Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.35687

Speed-Fisher Information: Chaos and Irreversibility in Classical and Quantum Dynamics

Nachiket Karve, Nathan Rose, David Campbell, Anatoli Polkovnikov

cond-mat.stat-mechnlin.CDquant-phSubmitted Sep 28, 2026• Announced Sep 29, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We propose a unified perspective on classical and quantum chaos based on the sensitivity of a system's stationary states to slow driving. We probe this sensitivity via the system's susceptibility to the average protocol speed, which we call the ``speed-Fisher information," and relate it to irreversible entropy production in the system. We show that chaotic dynamics manifests as a divergence of the speed-Fisher information with the protocol time, and that this response is controlled by the perturbation's low-frequency spectral weight. This approach to chaos applies to both classical and quantum Hamiltonian systems, and naturally extends to non-Hamiltonian classical flows. Additionally, we identify a quantum regime at times shorter than the Planckian timescale, in which the speed-Fisher information exhibits a uniquely quantum scaling. We illustrate this framework with simple classical and quantum examples

AI Summary

Can sensitivity to slow cyclic driving provide a common diagnostic of classical and quantum chaos? This paper defines “speed-Fisher information” $\mathscr I_{\bar v}(\mu)$ as the fidelity susceptibility of the final state to mean driving speed, with inverse protocol duration $\mu$, evaluated at zero speed. It derives spectral representations for quantum systems, classical Hamiltonian dynamics, and smooth stationary distributions of non-Hamiltonian flows. For Hamiltonian stationary states $\rho=P(H_0)$, the classical identity and low-frequency quantum approximation express this susceptibility as a filtered, score-weighted perturbation spectrum. If that spectrum scales as $|\omega|^\alpha$, then $\mathscr I_{\bar v}\sim\mu^{\alpha-1}$ for $-1<\alpha<1$. A spectral plateau gives $1/\mu$ growth; singular spectra give stronger growth. Under stated spectral and protocol assumptions, regular dynamics has bounded response. Specific protocols reproduce regularized adiabatic-gauge-potential norms. In the quasistatic regime, relative entropy production is approximately $\bar v^2\mathscr I_{\bar v}/2$, enabling extraction from dissipated work in thermal states. A Lorentzian relaxation model with exponential driving yields $t^4$, potentially intermediate $t^3$, and long-time $t$ growth, controlled by relaxation and Planckian times $\hbar/(k_BT)$. Analytical derivations are supplemented by driven simulations of pendula, spins, Bose–Hubbard and Ising models, and FPUT chains. The diagnostic depends on the state, perturbation, and observation timescale; conserved perturbations reveal nothing. Quantum quasistatic formulas require sufficiently small sampled energy differences, finite spectra restrict asymptotic interpretation, singular invariant measures require regularization, and the crossover results assume the specified spectral model.

Little sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsStrong assumptions

Central claim may not hold: The proposed chaos diagnostic is conditional on the stationary state and perturbation having appropriate low-frequency spectral weight, rather than following from chaos alone. The quantum long-duration divergence requires a continuum or thermodynamic limit, or a finite observation-time window, and does not persist indefinitely in a fixed finite-dimensional system. The claim that short-time μ⁻⁴ scaling is absent classically is false: the paper's exact classical formula gives that scaling whenever the second spectral moment is finite and nonzero, including for a driven thermal harmonic oscillator.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
23 pages, 10 figures

Related papers

Universal Dynamical Response to Slow Driving in Chaotic Systems

Nachiket Karve, Nathan Rose, David Campbell +1 more

We propose a unified perspective on classical and quantum chaos based on the sensitivity of a system's stationary states to slow driving. We probe this sensitivity via the system's susceptibility to the average protocol speed, which we call the ``speed-Fisher information," and relate it to irreversible entropy production in the system. We show that chaotic dynamics manifests as a divergence of the speed-Fisher information with the protocol time, and that this response is controlled by the perturbation's low-frequency spectral weight. This approach to chaos applies to both classical and quantum Hamiltonian systems, and naturally extends to non-Hamiltonian classical flows. We illustrate this framework with simple classical and quantum examples, along with a non-Hamiltonian flow that qualitatively exhibits analogous low-frequency spectral behavior.

