arXiv:2609.23277
Radial Coarse Graining Restores Vacuum Majorization in Wigner Phase Space
Ao-Xiang Liu, Cong-Feng Qiao
Abstract
Quantum uncertainty limits how strongly Wigner functions can concentrate in phase space. It is commonly conjectured that the vacuum Wigner function continuously majorizes that of any Wigner-positive state. However, by constructing Wigner-positive states whose localized quantum coherence lowers their Wigner entropy below the vacuum value, we show that this conjecture is incorrect. We restore vacuum majorization at finite resolution by integrating single-mode Wigner functions over concentric radial energy shells, obtaining probability vectors majorized by that of the vacuum for all Wigner-positive states and for Wigner-negative states with non-negative shell weights. Anchoring these shells to a fixed oscillator frame breaks affine symplectic invariance, rendering this relation strict for every non-vacuum Gaussian pure state. For Wigner-negative states, the persistence of negative shell weights defines a radial negativity scale with Airy-edge semiclassical asymptotics for highly excited Fock states. Operationally, we combine the majorization relation with partial transposition to obtain a two-mode entanglement criterion directly evaluable from radially binned joint homodyne outcomes without state reconstruction.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether the vacuum Wigner function continuously majorizes every Wigner-positive state, and whether a related concentration bound survives radial averaging. It constructs counterexamples by adding an exponentially small thermal admixture to $\sqrt{1-\epsilon^2}|0\rangle+\epsilon|n\rangle$. For $n\ge3$, the resulting Wigner function is globally positive but has Shannon-entropy shift $(2n-2^n)\epsilon^2+o(\epsilon^2)<0$. Analogous violations hold at every fixed Rényi order $0<\alpha<2$ for sufficiently small $\epsilon$. Tail estimates and an interval-arithmetic finite example establish positivity and the entropy violation; positive-part tests show continuous-majorization incomparability with the vacuum. For equal-area concentric shells defined by $(k-1)\Delta\le q^2+p^2<k\Delta$, any physical state with nonnegative shell weights obeys $\sum_{j=1}^m P_{\rho,j}^{\downarrow}\le1-e^{-m\Delta}$. Thus its shell vector is majorized by the vacuum’s geometric distribution. The proof uses phase averaging and a Mehler-based positive decomposition to establish a radial-tail inequality. Extensions cover bounded-width nonuniform partitions, phase-insensitive Gaussian channels and $s$-ordered distributions for $s\in[-1,0]$. Partial transposition converts the bound into an entanglement witness evaluable from radially binned commuting EPR homodyne outcomes. It detects arbitrarily weak two-mode squeezing at every positive shell width, and every entangled finite-support Schmidt-correlated pure state after suitable phase rotations and sufficiently fine binning. The shells use a fixed oscillator frame and are not POVM outcomes for general single-mode states. Wigner-negative inputs require nonnegative integrated weights; their radial negativity scale can be infinite even at finite energy. Extension to multimode total-energy shells remains open.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.