Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.15926

Achieving perfect completeness for one- and two-message quantum proof systems

Yupan Liu, Thomas Vidick

quant-phcs.CCSubmitted Sep 14, 2026• Announced Sep 15, 2026• 3 citations• Revised Oct 9, 2026 (v3)
v1 · Sep 14, 2026v2 · Sep 17, 2026v3 · Oct 9, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

While quantum interactive proof systems using at least three messages can achieve perfect completeness, as shown by Kitaev and Watrous (STOC 2000), whether perfect completeness is achievable for one- and two-message quantum proof systems has remained open. For the one-message case, whether $\sf QMA$ can achieve perfect completeness was posed as an open problem in Watrous (FOCS 2000) and Aharonov and Naveh (2002); for the two-message case, the corresponding problems were (implicitly) posed in Jain, Upadhyay, and Watrous~(FOCS 2009) and Kobayashi, Le Gall, and Nishimura (SICOMP, 2019). In this work, we establish that ${\sf QIP}(2)$, ${\rm qq}\text{-}{\sf QAM}$, $\sf QAM$, and $\sf QMA$ can achieve perfect completeness. Here ${\rm qq}\text{-}{\sf QAM}$ denotes the class of promise problems admitting two-message quantum-public-coin quantum interactive proof systems in which the verifier's only message consists of half-EPR pairs. Our main technical contributions are the follows: 1. For $\sf QMA$ (and directly for $\sf QAM$), an exactly constructible block-encoded matrix whose kernel certifies yes instances, constructed from the acceptance operator induced by the verification circuit. This also yields an alternative proof of ${\sf QCMA}={\sf QCMA}_1$. 2. For ${\sf QIP}(2)$ (and implicitly ${\rm qq}\text{-}{\sf QAM}$), a new turn-halving transformation that preserves completeness and ensures that the resulting proof system retains at least two messages, provided that the terminal state before the final measurement is efficiently preparable.

Comments
27 pages, 1 figure, 3 protocols. v3: Added an alternative proof of QCMA=QCMA_1, additional related work, and minor changes. v2: A simplified construction of QMA=QMA_1, along with minor changes

Related papers

Stronger methods of making quantum interactive proofs perfectly complete

Hirotada Kobayashi, François Le Gall, Harumichi Nishimura

This paper presents stronger methods of achieving perfect completeness in quantum interactive proofs. First, it is proved that any problem in QMA has a two-message quantum interactive proof system of perfect completeness with constant soundness error, where the verifier has only to send a constant number of halves of EPR pairs. This in particular implies that the class QMA is necessarily included by the class QIP1(2)} of problems having two-message quantum interactive proofs of perfect completeness, which gives the first nontrivial upper bound for QMA in terms of quantum interactive proofs. It is also proved that any problem having an $m$-message quantum interactive proof system necessarily has an ${(m+1)}$-message quantum interactive proof system of perfect completeness. This improves the previous result due to Kitaev and Watrous, where the resulting system of perfect completeness requires ${m+2}$ messages if not using the parallelization result.

Conference on Innovations in Theoretical Computer Science•Jan 3, 2013•13 citations

Stronger Methods of Making Quantum Interactive Proofs Perfectly Complete

Hirotada Kobayashi, François Le Gall, Harumichi Nishimura

This paper presents stronger methods of achieving perfect completeness in quantum interactive proofs. It is proved that any problem in QMA has a two-message quantum interactive proof system with perfect completeness and constant soundness error, where the verifier has only to send a constant number of halves of EPR pairs. This in particular implies that the class QMA is necessarily included by the class ${{QIP}_1(2)}$ of problems having two-message quantum interactive proofs with perfect completeness, which gives the first nontrivial upper bound for QMA in terms of quantum interactive proofs. It is also proved that any problem having an m-message quantum interactive proof system necessarily has an (m+1)-message quantum interactive proof system with perfect completeness for every ${m \geq 2}$. This improves the previous construction due to Kitaev and Watrous, which increases the number of messages by two to achieve perfect completeness, if not using the parallelization result.

arXiv:1210.1290•SIAM Journal on Computing•Jan 1, 2015•14 citations

Separating QMA from QCIP with a Classical Oracle, or, the Power of Quantum Proofs over Classical Interaction for Quantum Verifiers

