arXiv:2609.28136
Unbounded Operators, Physicality, and Modality in Quantum Theories
Zhonghao Lu
Abstract
In this paper, I address the problem regarding the physicality of Hilbert space in quantum mechanics, a topic brought into focus by Carcassi et al.'s paper "The unphysicality of Hilbert spaces" recently. I argue for the physicality of the Hilbert space in quantum mechanics, and demonstrate that there are inevitable ambiguity and arbitrariness if we want to identify the set of physical states with a proper subset of it. Moreover, I distinguish the ontological and modal reading of physicality from the pragmatic and operational reading of physicality, and then develop what I call the hierarchical view of physicality. According to this view, physicality is not a monolithic concept, but a layered one that admits degrees. I show the connection between the concept of physicality and modal metaphysics, and finally explain how it can be used to address the interpretational problem of quantum field theory brought by the existence of inequivalent representations.
AI Summary
The paper examines whether the full Hilbert space of quantum mechanics should be regarded as physically meaningful, or whether physical states should instead be restricted to a proper subset. It responds to the position advanced in “The unphysicality of Hilbert spaces” and defends retaining the full Hilbert space as the state space. The central argument is that identifying physical states with a proper subset of Hilbert space introduces unavoidable ambiguity and arbitrariness. To clarify what such a restriction would mean, the paper distinguishes ontological and modal readings of physicality from pragmatic and operational readings. It then proposes a “hierarchical view of physicality,” in which physicality is layered and admits degrees rather than functioning as a single binary classification. The discussion connects this framework to modal metaphysics and applies it to interpretational questions arising from inequivalent representations in quantum field theory. The abstract presents a conceptual and interpretational argument rather than a quantitative result; it reports no numerical bounds or experimental findings. Although unbounded operators appear in the title, the abstract does not specify their technical role or the mathematical assumptions underlying the argument. With the full text unavailable, the detailed reasoning, scope of the proposed hierarchy, and any explicitly stated limitations cannot be assessed.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the abstract only. Automated: it can be wrong.