Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2608.25961

Superadditivity of classical communication over quantum channels via random and deterministic permutations

Benjamin Lovitz, Peixue Wu

quant-phmath-phmath.PRSubmitted Aug 26, 2026• Announced Aug 27, 2026• 6 citations• Revised Oct 5, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Aug 26, 2026v2 · Oct 5, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Since Hastings' proof of superadditivity of classical communication over quantum channels, considerable effort has been devoted to finding a structural explanation of this phenomenon that was originally established by concentration of measure for Haar random unitaries. The main observation of this work is that Haar randomness can be replaced by random permutations without changing the limiting geometry responsible for nonadditivity. This replacement turns a continuous problem over unitary matrices into a discrete combinatorial problem over zero--one permutation matrices, and thereby opens a path toward derandomization. The theorem of Bordenave and Collins shows that random permutations have the required limiting behavior and the algorithm of O'Donnell and Wu then provides a deterministic asymptotic construction, running in polynomial time in the size when the channel parameters and accuracy are fixed. Thus the random construction can be derandomized in an asymptotic algorithmic sense. Finally, a quantitative random permutation estimate by Chen, Garza-Vargas, Tropp and van Handel gives a fully numerical estimate: there exists a tuple of 57,836,025 permutations acting on a set of size \[ N \le 5.422\times 10^{116216}\] such that the associated finite dimensional channel exhibits nonadditivity. This enormous value remains an obstacle to a practical construction.

Related papers

Approximate Unitary Designs Give Rise to Quantum Channels With Super Additive Classical Holevo Capacity

Aditya Nema, Pranab Sen

In a breakthrough, Hastings showed that there exist quantum channels whose classical Holevo capacity is superadditive i.e. more classical information can be transmitted by quantum encoding strategies entangled across multiple channel uses as compared to unentangled quantum encoding strategies. Hastings’ proof used Haar random unitaries to exhibit superadditivity. In this paper we show that a unitary chosen uniformly at random from an approximate$n^{2/3}$-design gives rise to a quantum channel with superadditive classical Holevo capacity, where$n$is the dimension of the unitary exhibiting the Stinespring dilation of the channel superoperator. We follow the geometric functional analytic approach of Aubrun, Szarek and Werner in order to prove our result. More precisely we prove a sharp Dvoretzky-like theorem stating that, with high probability under the choice of a unitary from an approximate$t$-design, random subspaces of large dimension make a Lipschitz function take almost constant value. Such theorems were known earlier only for Haar random unitaries. We obtain our result by appealing to Low’s technique for proving concentration of measure for an approximate$t$-design, combined with a stratified analysis of the variational behaviour of Lipschitz functions on the unit sphere in high dimension. The stratified analysis is the main technical advance of this work. Haar random unitaries require at least$\Omega (n^{2})$random bits in order to describe them with good precision. In contrast, there exist exact$n^{2/3}$-designs using only$O(n^{2/3} \log n)$random bits. Thus, our work can be viewed as a partial derandomisation of Hastings’ result, and a step towards the quest of finding an explicit quantum channel with superadditive classical Holevo capacity. Finally we also show that for any$p > 1$, approximate unitary$n^{1.7}$-designs give rise to channels violating subadditivity of Rényi$p$-entropy. In addition to stratified analysis, the proof of this result uses a new technique of approximating a monotonic differentiable function defined on a closed bounded interval and its derivative by moderate degree polynomials which should be of independent interest.

IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Apr 21, 2022•1 citation

Approximate Unitary n^{2/3}-Designs Give Rise to Quantum Channels with Super Additive Classical Holevo Capacity

