Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.19255

Deterministic Hypergraph SYK: Melonic Dominance and Maximal Chaos Without Disorder Averaging

Shiroman Prakash

hep-thcond-mat.str-elquant-phSubmitted Sep 16, 2026• Announced Sep 18, 2026• 0 citations• Revised Nov 3, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Sep 16, 2026v2 · Nov 3, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We show that the leading melonic structure of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model can be realized by a single sparse Majorana Hamiltonian, without disorder averaging. In our deterministic hypergraph SYK model (hSYK), $N$ Majorana fermions interact through $O(dN)$ terms with uniform couplings, arranged on a fixed $q$-uniform, $d$-regular hypergraph. If the hypergraph is linear, has few short cycles, and is a spectral expander, then at large $d$ the two-point function obeys the melonic Schwinger-Dyson equation site by site. The leading thermodynamics are therefore those of SYK, and at leading order in $1/d$ every bilocal fluctuation other than the Schwarzian is gapped. The four-point ladder splits into scrambling modes labeled by eigenvalues of the site adjacency operator. At strong coupling, the uniform mode is maximally chaotic, and a non-uniform mode grows only if its eigenvalue exceeds $1/(q-1)$. Exact diagonalization of single instances with $N\le24$ agrees with the melonic two-point function and thermodynamics more closely than dense SYK of the same size, shows Wigner-Dyson level statistics, and reproduces the predicted mode structure of out-of-time-order correlators. Numerically, random linear hypergraphs typically satisfy these conditions, and for $d>q$ also avoid emergent symmetries. The model is a natural candidate for quantum simulation.

AI Summary

Can a single sparse Hamiltonian reproduce SYK’s melonic saddle and maximal chaos without disorder averaging? The paper studies $N$ Majoranas on a fixed $q$-uniform, $d$-regular hypergraph, with $dN/q$ interactions and uniform couplings $J/\sqrt d$. It assumes linearity, bounded cycle rank in every fixed-radius incidence-graph neighborhood, and a normalized site-adjacency spectral gap $\kappa_1\le1-\varepsilon$. A cavity expansion and diagram counting suppress non-melonic contributions by $O(1/d)$ at each fixed perturbative order. The resulting self-energy is $\Sigma=J^2G^{q-1}$; a leading two-particle-irreducible functional gives SYK thermodynamics. Spectral expansion gaps non-uniform bilocal fluctuations, leaving the Schwarzian soft mode. The four-point ladder factorizes into the SYK temporal kernel and site adjacency. At strong coupling its uniform mode has $\lambda_L=2\pi/\beta$, while non-uniform modes grow only for $\kappa>1/(q-1)$. For $q=4$ and positive $\kappa$, $\lambda(\kappa)=\pi(3\kappa-1)/\beta$. Exact diagonalization at $18\le N\le24$ finds two-point deviations from the melonic solution 2.4–8.5 times smaller than same-size dense-SYK benchmarks, random-matrix-compatible level statistics, and approximately adjacency-diagonal OTOCs with mode-dependent decay rates. The asymptotics are conditional on a conjectured hypergraph family, supported numerically up to $N=10^5$. The analysis does not control perturbative resummation or ladders through scrambling time; finite-$N$ corrections are conjectural. Small-system diagonalization cannot test the required local geometry. Fixed-degree $O(1/d)$ corrections persist, and for $q\equiv0\pmod4$ may become order one at $\beta J\sim e^{c_q\sqrt d}$.

No sign of AI-generated textStrong assumptions

Central claim may not hold: The claimed maximal chaos follows from a formal resummation of ladders established only at fixed rung number, while the paper explicitly leaves control of the growing-rung regime needed near scrambling as an expectation rather than a result.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
41 pages, 11 figures. v2: Substantially revised and expanded. Code and data: https://github.com/spdei/deterministic-syk

