Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.30875

Quantum-circuit simulation of three-flavor neutrino oscillations: vacuum, matter, and CP diagnostics

Daming Li

quant-phSubmitted Sep 25, 2026• Announced Sep 28, 2026• 0 citations• Revised Oct 3, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Sep 25, 2026v2 · Oct 3, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We simulate three-flavor neutrino oscillations on two-qubit quantum circuits. The flavor space is embedded as $\ket{00}=ν_e$, $\ket{01}=ν_μ$, $\ket{10}=ν_τ$ with the $\ket{11}$ channel kept inert, and the input mixing parameters (NuFIT~5.3, normal ordering, with SK-atm) follow the global fit. We verify three physical settings against analytic or exact references: vacuum propagation, reproduced by a mass-eigenstate phase circuit to $\sim 10^{-16}$; constant-density Mikheev--Smirnov--Wolfenstein (MSW) matter effects, showing resonant flavor conversion when the matter potential $A$ crosses $Δm^2_{31}$; and varying-density (supernova shock-shell) propagation by slicing plus second-order Suzuki--Trotter splitting, with per-slice Trotter error $\sim 10^{-6}$ and total accuracy $\sim 10^{-4}$ against the continuous profile. We report a Suzuki--Trotter precision--resource calibration varying order, step number, and matrix/probability error. It delimits brute-force Trotterization on solar baselines: we quantify both standard alternatives, coherence averaging and adiabatic MSW. We also compute quantum-information diagnostics from the same model parameters, namely mode entanglement and the CP asymmetry. Finally, we extend the framework to open quantum systems via a Lindblad master equation with dephasing and absorptive channels. These results provide a reproducible link between low-energy oscillation observables and quantum-information measures.

AI Summary

The paper studies how two-qubit circuits can represent single-particle, three-flavor neutrino oscillations in vacuum and matter, and how simulation accuracy depends on Suzuki–Trotter splitting. Three computational states encode the flavors; the fourth is inactive during unitary evolution. Mixing parameters are fixed to the NuFIT 5.3 normal-ordering best fit. Vacuum evolution uses a PMNS basis change, mass-eigenstate phases, and the inverse basis change. Statevector simulations agree with analytic probabilities to approximately $10^{-16}$. Matter evolution uses a diagonal/off-diagonal Hamiltonian split. Numerical comparisons with exact matrix evolution recover $N^{-1}$ and $N^{-2}$ errors for first- and second-order splitting; the second-order matrix error is $2.23\times10^{-5}$ at $N=64$ for $L=500$ km and $E=1$ GeV. A constant-density scan reports electron-flavor survival near $0.08$ around $A=2.4\times10^{-3}\,\mathrm{eV}^2$. An exponential-density transit, discretized into 60 slices with 64 second-order steps each, agrees with continuous-profile propagation to roughly $2\times10^{-4}$. Additional calculations include encoding-dependent concurrence, vacuum CP asymmetry, and phenomenological Lindblad dephasing and absorption. The paper also estimates the large phase budget for solar propagation and discusses coherence averaging and adiabatic MSW as alternatives to uniform splitting. The treatment excludes neutrino–neutrino interactions, collective dynamics, and field-theoretic effects. Circuits use dense unitary matrices rather than hardware execution; elementary-gate decomposition, depth and noise estimates remain future work. Dissipative rates are not mapped to microscopic environments, and the reported precision calibration concerns the selected small-system parameter settings.

Likely largely AI-generatedOverclaimsIncrementalSmall numerics onlyPossible error

Error found: The claimed solar-baseline Trotter resource threshold is inferred from an unjustified oscillation-sampling requirement rather than demonstrated by convergence calculations or product-formula error bounds. The absorption caption incorrectly asserts zero muon and tau populations and electron-plus-sink probability equal to one despite the specified Hamiltonian continuing to convert flavors before absorption. The stated vacuum parameters produce a CP-asymmetry extremum near 4,600 km at 3 GeV of approximately -0.060 rather than the reported -0.068.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
18 pages, 10 figures

Related papers

Simulating three-flavor neutrino oscillations on a nuclear magnetic resonance quantum processor

