apply this framework to characterize fermionic non-local magic across diverse physical regimes: we derive an exact Page-like curve for typical random states, reveal logarithmic scaling at the quantum critical point of the XY model, and establish a quasiparticle picture for magic generation during out-of-equilibrium quantum quenches. Crucially, because our result relies solely on two-point correlation functions, it provides a scalable route for the experimental estimation of fermionic non-local magic in large-scale quantum processors via fermionic shadow tomography.

quant-pharXiv:2604.27049•May 1, 2026•20 citations

Nonlocal magic of fermions is bounded by entanglement fluctuations and is logarithmic for free fermions

Raghav G. Jha, Dengyao Luo, Alexander F. Kemper +1 more

Free-fermion states are classically simulable, yet, written as qubits, they typically carry extensive magic, the quantum resource that stabilizer circuits lack. Part of this magic is nonlocal: local unitaries acting separately on two parts of the system cannot remove it. If these local unitaries are restricted to Gaussian ones, the nonlocal magic grows linearly with the number $m$ of partially entangled fermion pairs. We show that this growth is an artifact of the Gaussian restriction: local Gaussian unitaries minimize the nonlocal stabilizer Rényi entropy for up to three pairs, but not from four pairs on. General local non-Gaussian unitaries that respect fermion parity take $m$ free-fermion pairs to fermionic Bell pairs with a fidelity that decays at most as $1/\sqrt m$ compared to exponential decay with Gaussian unitaries, so the nonlocal magic drops from linear to logarithmic in $m$. The reason is statistical --- Bell pairs have equal Schmidt weights, that is, a fully degenerate entanglement spectrum, and a state can stay far from them only if its Schmidt weights are spread over many orders of magnitude. This spread is measured by the capacity of entanglement $C_E$, the variance of the entanglement Hamiltonian, and the nonlocal magic of any fermionic state grows at most logarithmically with $C_E$. Free-fermion pairs add to $C_E$ independently, so $C_E$ grows only linearly in $m$, and this leads to the stabilizer fidelity decreasing at most as $1/\sqrt m$. Almost all the magic of free fermions, including Hartree--Fock and BCS mean-field states, is therefore local.

arXiv:2611.07003•Nov 4, 2026•0 citations

Nonlocal nonstabilizerness in free fermion models

Mario Collura, Benjamin Béri, Emanuele Tirrito

Nonlocal magic quantifies the irreducible nonstabilizerness of a bipartite quantum state after optimizing over local basis changes. We study nonlocal magic for pure fermionic Gaussian states, and derive a simple closed-form entanglement spectrum bound in terms of the singular values of the subsystem-restricted covariance matrix. We benchmark our result against simulated annealing over local Gaussian unitary transformations, which supports optimality along the full local Gaussian orbit. For states drawn from the Gaussian Haar ensemble, we show that the average nonlocal magic is extensive and determine its thermodynamic limit using random matrix theory for the appropriate circular unitary ensemble. We also study Gaussian ground states, focusing on the Kitaev chain, and find that nonlocal magic is suppressed deep in both trivial and topological phases and peaks near the critical points. Finally, we investigate Gaussian evolution via random circuits and in quenches with the XY chain. For random circuits, we find that nonlocal magic grows diffusively, while in the XY chain the XX limit reveals a striking separation between nonlocal magic and entanglement.

quant-pharXiv:2604.27055•May 1, 2026•17 citations

Magic of Kitaev spin liquids

Eleonora Lamma, Tim Bauer, Marcello Dalmonte +1 more

Quantum spin liquids (QSLs) are long-range entangled phases of matter and a natural setting for exploring how quantum correlations generate quantum complexity. Motivated by the emergence of magic, or nonstabilizerness, as a diagnostic of many-body complexity beyond entanglement, we study magic of QSLs by computing the stabilizer Rényi entropy (SRE) of the Kitaev honeycomb model. We derive a correspondence between Pauli strings and products of itinerant Majorana operators in the model's free-fermion description; this enables the sampling of SRE using an optimized algorithm for Gaussian states in systems with thousands of spins. Our results show that magic is largest in the gapless phase, where subleading volume-law corrections indicate nonlocal contributions, while in the gapped phases, SRE decreases in quantitative agreement with a perturbative expansion that we develop in the anisotropic limit. At the topological phase transition, SRE exhibits universal scaling dictated by critical exponents.

