arXiv:2609.31832
Characterising the precision of a clock without any external time reference
Pablo Á. Domínguez, Christopher Chubb, Mischa P. Woods
Abstract
Determining a clock's precision usually requires comparison with a better time reference, yet no ideal reference is physically attainable. We show how a single clock can characterise its own precision using only a signal splitter and delayed trigger, whose uncertainty is explicitly accounted for. The resulting estimator depends only on tick-count statistics. A purpose-built electronic circuit validates the method without an external timekeeper or a second clock.
AI Summary
Can a clock’s precision be measured without comparing it to another clock? This paper considers $R=\mu^2/\sigma^2$, where $\mu$ is the mean inter-tick interval and $\sigma^2$ is the asymptotic variance per tick, including correlations for stationary, weakly dependent tick sequences. It proposes splitting the clock’s output, using the first tick to activate a delayed trigger, and counting ticks until that trigger fires. For a long delay $D$ independent of the ticking process, the central result is the asymptotic relation $R\simeq\mathbb{E}[\tau_D]/[\operatorname{Var}(\tau_D)-\operatorname{Var}(D)/\mu^2]$. The derivation uses central-limit and renewal/random-walk asymptotics; finite-delay corrections are also presented. If the clock’s frequency can be varied while preserving $R$, measurements at multiple settings are proposed to separate delay fluctuations from clock fluctuations using tick-count statistics alone. An electronic implementation combines an RC-based delayed trigger, logic gates and a counter. Across 1,600 trials with a microcontroller-generated clock, temperature-corrected counts had mean $18408.46\pm0.18$ and standard deviation $7.21\pm0.12$, giving $R=353.89\pm12.5$. A conventional timing-uncertainty estimate gives the comparison range $296.43\le R\le566.22$. The method requires sufficiently stable, independent delays and the stated stationarity, moment and weak-dependence assumptions. Separating comparable clock and delay noise requires precision-preserving frequency tuning; doing so without modifying the clock remains open. The paper also notes potentially slow statistical convergence when delay noise is comparable to clock noise.
Central claim may not hold: The abstract's tick-count-only characterisation is conditional on controlling delay noise, or on tuning the clock frequency without changing its precision, rather than applying to an arbitrary single clock. The experiment does not quantitatively establish that residual delayed-trigger noise is negligible or subtract it, so its count variance does not independently identify the clock's precision. Equation (A5)'s universal finite-delay variance correction fails for exponential tick intervals, whose renewal count is exactly Poisson and has no claimed additional 4/3 constant. The reported conventional validation range uses a mean tick period half that implied by the stated 4096 Hz tick frequency, producing a factor-of-four discrepancy in precision.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 8 pages, 4 figures