Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1706.01874 · Physical review. E

Finite-size effects in canonical and grand-canonical quantum Monte Carlo simulations for fermions

Zhenjiu Wang, Fakher F. Assaad, Francesco Parisen Toldin

Published Oct 16, 2017• 26 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We introduce a quantum Monte Carlo method at finite temperature for interacting fermionic models in the canonical ensemble, where the conservation of the particle number is enforced. Although general thermodynamic arguments ensure the equivalence of the canonical and the grand-canonical ensembles in the thermodynamic limit, their approach to the infinite-volume limit is distinctively different. Observables computed in the canonical ensemble generically display a finite-size correction proportional to the inverse volume, whereas in the grand-canonical ensemble the approach is exponential in the ratio of the linear size over the correlation length. We verify these predictions by quantum Monte Carlo simulations of the Hubbard model in one and two dimensions in the grand-canonical and the canonical ensemble. We prove an exact formula for the finite-size part of the free energy density, energy density and other observables in the canonical ensemble and relate this correction to a susceptibility computed in the corresponding grand-canonical ensemble. This result is confirmed by an exact computation of the one-dimensional classical Ising model in the canonical ensemble, which for classical models corresponds to the so-called fixed-magnetization ensemble. Our method is useful for simulating finite systems which are not coupled to a particle bath, such as in nuclear or cold atom physics.

DOI
10.1103/physreve.96.042131

Related papers

Stable recursive auxiliary field quantum Monte Carlo algorithm in the canonical ensemble: Applications to thermometry and the Hubbard model

Tong Shen, Hatem Barghathi, Jiangyong Yu +2 more

Many experimentally accessible, finite-sized interacting quantum systems are most appropriately described by the canonical ensemble of statistical mechanics. Conventional numerical simulation methods either approximate them as being coupled to a particle bath or use projective algorithms which may suffer from nonoptimal scaling with system size or large algorithmic prefactors. In this paper, we introduce a highly stable, recursive auxiliary field quantum Monte Carlo approach that can directly simulate systems in the canonical ensemble. We apply the method to the fermion Hubbard model in one and two spatial dimensions in a regime known to exhibit a significant "sign" problem and find improved performance over existing approaches including rapid convergence to ground-state expectation values. The effects of excitations above the ground state are quantified using an estimator-agnostic approach including studying the temperature dependence of the purity and overlap fidelity of the canonical and grand canonical density matrices. As an important application, we show that thermometry approaches often exploited in ultracold atoms that employ an analysis of the velocity distribution in the grand canonical ensemble may be subject to errors leading to an underestimation of extracted temperatures with respect to the Fermi temperature.

arXiv:2212.08654•Physical review. E•May 9, 2023•10 citations

Linear Ensemble-Constrained Quantum Monte Carlo: From Dilute Fermi Gas to Flat-Band Ferromagnetism

Tu Hong, Kun Chen, Xiao Yan Xu

We present a finite-temperature canonical-ensemble determinant quantum Monte Carlo algorithm that enforces an exact fermion number and enables numerically stable simulations of correlated lattice fermions. We propose a stabilized QR update that reduces the computational complexity from standard cubic scaling O(βN^{3}) to linear scaling O(βN N_{e}^{2}) with respect to the system size N, where N_{e} is the particle number. This yields a dramatic speedup in dilute regimes (N_{e}≪N), opening unbiased access to large-scale simulations of strongly correlated low-density phases. We validate the method on the dilute Fermi gas with onsite Hubbard interactions, observing the suppression of the fermion sign problem in the dilute limit. Furthermore, we apply this approach to a one-dimensional flat-band system, where the canonical ensemble allows for precise control over filling. We reveal a ferromagnetic instability at low temperatures in the half-filling regime. Our linear-scaling approach provides a powerful tool for investigating emergent phenomena in dilute quantum matter.

arXiv:2601.08552•Physical Review Letters•Sep 28, 2026•2 citations

Finite-Temperature Monte Carlo Calculations for Systems with Fermions

Shiwei Zhang

We present a quantum Monte Carlo method which allows calculations on many-fermion systems at finite temperatures without any sign decay. This enables simulations of the grand-canonical ensemble at large system sizes and low temperatures. Both diagonal and off-diagonal expectations can be computed straightforwardly. The sign decay is eliminated by a constraint on the fermion determinant. The algorithm is approximate. Tests on the Hubbard model show that accurate results on the energy and correlation functions can be obtained.

