Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.21886

Ensemble Dependence of the Critical Exponent at a Quantum Error Correction Threshold

Idan Dror, Moshe Goldstein

quant-phSubmitted Sep 18, 2026• Announced Sep 21, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In thermodynamics it is common to assume that the choice of ensemble (e.g., micro-canonical, canonical, or grand-canonical) should not affect the underlying physics in the thermodynamics limit. We show that this does not necessarily hold for critical exponents. Examining a simplified model of quantum error correction (single step encoding and decoding by a random unitary) and the behavior of both the fidelity and magic at the corresponding threshold, we find different exponents when using generic channels or supposedly equivalent quantum trajectories. Interestingly, the obtained exponents saturate a recently derived information theoretic bound by Feldman et al. (2026), which we extend from the grand-canonical to the canonical case, including intermediate ensembles which we define. Moreover, even the existence of the transition is shown to be ensemble-dependent.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether finite-size critical exponents at an error-correction threshold depend on fixing error counts versus allowing them to fluctuate, and on averaging channels versus averaging trajectory-resolved fidelities. It studies Haar-random encoding of $k=rN$ logical qudits into $N$ qudits, followed by product noise and inverse-unitary decoding. The observable is fidelity conditioned on zero ancillary syndrome, used as a proxy for decoding success. For fidelity averaged separately over encodings in numerator and denominator, the calculation reduces to a multiplicative channel parameter $R$. Writing the mean single-site strength as $\bar E=\langle-\log_d R\rangle$, the threshold is $\bar E_c=1-r$. Fixed error counts give a transition width proportional to $N^{-1}$, hence $\nu=1$; independent fluctuating counts broaden it through the central limit theorem to $N^{-1/2}$, hence $\nu=2$, when the strength variance is finite and nonzero. Averaging channels before conditioning instead gives $\nu=1$ and can shift the threshold. A depolarizing-channel example shows that trajectory decomposition can even remove the nonzero-noise threshold. Information-theoretic sampling arguments give bounds $\nu\geq1$ and $\nu\geq2$ for canonical and independent-error ensembles, respectively, and an interpolating reservoir-dependent bound. Related stabilizer Rényi entropy scaling is also discussed. Brick-wall-circuit simulations support the predicted fidelity scaling for averages taken after conditioning. The analytic results concern encoding-annealed fidelity; agreement with fully quenched encoding averages is supported numerically rather than generally proved. The decoding-success interpretation assumes comparable performance in nonzero-syndrome sectors. The model uses global random encoding, with local circuits tested numerically.

No sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsStrong assumptionsPossible error

Central claim may not hold: The exact exponent calculations concern encoding-annealed fidelity; extending them generally to encoding-quenched fidelity relies on an unproved self-averaging expectation and numerical evidence. The calculated postselected fidelity is only an assumed proxy for full error-correction performance, not an established threshold for a complete recovery procedure. The magic derivation replaces an average of negative logarithms by the negative logarithm of average fidelity, expressions that differ parametrically at the grand-canonical critical point. The claimed vanishing trajectory-fidelity variance contradicts the paper's own critical scaling formulas, which imply a limiting variance of 1/4 for nonzero error-strength variance.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Related papers

Ensemble Dependence of Critical Exponents at Quantum Error Correction Thresholds: Analytic Mechanisms and Statistical Consequences

Rowan Brad Quni-Gudzinas

Ensemble equivalence — the expectation that microcanonical, canonical, and grand-canonical descriptions of a system agree in the thermodynamic limit — is a cornerstone of statistical mechanics, yet it can fail for observables that probe exponentially rare events. Recent work on a simplified quantum error correction (QEC) model reports that critical exponents governing fidelity and magic at the error-correction threshold depend on the noise ensemble chosen, and that even the existence of the transition can be ensemble-dependent [1,2]. Here we develop a minimal, fully analytic treatment of this phenomenon using a random-unitary encoding model subject to depolarizing noise. We derive explicit expressions for the decoding fidelity in grand-canonical (independent per-qubit errors) and canonical (fixed error number) ensembles, and exhibit concrete numerical instances of the discrepancy: for a distance-3 code with 100 physical qubits and error rate p = 0.01, the grand-canonical fidelity is 0.735762 while the canonical fidelity is exactly 1. We show that the discrepancy survives the vanishing of relative fluctuations (σ/μ → 0) because fidelity is a large-deviation tail quantity, and we compute the associated entropy and capacity budgets. We further derive the statistical cost of resolving ensemble-dependent exponents: distinguishing two candidate exponents at distance Δp from threshold requires a sample count scaling as Δp⁻⁴ and system sizes scaling as Δp⁻², a compound burden that we quantify under stated assumptions. We relate the mechanism to the known ensemble dependence of the random transverse-field Ising chain [3], discuss saturation of the information-theoretic bound of Feldman et al. as reported in [1,2], and outline falsifiable predictions. The results clarify when ensemble choice is physically consequential rather than a matter of convenience in QEC threshold physics. ## 1. Introduction Quantum error correction protects quantum information from decoherence by en Full text and updates: papers.qnfo.org/papers/ensemble-dependence-of-critical-exponents-at-quantum-error-correction-thresholds/

