arXiv:2609.17896
QEMScore: How Much Does the Measurement Add to Learned Quantum Error Mitigation?
Yue Zhao, Huayue Gu, Yushun Dong, Xiyang Hu
Abstract
How much does the noisy measurement add to learned quantum error mitigation? An accuracy table cannot say, because a model handed circuit structure can score well without reading the measurement at all. QEMScore adds the comparison that can. Each simulated circuit carries an exact ideal answer. The learned mitigator is scored beside a capacity-matched control, a model just as flexible that reads the same circuit description but never the measurement. Each method's measurement spend is accounted and not equalized. We run a controlled campaign on simulated circuits and reanalyze two published learned mitigators, Q-LEAR and QRAFT, from their released hardware data. Three findings stand out. First, under familiar within-family conditions (S0) evaluated across two spin-chain families and three seeds, continuous couplings identify the target, and the control that never reads the measurement matches 87.7 to 100.5 percent of the mitigator's gain over an affine fit to the circuit description. A plain polynomial in the coupling parameters, fitted after the campaign, beats the mitigator on all six evaluations, reflecting the selected learners' capacity. Second, for these selected learners, matching most of the gain is not matching the accuracy: on five of six evaluations the mitigator removes 19.5 to 74.5 percent of the error the capacity-matched control leaves, a learner-specific gap rather than a measurement requirement. Third, on released hardware data where descriptors only partially identify queries, the findings differ: flexible models of the descriptors show negligible mean gain over affine fits in Q-LEAR, and measurement inputs carry predictive gains in both Q-LEAR and QRAFT. These comparisons reflect representation- and protocol-specific behavior rather than an isolated cross-regime difference. A learned mitigator's accuracy should therefore be reported beside such controls.
AI Summary
Learned quantum error mitigation can predict ideal outputs from circuit descriptors without using noisy measurements. QEMScore measures the additional predictive benefit of measurement inputs by comparing a full learner with a descriptor-only control using the same candidate models and selection rule. It also accounts for measurement costs, without equalizing budgets. The controlled campaign uses ten-qubit transverse-field Ising and Heisenberg circuits, depolarizing-plus-readout noise, exact simulation labels, and held-out macro mean absolute error. Across six primary family–seed evaluations, capacity-matched descriptor controls reproduce 87.7–100.5% of the full learner’s improvement over an affine descriptor baseline. Nevertheless, measurements reduce the control’s remaining error by 19.5–74.5% on five evaluations; the sixth gap spans zero. These intervals bootstrap physical circuits conditional on fitted models. Because the sampled couplings determine the ideal target, these gaps are learner-specific, not irreducible measurement benefits. A post-campaign degree-five polynomial using couplings alone beats the full learner on all six evaluations. Released-data reanalyses show measurement-associated gains: Q-LEAR’s nonlinear descriptor control adds negligible mean improvement over its affine counterpart, while base statistics and depth-cut features reduce Hellinger error by 0.1969 and 0.0222, respectively. QRAFT’s descriptor-only error is roughly six times higher than with forward probabilities. Limitations include testing only familiar-condition generalization, two circuit families and one noise family; omitting executable CDR/vnCDR comparisons; and not matching measurement budgets. Hardware reanalyses condition on execution-selected output support and released splits, do not establish unseen-circuit generalization, and do not reproduce QRAFT’s published objective or results.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 55 pages, including references and appendices