Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.25242

From Effective Temperature to Non-Boltzmann State Selection in Driven-Dissipative Quantum Criticality

Tiago Jorge, Jens Paaske, Pedro Ribeiro

cond-mat.str-elcond-mat.mes-hallcond-mat.stat-mechquant-phSubmitted Sep 21, 2026• Announced Sep 23, 2026• 0 citations• Revised Oct 7, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Sep 21, 2026v2 · Oct 7, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Whether a nonequilibrium quantum-critical steady state can be described by an effective temperature remains an open question. We address it in a voltage-biased electronic Lipkin--Meshkov--Glick model, a minimal driven-dissipative model of a collective spin coupled to metallic leads. A controlled large-$N$ treatment reveals an overdamped open quantum-critical regime distinct from the closed model. The surrounding quantum critical fan, organized by temperature and voltage, is explored and fluctuations are found to be governed by an effective temperature $T_{\rm eff}$. At strong bias, the transition becomes first-order through a tricritical point. Remarkably, the same $T_{\rm eff}$ governs the strongly driven regime, but now varies across the entire order-parameter landscape. The steady state is therefore selected by a non-Boltzmann rule, shifting the first-order transition away from the equal-depth point of a deterministic potential. Driven criticality thus remains organized by an effective temperature while revealing non-thermal state selection.

AI Summary

The paper asks when an effective temperature describes driven quantum-critical fluctuations and whether it also determines phase selection at a first-order transition. It studies an electronic Lipkin–Meshkov–Glick dot with infinite-range Ising exchange, coupled to two voltage-biased metallic leads. Integrating out the fermions gives a Keldysh action with a controlled large-$N$ saddle point and Gaussian fluctuations. At zero temperature and bias, lead coupling changes the closed-model fluctuation divergence from $|h-h_c|^{-1/2}$ to logarithmic. For weak hybridization $\Gamma$, the overdamped critical regime crosses over to closed-like behavior at $|h-h_c|\sim\Gamma^4$, with $J=1$. At finite temperature or bias, the low-frequency fluctuation–dissipation ratio defines $T_{\rm eff}\simeq T/2+(V/4)\coth[V/(2T)]$ for small bias, approaching $V/4$ at $T=0$. This organizes the Gaussian quantum-critical fan. At $T=h=0$, the bias-driven transition becomes first order below a tricritical hybridization, with $(\Gamma_{\rm tc},V_{\rm tc})=(3,\sqrt3)/(2\pi)$. A slow-field expansion yields multiplicative-noise Langevin dynamics. Its stationary large-deviation function is $\mathcal W(\phi)=\int_0^\phi d\phi'\,\mathcal F'(\phi')/T_{\rm eff}(\phi')$. Consequently, coexistence follows equal depths of $\mathcal W$, not the deterministic potential $\mathcal F$: effective temperature varies along the order-parameter landscape. The setting assumes degenerate levels, screened charging effects and collective exchange. The state-selection calculation additionally requires collective relaxation slower than both electronic escape and the effective-temperature scale. These conditions are best satisfied near tricriticality; non-Markovian corrections are expected toward the bistable region’s small-$\Gamma$ or low-$T_{\rm eff}$ edges. The time-local noise description fails at the equilibrium quantum critical point.

Little sign of AI-generated textStrong assumptions

Central claim may not hold: The non-Boltzmann selection formula requires slow, effectively classical collective dynamics across the relevant order-parameter landscape, whereas the abstract states the strong-drive result without this restriction. Large N alone does not justify discarding higher quantum-field vertices when computing rare interwell switching, so the proposed quasipotential is established for the approximate Gaussian-noise dynamics rather than generally for the full electronic model.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Related papers

Critical Charge and Current Fluctuations across a Voltage-Driven Phase Transition

José F. B. Afonso, Stefan Kirchner, Pedro Ribeiro

We investigate bias-driven non-equilibrium quantum phase transitions in a paradigmatic quantum-transport setup: an interacting quantum dot coupled to non-interacting metallic leads. Using the Random Phase Approximation, which is exact in the limit of a large number of dot levels, we map out the zero-temperature non-equilibrium phase diagram as a function of interaction strength and applied bias. We focus our analysis on the behavior of the charge susceptibility and the current noise in the vicinity of the transition. Remarkably, despite the intrinsically non-equilibrium nature of the steady state, critical charge fluctuations admit an effective-temperature description, $T_{\text{eff}}(T,V)$, that collapses the steady-state behavior onto its equilibrium form. In sharp contrast, current fluctuations exhibit genuinely non-equilibrium features: the fluctuation-dissipation ratio becomes negative in the ordered phase, corresponding to a negative effective temperature for the current degrees of freedom. These results establish current noise as a sensitive probe of critical fluctuations at non-equilibrium quantum phase transitions and open new directions for exploring voltage-driven critical phenomena in quantum transport systems.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2601.20474•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jan 29, 2026•1 citation