Aditya Nema, Sen, Pranab

In a breakthrough, Hastings' showed that there exist quantum channels whose classical capacity is superadditive i.e. more classical information can be transmitted by quantum encoding strategies entangled across multiple channel uses as compared to unentangled quantum encoding strategies. Hastings' proof used Haar random unitaries to exhibit superadditivity. In this paper we show that a unitary chosen uniformly at random from an approximate $n^{2/3}$-design gives rise to a quantum channel with superadditive classical Holevo capacity, where $n$ is the dimension of the unitary exhibiting the Stinespring dilation of the channel superoperator. We prove a sharp Dvoretzky-like theorem (similar to Aubrun, Szarek, Werner, 2010) stating that, with high probability under the choice of a unitary from an approximate $t$-design, random subspaces of large dimension make a Lipschitz function take almost constant value. Such theorems were known earlier only for Haar random unitaries. We obtain our result by appealing to Low's technique for proving concentration of measure for an approximate $t$-design, combined with a stratified analysis of the variational behaviour of Lipschitz functions on the unit sphere in high dimension. The stratified analysis is the main technical advance of this work. Finally we also show that for any $p>1$, approximate unitary $(n^{1.7} \log n)$-designs give rise to channels violating subadditivity of Rényi $p$-entropy. In addition to stratified analysis, the proof of this result uses a new technique of approximating a monotonic differentiable function defined on a closed bounded interval and its derivative by moderate degree polynomials which should be of independent interest. Hence, our work can be viewed as a partial derandomisation of Hastings' result and a step towards the quest of finding an explicit quantum channel with superadditive classical Holevo capacity.

arXiv:1902.10808•Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Jan 1, 2019•3 citations

Superadditivity of Zero-Error Capacity in Noisy Classical and Perfect Quantum Channel Pairs

Ambuj, Anushko Chattopadhyay, Kunika Agarwal +2 more

We demonstrate superadditivity of one-shot zero-error classical capacity in an asymmetric communication setting where a noisy classical channel is used in parallel with a perfect quantum channel. Each channel individually supports only a fixed number of perfectly distinguishable messages. Their joint use enables transmission of strictly more messages than permitted by the product of the individual capacities. We present explicit constructions achieving this enhancement and establish that replacing the perfect quantum channel with a perfect classical channel eliminates the effect. Finally, we identify a structural criterion on the noisy channel governing this effect and show that the quantum advantage is rooted in Kochen-Specker contextuality.

quant-pharXiv:2601.08913•Jan 15, 2026•3 citations

LOW ENTROPY OUTPUT STATES FOR PRODUCTS OF RANDOM UNITARY CHANNELS

Benoît Collins, Motohisa Fukuda, Ion Nechita

In this paper, we study the behavior of the output of pure entangled states after being transformed by a product of conjugate random unitary channels. This study is motivated by the counterexamples by Hastings [Superadditivity of communication capacity using entangled inputs, Nat. Phys.5 (2009) 255–257] and Hayden–Winter [Counterexamples to the maximal p-norm multiplicativity conjecture for all p > 1, Comm. Math. Phys.284(1) (2008) 263–280] to the additivity problems. In particular, we study in depth the difference of behavior between random unitary channels and generic random channels. In the case where the number of unitary operators is fixed, we compute the limiting eigenvalues of the output states. In the case where the number of unitary operators grows linearly with the dimension of the input space, we show that the eigenvalue distribution converges to a limiting shape that we characterize with free probability tools. In order to perform the required computations, we need a systematic way of dealing with moment problems for random matrices whose blocks are i.i.d. Haar distributed unitary operators. This is achieved by extending the graphical Weingarten calculus introduced in [B. Collins and I. Nechita, Random quantum channels I: Graphical calculus and the Bell state phenomenon, Comm. Math. Phys.297(2) (2010) 345–370].

arXiv:1208.1449•Random Matrices Theory and Application•Jan 1, 2013•8 citations

Deterministic Minimum-Output-Entropy Nonadditivity via Haagerup's Inequality and Near-Free Permutation Representations

Guocheng Zhen, Chengkai Zhu, Ranyiliu Chen +1 more

We give a deterministic realization of the finite-dimensional quadratic certificate underlying Collins's mixed-unitary proof of minimum-output-entropy nonadditivity. For every fixed integer $K\ge 2$ and rational $η>0$ satisfying $\log K>2(3+η)^2$, a deterministic polynomial-time algorithm, for every sufficiently large target size $N$, outputs $K$ permutations on $N'=N+o_{K,η}(N)$ points. Restricting their permutation matrices to the nontrivial standard representation yields real orthogonal Stinespring blocks and a channel $Φ_{N'}:M_{N'-1}(\mathbb{C})\to M_K(\mathbb{C})$ such that \[ 2H_{\min}(Φ_{N'}) -H_{\min}(Φ_{N'}^{\otimes 2}) \ge \frac{\log K}{K} -2\log\left(1+\frac{(3+η)^2}{K}\right) >0. \] The construction combines Haagerup's length-two inequality with the simultaneous deterministic spectral approximation of O'Donnell and Wu. We further show that the constant $3$ is asymptotically sharp on the relevant Hermitian zero-diagonal coefficient class and that the finite spectral transfer is nearly saturated, thereby isolating the finer geometry of the full output body as the natural next level of refinement beyond the scalar-radius method. Finally, a standard covariant extension converts the same deterministic entropy gap exactly into self-tensor superadditivity of the one-shot Holevo quantity.

