arXiv:2609.17794
What does "instant thermalization" in large-$q$ SYK models mean?
Alexander Osterkorn, Jan C. Louw
Abstract
Motivated by the Planckian thermalization rate $Γ\sim T$ observed in the two-body interacting SYK model, we study thermalization in the $q/2$-body case. Previous studies of such systems have established the notion of instantaneous thermalization to leading order in $1/q$. It was conjectured that the thermalization may still be Planckian but with a divergent rate $Γ\sim T q$, explaining the ``instantaneous'' part. For an analytically and numerically tractable system, we calculate the effective temperatures after a quench at time $t = 0$ and indeed find a Planckian rate, albeit with the unexpected decaying behavior $Γ\sim T q^{-1} $. This is contrasted with the behavior of the causal Green's function $\mathcal{G}(t_1, t_2)$, which instantly acquires a thermal form in the two-time plane block $t_1, t_2 > 0$. The resulting picture is that instant thermalization is a meaningful concept only for this block, while the off-diagonal blocks $t_1 \cdot t_2 < 0$ are inherently non-thermal at any $q$. Since the effective temperature is obtained from correlations spanning all blocks, it inherits a finite rate set by the off-diagonal. We illustrate this directly by studying the non-thermal correlations' time dependence.
AI Summary
Large-$q$ SYK models exhibit “instantaneous thermalization” of post-quench two-point functions, seemingly at odds with finite-$q$ relaxation. This paper asks whether that statement implies a diverging thermalization rate, as previously conjectured, or depends on the diagnostic used. The setup is a complex-fermion SYK dot with two independently disordered, noncommuting $q/2$-body interactions, one of which is suddenly strengthened. Thermodynamic-limit numerical Green’s functions are compared with a leading-large-$q$ solution covering the entire two-time plane, derived in a companion paper. The maximum discrepancy scales numerically as $O(q^{-2})$. Instantaneous thermality applies only when both time arguments lie after the quench; correlations spanning the quench remain nonthermal. Effective temperatures extracted from low-frequency fluctuation–dissipation ratios in Wigner coordinates relax at finite rates because their Fourier transforms include these cross-quench correlations. Finite-$q$ calculations at $q=4,6,8$ and large-$q$ calculations extending to $q=50$ show approximately linear temperature dependence and decreasing rates, roughly $\Gamma\sim T_f/q$, rather than the conjectured $\Gamma\sim qT_f$. A separate sigmoid fit to correlator relaxation at fixed relative time $\tau$ gives $k\simeq2\pi/\tau$, with roughly ten-percent corrections in the small-$\tau$ regime. The inferred rates therefore characterize different diagnostics. The precise $q\to\infty$ rate is unresolved: linear extrapolations yield slightly negative intercepts within numerical uncertainty. Effective-temperature extraction depends on Fourier windows, low-frequency fitting, and coordinate choice; its asymptotic scaling is not derived analytically. The study primarily uses one quench strength, and extension to other protocols remains open.
Central claim may not hold: The abstract presents Γ ∼ T/q more definitively than the evidence supports: the larger-q results show an approximate numerical trend with explicitly uncertain asymptotic extrapolation. The fitted affine dependence Γ = Γ₀ + Γ₁(T_f − T_f^min) does not establish the abstract's proportionality to T_f without an additional relation between the fitted intercept and slope.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.