arXiv:2609.22504
Tripartite Form Universality in Holographic Entropy Inequalities
Veronika E. Hubeny, Yu Liu
Abstract
To elucidate the meaning of holographic entropy inequalities (beyond subadditivity) which characterize the entanglement structure of geometric states in holography, arXiv:2309.06296 proposed the "tripartite form" for these inequalities, consisting of tripartite information and conditional tripartite information terms with unit coefficients. While this provides a compact and useful packaging of the inequalities, it is not a priori guaranteed that all inequalities can be recast in this form. Here we conjecture that they can, and present substantial evidence, by proving that the two known infinite families of holographic entropy inequalities found in arXiv:2309.15145 can indeed be written in the tripartite form. This is significant because such recasting is particularly nontrivial for these families. Apart from providing the explicit tripartite form expressions for every member of these two infinite families, we detail how we arrived at them, in the process deriving several useful identities which may serve as stepping stones to formulate further repackaging of the corresponding information quantities. We also illustrate the power of the tripartite form by proving a number of structural properties satisfied by any holographic entropy inequality.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether every primitive holographic entropy inequality other than subadditivity admits a **tripartite form**: a finite sum of terms $-I_3(X:Y:Z\mid W)$ with disjoint, possibly composite arguments and unit coefficients. This representation automatically enforces superbalance and alternating signs in the multipartite-information basis, but does not itself imply holographic positivity. Explicit tripartite forms are established for every member of two previously known infinite families: the toric inequalities $Q_T(m,n)$, with odd $m,n$, and the projective-plane inequalities $Q_P(m)$, with integer $m>1$. The displayed toric form contains $(m^2+4mn-13)/8$ terms for $m\geq3$; the projective form contains $m(m-1)/2$ terms and is shown to have minimum length. For example, $Q_P(7)$ uses 21 tripartite-form terms, versus 97 entropy-basis terms and 1,023 multipartite-information-basis terms. The constructions use recursive decompositions, chain-rule identities, and explicit cancellation of wrong-sign terms introduced by changing the purifier. Singleton-argument expansions provide invariant term-count classifications. These results supply independently generated infinite-family evidence for universality, rather than inequalities obtained by searching a tripartite-form ansatz. They do not prove universality, characterize positivity of tripartite-form expressions, or generate new primitive inequalities. Several structural consequences are discussed conditionally on universality, including the absence of inequalities balanced beyond order two. Stronger claims involving an unavoidable unconditioned $I_3$ term rely on an additional empirical expectation without a rigorous proof. Building blocks that manifestly retain tripartite compatibility under purification remain an open direction.
Error found: The abstract overstates the universality of the structural-property proofs, several of which depend on the still-unproved conjecture that every superbalanced holographic entropy inequality is TF-compatible. The strict term-count inequality and universal GHZ-violation assertion additionally depend on the unproved requirement that every valid superbalanced holographic entropy inequality contain an unconditioned term in its TF representation.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 47 pages, 5 figures; v2: added references, fixed minor typos and corrected nomenclature "cyclic" to "dihedral"