Alper Çakan

Whether some problems require quantum proofs has been a central question in quantum complexity (Aharonov and Naveh, 2002; Aaronson and Kuperberg, CCC 2007). Recently, breakthrough work of Bostanci, Haferkamp, Nirkhe, and Zhandry (STOC 2026), followed by a simpler separation due to Bostanci, Huang, and Vaikuntanathan (FOCS 2026), established a classical oracle separation between $\mathsf{QMA}$ and $\mathsf{QCMA}$. However, while they are not in $\mathsf{QCMA}$, the problems used in both separations still lie in $\mathsf{AM}$: they admit a two-message public-coin proof system with a classical verifier. In this work, we ask whether some problems truly require quantum proofs. More formally, we consider the complexity class $\mathsf{QCIP}$, introduced by Buhrman, Le Gall, and Weggemans (2024), where an efficient quantum verifier interacts with an unbounded prover over a classical channel for an arbitrary polynomial number of rounds. We construct a classical oracle $\mathcal{O}$ such that $\mathsf{QMA}^{\mathcal{O}}\not\subseteq\mathsf{QCIP}^{\mathcal{O}}$, thus showing that some languages indeed require quantum proofs, with no classical replacements. Since $\mathsf{QCMA}=\mathsf{QCIP}[1]$, this strengthens the earlier $\mathsf{QMA}$--$\mathsf{QCMA}$ separations, which now follow as a special case of our result. As a technical contribution, we extend to the complexity theory setting the techniques developed by Cakan, Goyal, and Shmueli (CRYPTO 2026) in the context of cryptography for analyzing classically interacting quantum machines. We believe this may be of independent interest.

arXiv:2610.03648•Oct 2, 2026•1 citation

On quantum interactive proofs with a laconic prover

Zihan Hu, Yupan Liu

Interactive proof systems with a laconic prover, studied by Goldreich, Vadhan, and Wigderson (CC, 2002), capture problems verifiable with logarithmic prover communication in the classical setting. For two-message quantum analogs, even a single-bit prover response contains quantum statistical zero-knowledge ($\sf QSZK$), introduced by Watrous (FOCS 2002). However, restricting the verifier's question to classical public coins collapses the corresponding class to $\sf BQP$, as shown by Beigi, Shor, and Watrous (ToC, 2011). We further study two-message quantum interactive proof systems with a laconic prover. To this end, we introduce the class ${\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}(2)$, where $\ell$ is the length of the prover's response, and establish: 1. A natural complete characterization of ${\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}(2)$ by Multi-State Distinguishability. In particular, Quantum State Distinguishability (QSD) is ${\sf QIP}_{\rm bit}$-complete. Since QSD is $\sf QSZK$-hard, our result places ${\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}(2)$, for $\ell\geq 2$, in a landscape "just above" $\sf QSZK$. 2. Easy regimes for ${\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}(2)$ collapsing to $\sf QSZK$. We prove that QSD$[a,b]$ (and thus ${\sf QIP}_{\rm bit}[a,b]$) is in $\sf QSZK$ when $a(n)-b(n)\geq 1/O(\log n)$, and combine this with an answer compression from ${\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}[2,c,s]$ to ${\sf QIP}_{\rm bit}$ to obtain another easy regime when $2c>(1+2^{\ell/2})s$. Remarkably, our improved polarization applies to SD and $\sf SZK$, resolving an open problem in Sahai and Vadhan (JACM, 2003). 3. Quantum public coins also make the interaction useless: ${\sf qc}\text{-}{\sf QAM}[O(\sqrt{\log{n}})]$ with constant gap is in $\sf BQP$, where ${\sf qc}\text{-}{\sf QAM}[\ell]$ is a subclass of ${\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}(2)$ in which the verifier's question is exactly halves of EPR pairs.