Gayatri Singh, Kavita Dorai

Abstract Neutrino oscillations can be efficiently simulated on a quantum computer using the Pontecorvo-Maki-Nakagawa-Sakata (PMNS) theory in close analogy to the physical processes realized in experiments. We simulate three-flavor neutrino oscillations on a two-qubit NMR quantum information processor. The three-flavor neutrino states were encoded into the two-qubit system, leaving one redundant basis state (representing an unphysical sterile neutrino). The neutrino oscillations were experimentally simulated in different scenarios, including propagation in vacuum and through surrounding matter, and both with and without a CP violating phase δ at a Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment (DUNE) baseline distance of L = 1285 km. The oscillation probabilities were obtained after unitarily time evolving the initial flavor state and comparisons were performed between different scenarios. The interaction with matter is considered as a perturbation to the vacuum Hamiltonian, and the same quantum circuit is employed with an approximation of two mixing angles (θ 12 and θ 13) and mass eigenvalues. Our experimental results match well with numerical simulations and highlight the potential of quantum computers for exploring the physics of neutrino oscillations.

arXiv:2412.15617•Physica Scripta•Jul 10, 2025•7 citations

Neutrino oscillations as weight-preserving quantum circuits: what the qg symmetry filter reads, and what no oscillation circuit can see

Vicente Humberto Monteverde

A neutrino is produced and detected in a flavour state and propagates in mass states, so flavour oscillation is a rotation. We write it in the measurement-level units of the open-source library qang, where a qubit is described by qg_Z = <Z>, and place every flavour on its own qubit with a single excitation (the weight-1 sector). Every gate of the oscillation circuit then conserves the Hamming weight, and the qg symmetry filter (discard the shots that left the sector) applies. Six results follow, all on the noise models of IBM devices, each pre-registered and reported as passed or failed. (i) In vacuum qg_Z = cos²2θ + sin²2θ cos Δ is the spherical law of cosines, and at the oscillation maximum the mixing angle is a quarter of the qang angle arccos(qg_Z), with the θ-independent error bar 1/(4√(N+½)). (ii) Three flavours on three qubits: the filter cuts the error of the transition probabilities about 3× and the CP asymmetry at a DUNE-like baseline survives. (iii) Earth matter enters as a weight-preserving Trotter circuit, and matter fakes CP violation. (iv) In dense neutrino gases the conserved number is the number of ν₂, not the flavour number, so the filter applies in the mass basis (2.2-2.8×). (v) For solar neutrinos the phases are lost before detection, so the whole Sun is one rotation and the filter, though it works, is not needed. (vi) The mass ordering is read correctly through matter on three device models; Majorana phases change no oscillation probability, and the transpiler deletes them; a sterile neutrino is a fourth qubit in the weight-1 sector, where the filter cuts the error 5.5×. The link between neutrinos and qang is modelling, not new physics: the oscillation is a rotation, and qang reads rotations.

•Nov 5, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Circuit Simulation of Two-Flavor Neutrino Oscillation: Noise Robustness, Error Mitigation, and Validation on Real Quantum Hardware

Muhammad Abdullah Anwar

This project investigates whether a minimal single-qubit quantum circuit can accurately reproduce two-flavor neutrino oscillation probabilities, and quantifies the circuit's noise robustness in both simulation and on real IBM Quantum hardware. Using atmospheric-channel parameters from NuFit 6.0, an exact statevector circuit matches the analytical oscillation formula to floating-point precision (MAE ≈ 6.8×10⁻¹⁷), and a combined noise model (averaged over 5 random seeds) places the circuit's failure threshold at severity 1.143 ± 0.017; converting this to a real-hardware safety margin is sensitive to calibration choice, with plausible estimates ranging from roughly 1× to roughly 38× current hardware noise. A repeated 4-trial paired statistical test on real IBM Quantum hardware (ibm_marrakesh) found no significant effect of standard error-mitigation techniques (dynamical decoupling, gate twirling; p = 0.523) — reversing an initial single-trial result and illustrating why repeated trials are needed on noisy NISQ hardware. This archive contains all three Jupyter notebooks (classical baseline, ideal qubit simulation, noise/hardware validation), raw hardware measurement data, the full research paper, and a research log documenting every finding, correction, and methodological lesson from the project.