cond-mat.stat-mechCross-listedarXiv:2606.23810•Jun 24, 2026

Quantum and classical chaos through adiabatic transformations

Hyeongjin Kim

The study of non-equilibrium dynamics is central to understanding how macroscopic irreversibility and thermal behavior emerge from microscopic reversible dynamics. A quintessential phenomenon that commonly occurs in non-equilibrium dynamics is the emergence of chaos. Chaos, whose theory originates from classical dynamics, is traditionally understood through a system's exponential sensitivity to initial conditions through microscopic dynamics. However, this definition does not fully capture classical and quantum many-body systems. This dissertation establishes and explores adiabatic transformations as a unifying framework for understanding chaos, integrability, and thermalization across both regimes. First, we show that the complexity of adiabatic transformations, which preserve classical time-averaged trajectories and quantum eigenstates under Hamiltonian deformations, serves as a measure of chaos. Physically, this measure quantifies the response of observables through their long-time instabilities and irregularities as manifested by their low-frequency noise. The applications of adiabatic transformations go beyond serving as a diagnostic of chaos, as they can be used to obtain a deeper understanding of the nature of chaos: a theme that drives the rest of this dissertation. Second, we uncover the geometric structure of integrability and chaos. By constructing adiabatic flows that minimize eigenstate deformations in quantum many-body systems parameterized by two independent couplings, we reveal that integrability acts as an attractor of these flows. This provides an a priori method for identifying integrable regions in complex many-body systems. Third, we investigate the timescales of thermalization and chaos in many-spin systems by studying the response of observables. We uncover a novel phenomenon, denoted as deconfined chaos, in the central spin model with XX interactions, where chaotic instabilities and thermalization occur on the same timescale. Fourth, we establish a correspondence between temperature and integrability-breaking perturbation for both classical and quantum many-spin systems. Therefore, we demonstrate that chaos is not determined solely by microscopic terms but can be renormalized by macroscopic thermodynamic temperature.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Defining classical and quantum chaos through adiabatic transformations

Hyeongjin Kim, Cedric Lim, Kirill Matirko +2 more

Abstract We present a unified formalism which identifies chaos in both quantum and classical systems in an equivalent manner by means of adiabatic transformations . The complexity of adiabatic transformations which preserve classical time-averaged trajectories (quantum eigenstates) in response to Hamiltonian deformations serves as a measure of chaos. This complexity is quantified by the (properly regularized) fidelity susceptibility or, more generally, by the geometric tensor. Physically this measure quantifies (i) long time instabilities of physical observables due to small changes in the Hamiltonian of the system and (ii) irregularity of physical observables contained in low frequency noise. Our exposition clearly showcases the common structures underlying quantum and classical chaos and allows us to distinguish integrable, chaotic but non-thermalizing, and ergodic/mixing regimes. We apply the fidelity susceptibility to a model of two coupled spins and demonstrate that it successfully predicts the universal onset of chaos, both for finite spin S and in the classical limit S → ∞ . Interestingly, we find that finite S effects are anomalously large close to integrability.

arXiv:2401.01927•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jan 19, 2026•29 citations

Quantum Chaos and Quantum Randomness—Paradigms of Entropy Production on the Smallest Scales

Thomas Dittrich

Quantum chaos is presented as a paradigm of information processing by dynamical systems at the bottom of the range of phase-space scales. Starting with a brief review of classical chaos as entropy flow from micro- to macro-scales, I argue that quantum chaos came as an indispensable rectification, removing inconsistencies related to entropy in classical chaos: bottom-up information currents require an inexhaustible entropy production and a diverging information density in phase-space, reminiscent of Gibbs' paradox in statistical mechanics. It is shown how a mere discretization of the state space of classical models already entails phenomena similar to hallmarks of quantum chaos and how the unitary time evolution in a closed system directly implies the "quantum death" of classical chaos. As complementary evidence, I discuss quantum chaos under continuous measurement. Here, the two-way exchange of information with a macroscopic apparatus opens an inexhaustible source of entropy and lifts the limitations implied by unitary quantum dynamics in closed systems. The infiltration of fresh entropy restores permanent chaotic dynamics in observed quantum systems. Could other instances of stochasticity in quantum mechanics be interpreted in a similar guise? Where observed quantum systems generate randomness, could it result from an exchange of entropy with the macroscopic meter? This possibility is explored, presenting a model for spin measurement in a unitary setting and some preliminary analytical results based on it.