quant-pharXiv:2608.31081•Sep 1, 2026•5 citations

Symmetry and Randomness in Quantum Information Theory: Several Applications

Wei Dong Xie

This thesis studies four topics in quantum information theory using tools from representation theory and (high-dimensional) probability theory. \nFirst, we study the nonadditivity of minimum output von Neumann and Rényi entropy of quantum channels. A sketch of the proof by Aubrun, Szarek and Werner for nonadditivity of minimum output entropy is presented, and a slight simplification is given. We show that asymptotically the minimum output entropy of the random channel Ɛ ⊗ Ɛ ⊗ Ɛ* is achieved not by a tripartite genuinely entangled state, but by a tensor product of two states. We also study another model of random channel, and our estimation of the minimum output Rényi entropies fails to show the usefulness of genuine multipartite entanglement for the multiple nonadditivity. \nSecond, we study the generic entanglement in the random near-invariant tensors under the action of 𝔰𝔲(2), and random symmetric invariant tensors under the action of 𝔰𝔲(𝘥) for any 𝘥, serving as an extension of the random invariant tensors under 𝔰𝔲(2). We show that both the random tensors are asymptotically close to a maximally entangled state with respect to any bipartite cut. \nThird, we study efficient quantum certification for states and unitaries. We present an algorithm that uses 𝑂(ε⁻⁴ ln |𝒫|) copies of an unknown state to distinguish whether the unknown state is contained in or ε-far from a finite set 𝒫 of known states with respect to the trace distance. This algorithm is more sample-efficient in some settings. The previous study showed that one can distinguish whether an unknown unitary 𝑈 is equal to or ε-far from a known or unknown unitary 𝘝 in fixed dimension with 𝑂(ε⁻²) uses of the unitary, in which an ancilla system should be used. We give an algorithm that distinguishes the two cases with 𝑂(ε⁻¹) uses of the unitary, without using ancilla system or using ancilla system of much smaller dimension. \nFinally, we study the parallel repetition of extended nonlocal game motivated by its connection with multipartite steering and entanglement detection. We show that the probability of winning an 𝑛-fold parallel repetition of commuting nonsignaling extended nonlocal game 𝐺 decreases exponentially in 𝑛, provided that the game value of 𝐺 is strictly less than 1, following the approach used by Lancien and Winter based on de Finetti reduction.

