Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.21625

Discrete semiclassical theory of quantum-thermal escape

Luca Salasnich, Cesare Vianello

quant-phcond-mat.othercond-mat.stat-mechSubmitted Sep 18, 2026• Announced Sep 21, 2026• 0 citations• Revised Oct 21, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Sep 18, 2026v2 · Oct 21, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The dissipationless quantum-thermal escape rate from a metastable well is often written as a Boltzmann average of the Hill-Wheeler flux over a continuum of energies. This continuum treatment diverges exponentially at low temperature, because it pairs the quantum partition function of the well with a classical flux integral. Retaining the discrete nature of the quasibound spectrum removes the divergence exactly, and the resulting rate is obtained in closed form on both sides of the crossover temperature $T_0$. Evaluating a uniform Kemble transmission probability on Bohr-Sommerfeld levels further removes the parabolic-barrier error and recovers the WKB decay rate of the lowest resonance at zero temperature. Benchmarked against the resonances of cubic and quintic potentials, obtained by complex scaling, this uniform semiclassical rate stays within $9\%$ of the exact one over eleven orders of magnitude. Below $T_0$, the rate rises above its zero-temperature plateau with the level spacing as activation energy, and the plateau ends at a temperature $T_1$ noticeably below $T_0$. In an isolated well, whose levels are not replenished, the thermal rate is only the initial slope of a decay which ceases to be single exponential at $T_1$, while at $T_0$ the initial escape moves from tunneling inside the well to the barrier top. We discuss implications for Josephson junctions, single-electron pumps, and nuclear burning in dense stellar matter.

AI Summary

The paper examines dissipationless escape from a thermally populated one-dimensional metastable well, focusing on the low-temperature failure of a continuum Boltzmann average of Hill–Wheeler transmission. Combining that integral with a quantum well partition function leaves an uncompensated zero-point factor, producing an exponential divergence as $T\to0$. Replacing the continuum by a harmonic level sum removes the divergence and yields analytical expressions above and below $T_0=\hbar\omega_b/(2\pi k_B)$. To address the separate parabolic-barrier error, the construction uses Bohr–Sommerfeld levels, energy-dependent classical periods, and Kemble transmission with the actual barrier action. Its zero-temperature limit is the lowest-state WKB decay rate. Tests against arbitrary-precision complex-scaled resonances for cubic and quintic wells give thermal-rate deviations below $9\%$ over eleven orders of magnitude and individual-width errors around $10\%$ or less. The high-temperature reference shares the same approximate above-barrier flux, so agreement there is partly by construction. The low-temperature excess rate is activated by the level spacing. The plateau ends near $T_1=\Delta/[k_B\ln(\Gamma_1/\Gamma_0)]$, reaching $0.81T_0$ in the cubic example. For an isolated, initially thermal well, a resonance mixture instead predicts multiexponential decay and a stepwise effective rate approaching $\Gamma_0$; direct time evolution agrees within $0.1\%$ at late times. The treatment assumes one-dimensional coherent escape and semiclassical matching between discrete sub-barrier resonances and continuum flux. Higher-order semiclassical corrections improve low-level widths but deteriorate near the separatrix. Finite relaxation and damping are not treated dynamically.

No sign of AI-generated textIncrementalMissing comparison

Error found: The abstract overstates the benchmark as agreement with an exact thermal escape rate, although its reference uses the same approximate above-barrier Kemble flux as the proposed formula, making the high-temperature comparison partly circular.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
14 pages, 4 figures

Related papers

Semiclassical theory of energy diffusive escape

Alvise Verso, Joachim Ankerhold

Thermal escape out of a metastable well is considered in the weak friction regime, where the bottleneck for decay is energy diffusion, and at lower temperatures, where quantum tunneling becomes relevant. Within a systematic semiclassical formalism an extension of the classical diffusion equation is derived starting from a quantum mechanical master equation. In contrast to previous approaches finite barrier transmission also affects transition probabilities. The decay rate is obtained from the stationary nonequilibrium solution and captures the intimate interplay between thermal and quantum fluctuations above the crossover to the deep quantum regime.