arXiv:cond-mat/9909091•Physical Review Letters•Oct 4, 1999•70 citations

Finite-size scaling in the canonical ensemble

Youjin Deng, Henk W. J. Blöte

We investigate the critical scaling behavior of finite systems in the canonical ensemble. The essential difference with the grand canonical ensemble. i.e., the constraint on the number of particles, is already known to lead to the Fisher renormalization phenomenon that modifies the thermal critical singularities. We show that, in observables that are not Fisher renormalized, it also leads to a finite-size effect governed by an exponent $y_1$ that depends on the temperature exponent $y_t$ and the dimensionality $d$ as $y_1=-|2y_t-d|$. We verify this prediction by a Monte Carlo analysis of several two-dimensional lattice models in the percolation, the Ising and the 3-state Potts universality classes.

arXiv:cond-mat/0508348•Aug 15, 2005•2 citations

On finite-size errors in disordered-phase calculations at finite temperature

Deepak Iyer, Mark Srednicki, Marcos Rigol

It is common knowledge that the microcanonical, canonical, and grand canonical ensembles are equivalent in thermodynamically large systems. Here, we study finite-size effects in the latter two ensembles. We show that contrary to naive expectations, finite-size errors are exponentially small in grand canonical ensemble calculations for translationally invariant systems in phases without long range order at finite temperature. Open boundary conditions and canonical ensemble calculations suffer from finite-size errors that scale as the inverse length scale of the system. We further show that finite-size effects are generally smallest in numerical linked cluster expansions. Our conclusions are supported by analytical and numerical analyses of classical and quantum systems.

•May 14, 2015•0 citations

Quantum statistics and discreteness. Differences between the canonical and grand canonical ensembles for a fermionic lattice gas

Ryszard Kutner, R. Przeniosło, M. Kwiatkowski

Abstract Studying the electronic properties of small metallic particles Kubo and subsequently Denton, Mühlschlegel and Scalapino recognized the surprising effect that the mean occupation numbers of noninteracting fermions (electrons) are not given within the canonical ensemble by the usual expression of Fermi‐Dirac statistics. The fermions behave as if they are colder and observed deviations are most significant in the vicinity of the Fermi level. The results of our Monte Carlo simulations, as well as our complementary numerical and analytical results are in very good agreement with the predictions of Denton et al. We found that the effect vanishes for very small and very large spacing between the energy levels in comparison to the thermal energy kBT. Associated with this effect are the particle‐hole correlations. Extending the method used by Denton et al. we derive an analytical formula for the particle‐hole correlation functions whose predictions are again in very good agreement with our numerical results. The low‐temperature aspects of the effect are considered by applying a two‐state model. The role of the finite‐size effect is also discussed.

