arXiv:2609.24874
Anomalously enhanced lifetimes of low angular momentum Rydberg states in singly charged alkaline-earth metal ions
Simon Euchner, Weibin Li, Igor Lesanovsky
Abstract
Trapped ions excited to high-lying electronic states, so-called Rydberg states, open new opportunities for quantum simulation and quantum computing. Generally, the fidelity of quantum coherent operations critically depends on the longevity of Rydberg states. However, scaling laws predict that the lifetimes of Rydberg states in singly charged alkaline-earth metal ions are 16 times shorter, compared to their neutral atom counterparts. Here, we show that this is not generally the case. We report an anomalous lifetime enhancement of certain low angular momentum ionic Rydberg series by factors larger than eight. The anomaly is present at both zero and finite temperature, although it is caused by different mechanisms. At zero temperature, the anomalously enhanced lifetimes are caused by accidental cancellations of the relevant dipole transition matrix elements, while at room temperature the anomaly originates from the enlarged energetic separation of ionic Rydberg levels with respect to neutral-atom levels.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether low-angular-momentum Rydberg states in singly charged alkaline-earth ions necessarily have lifetimes 16 times shorter than neutral-atom counterparts, as suggested by the hydrogenic scaling $\tau\propto Z_{\mathrm{eff}}^{-4}$. It calculates spontaneous-emission and room-temperature black-body-induced depopulation rates using single-electron model potentials, spin–orbit coupling, and numerical eigenstates from AlkCalc. The main comparison is between isoelectronic Rb and Sr$^+$; supplementary tables cover Ca$^+$, Sr$^+$, and Rb for $20\leq n\leq80$. At zero temperature, ionic P-state lifetimes exceed the simple scaling prediction by factors greater than eight, approaching neutral-atom values. Suppressed radial dipole matrix elements for dominant decay channels to low-lying states explain the enhancement. For example, Sr$^+$ $50\mathrm{P}_{1/2}$ has a calculated radiative lifetime of $158.4\,\mu\mathrm{s}$, versus $280.7\,\mu\mathrm{s}$ in Rb and $7.181\,\mu\mathrm{s}$ for Sr$^+$ $50\mathrm{S}_{1/2}$. At $300\,\mathrm{K}$, black-body transitions dominate P-state depopulation. Hydrogenic scaling combined with the low-frequency thermal photon occupation gives $\tau\propto Z_{\mathrm{eff}}^{-2}$, predicting a neutral-to-ion lifetime ratio of four; calculated ratios are approximately three. S states show a weaker room-temperature enhancement. Calculations are benchmarked against Rb measurements and existing numerical results. Ionic P-state radiative lifetimes show quantitative model-potential sensitivity because their matrix elements involve cancellations. The calculations use the dipole approximation and truncate black-body excitation channels at $n+30$. Whether the longevity persists in strong trapping electromagnetic fields remains unresolved, limiting direct application to trapped-ion protocols.
The authors used \emph{Anthropic}'s \emph{Claude (Sonnet 4)} for grammar and spell-checking of the manuscript. All suggestions were reviewed and approved by the authors.
Error found: The numerical size of the zero-temperature Sr+ P-state lifetime enhancement has unquantified model uncertainty because the relevant matrix elements involve cancellations, alternative model predictions differ, and no experimental ionic lifetime benchmark is provided.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 13 pages, 5 figures