arXiv:2609.20597
Lyapunov-controlled thermalization: an exact real-time example
Jonas Loy, Jan C. Louw
Abstract
A verified Kubo-Martin-Schwinger (KMS) relation, after a drive has ceased, is not sufficient evidence to prove equilibrium. We demonstrate this in a large-$N$ large-$q$ Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) quench protocol. Although all post-quench fermion correlators are exactly thermal, a second quench back to the initial Hamiltonian reveals hidden memory of the initial state. It is encoded in correlators connecting to times before the first quench. This memory is an extensive nonequilibrium (NEQ) witness with its decay rate being the Lyapunov exponent $λ_L$. Thus $λ_L$ sets the rate at which the state becomes effectively indistinguishable from a Gibbs state. Despite being a unitary interacting many-body system, the complete NEQ real-time evolution is obtained exactly in the large-$N$, large-$q$ limit, making the setup ideal for analytically studying thermalization.
AI Summary
When do thermal post-quench correlators imply operational equilibration? This paper studies a return-quench protocol $H_0\to H_1\to H_0$ in SYK, starting from a Gibbs state of $H_0$. The Hamiltonians have correlated Gaussian disorder and equal coupling strength $\mathcal J$, with overlap $c$. In the large-$N$, leading large-$q$ theory, ordinary fermion correlators with all times after the first quench already match thermal reference correlators, while the expectation value of $H_0$ retains memory. The calculation gives the normalized return energy $\epsilon_2(t)=c\epsilon_1+(\epsilon_0-c\epsilon_1)|e^{g_{11}(t,0)}|$, where $\epsilon_a=2q^2\langle H_a\rangle/N$ and $\epsilon_1=c\epsilon_0$. Its deviation from the thermal-reference response starts quadratically in waiting time and decays asymptotically as $e^{-\lambda_L t}$, with $\lambda_L=4T_1\theta_1=2\mathcal J\cos\theta_1$, approaching $2\pi T_1$ at low temperature. A low-temperature intermediate regime instead has decay $(1+\mathcal J^2t^2)^{-1}$. These results follow from a blockwise recursive solution of the real-time Kadanoff–Baym equations, reduced to Liouville equations for arbitrary multiquench protocols. Mixed-time correlators encode the memory; individually suppressed $q$-body correlations collectively produce an extensive energy witness. A possible decrease of the assigned thermal-reference entropy under the return quench also diagnoses nonequilibrium. The exact solution is restricted to the stated large-$N$, large-$q$ approximation. A finite-$q$ weak-quench formula is provided, generally requiring numerical thermal propagators. The entropy during the waiting interval remains unresolved, and the demonstrated decay rate concerns this operational witness rather than unrestricted convergence to a Gibbs state.
Central claim may not hold: The abstract's assertion that all post-quench fermion correlators are thermal needs restriction to the ordinary leading-order correlator sector, since the Supplement explicitly exhibits nonthermal q-body correlations whose weighted sum is extensive. The paper establishes Lyapunov-rate decay of its return-energy witness, but does not establish that this rate controls effective indistinguishability from a Gibbs state across the stated class of accessible observables.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 15 pages, 4 figures