Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.15286

Spectral Chaos from a Fluctuating Quantum Horizon

Chong-Sun Chu

hep-thcond-mat.stat-mechquant-phSubmitted Sep 14, 2026• Announced Sep 15, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Black holes are conjectured to be maximally chaotic, with their quantum spectra expected to exhibit universal random-matrix correlations. This expectation, however, has so far rested largely on holographic descriptions or on many-body models in which randomness is introduced rather than derived from the microscopic degrees of freedom of the horizon itself. In the horizon matrix model, the fuzzy sphere supports highly degenerate parton states whose multiplicity accounts for the black-hole entropy. We show that quantum fluctuations of the horizon geometry lift this degeneracy and generate an ensemble of one-parton Hamiltonians. Both the operator structure and the rank-dependent covariance of this ensemble are determined by the microscopic model, rather than fixed by quenched couplings. Despite this structured covariance, the resulting spectra exhibit GOE, GUE, and GSE statistics dictated by their antiunitary symmetry classes, with the adjacent-gap statistic becoming increasingly self-averaging with matrix size. The model also realizes the universal Pandey--Mehta orthogonal-to-unitary crossover, with the crossover scale determined by the microscopic geometric covariance. A rank-resolved variance analysis shows that the fluctuation strength remains broadly distributed across tensor ranks up to the microscopic cutoff, providing a microscopic basis for the observed Wigner--Dyson universality and effectively nonlocal dynamics. The antiunitary symmetry acts directly on the fuzzy-sphere geometry, so the Dyson class of a conditional Hamiltonian is determined by the antiunitary symmetry of the underlying quantum geometry. This provides a microscopic counterpart of the Stanford--Witten relation between geometry and random-matrix universality in JT gravity. These results establish a microscopic route from quantum horizon geometry to black-hole spectral chaos.

Comments
58 pages, 5 figures

Related papers

Quantum chaos and holographic tensor models

Chethan Krishnan, Sambuddha Sanyal, P. N. Bala Subramanian

A class of tensor models were recently outlined as potentially calculable examples of holography: their perturbative large-N behavior is similar to the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model, but they are fully quantum mechanical (in the sense that there is no quenched disorder averaging). These facts make them intriguing tentative models for quantum black holes. In this note, we explicitly diagonalize the simplest non-trivial Gurau-Witten tensor model and study its spectral and late-time properties. We find parallels to (a single sample of) SYK where some of these features were recently attributed to random matrix behavior and quantum chaos. In particular, the spectral form factor exhibits a dip-ramp-plateau structure after a running time average, in qualitative agreement with SYK. But we also observe that even though the spectrum has a unique ground state, it has a huge (quasi-?)degeneracy of intermediate energy states, not seen in SYK. If one ignores the delta function due to the degeneracies however, there is level repulsion in the unfolded spacing distribution hinting chaos. Furthermore, there are gaps in the spectrum. The system also has a spectral mirror symmetry which we trace back to the presence of a unitary operator with which the Hamiltonian anticommutes. We use it to argue that to the extent that the model exhibits random matrix behavior, it is controlled not by the Dyson ensembles, but by the BDI (chiral orthogonal) class in the Altland-Zirnbauer classification.

arXiv:1612.06330•Journal of High Energy Physics•Mar 1, 2017•171 citations

Black Hole Horizon Fluctuations from Unruh Quantum Noise

Kashif Ammar Yasir

The mean Hawking flux does not determine how quantum stress fluctuations perturb a black-hole geometry. That information resides in field correlations, including vacuum contributions absent from the outgoing luminosity. Here we connect the complete exterior Unruh Wightman function to a finite-band stochastic reconstruction of Schwarzschild geometry. We retain the incoming vacuum and both outgoing frequency branches, form the connected stress covariance before angular projection, and propagate its monopole through a density-driven radial response. A shared Gaussian reconstruction then resolves how the value and derivative of the lapse control different geometric observables. For the specified covariance and noise amplitude, 2,200 realizations give relative widths of 0.0185 for the local horizon radius and 0.0483 for the surface-gravity temperature parameter, consistently across histograms and reconstruction checks. Covariance derivatives explain this unequal sensitivity. The construction separates the quantum-state input from the gravitational closure and spatial sampling assumptions, providing a reproducible finite-resolution description of how Hawking-field correlations affect horizon positions and surface-gravity statistics.

