Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2608.23935

A Clarifying Note on the Position-Momentum Correspondence: Pontryagin Duality, Fourier Transport, and Physical Normalization

Samuel B. Soltau

quant-phSubmitted Aug 25, 2026• Announced Aug 26, 2026• 0 citations• Revised Sep 13, 2026 (v3)
v1 · Aug 25, 2026v2 · Sep 1, 2026v3 · Sep 13, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The position--momentum correspondence combines several mathematically distinct identifications that are often conflated. For the additive group $(\mathbb R,+)$, every continuous character has the form $x\mapsto \mathrm e^{ikx}$. After choosing a coordinate $p=αk$ on the dual group, one obtains $\mathrm e^{ipx/α}$, so Pontryagin duality alone does not identify a particular dual coordinate with physical momentum. For the corresponding unitary Fourier transform, multiplication in position space is transported to convolution in momentum space, while the diagonal distribution is transported to the specific composition with the addition map $(p,q)\mapsto p+q$; it is not transported to pointwise multiplication in momentum space. The family $\hat P_α=-iα\,d/dx$ has commutator $[\hat X,\hat P_α]=iαI$ on $\mathcal S(\mathbb R)$, and the standard quantum-mechanical normalization $[\hat X,\hat P]=i\hbar I$ therefore selects $α=\hbar$ within this family. Equivalently, the standard normalization of the translation generator gives $\hat P=-i\hbar\,d/dx$. The resulting characters $\mathrm e^{ipx/\hbar}$ have spatial period $h/|p|$ for $p\neq0$. All distributional statements are formulated in the Schwartz rigging and no product or pullback of arbitrary tempered distributions is used.

Related papers

Position--Momentum Duality as Spectral Diagonalization of Bilocal Propagation A Continuation of the Action--Phase Program

Jonatan P. camargo

The objective of this work is to investigate whether the position--momentum duality can be reformulated, without ad hoc hypotheses and without circular reasoning, as a direct consequence of the spectral structure of bilocal unitary propagation. We start from the architecture already established in the Action--Phase program: the physical phase is given by \(\phi=S/\hbar\); self-adjoint structural operators organize the dynamics on a discrete lattice; such operators admit interpretation as unitary filters via Cayley realization; and the discrete unitary evolution can be written exactly as propagation by a bilocal kernel \(W(x,y)\). The central question is to determine under what hypotheses this bilocal kernel can be represented as a function of a self-adjoint structural operator, \[ \hat W=f(\hat H), \qquad \hat H=\hat H^\dagger, \] and how this structure implies the existence of an intrinsic spectral basis in which the propagation becomes diagonal. It is shown, step by step, that the spectral decomposition of \(\hat H\) induces a corresponding decomposition of the kernel, \[ W(x,y)=\sum_n f(\lambda_n)\,\phi_n(x)\phi_n^*(y), \] so that the unitary evolution begins to act multiplicatively on the spectral modes, \[ \widetilde\Psi_n(t+\Delta t)=f(\lambda_n)\widetilde\Psi_n(t), \] without the introduction of additional structures. In the homogeneous case, it is demonstrated that the eigenfunctions of the structural operator are discrete Fourier modes and that the continuous spectral parameter coincides with the usual wavenumber. In this regime, the spectral representation exactly reproduces the momentum sector of standard quantum mechanics. Outside this case, ``momentum'' is reinterpreted more generally as the spectral coordinate of the operator generating the propagation. The result of this stage is, therefore, conceptually precise: the position--momentum duality does not need to be postulated as an ontological duplication, but emerges as a duality between the nodal basis and the spectral basis of the same structural operator that governs the unitary propagation. The work does not intend, at this stage, to completely reconstruct the theory of canonical observables, nor to definitively resolve multiparticle systems or formulate a general covariant theory. Its role is to establish the minimum layer in which the spectral structure of propagation provides the mathematical origin of position--momentum duality, opening a controlled continuation program for these problems.

•Apr 6, 2026•0 citations

Translational Invariance and Spectral Objectivity: Plancherel-Parseval and Uncertainty under a Unitary Shift Representation

Gustaf Ullman

This working paper examines translational invariance as a minimal model of observer equivariance. Instead of treating translations only as displacements in physical space, it interprets them as abstract shifts between observer perspectives acting on a space of perspectives. The paper separates three layers: standard harmonic analysis, its observer-equivariance interpretation, and the additional physical calibration required to identify the dual spectral variable with momentum. Using a strongly continuous unitary representation of a locally compact abelian shift group, the note recalls the spectral description given by Pontryagin duality, Plancherel--Parseval, and, in the Euclidean case, the Heisenberg--Kennard uncertainty relation. The main interpretive point is that localization in perspective space and localization in the dual structural variable are subject to the usual Fourier trade-off. In this sense, uncertainty is read not merely as a feature of physical position and momentum, but as a structural constraint on perspective localization and the resolution of invariant modes. This version is a technical building block in a broader series of notes on observer equivariance, epistemic structural realism, and structural objectivity. The mathematical content is standard; the contribution is the reinterpretation of translational invariance as invariance under shifts of observer perspective.