arXiv:1901.09845•Entropy•Mar 15, 2019•7 citations

Time irreversibility of classically chaotic quantum dynamics

Giulio Casati, Boris V. Chirikov

The nature of classically chaotic quantum dynamics is studied by menas of a numerical time reversal experiment. It turns out that there is a fundamental quantum scale below which the system cannot exhibit classical irreversibility to external perturbations. On the other hand, a paradoxical phenomenon manifesting that quantum irreversibility may exceed its classical counterpart is discovered. These features are explained in terms of semicalssical dynamical theory. Introduction Classically chaotic quantum systems in general can exhibit intrinsinc chaotic behaviour on a quite restricted time scale [1], In particular localization phenomena provide direct evidence exhibiting the suppression of quantum ergodicity [2]. On the other hand, recent studies reveal that a many-dimensional system can mimic some aspects peculiar to chaotic dynamics quite well on an unexpectedly long time scale [3]. A remarkable feature that distinguishes chaotic motion from integrable motion is the sensitive dependence of dynamics on external perturbations. For classical dynamical systems such a sensitivity can be well defined by measuring how two nearby trajectories in the phase space separate in time. However, there has been proposed no systematic way to examine the sensitivity of quantum dynamics to external perturbation. In quantum dynamics, it is not possible to trace a well defined trajectory in phase space, because both quantum uncertainty and chaotic instability make a localized wavepacket spread suddenly over the phase space [4]. There is, however, a simple way in which we may test the quantum sensitivity quantitively. This is the time reversal experiment described below. In this chapter I describe several remarkable characteristics of quantal instability which have been clarified by the time reversal experiment.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 27, 1995•5 citations

Quantum Chaos and Quantum Optimal Transport

Jordan Cotler, Felipe Hernández

Chaos in classical systems can be characterized by Lyapunov exponents that measure the exponential divergence of nearby trajectories, but directly extending this framework to quantum mechanics has been a persistent challenge. The wavelike nature of quantum states and the non-commutative geometry of quantum phase space obstruct a straightforward generalization of classical chaos theory. Here we develop a rigorous approach to quantum chaos by leveraging quantum optimal transport theory, which provides the missing geometric foundation for measuring distances between extended quantum distributions. We define quantum Lyapunov exponents that naturally avoid divergences encountered when naïvely generalizing classical exponents, and show that in the semiclassical limit they recover the classical global expansion rate, and hence the usual maximal Lyapunov exponent when they coincide. Our framework provides a tight connection between the divergence of classical trajectories and semiclassical phase space evolution, and additionally clarifies the role of out-of-time-order correlators as diagnostics of quantum chaos. These results establish quantum optimal transport as a unifying mathematical foundation for quantum chaos theory, providing new tools to characterize dynamical behavior across the full range of quantum dynamics from simple few-body models to complex many-body systems.