Dissipation-driven quantum phase transitions in collective spin systems

S Morrison, A. S. Parkins

We consider two different collective spin systems subjected to strong dissipation -- on the same scale as interaction strengths and external fields -- and show that either continuous or discontinuous dissipative quantum phase transitions can occur as the dissipation strength is varied. First, we consider a well known model of cooperative resonance fluorescence that can exhibit a second-order quantum phase transition, and analyze the entanglement properties near the critical point. Next, we examine a dissipative version of the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick interacting collective spin model, where we find that either first- or second-order quantum phase transitions can occur, depending only on the ratio of the interaction and external field parameters. We give detailed results and interpretation for the steady state entanglement in the vicinity of the critical point, where it reaches a maximum. For the first-order transition we find that the semiclassical steady states exhibit a region of bistability.

arXiv:0805.1256•Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Sep 10, 2008•29 citations

Dynamics and universality in noise-driven dissipative systems

Emanuele G. Dalla Torre, Eugene Demler, Thierry Giamarchi +1 more

We investigate the dynamical properties of low-dimensional systems, driven by external noise sources. Specifically we consider a resistively shunted Josephson junction and a one-dimensional quantum liquid in a commensurate lattice potential, subject to $1/f$ noise. In absence of nonlinear coupling, we have shown previously that these systems establish a nonequilibrium critical steady state [Dalla Torre, Demler, Giamarchi, and Altman, Nat. Phys. 6, 806 (2010)]. Here, we use this state as the basis for a controlled renormalization group analysis using the Keldysh path integral formulation to treat the nonlinearities: the Josephson coupling and the commensurate lattice. The analysis to first order in the coupling constant indicates transitions between superconducting and localized regimes that are smoothly connected to the respective equilibrium transitions. However, at second order, the back action of the mode coupling on the critical state leads to renormalization of dissipation and emergence of an effective temperature. In the Josephson junction, the temperature is parametrically small allowing to observe a universal crossover between the superconducting and insulating regimes. The I-V characteristics of the junction displays algebraic behavior controlled by the underlying critical state over a wide range. In the noisy one-dimensional liquid, the generated dissipation and effective temperature are not small as in the junction. We find a crossover between a quasilocalized regime dominated by dissipation and another dominated by temperature. However, since in the thermal regime the thermalization rate is parametrically small, signatures of the nonequilibrium critical state may be seen in transient dynamics.

arXiv:1110.3678•Physical Review B•May 10, 2012•86 citations

Nonequilibrium thermal state of a voltage-biased Mott insulator

Arijit Dutta, Pinaki Majumdar

We establish the nonequilibrium thermal phases of a voltage driven antiferromagnetic Mott insulator in three dimensions, realized at steady state under a voltage bias. Starting from the Keldysh action for the half-filled Hubbard model, we derive an effective Langevin equation for the ``slow'' magnetic variables. The coupling of electrons to these degrees of freedom determine the transport properties. At low temperature we find a voltage-driven discontinuous insulator-metal transition, along with hysteresis. We map the suppression of the N\'eel temperature ${T}_{N}$ and pseudogap temperature ${T}_{\text{pg}}$ with increasing voltage, and discover that the biased Mott insulator has a finite temperature insulator-metal transition. The low temperature results resolve an experimental puzzle about hysteresis, and the thermal results make testable predictions on spectra and nonlinear transport.

arXiv:2009.04533•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Feb 28, 2022•3 citations

Dynamical Quantum Phase Transitions in the Dissipative Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick Model with Proposed Realization in Optical Cavity QED

S. Morrison, A. S. Parkins

We present an optical cavity QED configuration that is described by a dissipative version of the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick model of an infinitely coordinated spin system. This open quantum system exhibits both first- and second-order nonequilibrium quantum phase transitions as a single, effective field parameter is varied. Light emitted from the cavity offers measurable signatures of the critical behavior, including that of the spin-spin entanglement.

