Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.10808

Tight Time-Space Lower Bounds for Collision Finding and Element Distinctness under Label Symmetry

Frédéric Magniez, Sebastian Zur

quant-phcs.CCcs.CRcs.DSSubmitted Sep 9, 2026• Announced Sep 11, 2026• 1 citation• Revised Oct 2, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Sep 9, 2026v2 · Oct 2, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

How much memory is needed to retain the quantum speedup for collision finding? For a uniformly random function $f:[N]\to [N]$, the BHT algorithm finds a collision using $O(N^{1/3})$ queries and a quantumly accessible classical table containing $O(N^{1/3})$ input-output pairs, whereas a logarithmic-space Grover search uses $O(\sqrt N)$ queries. Determining the optimal query-space tradeoff between these extremes remains a major open problem. We resolve this equation within the class of label-symmetric algorithms, which treat the function $f$'s output labels as interchangeable. We prove that such algorithm that makes $T$ queries, uses $S$ qubits, and finds a collision in a uniformly random function $f:[M]\to [N]$ with constant probability satisfies $$T=Ω(N^{1/3}) \qquad\text{and}\qquad T^2S=Ω(N\log N).$$ For the setting where $M=N$, these bounds are matched by a space-efficient implementation of the BHT algorithm. As a consequence of our tradeoff, any label-symmetric algorithm for the search version of Element Distinctness on $f: [n] \to [n^2]$ must satisfy $$T=Ω(n^{2/3}) \qquad\text{and}\qquad T^2S=Ω(n^2\log n),$$ matching Ambainis's quantum walk. Thus, both tradeoffs are optimal within the class of label-symmetric algorithms. To prove these results, we develop a space-sensitive version of the compressed oracle technique. The compressed oracle records the information learned by the algorithm in an evolving superposition of databases. Using label symmetry and representation theory, we show that an algorithm using $S$ qubits can effectively retain information about only $O(S/\log N)$ collision-free database entries. Substituting this estimate into the compressed oracle technique yields the stated tradeoffs.

Comments
Addition of an example of an application to algorithms with intermediate measurements, together with minor edits

Related papers

Quantum Lower Bounds for Collision Problems

Pan Peng, Jingyu Wu

We establish tight lower bounds on the adaptive and non-adaptive quantum query complexities of Promised $k$-to-one Finding on an exactly $k$-to-one input string $x\in\mathbb Z_q^n$, for every fixed $k\ge2$ and every feasible alphabet size $q\ge n/k$. The lower bounds are $Ω_k(n^{1/2-1/(2(2^k-1))})$ for unrestricted adaptive algorithms and $Ω_k(n^{1-1/k})$ for one-round non-adaptive algorithms. The former matches the adaptive quantum algorithm of Liu and Zhandry [LZ19], whereas the latter matches classical birthday sampling even when the parallel queries are arbitrarily entangled. We also establish the non-adaptive lower bound $Ω_k(\sqrt{n/k})$ for $k$-to-one Testing when $q\ge n$, resolving an open question posed by Koiran, Landes, Portier, and Yao [KLPY10]. Our proofs generate the balanced input from a uniformly random permutation and use compressed permutation oracles to describe the information learned by the algorithm. The adaptive proof bounds the growth of partial collisions through successive queries. The one-round proof instead analyzes the state after the parallel queries directly, bounding the probability that the compressed database contains a full collision. In both proofs, a short verification step accounts for correct outputs that include unrecorded positions. For the decision problem, we also compare one-round states with independent and distinct output labels.

quant-pharXiv:2611.01767•Nov 3, 2026•0 citations

Compressed Oracle Duality: A simple framework for knowing what quantum adversaries know