quant-pharXiv:2608.27350•Aug 28, 2026
We propose a unified perspective on classical and quantum chaos based on the sensitivity of a system's stationary states to slow driving. We probe this sensitivity via the system's susceptibility to the average protocol speed, which we call the ``speed-Fisher information," and relate it to irreversible entropy production in the system. We show that chaotic dynamics manifests as a divergence of the speed-Fisher information with the protocol time, and that this response is controlled by the perturbation's low-frequency spectral weight. This approach to chaos applies to both classical and quantum Hamiltonian systems, and naturally extends to non-Hamiltonian classical flows. Additionally, we identify a quantum regime at times shorter than the Planckian timescale, in which the speed-Fisher information exhibits a uniquely quantum scaling. We illustrate this framework with simple classical and quantum examples
Can sensitivity to slow cyclic driving provide a common diagnostic of classical and quantum chaos? This paper defines “speed-Fisher information” Ivˉ(μ)\mathscr I_{\bar v}(\mu)Ivˉ​(μ) as the fidelity susceptibility of the final state to mean driving speed, with inverse protocol duration μ\muμ, evaluated at zero speed. It derives spectral representations for quantum systems, classical Hamiltonian dynamics, and smooth stationary distributions of non-Hamiltonian flows.
For Hamiltonian stationary states ρ=P(H0)\rho=P(H_0)ρ=P(H0​), the classical identity and low-frequency quantum approximation express this susceptibility as a filtered, score-weighted perturbation spectrum. If that spectrum scales as ∣ω∣α|\omega|^\alpha∣ω∣α, then Ivˉ∼μα−1\mathscr I_{\bar v}\sim\mu^{\alpha-1}Ivˉ​∼μα−1 for −1<α<1-1<\alpha<1−1<α<1. A spectral plateau gives 1/μ1/\mu1/μ growth; singular spectra give stronger growth. Under stated spectral and protocol assumptions, regular dynamics has bounded response. Specific protocols reproduce regularized adiabatic-gauge-potential norms. In the quasistatic regime, relative entropy production is approximately vˉ2Ivˉ/2\bar v^2\mathscr I_{\bar v}/2vˉ2Ivˉ​/2, enabling extraction from dissipated work in thermal states.
A Lorentzian relaxation model with exponential driving yields t4t^4t4, potentially intermediate t3t^3t3, and long-time ttt growth, controlled by relaxation and Planckian times ℏ/(kBT)\hbar/(k_BT)ℏ/(kB​T). Analytical derivations are supplemented by driven simulations of pendula, spins, Bose–Hubbard and Ising models, and FPUT chains.
The diagnostic depends on the state, perturbation, and observation timescale; conserved perturbations reveal nothing. Quantum quasistatic formulas require sufficiently small sampled energy differences, finite spectra restrict asymptotic interpretation, singular invariant measures require regularization, and the crossover results assume the specified spectral model.
We propose a unified perspective on classical and quantum chaos based on the sensitivity of a system's stationary states to slow driving. We probe this sensitivity via the system's susceptibility to the average protocol speed, which we call the ``speed-Fisher information," and relate it to irreversible entropy production in the system. We show that chaotic dynamics manifests as a divergence of the speed-Fisher information with the protocol time, and that this response is controlled by the perturbation's low-frequency spectral weight. This approach to chaos applies to both classical and quantum Hamiltonian systems, and naturally extends to non-Hamiltonian classical flows. We illustrate this framework with simple classical and quantum examples, along with a non-Hamiltonian flow that qualitatively exhibits analogous low-frequency spectral behavior.
The study of non-equilibrium dynamics is central to understanding how macroscopic irreversibility and thermal behavior emerge from microscopic reversible dynamics. A quintessential phenomenon that commonly occurs in non-equilibrium dynamics is the emergence of chaos. Chaos, whose theory originates from classical dynamics, is traditionally understood through a system's exponential sensitivity to initial conditions through microscopic dynamics. However, this definition does not fully capture classical and quantum many-body systems. This dissertation establishes and explores adiabatic transformations as a unifying framework for understanding chaos, integrability, and thermalization across both regimes. First, we show that the complexity of adiabatic transformations, which preserve classical time-averaged trajectories and quantum eigenstates under Hamiltonian deformations, serves as a measure of chaos. Physically, this measure quantifies the response of observables through their long-time instabilities and irregularities as manifested by their low-frequency noise. The applications of adiabatic transformations go beyond serving as a diagnostic of chaos, as they can be used to obtain a deeper understanding of the nature of chaos: a theme that drives the rest of this dissertation. Second, we uncover the geometric structure of integrability and chaos. By constructing adiabatic flows that minimize eigenstate deformations in quantum many-body systems parameterized by two independent couplings, we reveal that integrability acts as an attractor of these flows. This provides an a priori method for identifying integrable regions in complex many-body systems. Third, we investigate the timescales of thermalization and chaos in many-spin systems by studying the response of observables. We uncover a novel phenomenon, denoted as deconfined chaos, in the central spin model with XX interactions, where chaotic instabilities and thermalization occur on the same timescale. Fourth, we establish a correspondence between temperature and integrability-breaking perturbation for both classical and quantum many-spin systems. Therefore, we demonstrate that chaos is not determined solely by microscopic terms but can be renormalized by macroscopic thermodynamic temperature.