arXiv:0708.2753•Physical Review Letters•Jan 31, 2008•170 citations

Dynamics of non-equilibrium steady state quantum phase transitions

Patrik Hedvall, Jonas Larson

In this paper we address the question how the Kibble-Zurek mechanism, which describes the formation of topological defects in quantum systems subjected to a quench across a critical point, is generalized to the same scenario but for driven-dissipative quantum critical systems. In these out of equilibrium systems, the critical behavior is manifested in the steady states rather than in the ground states as in quantum critical models of closed systems. To give the generalization we need to establish what is meant by adiabaticity in open quantum systems. Another most crucial concept that we clarify is the characterization of non-adiabatic excitations. It is clear what these are for a Hamiltonian systems, but question is more subtle for driven-dissipative systems. In particular, the important observation is that the instantaneous steady states serve as reference states. From these the excitations can then be extracted by comparing the distance from the evolved state to the instantaneous steady state. With these issues resolved we demonstrate the applicability of the generalized Kibble-Zurek mechanism to an open Landau-Zener problem and show universal Kibble-Zurek scaling for an open transverse Ising model. Thus, our results support any assumption that non-equilibrium quantum critical behavior can be understood from universal features.

arXiv:1712.01560•Dec 5, 2017•14 citations
Whether a nonequilibrium quantum-critical steady state can be described by an effective temperature remains an open question. We address it in a voltage-biased electronic Lipkin--Meshkov--Glick model, a minimal driven-dissipative model of a collective spin coupled to metallic leads. A controlled large-NNN treatment reveals an overdamped open quantum-critical regime distinct from the closed model. The surrounding quantum critical fan, organized by temperature and voltage, is explored and fluctuations are found to be governed by an effective temperature TeffT_{\rm eff}Teff​. At strong bias, the transition becomes first-order through a tricritical point. Remarkably, the same TeffT_{\rm eff}Teff​ governs the strongly driven regime, but now varies across the entire order-parameter landscape. The steady state is therefore selected by a non-Boltzmann rule, shifting the first-order transition away from the equal-depth point of a deterministic potential. Driven criticality thus remains organized by an effective temperature while revealing non-thermal state selection.
The paper asks when an effective temperature describes driven quantum-critical fluctuations and whether it also determines phase selection at a first-order transition. It studies an electronic Lipkin–Meshkov–Glick dot with infinite-range Ising exchange, coupled to two voltage-biased metallic leads. Integrating out the fermions gives a Keldysh action with a controlled large-NNN saddle point and Gaussian fluctuations.
At zero temperature and bias, lead coupling changes the closed-model fluctuation divergence from ∣h−hc∣−1/2|h-h_c|^{-1/2}∣h−hc​∣−1/2 to logarithmic. For weak hybridization Γ\GammaΓ, the overdamped critical regime crosses over to closed-like behavior at ∣h−hc∣∼Γ4|h-h_c|\sim\Gamma^4∣h−hc​∣∼Γ4, with J=1J=1J=1. At finite temperature or bias, the low-frequency fluctuation–dissipation ratio defines Teff≃T/2+(V/4)coth⁡[V/(2T)]T_{\rm eff}\simeq T/2+(V/4)\coth[V/(2T)]Teff​≃T/2+(V/4)coth[V/(2T)] for small bias, approaching V/4V/4V/4 at T=0T=0T=0. This organizes the Gaussian quantum-critical fan.
At T=h=0T=h=0T=h=0, the bias-driven transition becomes first order below a tricritical hybridization, with (Γtc,Vtc)=(3,3)/(2π)(\Gamma_{\rm tc},V_{\rm tc})=(3,\sqrt3)/(2\pi)(Γtc​,Vtc​)=(3,3​)/(2π). A slow-field expansion yields multiplicative-noise Langevin dynamics. Its stationary large-deviation function is W(ϕ)=∫0ϕdϕ′ F′(ϕ′)/Teff(ϕ′)\mathcal W(\phi)=\int_0^\phi d\phi'\,\mathcal F'(\phi')/T_{\rm eff}(\phi')W(ϕ)=∫0ϕ​dϕ′F′(ϕ′)/Teff​(ϕ′). Consequently, coexistence follows equal depths of W\mathcal WW, not the deterministic potential F\mathcal FF: effective temperature varies along the order-parameter landscape.
The setting assumes degenerate levels, screened charging effects and collective exchange. The state-selection calculation additionally requires collective relaxation slower than both electronic escape and the effective-temperature scale. These conditions are best satisfied near tricriticality; non-Markovian corrections are expected toward the bistable region’s small-Γ\GammaΓ or low-TeffT_{\rm eff}Teff​ edges. The time-local noise description fails at the equilibrium quantum critical point.
We investigate bias-driven non-equilibrium quantum phase transitions in a paradigmatic quantum-transport setup: an interacting quantum dot coupled to non-interacting metallic leads. Using the Random Phase Approximation, which is exact in the limit of a large number of dot levels, we map out the zero-temperature non-equilibrium phase diagram as a function of interaction strength and applied bias. We focus our analysis on the behavior of the charge susceptibility and the current noise in the vicinity of the transition. Remarkably, despite the intrinsically non-equilibrium nature of the steady state, critical charge fluctuations admit an effective-temperature description, Teff(T,V)T_{\text{eff}}(T,V)Teff​(T,V), that collapses the steady-state behavior onto its equilibrium form. In sharp contrast, current fluctuations exhibit genuinely non-equilibrium features: the fluctuation-dissipation ratio becomes negative in the ordered phase, corresponding to a negative effective temperature for the current degrees of freedom. These results establish current noise as a sensitive probe of critical fluctuations at non-equilibrium quantum phase transitions and open new directions for exploring voltage-driven critical phenomena in quantum transport systems.