gr-qcCross-listedarXiv:2610.06223•Oct 6, 2026

Universality Classes of Black Hole Chaos

Doug Doucette

This paper investigates whether gravitational dynamics can be classified into distinct universality classes based on the architecture of chaos, rather than viewing black holes as a monolithic category. The authors build on the Maldacena-Shenker-Stanford (MSS) chaos bound, which establishes that black holes saturate the universal limit on information scrambling, making them maximally chaotic with a quantum Lyapunov exponent λ_L = 2πT. The paper proposes a fundamental reclassification. The Thick Chaos Universality Class comprises systems that saturate the MSS bound—these are the familiar black holes of Einstein gravity with dense, continuous spectra and immediate, complete transport of local instabilities. Their scrambling time is short: t_* ~ β log S. The Thin Chaos Universality Class is a mathematically coherent but hypothetical regime, defined by the structural conditions of the Trojan Universality Class (TUC): two dominant oscillatory modes, a persistent spectral gap Δ > 0, and near-integrability. In this class, the spectral gap suppresses transport, confining local instability and preventing it from acquiring operational reach. The central mathematical result is that the Thouless time—the timescale on which chaos becomes effective—scales exponentially with the spectral gap in the Thin Chaos Class: t_Th ~ (1/Δ)exp[(Δ/ε)^α], where ε is the perturbation strength. This establishes a rigorous distinction between the two classes: Thick Chaos has a short Thouless time; Thin Chaos delays chaos for exponentially long periods. The transition between classes occurs when Δ/ε ~ 1, marking the collapse of spectral protection—a genuine phase transition rather than a smooth interpolation. The paper translates these gravitational conditions into holographic terms: a CFT with a spectral gap and large Thouless time would be the signature of the Thin Chaos Class. The authors are transparent that the Thin Chaos Class may not be realized in nature. The results are theoretical and conditional on TUC assumptions, but they provide a precise mathematical language for describing what a non-maximal black hole would look like—a work of theoretical cartography that illuminates why maximal chaos is the rule by defining the mathematically possible exception.

•Jul 24, 2026•0 citations

Chaos and Randomness in Strongly-Interacting Quantum Systems

Nicholas Hunter-Jones

Quantum chaos entails an entropic and computational obstruction to describing a system and thus is intrinsically difficult to characterize. An understanding of quantum chaos is fundamentally related to the mechanism of thermalization in many-body systems and the quantum nature of black holes. In this thesis we adopt the view that quantum information theory provides a powerful framework in which to elucidate chaos in strongly-interacting quantum systems. We first push towards a more precise understanding of chaotic dynamics by relating different diagnostics of chaos, studying the time-evolution of random matrix Hamiltonians, and quantifying random matrix behavior in physical systems. We derive relations between out-of-time ordered correlation functions, spectral quantities, and frame potentials to relate the scrambling of quantum information, decay of correlators, and Haar-randomness. We give analytic expressions for these quantities in random matrix theory to explore universal aspects of late-time dynamics. Motivated by our random matrix results, we define k-invariance in order to capture the onset of random matrix behavior in physical systems. We then refine our diagnostics in order to study chaotic systems with symmetry by considering Haar-randomness with respect to quotients of the unitary group, and in doing so we generalize our quantum information machinery. We further consider extended random matrix ensembles in the context of strongly-interacting quantum systems dual to black holes. Lastly, we study operator growth in classes of random quantum circuits.