Abstract We present a unified formalism which identifies chaos in both quantum and classical systems in an equivalent manner by means of adiabatic transformations . The complexity of adiabatic transformations which preserve classical time-averaged trajectories (quantum eigenstates) in response to Hamiltonian deformations serves as a measure of chaos. This complexity is quantified by the (properly regularized) fidelity susceptibility or, more generally, by the geometric tensor. Physically this measure quantifies (i) long time instabilities of physical observables due to small changes in the Hamiltonian of the system and (ii) irregularity of physical observables contained in low frequency noise. Our exposition clearly showcases the common structures underlying quantum and classical chaos and allows us to distinguish integrable, chaotic but non-thermalizing, and ergodic/mixing regimes. We apply the fidelity susceptibility to a model of two coupled spins and demonstrate that it successfully predicts the universal onset of chaos, both for finite spin S and in the classical limit S → ∞ . Interestingly, we find that finite S effects are anomalously large close to integrability.
Quantum chaos is presented as a paradigm of information processing by dynamical systems at the bottom of the range of phase-space scales. Starting with a brief review of classical chaos as entropy flow from micro- to macro-scales, I argue that quantum chaos came as an indispensable rectification, removing inconsistencies related to entropy in classical chaos: bottom-up information currents require an inexhaustible entropy production and a diverging information density in phase-space, reminiscent of Gibbs' paradox in statistical mechanics. It is shown how a mere discretization of the state space of classical models already entails phenomena similar to hallmarks of quantum chaos and how the unitary time evolution in a closed system directly implies the "quantum death" of classical chaos. As complementary evidence, I discuss quantum chaos under continuous measurement. Here, the two-way exchange of information with a macroscopic apparatus opens an inexhaustible source of entropy and lifts the limitations implied by unitary quantum dynamics in closed systems. The infiltration of fresh entropy restores permanent chaotic dynamics in observed quantum systems. Could other instances of stochasticity in quantum mechanics be interpreted in a similar guise? Where observed quantum systems generate randomness, could it result from an exchange of entropy with the macroscopic meter? This possibility is explored, presenting a model for spin measurement in a unitary setting and some preliminary analytical results based on it.
The nature of classically chaotic quantum dynamics is studied by menas of a numerical time reversal experiment. It turns out that there is a fundamental quantum scale below which the system cannot exhibit classical irreversibility to external perturbations. On the other hand, a paradoxical phenomenon manifesting that quantum irreversibility may exceed its classical counterpart is discovered. These features are explained in terms of semicalssical dynamical theory. Introduction Classically chaotic quantum systems in general can exhibit intrinsinc chaotic behaviour on a quite restricted time scale [1], In particular localization phenomena provide direct evidence exhibiting the suppression of quantum ergodicity [2]. On the other hand, recent studies reveal that a many-dimensional system can mimic some aspects peculiar to chaotic dynamics quite well on an unexpectedly long time scale [3]. A remarkable feature that distinguishes chaotic motion from integrable motion is the sensitive dependence of dynamics on external perturbations. For classical dynamical systems such a sensitivity can be well defined by measuring how two nearby trajectories in the phase space separate in time. However, there has been proposed no systematic way to examine the sensitivity of quantum dynamics to external perturbation. In quantum dynamics, it is not possible to trace a well defined trajectory in phase space, because both quantum uncertainty and chaotic instability make a localized wavepacket spread suddenly over the phase space [4]. There is, however, a simple way in which we may test the quantum sensitivity quantitively. This is the time reversal experiment described below. In this chapter I describe several remarkable characteristics of quantal instability which have been clarified by the time reversal experiment.
Chaos in classical systems can be characterized by Lyapunov exponents that measure the exponential divergence of nearby trajectories, but directly extending this framework to quantum mechanics has been a persistent challenge. The wavelike nature of quantum states and the non-commutative geometry of quantum phase space obstruct a straightforward generalization of classical chaos theory. Here we develop a rigorous approach to quantum chaos by leveraging quantum optimal transport theory, which provides the missing geometric foundation for measuring distances between extended quantum distributions. We define quantum Lyapunov exponents that naturally avoid divergences encountered when naïvely generalizing classical exponents, and show that in the semiclassical limit they recover the classical global expansion rate, and hence the usual maximal Lyapunov exponent when they coincide. Our framework provides a tight connection between the divergence of classical trajectories and semiclassical phase space evolution, and additionally clarifies the role of out-of-time-order correlators as diagnostics of quantum chaos. These results establish quantum optimal transport as a unifying mathematical foundation for quantum chaos theory, providing new tools to characterize dynamical behavior across the full range of quantum dynamics from simple few-body models to complex many-body systems.