We consider two different collective spin systems subjected to strong dissipation -- on the same scale as interaction strengths and external fields -- and show that either continuous or discontinuous dissipative quantum phase transitions can occur as the dissipation strength is varied. First, we consider a well known model of cooperative resonance fluorescence that can exhibit a second-order quantum phase transition, and analyze the entanglement properties near the critical point. Next, we examine a dissipative version of the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick interacting collective spin model, where we find that either first- or second-order quantum phase transitions can occur, depending only on the ratio of the interaction and external field parameters. We give detailed results and interpretation for the steady state entanglement in the vicinity of the critical point, where it reaches a maximum. For the first-order transition we find that the semiclassical steady states exhibit a region of bistability.
We investigate the dynamical properties of low-dimensional systems, driven by external noise sources. Specifically we consider a resistively shunted Josephson junction and a one-dimensional quantum liquid in a commensurate lattice potential, subject to 1/f1/f1/f noise. In absence of nonlinear coupling, we have shown previously that these systems establish a nonequilibrium critical steady state [Dalla Torre, Demler, Giamarchi, and Altman, Nat. Phys. 6, 806 (2010)]. Here, we use this state as the basis for a controlled renormalization group analysis using the Keldysh path integral formulation to treat the nonlinearities: the Josephson coupling and the commensurate lattice. The analysis to first order in the coupling constant indicates transitions between superconducting and localized regimes that are smoothly connected to the respective equilibrium transitions. However, at second order, the back action of the mode coupling on the critical state leads to renormalization of dissipation and emergence of an effective temperature. In the Josephson junction, the temperature is parametrically small allowing to observe a universal crossover between the superconducting and insulating regimes. The I-V characteristics of the junction displays algebraic behavior controlled by the underlying critical state over a wide range. In the noisy one-dimensional liquid, the generated dissipation and effective temperature are not small as in the junction. We find a crossover between a quasilocalized regime dominated by dissipation and another dominated by temperature. However, since in the thermal regime the thermalization rate is parametrically small, signatures of the nonequilibrium critical state may be seen in transient dynamics.
We establish the nonequilibrium thermal phases of a voltage driven antiferromagnetic Mott insulator in three dimensions, realized at steady state under a voltage bias. Starting from the Keldysh action for the half-filled Hubbard model, we derive an effective Langevin equation for the ``slow'' magnetic variables. The coupling of electrons to these degrees of freedom determine the transport properties. At low temperature we find a voltage-driven discontinuous insulator-metal transition, along with hysteresis. We map the suppression of the N\'eel temperature TN{T}_{N}TN​ and pseudogap temperature Tpg{T}_{\text{pg}}Tpg​ with increasing voltage, and discover that the biased Mott insulator has a finite temperature insulator-metal transition. The low temperature results resolve an experimental puzzle about hysteresis, and the thermal results make testable predictions on spectra and nonlinear transport.
In this paper we address the question how the Kibble-Zurek mechanism, which describes the formation of topological defects in quantum systems subjected to a quench across a critical point, is generalized to the same scenario but for driven-dissipative quantum critical systems. In these out of equilibrium systems, the critical behavior is manifested in the steady states rather than in the ground states as in quantum critical models of closed systems. To give the generalization we need to establish what is meant by adiabaticity in open quantum systems. Another most crucial concept that we clarify is the characterization of non-adiabatic excitations. It is clear what these are for a Hamiltonian systems, but question is more subtle for driven-dissipative systems. In particular, the important observation is that the instantaneous steady states serve as reference states. From these the excitations can then be extracted by comparing the distance from the evolved state to the instantaneous steady state. With these issues resolved we demonstrate the applicability of the generalized Kibble-Zurek mechanism to an open Landau-Zener problem and show universal Kibble-Zurek scaling for an open transverse Ising model. Thus, our results support any assumption that non-equilibrium quantum critical behavior can be understood from universal features.