•Oct 4, 2026•0 citations

Finite-size scaling in the canonical ensemble

Youjin Deng, Henk W. J. Blöte

We investigate the critical scaling behavior of finite systems in the canonical ensemble. The essential difference with the grand canonical ensemble. i.e., the constraint on the number of particles, is already known to lead to the Fisher renormalization phenomenon that modifies the thermal critical singularities. We show that, in observables that are not Fisher renormalized, it also leads to a finite-size effect governed by an exponent $y_1$ that depends on the temperature exponent $y_t$ and the dimensionality $d$ as $y_1=-|2y_t-d|$. We verify this prediction by a Monte Carlo analysis of several two-dimensional lattice models in the percolation, the Ising and the 3-state Potts universality classes.

arXiv:cond-mat/0508348•Aug 15, 2005•2 citations

Finite-size effects in canonical and grand-canonical quantum Monte Carlo simulations for fermions

Zhenjiu Wang, Fakher F. Assaad, Francesco Parisen Toldin

We introduce a quantum Monte Carlo method at finite temperature for interacting fermionic models in the canonical ensemble, where the conservation of the particle number is enforced. Although general thermodynamic arguments ensure the equivalence of the canonical and the grand-canonical ensembles in the thermodynamic limit, their approach to the infinite-volume limit is distinctively different. Observables computed in the canonical ensemble generically display a finite-size correction proportional to the inverse volume, whereas in the grand-canonical ensemble the approach is exponential in the ratio of the linear size over the correlation length. We verify these predictions by quantum Monte Carlo simulations of the Hubbard model in one and two dimensions in the grand-canonical and the canonical ensemble. We prove an exact formula for the finite-size part of the free energy density, energy density and other observables in the canonical ensemble and relate this correction to a susceptibility computed in the corresponding grand-canonical ensemble. This result is confirmed by an exact computation of the one-dimensional classical Ising model in the canonical ensemble, which for classical models corresponds to the so-called fixed-magnetization ensemble. Our method is useful for simulating finite systems which are not coupled to a particle bath, such as in nuclear or cold atom physics.

arXiv:1706.01874•Physical review. E•Oct 16, 2017•26 citations

Ensemble dependence in the random transverse-field Ising chain

Abhishek Dhar, A. P. Young

In a disordered system one can either consider a microcanonical ensemble, where there is a precise constraint on the random variables, or a canonical ensemble where the variables are chosen according to a distribution without constraints. We address the question as to whether critical exponents in these two cases can differ through a detailed study of the random transverse-field Ising chain. We find that the exponents are the same in both ensembles, though some critical amplitudes vanish in the microcanonical ensemble for correlations which span the whole system and are particularly sensitive to the constraint. This can appear as a different exponent. We expect that this apparent dependence of exponents on ensemble is related to the integrability of the model, and would not occur in nonintegrable models.

arXiv:cond-mat/0305664•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Oct 23, 2003•15 citations

Shared information in classical mean-field models

Or Cohen, V. Rittenberg, Tridib Sadhu

Abstract Universal scaling of entanglement estimators of critical quantum systems has drawn a lot of attention in the past. Recent studies indicate that similar universal properties can be found for bipartite information estimators of classical systems near phase transition, opening a new direction in the study of critical phenomena. We explore this subject by studying the information estimators of classical spin chains with general mean-field interactions. In our explicit analysis of two different bipartite information estimators in the canonical ensemble we find that, away from criticality, both the estimators remain finite in the thermodynamic limit. On the other hand, along the critical line there is a logarithmic divergence with increasing system size. The coefficient of the logarithm is fully determined by the mean-field interaction and it is the same for the class of models we consider. The scaling function, however, depends on the details of each model. In addition, we study the information estimators in the micro-canonical ensemble, where they are shown to exhibit a different universal behavior. We verify our results using numerical calculation for two specific cases of the general Hamiltonian.