Matthew Ding, Mark Zhandry

Given a quantum adversary that queries a random oracle, how do we characterize the information that they "know"? The Compressed Oracle method of Zhandry (CRYPTO 2019) is one method that records the queries that the adversary makes; this recording serves as a representation of the information that is learned. However, a significant limitation of the Compressed Oracle method is that it may continue to store information that the adversary has "forgotten." This issue is especially pertinent in the space-bounded setting, where the adversary may uncompute information to free up space, while the information may still reside in the compressed oracle. In this work, we present a simple and interpretable framework called "Compressed Oracle Duality," which extends the Compressed Oracle method for space-bounded algorithms. By applying an isometry to the memory of a quantum adversary, we obtain a pair of compressed oracles with identical marginal distributions and classical correlations which correspond to the knowledge the adversary retains. In fact, we show that the outcome of measuring the new compressed oracle database corresponds exactly to applying the pretty-good measurement on the adversary's memory. As an application of our framework for collision search, we give a simplified proof of the recent $T^2S = Ω(N\log N)$ quantum time-space tradeoff for label-symmetric algorithms due to Magniez-Zur (arXiv:2609.10808); we also prove a stronger classical tradeoff of $TS=Ω(N\log N)$ assuming label symmetry. The proofs under our framework do not require representation theory and instead bound the mutual information between the compressed oracle pairs. This highlights both how the label symmetry assumption bypasses known proof barriers as well as the challenges that remain in achieving unconditional quantum time-space tradeoffs.

quant-pharXiv:2611.00609•Nov 3, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Time–Space Tradeoff for Finding Multiple Collision Pairs

Yassine Hamoudi, Frédéric Magniez

We study the problem of finding K collision pairs in a random function f : [N] → [N] by using a quantum computer. We prove that the number of queries to the function in the quantum random oracle model must increase significantly when the size of the available memory is limited. Namely, we demonstrate that any algorithm using S qubits of memory must perform a number T of queries that satisfies the tradeoff T 3 S ≥ Ω (K 3 N) . Classically, the same question has only been settled recently by Dinur [ 22 ], who showed that the Parallel Collision Search algorithm of van Oorschot and Wiener [ 36 ] achieves the optimal time–space tradeoff of T 2 S = Θ (K 2 N) . Our result limits the extent to which quantum computing may decrease this tradeoff. Our method is based on a novel application of Zhandry’s recording query technique [ 42 ] for proving lower bounds in the exponentially small success probability regime. As a second application, we give a simpler proof of the time–space tradeoff T 2 S ≥ Ω (N 3 ) for sorting N numbers on a quantum computer, which was first obtained by Klauck, Špalek, and de Wolf [ 30 ].

arXiv:2002.08944•ACM Transactions on Computation Theory•Apr 13, 2023•38 citations

Quantum lower bounds for the collision and the element distinctness problems

Yaoyun Shi

Given a function f as an oracle, the collision problem is to find two distinct inputs i and j such that f(i)=f(j), under the promise that such inputs exist. In this paper, we prove that any quantum algorithm for finding a collision in an r-to-one function must evaluate the function /spl Omega/ ((n/r)/sup 1/3/) times, where n is the size of the domain and r|n. This lower bound matches, up to a constant factor, the upper bound of Brassard, Hoyer and Tapp (1997), which uses the quantum algorithm of Grover (1996) in a novel way. The previously best quantum lower bound is /spl Omega/ ((n/r)/sup 1/5/) evaluations, due to Aaronson (2002). Our result implies a quantum lower bound of /spl Omega/ (n/sup 2/3/) queries to the inputs for another well studied problem, the element distinctness problem, which is to determine whether or not the given n real numbers are distinct. The previous best lower bound is /spl Omega/ (/spl radic/n) queries in the black-box model; and /spl Omega/ (/spl radic/n log n) comparisons in the comparisons-only model, due to Hoyer Neerbek, and Shi (2001).

arXiv:quant-ph/0112086•Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science•Jun 26, 2003•122 citations

A Noise Operator Approach to Quantum Query Complexity and Time-Space Tradeoff Lower Bounds