quant-pharXiv:2609.39495•Oct 1, 2026•0 citations

Two-Message Quantum Interactive Proofs and the Quantum Separability Problem

Patrick M. Hayden, Kevin Milner, Mark M. Wilde

Suppose that a polynomial-time mixed-state quantum circuit, described as a sequence of local unitary interactions followed by a partial trace, generates a quantum state shared between two parties. One might then wonder, does this quantum circuit produce a state that is separable or entangled? Here, we give evidence that it is computationally hard to decide the answer to this question, even if one has access to the power of quantum computation. We begin by exhibiting a two-message quantum interactive proof system that can decide the answer to a promise version of the question. We then prove that the promise problem is hard for the class of promise problems with "quantum statistical zero knowledge" (QSZK) proof systems by demonstrating a polynomial-time Karp reduction from the QSZK-complete promise problem "quantum state distinguish ability" to our quantum separability problem. By exploiting Knill's efficient encoding of a matrix description of a state into a description of a circuit to generate the state, we can show that our promise problem is NP-hard with respect to Cook reductions. Thus, the quantum separability problem (as phrased above) constitutes the first nontrivial promise problem decidable by a two-message quantum interactive proof system while being hard for both NP and QSZK. We also consider a variant of the problem, in which a given polynomial-time mixed-state quantum circuit accepts a quantum state as input, and the question is to decide if there is an input to this circuit which makes its output separable across some bipartite cut. We prove that this problem is a complete promise problem for the class QIP of problems decidable by quantum interactive proof systems. Finally, we show that a two-message quantum interactive proof system can also decide a multipartite generalization of the quantum separability problem.

arXiv:1211.6120•IEEE Conference on Computational Complexity (CCC)•Jun 1, 2013•26 citations

Two-message quantum interactive proofs and the quantum separability problem

Patrick M. Hayden, Kevin Milner, Mark M. Wilde

Suppose that a polynomial-time mixed-state quantum circuit, described as a sequence of local unitary interactions followed by a partial trace, generates a quantum state shared between two parties. One might then wonder, does this quantum circuit produce a state that is separable or entangled? Here, we give evidence that it is computationally hard to decide the answer to this question, even if one has access to the power of quantum computation. We begin by exhibiting a two-message quantum interactive proof system that can decide the answer to a promise version of the question. We then prove that the promise problem is hard for the class of promise problems with "quantum statistical zero knowledge" QSZK proof systems by demonstrating a polynomial-time Karp reduction from the QSZK-complete promise problem "quantum state distinguishability" to our quantum separability problem. By exploiting Knill's efficient encoding of a matrix description of a state into a description of a circuit to generate the state, we can show that our promise problem is NP-hard with respect to Cook reductions. Thus, the quantum separability problem (as phrased above) constitutes the first nontrivial promise problem decidable by a two-message quantum interactive proof system while being hard for both NP and QSZK. We also consider a variant of the problem, in which a given polynomial-time mixed-state quantum circuit accepts a quantum state as input, and the question is to decide if there is an input to this circuit which makes its output separable across some bipartite cut. We prove that this problem is a complete promise problem for the class QIP of problems decidable by quantum interactive proof systems. Finally, we show that a two-message quantum interactive proof system can also decide a multipartite generalization of the quantum separability problem.