Related papers

Majorana fermion quantum mechanics for higher rank tensors

Igor R. Klebanov, P. N. Pallegar, Fedor K. Popov

We study quantum mechanical models in which the dynamical degrees of freedom are real fermionic tensors of rank 5 and higher. They are the nonrandom counterparts of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) models where the Hamiltonian couples six or more fermions. For the tensors of rank 5, there is a unique $O(N{)}^{5}$ symmetric sixth-order Hamiltonian leading to a solvable $\mathrm{large}\text{\ensuremath{-}}N$ limit dominated by the melonic diagrams. We solve for the complete energy spectrum of this model when $N=2$ and deduce exact expressions for all the eigenvalues. The subset of states which are gauge invariant exhibits degeneracies related to the discrete symmetries of the gauged model. We also study quantum chaos properties of the tensor model and compare them with those of the $q=6$ SYK model. For $q>6$, there is a rapidly growing number of $O(N{)}^{q\ensuremath{-}1}$ invariant tensor interactions. We focus on those of them that are maximally single trace---their stranded diagrams stay connected when any set of $q\ensuremath{-}3$ colors is erased. We present a general discussion of why the tensor models with maximally single-trace interactions have $\mathrm{large}\text{\ensuremath{-}}N$ limits dominated by the melonic diagrams. We solve the $\mathrm{large}\text{\ensuremath{-}}N$ Schwinger-Dyson equations for the higher rank Majorana tensor models and show that they match those of the corresponding SYK models exactly. We also study other gauge invariant operators present in the tensor models.

arXiv:1905.06264•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Oct 7, 2019•29 citations

The chiral SYK model

Biao Lian, Shivaji L. Sondhi, Zhenbin Yang

Abstract We study the generalization of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model to a 1 + 1 dimensional chiral SYK model of N flavors of right-moving chiral Majorana fermions with all-to-all random 4-fermion interactions. The interactions in this model are exactly marginal, leading to an exact scaling symmetry. We show the Schwinger-Dyson equation of this model in the large N limit is exactly solvable. In addition, we show this model is integrable for small N ≤ 6 by bosonization. Surprisingly, the two point function in the large N limit has exactly the same form as that for N = 4, although the four point functions of the two cases are quite different. The ground state entropy in the large N limit is the same as that of N free chiral Majorana fermions, leading to a zero ground state entropy density. The OTOC of the model in the large N limit exhibits a non-trivial spacetime structure reminscent of that found by Gu and Kitaev [1] for generic SYK-like models. Specifically we find a Lyapunov regime inside an asymmetric butterfly cone, which are signatures of quantum chaos, and that the maximal velocity dependent Lyapunov exponent approaches the chaos bound 2π/β as the interaction strength approaches its physical upper bound. Finally, the model is integrable for (at least) N ≤ 6 but chaotic in the large N limit, leading us to conjecture that there is a transition from integrability to chaos as N increases past a critical value.

arXiv:1906.03308•Journal of High Energy Physics•Sep 1, 2019•27 citations

Sparse Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model, quantum chaos, and gravity duals

Antonio M. García-García, Yiyang Jia, Dario Rosa +1 more

We study a sparse Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model with $N$ Majoranas where only $\ensuremath{\sim}kN$ independent matrix elements are nonzero. We identify a minimum $k\ensuremath{\gtrsim}1$ for quantum chaos to occur by a level statistics analysis. The spectral density in this region, and for a larger $k$, is still given by the Schwarzian prediction of the dense SYK model, though with renormalized parameters. Similar results are obtained for a beyond linear scaling with $N$ of the number of nonzero matrix elements. This is a strong indication that this is the minimum connectivity for the sparse SYK model to still have a quantum gravity dual. We also find an intriguing exact relation between the leading correction to moments of the spectral density due to sparsity and the leading $1/d$ correction of Parisi's U(1) lattice gauge theory in a $d$-dimensional hypercube. In the $k\ensuremath{\rightarrow}1$ limit, different disorder realizations of the sparse SYK model show emergent random matrix statistics that for fixed $N$ can be in any universality class of the tenfold way. The agreement with random matrix statistics is restricted to short-range correlations, no more than a few level spacings, in particular in the tail of the spectrum. In addition, emergent discrete global symmetries in most of the disorder realizations for $k$ slightly below one give rise to ${2}^{m}$-fold degenerate spectra, with $m$ being a positive integer. For $k=3/4$, we observe a large number of such emergent global symmetries with a maximum ${2}^{8}$-fold degenerate spectra for $N=26$.