Paul Beame, Blake Holman, Niels Kornerup

Time and space (memory) are two of the most important measures of cost in computation, even more so for quantum computation. Yet, our tools for proving unconditional quantum tradeoffs between time and space are surprisingly limited. The first quantum time-space tradeoff lower bounds were proven for sorting by Klauck, Špalek and de Wolf. Unfortunately, their method is limited to proving output-oblivious lower bounds (i.e. the lower bounds only apply to algorithms with a non-adaptive output schedule) and other methods have yielded nothing beyond output-oblivious lower bounds for sorting. Here, we prove the first fully general quantum time-space tradeoff lower bound for sorting. We do so by introducing a novel method based on the noise operator to add to the analysis toolkit for proving quantum query and time-space tradeoff lower bounds. By combining our resulting quantum noise stability bound with quantum recording query methods, we prove an $Ω(n^{4/3} (\log \log n)/(S^{1/3} \log n))$ lower bound on the number of queries that a fully general quantum algorithm with at most $S$ qubits of memory requires to sort $n$ numbers from $[n^2]$. Applying our noise operator argument involves purely classical reasoning, which makes it particularly simple to use. We also use it to prove that, for any strongly universal (pairwise independent) hash function family $H$ from $n$ bits to $m$ bits, almost all hash functions in $H$ require any algorithm with at most $S$ qubits of memory to make $Ω(nm/S)$ quantum queries to input $x$ in order to compute $h(x)$, even with very small success probability. Previously, Mansour, Nisan, and Tiwari had shown a matching classical lower bound for computing $h(x)$ with both $h$ and $x$ as inputs using their hash mixing lemma. Our noise operator method allows us to use a related property of hash functions to prove our quantum lower bounds.

cs.CCCross-listedarXiv:2609.40334•Oct 1, 2026•0 citations

A Tight Quantum Algorithm for Multiple Collision Search

Xavier Bonnetain, Johanna Loyer, André Schrottenloher +1 more

Searching for collisions in random functions is a fundamental computational problem, with many applications in symmetric and asymmetric cryptanalysis. When one searches for a single collision, the known quantum algorithms match the query lower bound. This is not the case for the problem of finding multiple collisions, despite its regular appearance as a sub-component in sieving-type algorithms. At EUROCRYPT 2019, Liu and Zhandry gave a query lower bound $Ω(2^{m/3 + 2k/3})$ for finding $2^k$ collisions in a random function with m-bit output. At EUROCRYPT 2023, Bonnetain et al. gave a quantum algorithm matching this bound for a large range of $m$ and $k$, but not all admissible values. Like many previous collision-finding algorithms, theirs is based on the MNRS quantum walk framework, but it chains the walks by reusing the state after outputting a collision. In this paper, we give a new algorithm that tackles the remaining non-optimal range, closing the problem. Our algorithm is tight (up to a polynomial factor) in queries, and also in time under a quantum RAM assumption. The idea is to extend the chained walk to a regime in which several collisions are returned at each step, and the ``walks'' themselves only perform a single diffusion layer.