Quantum Information and Computation•May 1, 2014•13 citations
While quantum interactive proof systems using at least three messages can achieve perfect completeness, as shown by Kitaev and Watrous (STOC 2000), whether perfect completeness is achievable for one- and two-message quantum proof systems has remained open. For the one-message case, whether QMA\sf QMAQMA can achieve perfect completeness was posed as an open problem in Watrous (FOCS 2000) and Aharonov and Naveh (2002); for the two-message case, the corresponding problems were (implicitly) posed in Jain, Upadhyay, and Watrous~(FOCS 2009) and Kobayashi, Le Gall, and Nishimura (SICOMP, 2019).
In this work, we establish that QIP(2){\sf QIP}(2)QIP(2), qq-QAM{\rm qq}\text{-}{\sf QAM}qq-QAM, QAM\sf QAMQAM, and QMA\sf QMAQMA can achieve perfect completeness. Here qq-QAM{\rm qq}\text{-}{\sf QAM}qq-QAM denotes the class of promise problems admitting two-message quantum-public-coin quantum interactive proof systems in which the verifier's only message consists of half-EPR pairs. Our main technical contributions are the follows:
  1. For QMA\sf QMAQMA (and directly for QAM\sf QAMQAM), an exactly constructible block-encoded matrix whose kernel certifies yes instances, constructed from the acceptance operator induced by the verification circuit. This also yields an alternative proof of QCMA=QCMA1{\sf QCMA}={\sf QCMA}_1QCMA=QCMA1​.
  2. For QIP(2){\sf QIP}(2)QIP(2) (and implicitly qq-QAM{\rm qq}\text{-}{\sf QAM}qq-QAM), a new turn-halving transformation that preserves completeness and ensures that the resulting proof system retains at least two messages, provided that the terminal state before the final measurement is efficiently preparable.
This paper presents stronger methods of achieving perfect completeness in quantum interactive proofs. First, it is proved that any problem in QMA has a two-message quantum interactive proof system of perfect completeness with constant soundness error, where the verifier has only to send a constant number of halves of EPR pairs. This in particular implies that the class QMA is necessarily included by the class QIP1(2)} of problems having two-message quantum interactive proofs of perfect completeness, which gives the first nontrivial upper bound for QMA in terms of quantum interactive proofs. It is also proved that any problem having an mmm-message quantum interactive proof system necessarily has an (m+1){(m+1)}(m+1)-message quantum interactive proof system of perfect completeness. This improves the previous result due to Kitaev and Watrous, where the resulting system of perfect completeness requires m+2{m+2}m+2 messages if not using the parallelization result.
This paper presents stronger methods of achieving perfect completeness in quantum interactive proofs. It is proved that any problem in QMA has a two-message quantum interactive proof system with perfect completeness and constant soundness error, where the verifier has only to send a constant number of halves of EPR pairs. This in particular implies that the class QMA is necessarily included by the class QIP1(2){{QIP}_1(2)}QIP1​(2) of problems having two-message quantum interactive proofs with perfect completeness, which gives the first nontrivial upper bound for QMA in terms of quantum interactive proofs. It is also proved that any problem having an m-message quantum interactive proof system necessarily has an (m+1)-message quantum interactive proof system with perfect completeness for every m≥2{m \geq 2}m≥2. This improves the previous construction due to Kitaev and Watrous, which increases the number of messages by two to achieve perfect completeness, if not using the parallelization result.
Whether some problems require quantum proofs has been a central question in quantum complexity (Aharonov and Naveh, 2002; Aaronson and Kuperberg, CCC 2007). Recently, breakthrough work of Bostanci, Haferkamp, Nirkhe, and Zhandry (STOC 2026), followed by a simpler separation due to Bostanci, Huang, and Vaikuntanathan (FOCS 2026), established a classical oracle separation between QMA\mathsf{QMA}QMA and QCMA\mathsf{QCMA}QCMA. However, while they are not in QCMA\mathsf{QCMA}QCMA, the problems used in both separations still lie in AM\mathsf{AM}AM: they admit a two-message public-coin proof system with a classical verifier. In this work, we ask whether some problems truly require quantum proofs. More formally, we consider the complexity class QCIP\mathsf{QCIP}QCIP, introduced by Buhrman, Le Gall, and Weggemans (2024), where an efficient quantum verifier interacts with an unbounded prover over a classical channel for an arbitrary polynomial number of rounds. We construct a classical oracle O\mathcal{O}O such that QMAO⊈QCIPO\mathsf{QMA}^{\mathcal{O}}\not\subseteq\mathsf{QCIP}^{\mathcal{O}}QMAO⊆QCIPO, thus showing that some languages indeed require quantum proofs, with no classical replacements. Since QCMA=QCIP[1]\mathsf{QCMA}=\mathsf{QCIP}[1]QCMA=QCIP[1], this strengthens the earlier QMA\mathsf{QMA}QMA--QCMA\mathsf{QCMA}QCMA separations, which now follow as a special case of our result. As a technical contribution, we extend to the complexity theory setting the techniques developed by Cakan, Goyal, and Shmueli (CRYPTO 2026) in the context of cryptography for analyzing classically interacting quantum machines. We believe this may be of independent interest.
