arXiv:2609.20951
Nonlocal Magic Spreading in Many-body Quantum Dynamics: From Chaotic Evolution to Quasi-particle Picture in Integrable Models
Sreemayee Aditya, Piotr Sierant, Xhek Turkeshi
Abstract
Entanglement and magic are resources that reveal complementary aspects of quantum many-body systems. Their interplay is captured by nonlocal magic, the magic that survives arbitrary local changes of basis. Yet their markedly different dynamical behavior leaves open how this irreducible component of magic spreads. Here we connect nonlocal magic to the capacity of entanglement, a tractable quantity measuring fluctuations of the entanglement Hamiltonian. This connection enables analytically controlled predictions across a wide range of many-body dynamics, from chaotic to integrable systems, which we investigate also using large-scale numerical simulations. In chaotic systems, nonlocal magic exhibits a transient buildup, with logarithmic growth in time followed by decay to a size-independent value. For integrable systems, we develop a quasiparticle picture in quantitative agreement with numerics, showing that the same initial growth instead leads to saturation at a value logarithmic in subsystem size. These contrasting behaviors have an operational consequence for entanglement embezzlement: the strongest scramblers embezzle only transiently, whereas free-fermionic dynamics can sustain universal embezzlement in the steady state.
AI Summary
The paper studies how nonlocal magic—the magic remaining after arbitrary unitaries within each side of a bipartition—develops under many-body dynamics. Starting from an existing exact expression in terms of ordered Schmidt probabilities, it relates this resource to the distribution of entanglement energies and its variance, the capacity of entanglement $C$. For broad, smooth, approximately Gaussian spectra, it derives $D_{\mathrm{NL}}\simeq\tfrac12\log_2(\pi\ln^2(2)C/8)$; near a flat dyadic spectrum, $D_{\mathrm{NL}}\simeq(\ln2/4)C$. A distribution-independent bound gives $D_{\mathrm{NL}}\leq\tfrac12\log_2(1+C)+5.74$, although large capacity alone does not imply large nonlocal magic. A finite-width Gaussian approximation uses only entropy and capacity. State-vector simulations of Haar circuits and chaotic Ising dynamics show logarithmic initial growth followed by a peak and decay. Haar circuits have peak time proportional to subsystem size and logarithmic peak height; the balanced-cut stationary value is approximately $0.244$. Energy conservation produces algebraic rather than exponential relaxation. Free-fermion quenches instead retain extensive stationary capacity, giving $D_{\mathrm{NL}}(\infty)=\tfrac12\log_2L_A+O(1)$. Quasiparticle predictions are tested using covariance-matrix simulations; random matchgate circuits show analogous retention with diffusive saturation times proportional to $L_A^2$. These diverging families support universal entanglement embezzlement. The Gaussian description requires spectral regularity and suppressed higher normalized cumulants. Chaotic Hamiltonian data remain preasymptotic and do not show systematically improving quantitative agreement. Retention requires nonzero capacity density: half-filled Néel quenches provide an exception. A conditional thermodynamic-Bethe-ansatz extension predicts the same stationary logarithmic law in interacting integrable systems, without numerical verification.
Central claim may not hold: Integrable dynamics need not retain logarithmically growing stationary nonlocal magic: the paper's Néel-state XX quench has zero stationary capacity density and vanishing stationary nonlocal magic, so the abstract needs a positive-capacity qualification. Chaotic Hamiltonian dynamics need not have size-independent stationary nonlocal magic: a regular thermal steady state at fixed nonzero temperature has extensive capacity and therefore logarithmic nonlocal magic under the paper's own spectral assumptions.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 18 pages, 8 figures