•Aug 20, 2026•0 citations

Quantum circuits for simulating neutrino propagation in matter

Sandeep Joshi, Garima Rajpoot, P. Shukla

Abstract Quantum simulation of particle phenomena is a rapidly advancing field of research. With the widespread availability of quantum simulators, a given quantum system can be simulated in numerous ways, offering flexibility in implementation and exploration. Here, we perform quantum simulation of neutrino propagation in matter, a phenomenon that plays a crucial role in neutrino oscillations. We present quantum circuits with novel gate arrangements to simulate neutrino propagation in both constant and varying matter density profiles. The oscillation probabilities are determined by encoding and measuring the qubit states in the neutrino flavor basis, showing excellent agreement with theoretical predictions.

arXiv:2503.20238•Physica Scripta•Jul 24, 2025•2 citations

Trapped-ion quantum simulation of collective neutrino oscillations

Valentina Amitrano, Alessandro Roggero, Piero Luchi +3 more

It is well known that the neutrino flavor in extreme astrophysical environments changes under the effect of three contributions: the vacuum oscillation, the interaction with the surrounding matter, and the collective oscillations due to interactions between different neutrinos. The latter adds a nonlinear contribution to the equations of motion, making the description of their dynamics complex. In this work we study various strategies to simulate the coherent collective oscillations of a system of $N$ neutrinos in the two-flavor approximation using quantum computation. This was achieved by using a pair-neutrino decomposition designed to account for the fact that the flavor Hamiltonian, in the presence of the neutrino-neutrino term, presents an all-to-all interaction that makes the implementation of the evolution dependent on the qubit topology. We analyze the Trotter error caused by the decomposition demonstrating that the complexity of the implementation of time evolution scales polynomially with the number of neutrinos and that the noise from near-term quantum device simulation can be reduced by optimizing the quantum circuit decomposition and exploiting a full-qubit connectivity. We find that the gate complexity using second order Trotter-Suzuki formulas scales better with system size than with other decomposition methods such as quantum signal processing. We finally present the application and the results of our algorithm on a real quantum device based on trapped-ion qubits.

arXiv:2207.03189•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jan 13, 2023•58 citations

CP asymmetry and visible decay in $3+1$ neutrino oscillations on a quantum computer

Amartya Sengupta, Sidhartha Samtani, Ani Girgvliani +1 more

We use quantum simulation to study how visible neutrino decay modifies the vacuum CP asymmetry in muon-to-electron oscillations within a $3+1$ neutrino scenario. The decay channel preserves CP symmetry, with CP violation arising from phases in the mixing matrix. We track the energy redistribution from visible decay and distinguish how parent attenuation and daughter regeneration modify the CP asymmetry. For the reference benchmark, the regenerated contribution is $4.85\times10^{-4}$, approximately $46\%$ of the total decay-induced shift. The full circuit for an effective two-energy model agrees with independent classical evolution. On an IBM quantum processor, we prepare the daughter state conditioned on decay and restore its physical normalization using fixed source and decay probabilities. After correction for measurement errors, the flavor-probability and coherence measurements both agree with the prediction within one standard error. Null controls test the suppression of the regenerated signal when daughter coherence or the relevant CP-sensitive mixing factor vanishes.