arXiv:2509.13909•Sep 17, 2025•0 citations
How much memory is needed to retain the quantum speedup for collision finding? For a uniformly random function f:[N]→[N]f:[N]\to [N]f:[N]→[N], the BHT algorithm finds a collision using O(N1/3)O(N^{1/3})O(N1/3) queries and a quantumly accessible classical table containing O(N1/3)O(N^{1/3})O(N1/3) input-output pairs, whereas a logarithmic-space Grover search uses O(N)O(\sqrt N)O(N​) queries. Determining the optimal query-space tradeoff between these extremes remains a major open problem.
We resolve this equation within the class of label-symmetric algorithms, which treat the function fff's output labels as interchangeable. We prove that such algorithm that makes TTT queries, uses SSS qubits, and finds a collision in a uniformly random function f:[M]→[N]f:[M]\to [N]f:[M]→[N] with constant probability satisfies T=Ω(N1/3)andT2S=Ω(Nlog⁡N).T=Ω(N^{1/3}) \qquad\text{and}\qquad T^2S=Ω(N\log N).T=Ω(N1/3)andT2S=Ω(NlogN). For the setting where M=NM=NM=N, these bounds are matched by a space-efficient implementation of the BHT algorithm. As a consequence of our tradeoff, any label-symmetric algorithm for the search version of Element Distinctness on f:[n]→[n2]f: [n] \to [n^2]f:[n]→[n2] must satisfy T=Ω(n2/3)andT2S=Ω(n2log⁡n),T=Ω(n^{2/3}) \qquad\text{and}\qquad T^2S=Ω(n^2\log n),T=Ω(n2/3)andT2S=Ω(n2logn), matching Ambainis's quantum walk. Thus, both tradeoffs are optimal within the class of label-symmetric algorithms.
To prove these results, we develop a space-sensitive version of the compressed oracle technique. The compressed oracle records the information learned by the algorithm in an evolving superposition of databases. Using label symmetry and representation theory, we show that an algorithm using SSS qubits can effectively retain information about only O(S/log⁡N)O(S/\log N)O(S/logN) collision-free database entries. Substituting this estimate into the compressed oracle technique yields the stated tradeoffs.
We establish tight lower bounds on the adaptive and non-adaptive quantum query complexities of Promised kkk-to-one Finding on an exactly kkk-to-one input string x∈Zqnx\in\mathbb Z_q^nx∈Zqn​, for every fixed k≥2k\ge2k≥2 and every feasible alphabet size q≥n/kq\ge n/kq≥n/k. The lower bounds are Ωk(n1/2−1/(2(2k−1)))Ω_k(n^{1/2-1/(2(2^k-1))})Ωk​(n1/2−1/(2(2k−1))) for unrestricted adaptive algorithms and Ωk(n1−1/k)Ω_k(n^{1-1/k})Ωk​(n1−1/k) for one-round non-adaptive algorithms. The former matches the adaptive quantum algorithm of Liu and Zhandry [LZ19], whereas the latter matches classical birthday sampling even when the parallel queries are arbitrarily entangled. We also establish the non-adaptive lower bound Ωk(n/k)Ω_k(\sqrt{n/k})Ωk​(n/k​) for kkk-to-one Testing when q≥nq\ge nq≥n, resolving an open question posed by Koiran, Landes, Portier, and Yao [KLPY10]. Our proofs generate the balanced input from a uniformly random permutation and use compressed permutation oracles to describe the information learned by the algorithm. The adaptive proof bounds the growth of partial collisions through successive queries. The one-round proof instead analyzes the state after the parallel queries directly, bounding the probability that the compressed database contains a full collision. In both proofs, a short verification step accounts for correct outputs that include unrecorded positions. For the decision problem, we also compare one-round states with independent and distinct output labels.
Given a quantum adversary that queries a random oracle, how do we characterize the information that they "know"? The Compressed Oracle method of Zhandry (CRYPTO 2019) is one method that records the queries that the adversary makes; this recording serves as a representation of the information that is learned. However, a significant limitation of the Compressed Oracle method is that it may continue to store information that the adversary has "forgotten." This issue is especially pertinent in the space-bounded setting, where the adversary may uncompute information to free up space, while the information may still reside in the compressed oracle. In this work, we present a simple and interpretable framework called "Compressed Oracle Duality," which extends the Compressed Oracle method for space-bounded algorithms. By applying an isometry to the memory of a quantum adversary, we obtain a pair of compressed oracles with identical marginal distributions and classical correlations which correspond to the knowledge the adversary retains. In fact, we show that the outcome of measuring the new compressed oracle database corresponds exactly to applying the pretty-good measurement on the adversary's memory. As an application of our framework for collision search, we give a simplified proof of the recent T2S=Ω(Nlog⁡N)T^2S = Ω(N\log N)T2S=Ω(NlogN) quantum time-space tradeoff for label-symmetric algorithms due to Magniez-Zur (arXiv:2609.10808); we also prove a stronger classical tradeoff of TS=Ω(Nlog⁡N)TS=Ω(N\log N)TS=Ω(NlogN) assuming label symmetry. The proofs under our framework do not require representation theory and instead bound the mutual information between the compressed oracle pairs. This highlights both how the label symmetry assumption bypasses known proof barriers as well as the challenges that remain in achieving unconditional quantum time-space tradeoffs.