quant-pharXiv:2608.25929•Aug 27, 2026•5 citations

Scaling behavior of entanglement in two- and three-dimensional free-fermion systems

Weifei Li, Letian Ding, Rong Yu +2 more

Exactly solving a spinless fermionic system in two and three dimensions, we investigate the scaling behavior of the block entropy in critical and noncritical phases. The scaling of the block entropy crucially depends on the nature of the excitation spectrum of the system and on the topology of the Fermi surface. Noticeably, in the critical phases the scaling violates the area law and acquires a logarithmic correction only when a well-defined Fermi surface exists in the system. When the area law is violated, we accurately verify a conjecture for the prefactor of the logarithmic correction, proposed by D. Gioev and I. Klich [Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 100503 (2006)].

arXiv:quant-ph/0602094•Physical Review B•Aug 17, 2006•126 citations

Nonlocal Magic Spreading in Many-body Quantum Dynamics: From Chaotic Evolution to Quasi-particle Picture in Integrable Models

Sreemayee Aditya, Piotr Sierant, Xhek Turkeshi

Entanglement and magic are resources that reveal complementary aspects of quantum many-body systems. Their interplay is captured by nonlocal magic, the magic that survives arbitrary local changes of basis. Yet their markedly different dynamical behavior leaves open how this irreducible component of magic spreads. Here we connect nonlocal magic to the capacity of entanglement, a tractable quantity measuring fluctuations of the entanglement Hamiltonian. This connection enables analytically controlled predictions across a wide range of many-body dynamics, from chaotic to integrable systems, which we investigate also using large-scale numerical simulations. In chaotic systems, nonlocal magic exhibits a transient buildup, with logarithmic growth in time followed by decay to a size-independent value. For integrable systems, we develop a quasiparticle picture in quantitative agreement with numerics, showing that the same initial growth instead leads to saturation at a value logarithmic in subsystem size. These contrasting behaviors have an operational consequence for entanglement embezzlement: the strongest scramblers embezzle only transiently, whereas free-fermionic dynamics can sustain universal embezzlement in the steady state.