arXiv:0908.1484•Physical Review A•Feb 19, 2009•3 citations

QUANTUM–STATISTICAL DECAY

In part II, I considered examples of exactly solvable linear dissipative quantum systems. We now leave that simple class of models and consider the situation in which a metastable state is separated from a continuum or quasi-continuum of states by a free energy barrier. The problem of escape from a metastable state plays a central role in many scientific areas including low-temperature physics, nuclear physics, chemical kinetics and transport in biomolecules. At sufficiently high temperatures, the system escapes predominantly over the barrier by thermal activation. On the other hand, at zero temperature, the system can only decay by quantum-mechanical tunneling from the ground state in the metastable well. Our emphasis will be put on answering the question “What is the influence of dissipation on the decay process ?”. The discussion of the posed problem will focus on an effective method which enables the study in the range from T = 0 up to the classical regime in an unified approach.

Series in modern condensed matter physics•Mar 1, 1993•0 citations

QUANTUM STATISTICAL DECAY

In the second part, I considered the exactly solvable case of linear dissipative quantum systems, the thermodynamic variational approach useful for nonlinear quantum systems, and issues of quantum decoherence. Now I turn to a study of the frequent situation in which a metastable state is separated from the outside region by a free energy barrier. The decay of a metastable state plays a central role in many scientific areas including low-temperature physics, nuclear physics, chemical kinetics and transport in biomolecules. At high temperatures, the system escapes from the metastable well predominantly over the barrier by thermal activation. At zero temperature on the other hand, the system is in the localized ground state of the metastable well and can escape only by quantum mechanical tunneling through the barrier. I shall focus the discussion on the influence of friction on the decay process. The treatment will be based on an effective method which allows to study this problem in a unified manner for temperatures ranging from T = 0 up to the classical regime.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Mar 1, 2012•0 citations

QUANTUM STATISTICAL DECAY

In the second part, I considered the exactly solvable case of linear dissipative quantum systems, the thermodynamic variational approach useful for nonlinear quantum systems, and issues of quantum decoherence. Now I turn to a study of the frequent situation in which a metastable state is separated from the outside region by a free energy barrier. The decay of a metastable state plays a central role in many scientific areas including low-temperature physics, nuclear physics, chemical kinetics and transport in biomolecules. At high temperatures, the system escapes from the metastable well predominantly over the barrier by thermal activation. At zero temperature on the other hand, the system is in the localized ground state of the metastable well and can escape only by quantum mechanical tunneling through the barrier. I shall focus the discussion on the influence of friction on the decay process. The treatment will be based on an effective method which allows to study this problem in a unified manner for temperatures ranging from T = 0 up to the classical regime.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Oct 1, 2021•0 citations

QUANTUM STATISTICAL DECAY

In the second part, I considered the exactly solvable case of linear dissipative quantum systems, the thermodynamic variational approach useful for nonlinear quantum systems, and the quantum decoherence problem. We now turn to a study of the frequent situation in which a metastable state is separated from the outside region by a free energy barrier. The decay of a metastable state plays a central role in many scientific areas including low-temperature physics, nuclear physics, chemical kinetics and transport in biomolecules. At high temperatures, the system escapes from the metastable well predominantly over the barrier by thermal activation. At zero temperature on the other hand, the system is in the localized ground state of the metastable well and can escape only by quantum mechanical tunneling through the barrier. We shall focus the discussion on the influence of friction on the decay process. The treatment will be based on an effective method which allows to study this problem in a unified manner for temperatures ranging from T = 0 up to the classical regime.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Oct 1, 1999•0 citations

Dissipative quantum systems with a potential barrier. III. Steady state nonequilibrium flux and reaction rate

Joachim Ankerhold, Hermann Grabert

We study the real time dynamics of a dissipative quantum system in a metastable state which may decay by crossing a potential barrier. Starting from an initial state where the system is in thermal equilibrium on one side of the barrier, the time evolution of the density matrix is evaluated analytically in the semiclassical approximation for coordinates near the barrier top. In a region about a critical temperature ${\mathrm{T}}_{\mathrm{c}}$ large quantum fluctuations render the harmonic approximation of the potential insufficient and anharmonicities become essential. Accounting for non-Gaussian fluctuation modes, we show that the density matrix approaches a quasistationary state with a constant flux across the barrier. This extends our earlier results [Phys. Rev. E 51, 4267 (1995)] on the quantum generalization of the Kramers flux state to the region about ${\mathrm{T}}_{\mathrm{c}}$. By matching the flux state onto the equilibrium state on one side of the barrier, we determine the decay rate out of the metastable state. The rate constant shows a changeover from thermally activated decay to quantum tunneling for temperatures below ${\mathrm{T}}_{\mathrm{c}}$.

Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics•Feb 1, 1997•9 citations
The dissipationless quantum-thermal escape rate from a metastable well is often written as a Boltzmann average of the Hill-Wheeler flux over a continuum of energies. This continuum treatment diverges exponentially at low temperature, because it pairs the quantum partition function of the well with a classical flux integral. Retaining the discrete nature of the quasibound spectrum removes the divergence exactly, and the resulting rate is obtained in closed form on both sides of the crossover temperature T0T_0T0​. Evaluating a uniform Kemble transmission probability on Bohr-Sommerfeld levels further removes the parabolic-barrier error and recovers the WKB decay rate of the lowest resonance at zero temperature. Benchmarked against the resonances of cubic and quintic potentials, obtained by complex scaling, this uniform semiclassical rate stays within 9%9\%9% of the exact one over eleven orders of magnitude. Below T0T_0T0​, the rate rises above its zero-temperature plateau with the level spacing as activation energy, and the plateau ends at a temperature T1T_1T1​ noticeably below T0T_0T0​. In an isolated well, whose levels are not replenished, the thermal rate is only the initial slope of a decay which ceases to be single exponential at T1T_1T1​, while at T0T_0T0​ the initial escape moves from tunneling inside the well to the barrier top. We discuss implications for Josephson junctions, single-electron pumps, and nuclear burning in dense stellar matter.
The paper examines dissipationless escape from a thermally populated one-dimensional metastable well, focusing on the low-temperature failure of a continuum Boltzmann average of Hill–Wheeler transmission. Combining that integral with a quantum well partition function leaves an uncompensated zero-point factor, producing an exponential divergence as T→0T\to0T→0.
Replacing the continuum by a harmonic level sum removes the divergence and yields analytical expressions above and below T0=ℏωb/(2πkB)T_0=\hbar\omega_b/(2\pi k_B)T0​=ℏωb​/(2πkB​). To address the separate parabolic-barrier error, the construction uses Bohr–Sommerfeld levels, energy-dependent classical periods, and Kemble transmission with the actual barrier action. Its zero-temperature limit is the lowest-state WKB decay rate. Tests against arbitrary-precision complex-scaled resonances for cubic and quintic wells give thermal-rate deviations below 9%9\%9% over eleven orders of magnitude and individual-width errors around 10%10\%10% or less. The high-temperature reference shares the same approximate above-barrier flux, so agreement there is partly by construction.
The low-temperature excess rate is activated by the level spacing. The plateau ends near T1=Δ/[kBln⁡(Γ1/Γ0)]T_1=\Delta/[k_B\ln(\Gamma_1/\Gamma_0)]T1​=Δ/[kB​ln(Γ1​/Γ0​)], reaching 0.81T00.81T_00.81T0​ in the cubic example. For an isolated, initially thermal well, a resonance mixture instead predicts multiexponential decay and a stepwise effective rate approaching Γ0\Gamma_0Γ0​; direct time evolution agrees within 0.1%0.1\%0.1% at late times.
The treatment assumes one-dimensional coherent escape and semiclassical matching between discrete sub-barrier resonances and continuum flux. Higher-order semiclassical corrections improve low-level widths but deteriorate near the separatrix. Finite relaxation and damping are not treated dynamically.
Thermal escape out of a metastable well is considered in the weak friction regime, where the bottleneck for decay is energy diffusion, and at lower temperatures, where quantum tunneling becomes relevant. Within a systematic semiclassical formalism an extension of the classical diffusion equation is derived starting from a quantum mechanical master equation. In contrast to previous approaches finite barrier transmission also affects transition probabilities. The decay rate is obtained from the stationary nonequilibrium solution and captures the intimate interplay between thermal and quantum fluctuations above the crossover to the deep quantum regime.
In part II, I considered examples of exactly solvable linear dissipative quantum systems. We now leave that simple class of models and consider the situation in which a metastable state is separated from a continuum or quasi-continuum of states by a free energy barrier. The problem of escape from a metastable state plays a central role in many scientific areas including low-temperature physics, nuclear physics, chemical kinetics and transport in biomolecules. At sufficiently high temperatures, the system escapes predominantly over the barrier by thermal activation. On the other hand, at zero temperature, the system can only decay by quantum-mechanical tunneling from the ground state in the metastable well. Our emphasis will be put on answering the question “What is the influence of dissipation on the decay process ?”. The discussion of the posed problem will focus on an effective method which enables the study in the range from T = 0 up to the classical regime in an unified approach.
