arXiv:2609.19255
Deterministic Hypergraph SYK: Melonic Dominance and Maximal Chaos Without Disorder Averaging
Shiroman Prakash
Abstract
We show that the leading melonic structure of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model can be realized by a single sparse Majorana Hamiltonian, without disorder averaging. In our deterministic hypergraph SYK model (hSYK), $N$ Majorana fermions interact through $O(dN)$ terms with uniform couplings, arranged on a fixed $q$-uniform, $d$-regular hypergraph. If the hypergraph is linear, has few short cycles, and is a spectral expander, then at large $d$ the two-point function obeys the melonic Schwinger-Dyson equation site by site. The leading thermodynamics are therefore those of SYK, and at leading order in $1/d$ every bilocal fluctuation other than the Schwarzian is gapped. The four-point ladder splits into scrambling modes labeled by eigenvalues of the site adjacency operator. At strong coupling, the uniform mode is maximally chaotic, and a non-uniform mode grows only if its eigenvalue exceeds $1/(q-1)$. Exact diagonalization of single instances with $N\le24$ agrees with the melonic two-point function and thermodynamics more closely than dense SYK of the same size, shows Wigner-Dyson level statistics, and reproduces the predicted mode structure of out-of-time-order correlators. Numerically, random linear hypergraphs typically satisfy these conditions, and for $d>q$ also avoid emergent symmetries. The model is a natural candidate for quantum simulation.
AI Summary
Can a single sparse Hamiltonian reproduce SYK’s melonic saddle and maximal chaos without disorder averaging? The paper studies $N$ Majoranas on a fixed $q$-uniform, $d$-regular hypergraph, with $dN/q$ interactions and uniform couplings $J/\sqrt d$. It assumes linearity, bounded cycle rank in every fixed-radius incidence-graph neighborhood, and a normalized site-adjacency spectral gap $\kappa_1\le1-\varepsilon$. A cavity expansion and diagram counting suppress non-melonic contributions by $O(1/d)$ at each fixed perturbative order. The resulting self-energy is $\Sigma=J^2G^{q-1}$; a leading two-particle-irreducible functional gives SYK thermodynamics. Spectral expansion gaps non-uniform bilocal fluctuations, leaving the Schwarzian soft mode. The four-point ladder factorizes into the SYK temporal kernel and site adjacency. At strong coupling its uniform mode has $\lambda_L=2\pi/\beta$, while non-uniform modes grow only for $\kappa>1/(q-1)$. For $q=4$ and positive $\kappa$, $\lambda(\kappa)=\pi(3\kappa-1)/\beta$. Exact diagonalization at $18\le N\le24$ finds two-point deviations from the melonic solution 2.4–8.5 times smaller than same-size dense-SYK benchmarks, random-matrix-compatible level statistics, and approximately adjacency-diagonal OTOCs with mode-dependent decay rates. The asymptotics are conditional on a conjectured hypergraph family, supported numerically up to $N=10^5$. The analysis does not control perturbative resummation or ladders through scrambling time; finite-$N$ corrections are conjectural. Small-system diagonalization cannot test the required local geometry. Fixed-degree $O(1/d)$ corrections persist, and for $q\equiv0\pmod4$ may become order one at $\beta J\sim e^{c_q\sqrt d}$.
Central claim may not hold: The claimed maximal chaos follows from a formal resummation of ladders established only at fixed rung number, while the paper explicitly leaves control of the growing-rung regime needed near scrambling as an expectation rather than a result.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 41 pages, 11 figures. v2: Substantially revised and expanded. Code and data: https://github.com/spdei/deterministic-syk