•Jan 1, 2020•0 citations
Since Hastings' proof of superadditivity of classical communication over quantum channels, considerable effort has been devoted to finding a structural explanation of this phenomenon that was originally established by concentration of measure for Haar random unitaries.
The main observation of this work is that Haar randomness can be replaced by random permutations without changing the limiting geometry responsible for nonadditivity. This replacement turns a continuous problem over unitary matrices into a discrete combinatorial problem over zero--one permutation matrices, and thereby opens a path toward derandomization. The theorem of Bordenave and Collins shows that random permutations have the required limiting behavior and the algorithm of O'Donnell and Wu then provides a deterministic asymptotic construction, running in polynomial time in the size when the channel parameters and accuracy are fixed. Thus the random construction can be derandomized in an asymptotic algorithmic sense.
Finally, a quantitative random permutation estimate by Chen, Garza-Vargas, Tropp and van Handel gives a fully numerical estimate: there exists a tuple of 57,836,025 permutations acting on a set of size [ N \le 5.422\times 10^{116216}] such that the associated finite dimensional channel exhibits nonadditivity. This enormous value remains an obstacle to a practical construction.
In a breakthrough, Hastings showed that there exist quantum channels whose classical Holevo capacity is superadditive i.e. more classical information can be transmitted by quantum encoding strategies entangled across multiple channel uses as compared to unentangled quantum encoding strategies. Hastings’ proof used Haar random unitaries to exhibit superadditivity. In this paper we show that a unitary chosen uniformly at random from an approximaten2/3n^{2/3}n2/3-design gives rise to a quantum channel with superadditive classical Holevo capacity, wherennnis the dimension of the unitary exhibiting the Stinespring dilation of the channel superoperator. We follow the geometric functional analytic approach of Aubrun, Szarek and Werner in order to prove our result. More precisely we prove a sharp Dvoretzky-like theorem stating that, with high probability under the choice of a unitary from an approximatettt-design, random subspaces of large dimension make a Lipschitz function take almost constant value. Such theorems were known earlier only for Haar random unitaries. We obtain our result by appealing to Low’s technique for proving concentration of measure for an approximatettt-design, combined with a stratified analysis of the variational behaviour of Lipschitz functions on the unit sphere in high dimension. The stratified analysis is the main technical advance of this work. Haar random unitaries require at leastΩ(n2)\Omega (n^{2})Ω(n2)random bits in order to describe them with good precision. In contrast, there exist exactn2/3n^{2/3}n2/3-designs using onlyO(n2/3log⁡n)O(n^{2/3} \log n)O(n2/3logn)random bits. Thus, our work can be viewed as a partial derandomisation of Hastings’ result, and a step towards the quest of finding an explicit quantum channel with superadditive classical Holevo capacity. Finally we also show that for anyp>1p > 1p>1, approximate unitaryn1.7n^{1.7}n1.7-designs give rise to channels violating subadditivity of Rényippp-entropy. In addition to stratified analysis, the proof of this result uses a new technique of approximating a monotonic differentiable function defined on a closed bounded interval and its derivative by moderate degree polynomials which should be of independent interest.
In a breakthrough, Hastings' showed that there exist quantum channels whose classical capacity is superadditive i.e. more classical information can be transmitted by quantum encoding strategies entangled across multiple channel uses as compared to unentangled quantum encoding strategies. Hastings' proof used Haar random unitaries to exhibit superadditivity. In this paper we show that a unitary chosen uniformly at random from an approximate n2/3n^{2/3}n2/3-design gives rise to a quantum channel with superadditive classical Holevo capacity, where nnn is the dimension of the unitary exhibiting the Stinespring dilation of the channel superoperator. We prove a sharp Dvoretzky-like theorem (similar to Aubrun, Szarek, Werner, 2010) stating that, with high probability under the choice of a unitary from an approximate ttt-design, random subspaces of large dimension make a Lipschitz function take almost constant value. Such theorems were known earlier only for Haar random unitaries. We obtain our result by appealing to Low's technique for proving concentration of measure for an approximate ttt-design, combined with a stratified analysis of the variational behaviour of Lipschitz functions on the unit sphere in high dimension. The stratified analysis is the main technical advance of this work. Finally we also show that for any p>1p>1p>1, approximate unitary (n1.7log⁡n)(n^{1.7} \log n)(n1.7logn)-designs give rise to channels violating subadditivity of Rényi ppp-entropy. In addition to stratified analysis, the proof of this result uses a new technique of approximating a monotonic differentiable function defined on a closed bounded interval and its derivative by moderate degree polynomials which should be of independent interest. Hence, our work can be viewed as a partial derandomisation of Hastings' result and a step towards the quest of finding an explicit quantum channel with superadditive classical Holevo capacity.