•Jun 4, 2018•18 citations

Quantum Control Geometry as a Metric of Chaos

Mahmoud Abdelshafy, Joaquin F. Rodriguez-Nieva

Quantum-chaotic systems share the same coarse-grained features characteristic of random matrices, such as Wigner-Dyson level-spacing statistics, yet can exhibit strikingly different eigenstate structure and many-body dynamics, including relaxation, transport, scrambling, and entanglement growth. This raises the fundamental question of whether these finer-grained features probe genuinely distinct aspects of quantum chaos or, instead, reflect different manifestations of a common underlying structure---and whether such structure provides a meaningful basis for regarding one many-body quantum system as "more chaotic" than another. Here, we address this question by introducing a quantum geometric framework that quantifies the susceptibility of many-body eigenstates to physically allowed deformations of the Hamiltonian, as constrained by spatial locality, symmetries, and conservation laws. The resulting geometric susceptibility is quantitative, providing a metric of chaos beyond traditional binary diagnostics; intrinsic, as it depends on the manifold of allowed Hamiltonian deformations rather than on the way the system is probed; and unifying, as it directly connects eigenstate structure with dynamics. For canonical models of quantum chaos, we find that minimal geometric susceptibility, maximal eigenstate randomness, broad spectral response of local operators, and the suppression of nonhydrodynamic slow structure coalesce in the same region of Hamiltonian control space. This suggests that these seemingly distinct signatures of chaos are different manifestations of a common underlying geometric structure. Our framework provides a route toward understanding the limits of relaxation and scrambling under physical constraints; in applications, it offers a means to engineer strongly chaotic regimes in programmable quantum systems with restricted controls.

arXiv:2611.13101•Nov 9, 2026•0 citations

Geometry of quantum states in random matrix ensembles and the chaos-integrability transition

Anonymous, Keun-young Kim A, Kunal Pal +1 more

We consider the geometry of quantum states associated with random matrix Hamiltonians belonging to ensembles that exhibit an integrable-to-chaotic transition in terms of the nearest-neighbour energy level spacing distribution, focusing on the $β$-Gaussian ensembles with generic Dyson index. For the tridiagonal Gaussian $β$-ensemble, which shows chaos-to-integrability transition with varying Dyson index, we first calculate an analytical expression for the ensemble-averaged fidelity susceptibility for a two-by-two matrix representation of the Hamiltonian for generic values of the Dyson index, and show that it diverges as the total Hamiltonian, which is the sum of a diagonal matrix with independent elements and a tridiagonal $β$-matrix, goes over to the integrable phase. Next, for large-dimensional matrices, we numerically compute the fidelity susceptibility and the quantum metric tensor, respectively, for a one-parameter and a two-parameter class of Hamiltonians that we construct from the $β$-ensemble, and find scaling relations of these quantities for chaotic and integrable phases. We also consider variations of the $β$-ensemble, such as the one that preserves the rotational invariance of the ensemble, and compute the relevant ensemble-averaged fidelity susceptibility to show that it has similar features as the tridiagonal ensemble in the integrable as well as the chaotic phase, thereby establishing the universality of these properties. Finally, the presence of non-vanishing non-diagonal elements, which arises due to the rotational non-invariance of the $β$-ensembles, is a specific feature of the corresponding metric tensor, and we use this to illuminate the difference between the quantum state space geometry of these ensembles and the rotationally invariant ones, such as the classical Gaussian ensembles.