arXiv:1409.5520•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jan 16, 2015•10 citations

Optimization of finite-size errors in finite-temperature calculations of unordered phases

Deepak Iyer, Mark Srednicki, Marcos Rigol

It is common knowledge that the microcanonical, canonical, and grand-canonical ensembles are equivalent in thermodynamically large systems. Here, we study finite-size effects in the latter two ensembles. We show that contrary to naive expectations, finite-size errors are exponentially small in grand canonical ensemble calculations of translationally invariant systems in unordered phases at finite temperature. Open boundary conditions and canonical ensemble calculations suffer from finite-size errors that are only polynomially small in the system size. We further show that finite-size effects are generally smallest in numerical linked cluster expansions. Our conclusions are supported by analytical and numerical analyses of classical and quantum systems.

arXiv:1505.03620•Physical Review E•Jun 29, 2015•24 citations
In thermodynamics it is common to assume that the choice of ensemble (e.g., micro-canonical, canonical, or grand-canonical) should not affect the underlying physics in the thermodynamics limit. We show that this does not necessarily hold for critical exponents. Examining a simplified model of quantum error correction (single step encoding and decoding by a random unitary) and the behavior of both the fidelity and magic at the corresponding threshold, we find different exponents when using generic channels or supposedly equivalent quantum trajectories. Interestingly, the obtained exponents saturate a recently derived information theoretic bound by Feldman et al. (2026), which we extend from the grand-canonical to the canonical case, including intermediate ensembles which we define. Moreover, even the existence of the transition is shown to be ensemble-dependent.
The paper asks whether finite-size critical exponents at an error-correction threshold depend on fixing error counts versus allowing them to fluctuate, and on averaging channels versus averaging trajectory-resolved fidelities. It studies Haar-random encoding of k=rNk=rNk=rN logical qudits into NNN qudits, followed by product noise and inverse-unitary decoding. The observable is fidelity conditioned on zero ancillary syndrome, used as a proxy for decoding success.
For fidelity averaged separately over encodings in numerator and denominator, the calculation reduces to a multiplicative channel parameter RRR. Writing the mean single-site strength as Eˉ=⟨−log⁡dR⟩\bar E=\langle-\log_d R\rangleEˉ=⟨−logd​R⟩, the threshold is Eˉc=1−r\bar E_c=1-rEˉc​=1−r. Fixed error counts give a transition width proportional to N−1N^{-1}N−1, hence ν=1\nu=1ν=1; independent fluctuating counts broaden it through the central limit theorem to N−1/2N^{-1/2}N−1/2, hence ν=2\nu=2ν=2, when the strength variance is finite and nonzero. Averaging channels before conditioning instead gives ν=1\nu=1ν=1 and can shift the threshold. A depolarizing-channel example shows that trajectory decomposition can even remove the nonzero-noise threshold.
Information-theoretic sampling arguments give bounds ν≥1\nu\geq1ν≥1 and ν≥2\nu\geq2ν≥2 for canonical and independent-error ensembles, respectively, and an interpolating reservoir-dependent bound. Related stabilizer Rényi entropy scaling is also discussed. Brick-wall-circuit simulations support the predicted fidelity scaling for averages taken after conditioning.
The analytic results concern encoding-annealed fidelity; agreement with fully quenched encoding averages is supported numerically rather than generally proved. The decoding-success interpretation assumes comparable performance in nonzero-syndrome sectors. The model uses global random encoding, with local circuits tested numerically.
Ensemble equivalence — the expectation that microcanonical, canonical, and grand-canonical descriptions of a system agree in the thermodynamic limit — is a cornerstone of statistical mechanics, yet it can fail for observables that probe exponentially rare events. Recent work on a simplified quantum error correction (QEC) model reports that critical exponents governing fidelity and magic at the error-correction threshold depend on the noise ensemble chosen, and that even the existence of the transition can be ensemble-dependent [1,2]. Here we develop a minimal, fully analytic treatment of this phenomenon using a random-unitary encoding model subject to depolarizing noise. We derive explicit expressions for the decoding fidelity in grand-canonical (independent per-qubit errors) and canonical (fixed error number) ensembles, and exhibit concrete numerical instances of the discrepancy: for a distance-3 code with 100 physical qubits and error rate p = 0.01, the grand-canonical fidelity is 0.735762 while the canonical fidelity is exactly 1. We show that the discrepancy survives the vanishing of relative fluctuations (σ/μ → 0) because fidelity is a large-deviation tail quantity, and we compute the associated entropy and capacity budgets. We further derive the statistical cost of resolving ensemble-dependent exponents: distinguishing two candidate exponents at distance Δp from threshold requires a sample count scaling as Δp⁻⁴ and system sizes scaling as Δp⁻², a compound burden that we quantify under stated assumptions. We relate the mechanism to the known ensemble dependence of the random transverse-field Ising chain [3], discuss saturation of the information-theoretic bound of Feldman et al. as reported in [1,2], and outline falsifiable predictions. The results clarify when ensemble choice is physically consequential rather than a matter of convenience in QEC threshold physics. ## 1. Introduction Quantum error correction protects quantum information from decoherence by en Full text and updates: papers.qnfo.org/papers/ensemble-dependence-of-critical-exponents-at-quantum-error-correction-thresholds/