arXiv:2007.13837•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•May 3, 2021•82 citations

Two indices Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model

Jinwu Ye

We study the original Sachdev-Ye (SY) model in its Majorana fermion representation which can be called the two indices Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model. Its advantage over the original SY model in the $ SU(M) $ complex fermion representation is that it need no local constraints, so a $1/M $ expansion can be more easily performed. Its advantage over the 4 indices SYK model is that it has only two site indices $ J_{ij} $ instead of four indices $ J_{ijkl} $, so it may fit the bulk string theory better. By performing a $1/M $ expansion at $ N=\infty $, we show that a quantum spin liquid (QSL) state remains stable at a finite $ M $. The $ 1/M $ corrections are exactly marginal, so the system remains conformably invariant at any finite $ M $. The 4-point out of time correlation ( OTOC ) shows quantum chaos neither at $ N=\infty $ at any finite $ M $, nor at $ M=\infty $ at any finite $ N $. By looking at the replica off-diagonal channel, we find there is a quantum spin glass (QSG) instability at an exponentially suppressed temperature in $ M $. We work out a criterion for the two large numbers $ N $ and $ M $ to satisfy so that the QSG instability may be avoided. We speculate that at any finite $ N $, the quantum chaos appears at the order of $ 1/M^{0} $, which is the subleading order in the $ 1/M $ expansion. When the $ 1/N $ quantum fluctuations at any finite $ M $ are considered, from a general reparametrization symmetry breaking point of view, we argue that the eThis work may motivate future works to study the possible new gravity dual of the 2 indices SYK model.ffective action should still be described by the Schwarzian one, the OTOC shows maximal quantum chaos.

arXiv:1809.06667•Sep 18, 2018•7 citations

Tunable Chaos in the Finite Mean SYK Model

Arkaprava Mukherjee, Sumilan Banerjee, Sandip P. Trivedi +1 more

The complex Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model, featuring fermions with all-to-all interactions, serves as a dual paradigm for understanding non-Fermi liquid behavior and the holographic nature of charged black holes. Two defining characteristics of the standard SYK model are its maximal chaos (Lyapunov exponent $λ_{\mathrm{L}}=2πT$ at temperature $T$), and its finite zero-temperature residual entropy. While previous studies have largely focused on couplings drawn from a zero-mean Gaussian distribution, we investigate a generalized model with a finite mean-to-standard-deviation ratio, $g\equiv J_{0}/δJ$ of the coupling distribution in order to get deeper insight into the evolution of chaos. We find that increasing $g$ yields the following effects: (i) The system remains a fast scrambler with $λ_{\mathrm{L}}=A~T$, but with a suppressed coefficient $A<2π$. (ii) In the limit $g\to \infty$, out-of-time-ordered correlators (OTOCs) no longer exhibit exponential growth with $λ_{\mathrm{L}}\simeq 0$. (iii) The spectral correlations indicative of late-time chaos maintain Wigner-Dyson level spacing statistics for all values of $g$. (iv) The system preserves a finite residual entropy, albeit with reduced magnitude, for all $g$ values. We conclude that in this generalized SYK model, there is a chaotic to non-chaotic crossover. Moreover different measures of chaos decouple, demonstrating that the presence of finite residual entropy does not strictly imply maximal chaos.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2606.18529•Jun 18, 2026•0 citations

Combinatorial aspects of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model

Matteo Laudonio, Romain Pascalie, Adrian Tanasă

The Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model is a model of $q$ interacting fermions whose large N limit is dominated by melonic graphs. In this review we first present a diagrammatic proof of that result by direct, combinatorial analysis of its Feynman graphs. Gross and Rosenhaus have then proposed a generalization of the SYK model which involves fermions with different flavors. In terms of Feynman graphs, these flavors can be seen as reminiscent of the colors used in random tensor theory. Applying modern tools from random tensors to such a colored SYK model, all leading and next-to-leading orders diagrams of the 2-point and 4-point functions in the large $N$ expansion can be identified. We then study the effect of non-Gaussian average over the random couplings in a complex, colored version of the SYK model. Using a Polchinski-like equation and random tensor Gaussian universality, we show that the effect of this non-Gaussian averaging leads to a modification of the variance of the Gaussian distribution of couplings at leading order in $N$. We then derive the form of the effective action to all orders.