Annalen der Physik•Jan 1, 1995•2 citations
We introduce a quantum Monte Carlo method at finite temperature for interacting fermionic models in the canonical ensemble, where the conservation of the particle number is enforced. Although general thermodynamic arguments ensure the equivalence of the canonical and the grand-canonical ensembles in the thermodynamic limit, their approach to the infinite-volume limit is distinctively different. Observables computed in the canonical ensemble generically display a finite-size correction proportional to the inverse volume, whereas in the grand-canonical ensemble the approach is exponential in the ratio of the linear size over the correlation length. We verify these predictions by quantum Monte Carlo simulations of the Hubbard model in one and two dimensions in the grand-canonical and the canonical ensemble. We prove an exact formula for the finite-size part of the free energy density, energy density and other observables in the canonical ensemble and relate this correction to a susceptibility computed in the corresponding grand-canonical ensemble. This result is confirmed by an exact computation of the one-dimensional classical Ising model in the canonical ensemble, which for classical models corresponds to the so-called fixed-magnetization ensemble. Our method is useful for simulating finite systems which are not coupled to a particle bath, such as in nuclear or cold atom physics.
Many experimentally accessible, finite-sized interacting quantum systems are most appropriately described by the canonical ensemble of statistical mechanics. Conventional numerical simulation methods either approximate them as being coupled to a particle bath or use projective algorithms which may suffer from nonoptimal scaling with system size or large algorithmic prefactors. In this paper, we introduce a highly stable, recursive auxiliary field quantum Monte Carlo approach that can directly simulate systems in the canonical ensemble. We apply the method to the fermion Hubbard model in one and two spatial dimensions in a regime known to exhibit a significant "sign" problem and find improved performance over existing approaches including rapid convergence to ground-state expectation values. The effects of excitations above the ground state are quantified using an estimator-agnostic approach including studying the temperature dependence of the purity and overlap fidelity of the canonical and grand canonical density matrices. As an important application, we show that thermometry approaches often exploited in ultracold atoms that employ an analysis of the velocity distribution in the grand canonical ensemble may be subject to errors leading to an underestimation of extracted temperatures with respect to the Fermi temperature.
We present a finite-temperature canonical-ensemble determinant quantum Monte Carlo algorithm that enforces an exact fermion number and enables numerically stable simulations of correlated lattice fermions. We propose a stabilized QR update that reduces the computational complexity from standard cubic scaling O(βN^{3}) to linear scaling O(βN N_{e}^{2}) with respect to the system size N, where N_{e} is the particle number. This yields a dramatic speedup in dilute regimes (N_{e}≪N), opening unbiased access to large-scale simulations of strongly correlated low-density phases. We validate the method on the dilute Fermi gas with onsite Hubbard interactions, observing the suppression of the fermion sign problem in the dilute limit. Furthermore, we apply this approach to a one-dimensional flat-band system, where the canonical ensemble allows for precise control over filling. We reveal a ferromagnetic instability at low temperatures in the half-filling regime. Our linear-scaling approach provides a powerful tool for investigating emergent phenomena in dilute quantum matter.
We present a quantum Monte Carlo method which allows calculations on many-fermion systems at finite temperatures without any sign decay. This enables simulations of the grand-canonical ensemble at large system sizes and low temperatures. Both diagonal and off-diagonal expectations can be computed straightforwardly. The sign decay is eliminated by a constraint on the fermion determinant. The algorithm is approximate. Tests on the Hubbard model show that accurate results on the energy and correlation functions can be obtained.
We investigate the critical scaling behavior of finite systems in the canonical ensemble. The essential difference with the grand canonical ensemble. i.e., the constraint on the number of particles, is already known to lead to the Fisher renormalization phenomenon that modifies the thermal critical singularities. We show that, in observables that are not Fisher renormalized, it also leads to a finite-size effect governed by an exponent y1y_1y1​ that depends on the temperature exponent yty_tyt​ and the dimensionality ddd as y1=−∣2yt−d∣y_1=-|2y_t-d|y1​=−∣2yt​−d∣. We verify this prediction by a Monte Carlo analysis of several two-dimensional lattice models in the percolation, the Ising and the 3-state Potts universality classes.
It is common knowledge that the microcanonical, canonical, and grand canonical ensembles are equivalent in thermodynamically large systems. Here, we study finite-size effects in the latter two ensembles. We show that contrary to naive expectations, finite-size errors are exponentially small in grand canonical ensemble calculations for translationally invariant systems in phases without long range order at finite temperature. Open boundary conditions and canonical ensemble calculations suffer from finite-size errors that scale as the inverse length scale of the system. We further show that finite-size effects are generally smallest in numerical linked cluster expansions. Our conclusions are supported by analytical and numerical analyses of classical and quantum systems.
Abstract Studying the electronic properties of small metallic particles Kubo and subsequently Denton, Mühlschlegel and Scalapino recognized the surprising effect that the mean occupation numbers of noninteracting fermions (electrons) are not given within the canonical ensemble by the usual expression of Fermi‐Dirac statistics. The fermions behave as if they are colder and observed deviations are most significant in the vicinity of the Fermi level. The results of our Monte Carlo simulations, as well as our complementary numerical and analytical results are in very good agreement with the predictions of Denton et al. We found that the effect vanishes for very small and very large spacing between the energy levels in comparison to the thermal energy kBT. Associated with this effect are the particle‐hole correlations. Extending the method used by Denton et al. we derive an analytical formula for the particle‐hole correlation functions whose predictions are again in very good agreement with our numerical results. The low‐temperature aspects of the effect are considered by applying a two‐state model. The role of the finite‐size effect is also discussed.