We investigate the critical scaling behavior of finite systems in the canonical ensemble. The essential difference with the grand canonical ensemble. i.e., the constraint on the number of particles, is already known to lead to the Fisher renormalization phenomenon that modifies the thermal critical singularities. We show that, in observables that are not Fisher renormalized, it also leads to a finite-size effect governed by an exponent y1y_1y1​ that depends on the temperature exponent yty_tyt​ and the dimensionality ddd as y1=−∣2yt−d∣y_1=-|2y_t-d|y1​=−∣2yt​−d∣. We verify this prediction by a Monte Carlo analysis of several two-dimensional lattice models in the percolation, the Ising and the 3-state Potts universality classes.
We introduce a quantum Monte Carlo method at finite temperature for interacting fermionic models in the canonical ensemble, where the conservation of the particle number is enforced. Although general thermodynamic arguments ensure the equivalence of the canonical and the grand-canonical ensembles in the thermodynamic limit, their approach to the infinite-volume limit is distinctively different. Observables computed in the canonical ensemble generically display a finite-size correction proportional to the inverse volume, whereas in the grand-canonical ensemble the approach is exponential in the ratio of the linear size over the correlation length. We verify these predictions by quantum Monte Carlo simulations of the Hubbard model in one and two dimensions in the grand-canonical and the canonical ensemble. We prove an exact formula for the finite-size part of the free energy density, energy density and other observables in the canonical ensemble and relate this correction to a susceptibility computed in the corresponding grand-canonical ensemble. This result is confirmed by an exact computation of the one-dimensional classical Ising model in the canonical ensemble, which for classical models corresponds to the so-called fixed-magnetization ensemble. Our method is useful for simulating finite systems which are not coupled to a particle bath, such as in nuclear or cold atom physics.
In a disordered system one can either consider a microcanonical ensemble, where there is a precise constraint on the random variables, or a canonical ensemble where the variables are chosen according to a distribution without constraints. We address the question as to whether critical exponents in these two cases can differ through a detailed study of the random transverse-field Ising chain. We find that the exponents are the same in both ensembles, though some critical amplitudes vanish in the microcanonical ensemble for correlations which span the whole system and are particularly sensitive to the constraint. This can appear as a different exponent. We expect that this apparent dependence of exponents on ensemble is related to the integrability of the model, and would not occur in nonintegrable models.
Abstract Universal scaling of entanglement estimators of critical quantum systems has drawn a lot of attention in the past. Recent studies indicate that similar universal properties can be found for bipartite information estimators of classical systems near phase transition, opening a new direction in the study of critical phenomena. We explore this subject by studying the information estimators of classical spin chains with general mean-field interactions. In our explicit analysis of two different bipartite information estimators in the canonical ensemble we find that, away from criticality, both the estimators remain finite in the thermodynamic limit. On the other hand, along the critical line there is a logarithmic divergence with increasing system size. The coefficient of the logarithm is fully determined by the mean-field interaction and it is the same for the class of models we consider. The scaling function, however, depends on the details of each model. In addition, we study the information estimators in the micro-canonical ensemble, where they are shown to exhibit a different universal behavior. We verify our results using numerical calculation for two specific cases of the general Hamiltonian.
It is common knowledge that the microcanonical, canonical, and grand-canonical ensembles are equivalent in thermodynamically large systems. Here, we study finite-size effects in the latter two ensembles. We show that contrary to naive expectations, finite-size errors are exponentially small in grand canonical ensemble calculations of translationally invariant systems in unordered phases at finite temperature. Open boundary conditions and canonical ensemble calculations suffer from finite-size errors that are only polynomially small in the system size. We further show that finite-size effects are generally smallest in numerical linked cluster expansions. Our conclusions are supported by analytical and numerical analyses of classical and quantum systems.