quant-pharXiv:2609.20951•Sep 21, 2026•5 citations
We study fermionic non-local magic in higher-dimensional free-fermion systems through the lens of the entanglement spectrum. For translationally invariant Gaussian states in strip geometries, dimensional reduction maps the problem to independent lower-dimensional momentum sectors, leading in two dimensions to a multiplicative logarithmic violation of the boundary law analogous to Gioev-Klich-Widom scaling. We further show that the second Rényi fermionic non-local magic is bounded by the capacity of entanglement and introduce an entanglement-temperature deformation that probes the low-energy structure of the entanglement Hamiltonian. Applied to the matter-Majorana sector of the Kitaev model, this response is exponentially suppressed in the Abelian phase and algebraic in the non-Abelian phase, where its ratio with the capacity approaches a universal constant. Out of equilibrium, we extend the quasi-particle description to fermionic non-local magic in higher-dimensional quenches and show that random Gaussian circuits exhibit diffusive spreading in two spatial dimensions.
The paper asks how fermionic non-local magic (FNL)—stabilizer Rényi entropy minimized over bipartition-local Gaussian unitaries—is controlled by the entanglement spectrum in higher-dimensional free-fermion systems. It uses the existing additive covariance-spectrum formula to study equilibrium scaling, entanglement-temperature response, and dynamics.
For translation-invariant strips, transverse Fourier transformation gives an exact decomposition into one-dimensional momentum sectors. A finite density of critical sectors produces MαFNL∼Lylog⁡ℓM_\alpha^{\mathrm{FNL}}\sim L_y\log\ellMαFNL​∼Ly​logℓ in two dimensions. Fisher–Hartwig asymptotics yield explicit coefficients and subleading terms for square-lattice hopping, checked numerically. A pointwise comparison of spectral kernels establishes M2FNL≤CEM_2^{\mathrm{FNL}}\leq C_EM2FNL​≤CE​, where CEC_ECE​ is the capacity of entanglement.
Introducing ρA(TE)∝ρA1/TE\rho_A(T_E)\propto\rho_A^{1/T_E}ρA​(TE​)∝ρA1/TE​​ resolves low-energy entanglement modes. In the Kitaev model’s Gaussian matter-Majorana sector, FNL scales as LyTEe−ΔE/TEL_y\sqrt{T_E}e^{-\Delta_E/T_E}Ly​TE​​e−ΔE​/TE​ for a gapped band with a quadratic minimum, versus LyTEL_yT_ELy​TE​ for linear gapless branches. For the latter, M2FNL/CE→(6/π2)[π2/4−log⁡2(2+3)]M_2^{\mathrm{FNL}}/C_E\to(6/\pi^2)[\pi^2/4-\log^2(2+\sqrt3)]M2FNL​/CE​→(6/π2)[π2/4−log2(2+3​)]. These results follow from spectral-kernel asymptotics and numerical spectra.
For quadratic quenches, a quasiparticle formula reproduces numerical FNL dynamics. Random Gaussian circuits show LytL_y\sqrt tLy​t​ growth numerically, consistent with an analytical diffusion equation for averaged Majorana weight; this does not establish the FNL growth law analytically. The analysis largely assumes strip geometries and pure Gaussian states. The Kitaev quantity is not generally the physical spin-state non-local magic; claims about unrestricted local-unitary minimization remain conjectural. Low-temperature continuum scaling also requires sufficiently large boundary length.
Entanglement and magic are fundamental resources that capture the complexity of quantum many-body systems. Non-local magic isolates the irreducible nonstabilizerness intrinsically tied to entanglement. However, evaluating this quantity generally requires a prohibitive minimization over the full Hilbert space, making it computationally inaccessible beyond a few qubits. Here, we overcome this bottleneck by establishing a closed-form expression for the non-local stabilizer entropies of fermionic Gaussian states over local Gaussian unitaries, which we prove at Rényi index α=2α=2α=2 for arbitrary subsystem size, and which can be evaluated in polynomial time directly from the eigenvalues of the reduced Majorana covariance matrix. We apply this framework to characterize fermionic non-local magic across diverse physical regimes: we derive an exact Page-like curve for typical random states, reveal logarithmic scaling at the quantum critical point of the XY model, and establish a quasiparticle picture for magic generation during out-of-equilibrium quantum quenches. Crucially, because our result relies solely on two-point correlation functions, it provides a scalable route for the experimental estimation of fermionic non-local magic in large-scale quantum processors via fermionic shadow tomography.