arXiv:2507.13067•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Aug 6, 2026•2 citations
Black holes are conjectured to be maximally chaotic, with their quantum spectra expected to exhibit universal random-matrix correlations. This expectation, however, has so far rested largely on holographic descriptions or on many-body models in which randomness is introduced rather than derived from the microscopic degrees of freedom of the horizon itself. In the horizon matrix model, the fuzzy sphere supports highly degenerate parton states whose multiplicity accounts for the black-hole entropy. We show that quantum fluctuations of the horizon geometry lift this degeneracy and generate an ensemble of one-parton Hamiltonians. Both the operator structure and the rank-dependent covariance of this ensemble are determined by the microscopic model, rather than fixed by quenched couplings.
Despite this structured covariance, the resulting spectra exhibit GOE, GUE, and GSE statistics dictated by their antiunitary symmetry classes, with the adjacent-gap statistic becoming increasingly self-averaging with matrix size. The model also realizes the universal Pandey--Mehta orthogonal-to-unitary crossover, with the crossover scale determined by the microscopic geometric covariance. A rank-resolved variance analysis shows that the fluctuation strength remains broadly distributed across tensor ranks up to the microscopic cutoff, providing a microscopic basis for the observed Wigner--Dyson universality and effectively nonlocal dynamics. The antiunitary symmetry acts directly on the fuzzy-sphere geometry, so the Dyson class of a conditional Hamiltonian is determined by the antiunitary symmetry of the underlying quantum geometry. This provides a microscopic counterpart of the Stanford--Witten relation between geometry and random-matrix universality in JT gravity. These results establish a microscopic route from quantum horizon geometry to black-hole spectral chaos.
A class of tensor models were recently outlined as potentially calculable examples of holography: their perturbative large-N behavior is similar to the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model, but they are fully quantum mechanical (in the sense that there is no quenched disorder averaging). These facts make them intriguing tentative models for quantum black holes. In this note, we explicitly diagonalize the simplest non-trivial Gurau-Witten tensor model and study its spectral and late-time properties. We find parallels to (a single sample of) SYK where some of these features were recently attributed to random matrix behavior and quantum chaos. In particular, the spectral form factor exhibits a dip-ramp-plateau structure after a running time average, in qualitative agreement with SYK. But we also observe that even though the spectrum has a unique ground state, it has a huge (quasi-?)degeneracy of intermediate energy states, not seen in SYK. If one ignores the delta function due to the degeneracies however, there is level repulsion in the unfolded spacing distribution hinting chaos. Furthermore, there are gaps in the spectrum. The system also has a spectral mirror symmetry which we trace back to the presence of a unitary operator with which the Hamiltonian anticommutes. We use it to argue that to the extent that the model exhibits random matrix behavior, it is controlled not by the Dyson ensembles, but by the BDI (chiral orthogonal) class in the Altland-Zirnbauer classification.
The mean Hawking flux does not determine how quantum stress fluctuations perturb a black-hole geometry. That information resides in field correlations, including vacuum contributions absent from the outgoing luminosity. Here we connect the complete exterior Unruh Wightman function to a finite-band stochastic reconstruction of Schwarzschild geometry. We retain the incoming vacuum and both outgoing frequency branches, form the connected stress covariance before angular projection, and propagate its monopole through a density-driven radial response. A shared Gaussian reconstruction then resolves how the value and derivative of the lapse control different geometric observables. For the specified covariance and noise amplitude, 2,200 realizations give relative widths of 0.0185 for the local horizon radius and 0.0483 for the surface-gravity temperature parameter, consistently across histograms and reconstruction checks. Covariance derivatives explain this unequal sensitivity. The construction separates the quantum-state input from the gravitational closure and spatial sampling assumptions, providing a reproducible finite-resolution description of how Hawking-field correlations affect horizon positions and surface-gravity statistics.
This paper investigates whether gravitational dynamics can be classified into distinct universality classes based on the architecture of chaos, rather than viewing black holes as a monolithic category. The authors build on the Maldacena-Shenker-Stanford (MSS) chaos bound, which establishes that black holes saturate the universal limit on information scrambling, making them maximally chaotic with a quantum Lyapunov exponent λ_L = 2πT. The paper proposes a fundamental reclassification. The Thick Chaos Universality Class comprises systems that saturate the MSS bound—these are the familiar black holes of Einstein gravity with dense, continuous spectra and immediate, complete transport of local instabilities. Their scrambling time is short: t_* ~ β log S. The Thin Chaos Universality Class is a mathematically coherent but hypothetical regime, defined by the structural conditions of the Trojan Universality Class (TUC): two dominant oscillatory modes, a persistent spectral gap Δ > 0, and near-integrability. In this class, the spectral gap suppresses transport, confining local instability and preventing it from acquiring operational reach. The central mathematical result is that the Thouless time—the timescale on which chaos becomes effective—scales exponentially with the spectral gap in the Thin Chaos Class: t_Th ~ (1/Δ)exp[(Δ/ε)^α], where ε is the perturbation strength. This establishes a rigorous distinction between the two classes: Thick Chaos has a short Thouless time; Thin Chaos delays chaos for exponentially long periods. The transition between classes occurs when Δ/ε ~ 1, marking the collapse of spectral protection—a genuine phase transition rather than a smooth interpolation. The paper translates these gravitational conditions into holographic terms: a CFT with a spectral gap and large Thouless time would be the signature of the Thin Chaos Class. The authors are transparent that the Thin Chaos Class may not be realized in nature. The results are theoretical and conditional on TUC assumptions, but they provide a precise mathematical language for describing what a non-maximal black hole would look like—a work of theoretical cartography that illuminates why maximal chaos is the rule by defining the mathematically possible exception.