hep-phCross-listedarXiv:2609.27670•Sep 24, 2026•0 citations
We simulate three-flavor neutrino oscillations on two-qubit quantum circuits. The flavor space is embedded as ∣00⟩=νe\ket{00}=ν_e∣00⟩=νe​, ∣01⟩=νμ\ket{01}=ν_μ∣01⟩=νμ​, ∣10⟩=ντ\ket{10}=ν_τ∣10⟩=ντ​ with the ∣11⟩\ket{11}∣11⟩ channel kept inert, and the input mixing parameters (NuFIT~5.3, normal ordering, with SK-atm) follow the global fit. We verify three physical settings against analytic or exact references: vacuum propagation, reproduced by a mass-eigenstate phase circuit to ∼10−16\sim 10^{-16}∼10−16; constant-density Mikheev--Smirnov--Wolfenstein (MSW) matter effects, showing resonant flavor conversion when the matter potential AAA crosses Δm312Δm^2_{31}Δm312​; and varying-density (supernova shock-shell) propagation by slicing plus second-order Suzuki--Trotter splitting, with per-slice Trotter error ∼10−6\sim 10^{-6}∼10−6 and total accuracy ∼10−4\sim 10^{-4}∼10−4 against the continuous profile. We report a Suzuki--Trotter precision--resource calibration varying order, step number, and matrix/probability error. It delimits brute-force Trotterization on solar baselines: we quantify both standard alternatives, coherence averaging and adiabatic MSW. We also compute quantum-information diagnostics from the same model parameters, namely mode entanglement and the CP asymmetry. Finally, we extend the framework to open quantum systems via a Lindblad master equation with dephasing and absorptive channels. These results provide a reproducible link between low-energy oscillation observables and quantum-information measures.
The paper studies how two-qubit circuits can represent single-particle, three-flavor neutrino oscillations in vacuum and matter, and how simulation accuracy depends on Suzuki–Trotter splitting. Three computational states encode the flavors; the fourth is inactive during unitary evolution. Mixing parameters are fixed to the NuFIT 5.3 normal-ordering best fit.
Vacuum evolution uses a PMNS basis change, mass-eigenstate phases, and the inverse basis change. Statevector simulations agree with analytic probabilities to approximately 10−1610^{-16}10−16. Matter evolution uses a diagonal/off-diagonal Hamiltonian split. Numerical comparisons with exact matrix evolution recover N−1N^{-1}N−1 and N−2N^{-2}N−2 errors for first- and second-order splitting; the second-order matrix error is 2.23×10−52.23\times10^{-5}2.23×10−5 at N=64N=64N=64 for L=500L=500L=500 km and E=1E=1E=1 GeV. A constant-density scan reports electron-flavor survival near 0.080.080.08 around A=2.4×10−3 eV2A=2.4\times10^{-3}\,\mathrm{eV}^2A=2.4×10−3eV2. An exponential-density transit, discretized into 60 slices with 64 second-order steps each, agrees with continuous-profile propagation to roughly 2×10−42\times10^{-4}2×10−4.
Additional calculations include encoding-dependent concurrence, vacuum CP asymmetry, and phenomenological Lindblad dephasing and absorption. The paper also estimates the large phase budget for solar propagation and discusses coherence averaging and adiabatic MSW as alternatives to uniform splitting.
The treatment excludes neutrino–neutrino interactions, collective dynamics, and field-theoretic effects. Circuits use dense unitary matrices rather than hardware execution; elementary-gate decomposition, depth and noise estimates remain future work. Dissipative rates are not mapped to microscopic environments, and the reported precision calibration concerns the selected small-system parameter settings.
Abstract Neutrino oscillations can be efficiently simulated on a quantum computer using the Pontecorvo-Maki-Nakagawa-Sakata (PMNS) theory in close analogy to the physical processes realized in experiments. We simulate three-flavor neutrino oscillations on a two-qubit NMR quantum information processor. The three-flavor neutrino states were encoded into the two-qubit system, leaving one redundant basis state (representing an unphysical sterile neutrino). The neutrino oscillations were experimentally simulated in different scenarios, including propagation in vacuum and through surrounding matter, and both with and without a CP violating phase δ at a Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment (DUNE) baseline distance of L = 1285 km. The oscillation probabilities were obtained after unitarily time evolving the initial flavor state and comparisons were performed between different scenarios. The interaction with matter is considered as a perturbation to the vacuum Hamiltonian, and the same quantum circuit is employed with an approximation of two mixing angles (θ 12 and θ 13) and mass eigenvalues. Our experimental results match well with numerical simulations and highlight the potential of quantum computers for exploring the physics of neutrino oscillations.
A neutrino is produced and detected in a flavour state and propagates in mass states, so flavour oscillation is a rotation. We write it in the measurement-level units of the open-source library qang, where a qubit is described by qg_Z = <Z>, and place every flavour on its own qubit with a single excitation (the weight-1 sector). Every gate of the oscillation circuit then conserves the Hamming weight, and the qg symmetry filter (discard the shots that left the sector) applies. Six results follow, all on the noise models of IBM devices, each pre-registered and reported as passed or failed. (i) In vacuum qg_Z = cos²2θ + sin²2θ cos Δ is the spherical law of cosines, and at the oscillation maximum the mixing angle is a quarter of the qang angle arccos(qg_Z), with the θ-independent error bar 1/(4√(N+½)). (ii) Three flavours on three qubits: