arXiv:2609.24670
Wigner-positive quantum states can have lower entropy than the vacuum
Zacharie Van Herstraeten, Nicolas J. Cerf, Ulysse Chabaud
Abstract
The Wigner entropy conjecture posits that pure Gaussian states minimize the Shannon entropy of non-negative Wigner functions, known as the Wigner entropy. We show that mixing a specific pure Wigner-negative state with another suitably chosen quantum state can restore Wigner positivity while retaining a Wigner entropy that is slightly - but strictly - below the vacuum entropy. As a consequence, we disprove the Wigner entropy conjecture, as well as the stronger Wigner majorization conjecture, by deriving simple analytical counterexamples with violations of the entropy bound no larger than $10^{-3}$. Such states with sub-vacuum Wigner entropy can be found arbitrarily close to the vacuum and can also exhibit sub-vacuum Wigner-Rényi $α$-entropy for $0<α<2$. We identify the physical mechanism behind the existence of such states, which arises from a subtle interplay between the uncertainty principle and non-Gaussianity. The key idea of this paper was developed with the help of AI tools, building on the characterization of extreme non-negative Wigner functions.
AI Summary
The paper addresses the Wigner entropy conjecture: whether every single-mode state with a non-negative Wigner function satisfies $h(W)\geq 1+\ln\pi$, the vacuum value. It constructs analytical counterexamples, thereby also disproving the stronger Wigner majorization conjecture. One family consists of states supported on $\mathrm{span}\{|0\rangle,|n\rangle\}$, with population $t$ in $|n\rangle$ and coherence chosen near the Wigner-positive boundary. For every fixed $n\geq3$, the entropy obeys $h(W)=1+\ln\pi+(2n-2^n)t+o(t)$, giving violations arbitrarily close to the vacuum. Wigner positivity is established through bounds on Laguerre polynomials, and the entropy expansion is justified using global remainder bounds and dominated convergence. A second family, supported on the three lowest Fock levels, mixes a specified pure state with $|2\rangle$ at weight $\epsilon^4$ and has entropy $1+\ln\pi-\tfrac23\epsilon^3+O(\epsilon^4)$. The conjecture is also proved within $\mathrm{span}\{|0\rangle,|2\rangle\}$ by representing its Wigner-positive states as reduced balanced-beam-splitter outputs. Both constructions violate the corresponding vacuum bound for every fixed Rényi order $0<\alpha<2$; the established bounds for $\alpha\geq2$ remain intact. The entropy reduction occurs when non-Gaussianity outweighs the entropy increase associated with second moments. Numerically observed Shannon-entropy violations are small: approximately $4\times10^{-5}$ at best in the first family, and at most order $10^{-3}$ in a broader search. These are not global upper bounds. The optimal entropy minimum remains undetermined; the known lower bound is $\ln(2\pi)$.
The key idea of this paper was developed with the help of AI tools, building on the characterization of extreme non-negative Wigner functions.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 5+12 pages, 1 figure, 3 tables. Comments welcome