We demonstrate superadditivity of one-shot zero-error classical capacity in an asymmetric communication setting where a noisy classical channel is used in parallel with a perfect quantum channel. Each channel individually supports only a fixed number of perfectly distinguishable messages. Their joint use enables transmission of strictly more messages than permitted by the product of the individual capacities. We present explicit constructions achieving this enhancement and establish that replacing the perfect quantum channel with a perfect classical channel eliminates the effect. Finally, we identify a structural criterion on the noisy channel governing this effect and show that the quantum advantage is rooted in Kochen-Specker contextuality.
In this paper, we study the behavior of the output of pure entangled states after being transformed by a product of conjugate random unitary channels. This study is motivated by the counterexamples by Hastings [Superadditivity of communication capacity using entangled inputs, Nat. Phys.5 (2009) 255–257] and Hayden–Winter [Counterexamples to the maximal p-norm multiplicativity conjecture for all p > 1, Comm. Math. Phys.284(1) (2008) 263–280] to the additivity problems. In particular, we study in depth the difference of behavior between random unitary channels and generic random channels. In the case where the number of unitary operators is fixed, we compute the limiting eigenvalues of the output states. In the case where the number of unitary operators grows linearly with the dimension of the input space, we show that the eigenvalue distribution converges to a limiting shape that we characterize with free probability tools. In order to perform the required computations, we need a systematic way of dealing with moment problems for random matrices whose blocks are i.i.d. Haar distributed unitary operators. This is achieved by extending the graphical Weingarten calculus introduced in [B. Collins and I. Nechita, Random quantum channels I: Graphical calculus and the Bell state phenomenon, Comm. Math. Phys.297(2) (2010) 345–370].
We give a deterministic realization of the finite-dimensional quadratic certificate underlying Collins's mixed-unitary proof of minimum-output-entropy nonadditivity. For every fixed integer K≥2K\ge 2K≥2 and rational η>0η>0η>0 satisfying log⁡K>2(3+η)2\log K>2(3+η)^2logK>2(3+η)2, a deterministic polynomial-time algorithm, for every sufficiently large target size NNN, outputs KKK permutations on N′=N+oK,η(N)N'=N+o_{K,η}(N)N′=N+oK,η​(N) points. Restricting their permutation matrices to the nontrivial standard representation yields real orthogonal Stinespring blocks and a channel ΦN′:MN′−1(C)→MK(C)Φ_{N'}:M_{N'-1}(\mathbb{C})\to M_K(\mathbb{C})ΦN′​:MN′−1​(C)→MK​(C) such that 2Hmin⁡(ΦN′)−Hmin⁡(ΦN′⊗2)≥log⁡KK−2log⁡(1+(3+η)2K)>0. 2H_{\min}(Φ_{N'}) -H_{\min}(Φ_{N'}^{\otimes 2}) \ge \frac{\log K}{K} -2\log\left(1+\frac{(3+η)^2}{K}\right) >0. 2Hmin​(ΦN′​)−Hmin​(ΦN′⊗2​)≥KlogK​−2log(1+K(3+η)2​)>0. The construction combines Haagerup's length-two inequality with the simultaneous deterministic spectral approximation of O'Donnell and Wu. We further show that the constant 333 is asymptotically sharp on the relevant Hermitian zero-diagonal coefficient class and that the finite spectral transfer is nearly saturated, thereby isolating the finer geometry of the full output body as the natural next level of refinement beyond the scalar-radius method. Finally, a standard covariant extension converts the same deterministic entropy gap exactly into self-tensor superadditivity of the one-shot Holevo quantity.
This thesis studies four topics in quantum information theory using tools from representation theory and (high-dimensional) probability theory. \nFirst, we study the nonadditivity of minimum output von Neumann and Rényi entropy of quantum channels. A sketch of the proof by Aubrun, Szarek and Werner for nonadditivity of minimum output entropy is presented, and a slight simplification is given. We show that asymptotically the minimum output entropy of the random channel Ɛ ⊗ Ɛ ⊗ Ɛ* is achieved not by a tripartite genuinely entangled state, but by a tensor product of two states. We also study another model of random channel, and our estimation of the minimum output Rényi entropies fails to show the usefulness of genuine multipartite entanglement for the multiple nonadditivity. \nSecond, we study the generic entanglement in the random near-invariant tensors under the action of 𝔰𝔲(2), and random symmetric invariant tensors under the action of 𝔰𝔲(𝘥) for any 𝘥, serving as an extension of the random invariant tensors under 𝔰𝔲(2). We show that both the random tensors are asymptotically close to a maximally entangled state with respect to any bipartite cut. \nThird, we study efficient quantum certification for states and unitaries. We present an algorithm that uses 𝑂(ε⁻⁴ ln |𝒫|) copies of an unknown state to distinguish whether the unknown state is contained in or ε-far from a finite set 𝒫 of known states with respect to the trace distance. This algorithm is more sample-efficient in some settings. The previous study showed that one can distinguish whether an unknown unitary 𝑈 is equal to or ε-far from a known or unknown unitary 𝘝 in fixed dimension with 𝑂(ε⁻²) uses of the unitary, in which an ancilla system should be used. We give an algorithm that distinguishes the two cases with 𝑂(ε⁻¹) uses of the unitary, without using ancilla system or using ancilla system of much smaller dimension. \nFinally, we study the parallel repetition of extended nonlocal game motivated by its connection with multipartite steering and entanglement detection. We show that the probability of winning an 𝑛-fold parallel repetition of commuting nonsignaling extended nonlocal game 𝐺 decreases exponentially in 𝑛, provided that the game value of 𝐺 is strictly less than 1, following the approach used by Lancien and Winter based on de Finetti reduction.