In the second part, I considered the exactly solvable case of linear dissipative quantum systems, the thermodynamic variational approach useful for nonlinear quantum systems, and issues of quantum decoherence. Now I turn to a study of the frequent situation in which a metastable state is separated from the outside region by a free energy barrier. The decay of a metastable state plays a central role in many scientific areas including low-temperature physics, nuclear physics, chemical kinetics and transport in biomolecules. At high temperatures, the system escapes from the metastable well predominantly over the barrier by thermal activation. At zero temperature on the other hand, the system is in the localized ground state of the metastable well and can escape only by quantum mechanical tunneling through the barrier. I shall focus the discussion on the influence of friction on the decay process. The treatment will be based on an effective method which allows to study this problem in a unified manner for temperatures ranging from T = 0 up to the classical regime.
In the second part, I considered the exactly solvable case of linear dissipative quantum systems, the thermodynamic variational approach useful for nonlinear quantum systems, and issues of quantum decoherence. Now I turn to a study of the frequent situation in which a metastable state is separated from the outside region by a free energy barrier. The decay of a metastable state plays a central role in many scientific areas including low-temperature physics, nuclear physics, chemical kinetics and transport in biomolecules. At high temperatures, the system escapes from the metastable well predominantly over the barrier by thermal activation. At zero temperature on the other hand, the system is in the localized ground state of the metastable well and can escape only by quantum mechanical tunneling through the barrier. I shall focus the discussion on the influence of friction on the decay process. The treatment will be based on an effective method which allows to study this problem in a unified manner for temperatures ranging from T = 0 up to the classical regime.
In the second part, I considered the exactly solvable case of linear dissipative quantum systems, the thermodynamic variational approach useful for nonlinear quantum systems, and the quantum decoherence problem. We now turn to a study of the frequent situation in which a metastable state is separated from the outside region by a free energy barrier. The decay of a metastable state plays a central role in many scientific areas including low-temperature physics, nuclear physics, chemical kinetics and transport in biomolecules. At high temperatures, the system escapes from the metastable well predominantly over the barrier by thermal activation. At zero temperature on the other hand, the system is in the localized ground state of the metastable well and can escape only by quantum mechanical tunneling through the barrier. We shall focus the discussion on the influence of friction on the decay process. The treatment will be based on an effective method which allows to study this problem in a unified manner for temperatures ranging from T = 0 up to the classical regime.
We study the real time dynamics of a dissipative quantum system in a metastable state which may decay by crossing a potential barrier. Starting from an initial state where the system is in thermal equilibrium on one side of the barrier, the time evolution of the density matrix is evaluated analytically in the semiclassical approximation for coordinates near the barrier top. In a region about a critical temperature Tc{\mathrm{T}}_{\mathrm{c}}Tc​ large quantum fluctuations render the harmonic approximation of the potential insufficient and anharmonicities become essential. Accounting for non-Gaussian fluctuation modes, we show that the density matrix approaches a quasistationary state with a constant flux across the barrier. This extends our earlier results [Phys. Rev. E 51, 4267 (1995)] on the quantum generalization of the Kramers flux state to the region about Tc{\mathrm{T}}_{\mathrm{c}}Tc​. By matching the flux state onto the equilibrium state on one side of the barrier, we determine the decay rate out of the metastable state. The rate constant shows a changeover from thermally activated decay to quantum tunneling for temperatures below Tc{\mathrm{T}}_{\mathrm{c}}Tc​.