Free-fermion states are classically simulable, yet, written as qubits, they typically carry extensive magic, the quantum resource that stabilizer circuits lack. Part of this magic is nonlocal: local unitaries acting separately on two parts of the system cannot remove it. If these local unitaries are restricted to Gaussian ones, the nonlocal magic grows linearly with the number mmm of partially entangled fermion pairs. We show that this growth is an artifact of the Gaussian restriction: local Gaussian unitaries minimize the nonlocal stabilizer Rényi entropy for up to three pairs, but not from four pairs on. General local non-Gaussian unitaries that respect fermion parity take mmm free-fermion pairs to fermionic Bell pairs with a fidelity that decays at most as 1/m1/\sqrt m1/m​ compared to exponential decay with Gaussian unitaries, so the nonlocal magic drops from linear to logarithmic in mmm. The reason is statistical --- Bell pairs have equal Schmidt weights, that is, a fully degenerate entanglement spectrum, and a state can stay far from them only if its Schmidt weights are spread over many orders of magnitude. This spread is measured by the capacity of entanglement CEC_ECE​, the variance of the entanglement Hamiltonian, and the nonlocal magic of any fermionic state grows at most logarithmically with CEC_ECE​. Free-fermion pairs add to CEC_ECE​ independently, so CEC_ECE​ grows only linearly in mmm, and this leads to the stabilizer fidelity decreasing at most as 1/m1/\sqrt m1/m​. Almost all the magic of free fermions, including Hartree--Fock and BCS mean-field states, is therefore local.
Nonlocal magic quantifies the irreducible nonstabilizerness of a bipartite quantum state after optimizing over local basis changes. We study nonlocal magic for pure fermionic Gaussian states, and derive a simple closed-form entanglement spectrum bound in terms of the singular values of the subsystem-restricted covariance matrix. We benchmark our result against simulated annealing over local Gaussian unitary transformations, which supports optimality along the full local Gaussian orbit. For states drawn from the Gaussian Haar ensemble, we show that the average nonlocal magic is extensive and determine its thermodynamic limit using random matrix theory for the appropriate circular unitary ensemble. We also study Gaussian ground states, focusing on the Kitaev chain, and find that nonlocal magic is suppressed deep in both trivial and topological phases and peaks near the critical points. Finally, we investigate Gaussian evolution via random circuits and in quenches with the XY chain. For random circuits, we find that nonlocal magic grows diffusively, while in the XY chain the XX limit reveals a striking separation between nonlocal magic and entanglement.
Quantum spin liquids (QSLs) are long-range entangled phases of matter and a natural setting for exploring how quantum correlations generate quantum complexity. Motivated by the emergence of magic, or nonstabilizerness, as a diagnostic of many-body complexity beyond entanglement, we study magic of QSLs by computing the stabilizer Rényi entropy (SRE) of the Kitaev honeycomb model. We derive a correspondence between Pauli strings and products of itinerant Majorana operators in the model's free-fermion description; this enables the sampling of SRE using an optimized algorithm for Gaussian states in systems with thousands of spins. Our results show that magic is largest in the gapless phase, where subleading volume-law corrections indicate nonlocal contributions, while in the gapped phases, SRE decreases in quantitative agreement with a perturbative expansion that we develop in the anisotropic limit. At the topological phase transition, SRE exhibits universal scaling dictated by critical exponents.
Exactly solving a spinless fermionic system in two and three dimensions, we investigate the scaling behavior of the block entropy in critical and noncritical phases. The scaling of the block entropy crucially depends on the nature of the excitation spectrum of the system and on the topology of the Fermi surface. Noticeably, in the critical phases the scaling violates the area law and acquires a logarithmic correction only when a well-defined Fermi surface exists in the system. When the area law is violated, we accurately verify a conjecture for the prefactor of the logarithmic correction, proposed by D. Gioev and I. Klich [Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 100503 (2006)].
Entanglement and magic are resources that reveal complementary aspects of quantum many-body systems. Their interplay is captured by nonlocal magic, the magic that survives arbitrary local changes of basis. Yet their markedly different dynamical behavior leaves open how this irreducible component of magic spreads. Here we connect nonlocal magic to the capacity of entanglement, a tractable quantity measuring fluctuations of the entanglement Hamiltonian. This connection enables analytically controlled predictions across a wide range of many-body dynamics, from chaotic to integrable systems, which we investigate also using large-scale numerical simulations. In chaotic systems, nonlocal magic exhibits a transient buildup, with logarithmic growth in time followed by decay to a size-independent value. For integrable systems, we develop a quasiparticle picture in quantitative agreement with numerics, showing that the same initial growth instead leads to saturation at a value logarithmic in subsystem size. These contrasting behaviors have an operational consequence for entanglement embezzlement: the strongest scramblers embezzle only transiently, whereas free-fermionic dynamics can sustain universal embezzlement in the steady state.