Quantum chaos entails an entropic and computational obstruction to describing a system and thus is intrinsically difficult to characterize. An understanding of quantum chaos is fundamentally related to the mechanism of thermalization in many-body systems and the quantum nature of black holes. In this thesis we adopt the view that quantum information theory provides a powerful framework in which to elucidate chaos in strongly-interacting quantum systems. We first push towards a more precise understanding of chaotic dynamics by relating different diagnostics of chaos, studying the time-evolution of random matrix Hamiltonians, and quantifying random matrix behavior in physical systems. We derive relations between out-of-time ordered correlation functions, spectral quantities, and frame potentials to relate the scrambling of quantum information, decay of correlators, and Haar-randomness. We give analytic expressions for these quantities in random matrix theory to explore universal aspects of late-time dynamics. Motivated by our random matrix results, we define k-invariance in order to capture the onset of random matrix behavior in physical systems. We then refine our diagnostics in order to study chaotic systems with symmetry by considering Haar-randomness with respect to quotients of the unitary group, and in doing so we generalize our quantum information machinery. We further consider extended random matrix ensembles in the context of strongly-interacting quantum systems dual to black holes. Lastly, we study operator growth in classes of random quantum circuits.
Quantum-chaotic systems share the same coarse-grained features characteristic of random matrices, such as Wigner-Dyson level-spacing statistics, yet can exhibit strikingly different eigenstate structure and many-body dynamics, including relaxation, transport, scrambling, and entanglement growth. This raises the fundamental question of whether these finer-grained features probe genuinely distinct aspects of quantum chaos or, instead, reflect different manifestations of a common underlying structure---and whether such structure provides a meaningful basis for regarding one many-body quantum system as "more chaotic" than another. Here, we address this question by introducing a quantum geometric framework that quantifies the susceptibility of many-body eigenstates to physically allowed deformations of the Hamiltonian, as constrained by spatial locality, symmetries, and conservation laws. The resulting geometric susceptibility is quantitative, providing a metric of chaos beyond traditional binary diagnostics; intrinsic, as it depends on the manifold of allowed Hamiltonian deformations rather than on the way the system is probed; and unifying, as it directly connects eigenstate structure with dynamics. For canonical models of quantum chaos, we find that minimal geometric susceptibility, maximal eigenstate randomness, broad spectral response of local operators, and the suppression of nonhydrodynamic slow structure coalesce in the same region of Hamiltonian control space. This suggests that these seemingly distinct signatures of chaos are different manifestations of a common underlying geometric structure. Our framework provides a route toward understanding the limits of relaxation and scrambling under physical constraints; in applications, it offers a means to engineer strongly chaotic regimes in programmable quantum systems with restricted controls.
We consider the geometry of quantum states associated with random matrix Hamiltonians belonging to ensembles that exhibit an integrable-to-chaotic transition in terms of the nearest-neighbour energy level spacing distribution, focusing on the βββ-Gaussian ensembles with generic Dyson index. For the tridiagonal Gaussian βββ-ensemble, which shows chaos-to-integrability transition with varying Dyson index, we first calculate an analytical expression for the ensemble-averaged fidelity susceptibility for a two-by-two matrix representation of the Hamiltonian for generic values of the Dyson index, and show that it diverges as the total Hamiltonian, which is the sum of a diagonal matrix with independent elements and a tridiagonal βββ-matrix, goes over to the integrable phase. Next, for large-dimensional matrices, we numerically compute the fidelity susceptibility and the quantum metric tensor, respectively, for a one-parameter and a two-parameter class of Hamiltonians that we construct from the βββ-ensemble, and find scaling relations of these quantities for chaotic and integrable phases. We also consider variations of the βββ-ensemble, such as the one that preserves the rotational invariance of the ensemble, and compute the relevant ensemble-averaged fidelity susceptibility to show that it has similar features as the tridiagonal ensemble in the integrable as well as the chaotic phase, thereby establishing the universality of these properties. Finally, the presence of non-vanishing non-diagonal elements, which arises due to the rotational non-invariance of the βββ-ensembles, is a specific feature of the corresponding metric tensor, and we use this to illuminate the difference between the quantum state space geometry of these ensembles and the rotationally invariant ones, such as the classical Gaussian ensembles.