We study the problem of finding K collision pairs in a random function f : [N] → [N] by using a quantum computer. We prove that the number of queries to the function in the quantum random oracle model must increase significantly when the size of the available memory is limited. Namely, we demonstrate that any algorithm using S qubits of memory must perform a number T of queries that satisfies the tradeoff T 3 S ≥ Ω (K 3 N) . Classically, the same question has only been settled recently by Dinur [ 22 ], who showed that the Parallel Collision Search algorithm of van Oorschot and Wiener [ 36 ] achieves the optimal time–space tradeoff of T 2 S = Θ (K 2 N) . Our result limits the extent to which quantum computing may decrease this tradeoff. Our method is based on a novel application of Zhandry’s recording query technique [ 42 ] for proving lower bounds in the exponentially small success probability regime. As a second application, we give a simpler proof of the time–space tradeoff T 2 S ≥ Ω (N 3 ) for sorting N numbers on a quantum computer, which was first obtained by Klauck, Špalek, and de Wolf [ 30 ].
Given a function f as an oracle, the collision problem is to find two distinct inputs i and j such that f(i)=f(j), under the promise that such inputs exist. In this paper, we prove that any quantum algorithm for finding a collision in an r-to-one function must evaluate the function /spl Omega/ ((n/r)/sup 1/3/) times, where n is the size of the domain and r|n. This lower bound matches, up to a constant factor, the upper bound of Brassard, Hoyer and Tapp (1997), which uses the quantum algorithm of Grover (1996) in a novel way. The previously best quantum lower bound is /spl Omega/ ((n/r)/sup 1/5/) evaluations, due to Aaronson (2002). Our result implies a quantum lower bound of /spl Omega/ (n/sup 2/3/) queries to the inputs for another well studied problem, the element distinctness problem, which is to determine whether or not the given n real numbers are distinct. The previous best lower bound is /spl Omega/ (/spl radic/n) queries in the black-box model; and /spl Omega/ (/spl radic/n log n) comparisons in the comparisons-only model, due to Hoyer Neerbek, and Shi (2001).
Time and space (memory) are two of the most important measures of cost in computation, even more so for quantum computation. Yet, our tools for proving unconditional quantum tradeoffs between time and space are surprisingly limited. The first quantum time-space tradeoff lower bounds were proven for sorting by Klauck, Špalek and de Wolf. Unfortunately, their method is limited to proving output-oblivious lower bounds (i.e. the lower bounds only apply to algorithms with a non-adaptive output schedule) and other methods have yielded nothing beyond output-oblivious lower bounds for sorting. Here, we prove the first fully general quantum time-space tradeoff lower bound for sorting. We do so by introducing a novel method based on the noise operator to add to the analysis toolkit for proving quantum query and time-space tradeoff lower bounds. By combining our resulting quantum noise stability bound with quantum recording query methods, we prove an Ω(n4/3(log⁡log⁡n)/(S1/3log⁡n))Ω(n^{4/3} (\log \log n)/(S^{1/3} \log n))Ω(n4/3(loglogn)/(S1/3logn)) lower bound on the number of queries that a fully general quantum algorithm with at most SSS qubits of memory requires to sort nnn numbers from [n2][n^2][n2]. Applying our noise operator argument involves purely classical reasoning, which makes it particularly simple to use. We also use it to prove that, for any strongly universal (pairwise independent) hash function family HHH from nnn bits to mmm bits, almost all hash functions in HHH require any algorithm with at most SSS qubits of memory to make Ω(nm/S)Ω(nm/S)Ω(nm/S) quantum queries to input xxx in order to compute h(x)h(x)h(x), even with very small success probability. Previously, Mansour, Nisan, and Tiwari had shown a matching classical lower bound for computing h(x)h(x)h(x) with both hhh and xxx as inputs using their hash mixing lemma. Our noise operator method allows us to use a related property of hash functions to prove our quantum lower bounds.
Searching for collisions in random functions is a fundamental computational problem, with many applications in symmetric and asymmetric cryptanalysis. When one searches for a single collision, the known quantum algorithms match the query lower bound. This is not the case for the problem of finding multiple collisions, despite its regular appearance as a sub-component in sieving-type algorithms. At EUROCRYPT 2019, Liu and Zhandry gave a query lower bound Ω(2m/3+2k/3)Ω(2^{m/3 + 2k/3})Ω(2m/3+2k/3) for finding 2k2^k2k collisions in a random function with m-bit output. At EUROCRYPT 2023, Bonnetain et al. gave a quantum algorithm matching this bound for a large range of mmm and kkk, but not all admissible values. Like many previous collision-finding algorithms, theirs is based on the MNRS quantum walk framework, but it chains the walks by reusing the state after outputting a collision. In this paper, we give a new algorithm that tackles the remaining non-optimal range, closing the problem. Our algorithm is tight (up to a polynomial factor) in queries, and also in time under a quantum RAM assumption. The idea is to extend the chained walk to a regime in which several collisions are returned at each step, and the ``walks'' themselves only perform a single diffusion layer.