arXiv:2001.11849•Jan 31, 2020•28 citations
We show that the leading melonic structure of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model can be realized by a single sparse Majorana Hamiltonian, without disorder averaging. In our deterministic hypergraph SYK model (hSYK), NNN Majorana fermions interact through O(dN)O(dN)O(dN) terms with uniform couplings, arranged on a fixed qqq-uniform, ddd-regular hypergraph. If the hypergraph is linear, has few short cycles, and is a spectral expander, then at large ddd the two-point function obeys the melonic Schwinger-Dyson equation site by site. The leading thermodynamics are therefore those of SYK, and at leading order in 1/d1/d1/d every bilocal fluctuation other than the Schwarzian is gapped. The four-point ladder splits into scrambling modes labeled by eigenvalues of the site adjacency operator. At strong coupling, the uniform mode is maximally chaotic, and a non-uniform mode grows only if its eigenvalue exceeds 1/(q−1)1/(q-1)1/(q−1). Exact diagonalization of single instances with N≤24N\le24N≤24 agrees with the melonic two-point function and thermodynamics more closely than dense SYK of the same size, shows Wigner-Dyson level statistics, and reproduces the predicted mode structure of out-of-time-order correlators. Numerically, random linear hypergraphs typically satisfy these conditions, and for d>qd>qd>q also avoid emergent symmetries. The model is a natural candidate for quantum simulation.
Can a single sparse Hamiltonian reproduce SYK’s melonic saddle and maximal chaos without disorder averaging? The paper studies NNN Majoranas on a fixed qqq-uniform, ddd-regular hypergraph, with dN/qdN/qdN/q interactions and uniform couplings J/dJ/\sqrt dJ/d​. It assumes linearity, bounded cycle rank in every fixed-radius incidence-graph neighborhood, and a normalized site-adjacency spectral gap κ1≤1−ε\kappa_1\le1-\varepsilonκ1​≤1−ε.
A cavity expansion and diagram counting suppress non-melonic contributions by O(1/d)O(1/d)O(1/d) at each fixed perturbative order. The resulting self-energy is Σ=J2Gq−1\Sigma=J^2G^{q-1}Σ=J2Gq−1; a leading two-particle-irreducible functional gives SYK thermodynamics. Spectral expansion gaps non-uniform bilocal fluctuations, leaving the Schwarzian soft mode. The four-point ladder factorizes into the SYK temporal kernel and site adjacency. At strong coupling its uniform mode has λL=2π/β\lambda_L=2\pi/\betaλL​=2π/β, while non-uniform modes grow only for κ>1/(q−1)\kappa>1/(q-1)κ>1/(q−1). For q=4q=4q=4 and positive κ\kappaκ, λ(κ)=π(3κ−1)/β\lambda(\kappa)=\pi(3\kappa-1)/\betaλ(κ)=π(3κ−1)/β.
Exact diagonalization at 18≤N≤2418\le N\le2418≤N≤24 finds two-point deviations from the melonic solution 2.4–8.5 times smaller than same-size dense-SYK benchmarks, random-matrix-compatible level statistics, and approximately adjacency-diagonal OTOCs with mode-dependent decay rates.
The asymptotics are conditional on a conjectured hypergraph family, supported numerically up to N=105N=10^5N=105. The analysis does not control perturbative resummation or ladders through scrambling time; finite-NNN corrections are conjectural. Small-system diagonalization cannot test the required local geometry. Fixed-degree O(1/d)O(1/d)O(1/d) corrections persist, and for q≡0(mod4)q\equiv0\pmod4q≡0(mod4) may become order one at βJ∼ecqd\beta J\sim e^{c_q\sqrt d}βJ∼ecq​d​.
We study quantum mechanical models in which the dynamical degrees of freedom are real fermionic tensors of rank 5 and higher. They are the nonrandom counterparts of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) models where the Hamiltonian couples six or more fermions. For the tensors of rank 5, there is a unique O(N)5O(N{)}^{5}O(N)5 symmetric sixth-order Hamiltonian leading to a solvable $\mathrm{large}\text{\ensuremath{-}}N$ limit dominated by the melonic diagrams. We solve for the complete energy spectrum of this model when N=2N=2N=2 and deduce exact expressions for all the eigenvalues. The subset of states which are gauge invariant exhibits degeneracies related to the discrete symmetries of the gauged model. We also study quantum chaos properties of the tensor