Interactive proof systems with a laconic prover, studied by Goldreich, Vadhan, and Wigderson (CC, 2002), capture problems verifiable with logarithmic prover communication in the classical setting. For two-message quantum analogs, even a single-bit prover response contains quantum statistical zero-knowledge (QSZK\sf QSZKQSZK), introduced by Watrous (FOCS 2002). However, restricting the verifier's question to classical public coins collapses the corresponding class to BQP\sf BQPBQP, as shown by Beigi, Shor, and Watrous (ToC, 2011). We further study two-message quantum interactive proof systems with a laconic prover. To this end, we introduce the class QIPℓ-bit(2){\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}(2)QIPℓ-bit​(2), where ℓ\ellℓ is the length of the prover's response, and establish: 1. A natural complete characterization of QIPℓ-bit(2){\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}(2)QIPℓ-bit​(2) by Multi-State Distinguishability. In particular, Quantum State Distinguishability (QSD) is QIPbit{\sf QIP}_{\rm bit}QIPbit​-complete. Since QSD is QSZK\sf QSZKQSZK-hard, our result places QIPℓ-bit(2){\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}(2)QIPℓ-bit​(2), for ℓ≥2\ell\geq 2ℓ≥2, in a landscape "just above" QSZK\sf QSZKQSZK. 2. Easy regimes for QIPℓ-bit(2){\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}(2)QIPℓ-bit​(2) collapsing to QSZK\sf QSZKQSZK. We prove that QSD[a,b][a,b][a,b] (and thus QIPbit[a,b]{\sf QIP}_{\rm bit}[a,b]QIPbit​[a,b]) is in QSZK\sf QSZKQSZK when a(n)−b(n)≥1/O(log⁡n)a(n)-b(n)\geq 1/O(\log n)a(n)−b(n)≥1/O(logn), and combine this with an answer compression from QIPℓ-bit[2,c,s]{\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}[2,c,s]QIPℓ-bit​[2,c,s] to QIPbit{\sf QIP}_{\rm bit}QIPbit​ to obtain another easy regime when 2c>(1+2ℓ/2)s2c>(1+2^{\ell/2})s2c>(1+2ℓ/2)s. Remarkably, our improved polarization applies to SD and SZK\sf SZKSZK, resolving an open problem in Sahai and Vadhan (JACM, 2003). 3. Quantum public coins also make the interaction useless: qc-QAM[O(log⁡n)]{\sf qc}\text{-}{\sf QAM}[O(\sqrt{\log{n}})]qc-QAM[O(logn​)] with constant gap is in BQP\sf BQPBQP, where qc-QAM[ℓ]{\sf qc}\text{-}{\sf QAM}[\ell]qc-QAM[ℓ] is a subclass of QIPℓ-bit(2){\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}(2)QIPℓ-bit​(2) in which the verifier's question is exactly halves of EPR pairs.
Suppose that a polynomial-time mixed-state quantum circuit, described as a sequence of local unitary interactions followed by a partial trace, generates a quantum state shared between two parties. One might then wonder, does this quantum circuit produce a state that is separable or entangled? Here, we give evidence that it is computationally hard to decide the answer to this question, even if one has access to the power of quantum computation. We begin by exhibiting a two-message quantum interactive proof system that can decide the answer to a promise version of the question. We then prove that the promise problem is hard for the class of promise problems with "quantum statistical zero knowledge" (QSZK) proof systems by demonstrating a polynomial-time Karp reduction from the QSZK-complete promise problem "quantum state distinguish ability" to our quantum separability problem. By exploiting Knill's efficient encoding of a matrix description of a state into a description of a circuit to generate the state, we can show that our promise problem is NP-hard with respect to Cook reductions. Thus, the quantum separability problem (as phrased above) constitutes the first nontrivial promise problem decidable by a two-message quantum interactive proof system while being hard for both NP and QSZK. We also consider a variant of the problem, in which a given polynomial-time mixed-state quantum circuit accepts a quantum state as input, and the question is to decide if there is an input to this circuit which makes its output separable across some bipartite cut. We prove that this problem is a complete promise problem for the class QIP of problems decidable by quantum interactive proof systems. Finally, we show that a two-message quantum interactive proof system can also decide a multipartite generalization of the quantum separability problem.
Suppose that a polynomial-time mixed-state quantum circuit, described as a sequence of local unitary interactions followed by a partial trace, generates a quantum state shared between two parties. One might then wonder, does this quantum circuit produce a state that is separable or entangled? Here, we give evidence that it is computationally hard to decide the answer to this question, even if one has access to the power of quantum computation. We begin by exhibiting a two-message quantum interactive proof system that can decide the answer to a promise version of the question. We then prove that the promise problem is hard for the class of promise problems with "quantum statistical zero knowledge" QSZK proof systems by demonstrating a polynomial-time Karp reduction from the QSZK-complete promise problem "quantum state distinguishability" to our quantum separability problem. By exploiting Knill's efficient encoding of a matrix description of a state into a description of a circuit to generate the state, we can show that our promise problem is NP-hard with respect to Cook reductions. Thus, the quantum separability problem (as phrased above) constitutes the first nontrivial promise problem decidable by a two-message quantum interactive proof system while being hard for both NP and QSZK. We also consider a variant of the problem, in which a given polynomial-time mixed-state quantum circuit accepts a quantum state as input, and the question is to decide if there is an input to this circuit which makes its output separable across some bipartite cut. We prove that this problem is a complete promise problem for the class QIP of problems decidable by quantum interactive proof systems. Finally, we show that a two-message quantum interactive proof system can also decide a multipartite generalization of the quantum separability problem.