the filter cuts the error of the transition probabilities about 3× and the CP asymmetry at a DUNE-like baseline survives. (iii) Earth matter enters as a weight-preserving Trotter circuit, and matter fakes CP violation. (iv) In dense neutrino gases the conserved number is the number of ν₂, not the flavour number, so the filter applies in the mass basis (2.2-2.8×). (v) For solar neutrinos the phases are lost before detection, so the whole Sun is one rotation and the filter, though it works, is not needed. (vi) The mass ordering is read correctly through matter on three device models; Majorana phases change no oscillation probability, and the transpiler deletes them; a sterile neutrino is a fourth qubit in the weight-1 sector, where the filter cuts the error 5.5×. The link between neutrinos and qang is modelling, not new physics: the oscillation is a rotation, and qang reads rotations.
This project investigates whether a minimal single-qubit quantum circuit can accurately reproduce two-flavor neutrino oscillation probabilities, and quantifies the circuit's noise robustness in both simulation and on real IBM Quantum hardware. Using atmospheric-channel parameters from NuFit 6.0, an exact statevector circuit matches the analytical oscillation formula to floating-point precision (MAE ≈ 6.8×10⁻¹⁷), and a combined noise model (averaged over 5 random seeds) places the circuit's failure threshold at severity 1.143 ± 0.017; converting this to a real-hardware safety margin is sensitive to calibration choice, with plausible estimates ranging from roughly 1× to roughly 38× current hardware noise. A repeated 4-trial paired statistical test on real IBM Quantum hardware (ibm_marrakesh) found no significant effect of standard error-mitigation techniques (dynamical decoupling, gate twirling; p = 0.523) — reversing an initial single-trial result and illustrating why repeated trials are needed on noisy NISQ hardware. This archive contains all three Jupyter notebooks (classical baseline, ideal qubit simulation, noise/hardware validation), raw hardware measurement data, the full research paper, and a research log documenting every finding, correction, and methodological lesson from the project.
Abstract Quantum simulation of particle phenomena is a rapidly advancing field of research. With the widespread availability of quantum simulators, a given quantum system can be simulated in numerous ways, offering flexibility in implementation and exploration. Here, we perform quantum simulation of neutrino propagation in matter, a phenomenon that plays a crucial role in neutrino oscillations. We present quantum circuits with novel gate arrangements to simulate neutrino propagation in both constant and varying matter density profiles. The oscillation probabilities are determined by encoding and measuring the qubit states in the neutrino flavor basis, showing excellent agreement with theoretical predictions.
It is well known that the neutrino flavor in extreme astrophysical environments changes under the effect of three contributions: the vacuum oscillation, the interaction with the surrounding matter, and the collective oscillations due to interactions between different neutrinos. The latter adds a nonlinear contribution to the equations of motion, making the description of their dynamics complex. In this work we study various strategies to simulate the coherent collective oscillations of a system of NNN neutrinos in the two-flavor approximation using quantum computation. This was achieved by using a pair-neutrino decomposition designed to account for the fact that the flavor Hamiltonian, in the presence of the neutrino-neutrino term, presents an all-to-all interaction that makes the implementation of the evolution dependent on the qubit topology. We analyze the Trotter error caused by the decomposition demonstrating that the complexity of the implementation of time evolution scales polynomially with the number of neutrinos and that the noise from near-term quantum device simulation can be reduced by optimizing the quantum circuit decomposition and exploiting a full-qubit connectivity. We find that the gate complexity using second order Trotter-Suzuki formulas scales better with system size than with other decomposition methods such as quantum signal processing. We finally present the application and the results of our algorithm on a real quantum device based on trapped-ion qubits.
CP asymmetry and visible decay in 3+13+13+1 neutrino oscillations on a quantum computer
We use quantum simulation to study how visible neutrino decay modifies the vacuum CP asymmetry in muon-to-electron oscillations within a 3+13+13+1 neutrino scenario. The decay channel preserves CP symmetry, with CP violation arising from phases in the mixing matrix. We track the energy redistribution from visible decay and distinguish how parent attenuation and daughter regeneration modify the CP asymmetry. For the reference benchmark, the regenerated contribution is 4.85×10−44.85\times10^{-4}4.85×10−4, approximately 46%46\%46% of the total decay-induced shift. The full circuit for an effective two-energy model agrees with independent classical evolution. On an IBM quantum processor, we prepare the daughter state conditioned on decay and restore its physical normalization using fixed source and decay probabilities. After correction for measurement errors, the flavor-probability and coherence measurements both agree with the prediction within one standard error. Null controls test the suppression of the regenerated signal when daughter coherence or the relevant CP-sensitive mixing factor vanishes.