model and compare them with those of the q=6q=6q=6 SYK model. For q>6q>6q>6, there is a rapidly growing number of $O(N{)}^{q\ensuremath{-}1}$ invariant tensor interactions. We focus on those of them that are maximally single trace---their stranded diagrams stay connected when any set of $q\ensuremath{-}3$ colors is erased. We present a general discussion of why the tensor models with maximally single-trace interactions have $\mathrm{large}\text{\ensuremath{-}}N$ limits dominated by the melonic diagrams. We solve the $\mathrm{large}\text{\ensuremath{-}}N$ Schwinger-Dyson equations for the higher rank Majorana tensor models and show that they match those of the corresponding SYK models exactly. We also study other gauge invariant operators present in the tensor models.
Abstract We study the generalization of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model to a 1 + 1 dimensional chiral SYK model of N flavors of right-moving chiral Majorana fermions with all-to-all random 4-fermion interactions. The interactions in this model are exactly marginal, leading to an exact scaling symmetry. We show the Schwinger-Dyson equation of this model in the large N limit is exactly solvable. In addition, we show this model is integrable for small N ≤ 6 by bosonization. Surprisingly, the two point function in the large N limit has exactly the same form as that for N = 4, although the four point functions of the two cases are quite different. The ground state entropy in the large N limit is the same as that of N free chiral Majorana fermions, leading to a zero ground state entropy density. The OTOC of the model in the large N limit exhibits a non-trivial spacetime structure reminscent of that found by Gu and Kitaev [1] for generic SYK-like models. Specifically we find a Lyapunov regime inside an asymmetric butterfly cone, which are signatures of quantum chaos, and that the maximal velocity dependent Lyapunov exponent approaches the chaos bound 2π/β as the interaction strength approaches its physical upper bound. Finally, the model is integrable for (at least) N ≤ 6 but chaotic in the large N limit, leading us to conjecture that there is a transition from integrability to chaos as N increases past a critical value.
We study a sparse Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model with NNN Majoranas where only $\ensuremath{\sim}kN$ independent matrix elements are nonzero. We identify a minimum $k\ensuremath{\gtrsim}1$ for quantum chaos to occur by a level statistics analysis. The spectral density in this region, and for a larger kkk, is still given by the Schwarzian prediction of the dense SYK model, though with renormalized parameters. Similar results are obtained for a beyond linear scaling with NNN of the number of nonzero matrix elements. This is a strong indication that this is the minimum connectivity for the sparse SYK model to still have a quantum gravity dual. We also find an intriguing exact relation between the leading correction to moments of the spectral density due to sparsity and the leading 1/d1/d1/d correction of Parisi's U(1) lattice gauge theory in a ddd-dimensional hypercube. In the $k\ensuremath{\rightarrow}1$ limit, different disorder realizations of the sparse SYK model show emergent random matrix statistics that for fixed NNN can be in any universality class of the tenfold way. The agreement with random matrix statistics is restricted to short-range correlations, no more than a few level spacings, in particular in the tail of the spectrum. In addition, emergent discrete global symmetries in most of the disorder realizations for kkk slightly below one give rise to 2m{2}^{m}2m-fold degenerate spectra, with mmm being a positive integer. For k=3/4k=3/4k=3/4, we observe a large number of such emergent global symmetries with a maximum 28{2}^{8}28-fold degenerate spectra for N=26N=26N=26.
We study the original Sachdev-Ye (SY) model in its Majorana fermion representation which can be called the two indices Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model. Its advantage over the original SY model in the $ SU(M) $ complex fermion representation is that it need no local constraints, so a $1/M $ expansion can be more easily performed. Its advantage over the 4 indices SYK model is that it has only two site indices $ J_{ij} $ instead of four indices $ J_{ijkl} $, so it may fit the bulk string theory better. By performing a $1/M $ expansion at $ N=\infty $, we show that a quantum spin liquid (QSL) state remains stable at a finite $ M $. The $ 1/M $ corrections are exactly marginal, so the system remains conformably invariant at any finite $ M $. The 4-point out of time correlation ( OTOC ) shows quantum chaos neither at $ N=\infty $ at any finite $ M $, nor at $ M=\infty $ at any finite $ N $. By looking at the replica off-diagonal channel, we find there is a quantum spin glass (QSG) instability at an exponentially suppressed temperature in $ M $. We work out a criterion for the two large numbers $ N $ and $ M $ to satisfy so that the QSG instability may be avoided. We speculate that at any finite $ N $, the quantum chaos appears at the order of $ 1/M^{0} $, which is the subleading order in the $ 1/M $ expansion. When the $ 1/N $ quantum fluctuations at any finite $ M $ are considered, from a general reparametrization symmetry breaking point of view, we argue that the eThis work may motivate future works to study the possible new gravity dual of the 2 indices SYK model.ffective action should still be described by the Schwarzian one, the OTOC shows maximal quantum chaos.
The complex Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model, featuring fermions with all-to-all interactions, serves as a dual paradigm for understanding non-Fermi liquid behavior and the holographic nature of charged black holes. Two defining characteristics of the standard SYK model are its maximal chaos (Lyapunov exponent λL=2πTλ_{\mathrm{L}}=2πTλL​=2πT at temperature TTT), and its finite zero-temperature residual entropy. While previous studies have largely focused on couplings drawn from a zero-mean Gaussian distribution, we investigate a generalized model with a finite mean-to-standard-deviation ratio, g≡J0/δJg\equiv J_{0}/δJg≡J0​/δJ of the coupling distribution in order to get deeper insight into the evolution of chaos. We find that increasing ggg yields the following effects: (i) The system remains a fast scrambler with λL=A Tλ_{\mathrm{L}}=A~TλL​=A T, but with a suppressed coefficient A<2πA<2πA<2π. (ii) In the limit g→∞g\to \inftyg→∞, out-of-time-ordered correlators (OTOCs) no longer exhibit exponential growth with λL≃0λ_{\mathrm{L}}\simeq 0λL​≃0. (iii) The spectral correlations indicative of late-time chaos maintain Wigner-Dyson level spacing statistics for all values of ggg. (iv) The system preserves a finite residual entropy, albeit with reduced magnitude, for all ggg values. We conclude that in this generalized SYK model, there is a chaotic to non-chaotic crossover. Moreover different measures of chaos decouple, demonstrating that the presence of finite residual entropy does not strictly imply maximal chaos.
The Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model is a model of qqq interacting fermions whose large N limit is dominated by melonic graphs. In this review we first present a diagrammatic proof of that result by direct, combinatorial analysis of its Feynman graphs. Gross and Rosenhaus have then proposed a generalization of the SYK model which involves fermions with different flavors. In terms of Feynman graphs, these flavors can be seen as reminiscent of the colors used in random tensor theory. Applying modern tools from random tensors to such a colored SYK model, all leading and next-to-leading orders diagrams of the 2-point and 4-point functions in the large NNN expansion can be identified. We then study the effect of non-Gaussian average over the random couplings in a complex, colored version of the SYK model. Using a Polchinski-like equation and random tensor Gaussian universality, we show that the effect of this non-Gaussian averaging leads to a modification of the variance of the Gaussian distribution of couplings at leading order in NNN. We then derive the form of the effective action to all orders.