•May 23, 2026•0 citations

The ubiquitous XP commutator

Alberto C de la Torre

Position and momentum of a particle can take any value in a continuous spectrum; these values are independent but their indeterminacies are correlated; momentum and position are mutually the generators of the transformations in each other. It is shown in a concise way, how all these features arise solely from their commutation relation $[X,P]=i\hbar$. The article is complete and self contained, adequate for didactic use.

arXiv:quant-ph/0509171•European Journal of Physics•Jan 3, 2006•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics on Lie Groups: I. Noncommutative Fourier Transforms

Mathieu Beauvillain, Blagoje Oblak, Marios Petropoulos

Starting from square-integrable wave functions on a Lie group, we build an invertible Fourier transform mapping them on wave functions on the dual of the Lie algebra. This is a group-theoretic version of the map from position space to momentum space, with generally noncommuting momenta owing to the group structure. As a result, the multiplication of momentum-dependent functions involves star products, which makes the construction of noncommutative Fourier series much more involved than that of their commutative cousin. This is especially true when compact subgroups are present, in which case we carefully take into account quotients of the operator algebra, and the resulting normalization issues. We show that our formalism provides an isometry of Hilbert spaces, and use it to derive a noncommutative Poisson summation formula for any compact Lie group. This is a key preliminary for the computation of Wigner functions and path integrals for quantum systems on group manifolds.

quant-pharXiv:2512.19840•Dec 24, 2025

The ubiquitous XP commutator

Alberto C. De La Torre

Position and momentum of a particle can take any value in a continuous spectrum; these values are independent but their indeterminacies are correlated; momentum and position are mutually the generators of the transformations in each other. It is shown in a concise way, how all these features arise solely from their commutation relation $[X,P]=i\\hbar$. The article is complete and self contained, adequate for didactic use.

•Sep 23, 2005•3 citations

MOMENTUM OPERATORS IN QUANTUM MECHANICS

A. M. Arthurs

Representation for real functions of quantum mechanical momentum operator obtained by functional integration in phase space

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Aug 1, 1968•9 citations
The position--momentum correspondence combines several mathematically distinct identifications that are often conflated. For the additive group (R,+)(\mathbb R,+)(R,+), every continuous character has the form x↦eikxx\mapsto \mathrm e^{ikx}x↦eikx. After choosing a coordinate p=αkp=αkp=αk on the dual group, one obtains eipx/α\mathrm e^{ipx/α}eipx/α, so Pontryagin duality alone does not identify a particular dual coordinate with physical momentum. For the corresponding unitary Fourier transform, multiplication in position space is transported to convolution in momentum space, while the diagonal distribution is transported to the specific composition with the addition map (p,q)↦p+q(p,q)\mapsto p+q(p,q)↦p+q; it is not transported to pointwise multiplication in momentum space. The family P^α=−iα d/dx\hat P_α=-iα\,d/dxP^α​=−iαd/dx has commutator [X^,P^α]=iαI[\hat X,\hat P_α]=iαI[X^,P^α​]=iαI on S(R)\mathcal S(\mathbb R)S(R), and the standard quantum-mechanical normalization [X^,P^]=iℏI[\hat X,\hat P]=i\hbar I[X^,P^]=iℏI therefore selects α=ℏα=\hbarα=ℏ within this family. Equivalently, the standard normalization of the translation generator gives P^=−iℏ d/dx\hat P=-i\hbar\,d/dxP^=−iℏd/dx. The resulting characters eipx/ℏ\mathrm e^{ipx/\hbar}eipx/ℏ have spatial period h/∣p∣h/|p|h/∣p∣ for p≠0p\neq0p=0. All distributional statements are formulated in the Schwartz rigging and no product or pullback of arbitrary tempered distributions is used.
The objective of this work is to investigate whether the position--momentum duality can be reformulated, without ad hoc hypotheses and without circular reasoning, as a direct consequence of the spectral structure of bilocal unitary propagation. We start from the architecture already established in the Action--Phase program: the physical phase is given by ϕ=S/ℏ\phi=S/\hbarϕ=S/ℏ; self-adjoint structural operators organize the dynamics on a discrete lattice; such operators admit interpretation as unitary filters via Cayley realization; and the discrete unitary evolution can be written exactly as propagation by a bilocal kernel W(x,y)W(x,y)W(x,y). The central question is to determine under what hypotheses this bilocal kernel can be represented as a function of a self-adjoint structural operator, W^=f(H^),H^=H^†, \hat W=f(\hat H), \qquad \hat H=\hat H^\dagger, W^=f(H^),H^=H^†, and how this structure implies the existence of an intrinsic spectral basis in which the propagation becomes diagonal. It is shown, step by step, that the spectral decomposition of H^\hat HH^ induces a corresponding decomposition of the kernel, W(x,y)=∑nf(λn) ϕn(x)ϕn∗(y), W(x,y)=\sum_n f(\lambda_n)\,\phi_n(x)\phi_n^*(y), W(x,y)=∑n​f(λn​)ϕn​(x)ϕn∗​(y), so that the unitary evolution begins to act multiplicatively on the spectral modes, Ψ~n(t+Δt)=f(λn)Ψ~n(t), \widetilde\Psi_n(t+\Delta t)=f(\lambda_n)\widetilde\Psi_n(t), Ψn​(t+Δt)=f(λn​)Ψn​(t), without the introduction of additional structures. In the homogeneous case, it is demonstrated that the eigenfunctions of the structural operator are discrete Fourier modes and that the continuous spectral parameter coincides with the usual wavenumber. In this regime, the spectral representation exactly reproduces the momentum sector of standard quantum mechanics. Outside this case, ``momentum'' is reinterpreted more generally as the spectral coordinate of the operator generating the propagation. The result of this stage is, therefore, conceptually precise: the position--momentum duality does not need to be postulated as an ontological duplication, but emerges as a duality between the nodal basis and the spectral basis of the same structural operator that governs the unitary propagation. The work does not intend, at this stage, to completely reconstruct the theory of canonical observables, nor to definitively resolve multiparticle systems or formulate a general covariant theory. Its role is to establish the minimum layer in which the spectral structure of propagation provides the mathematical origin of position--momentum duality, opening a controlled continuation program for these problems.
This working paper examines translational invariance as a minimal model of observer equivariance. Instead of treating translations only as displacements in physical space, it interprets them as abstract shifts between observer perspectives acting on a space of perspectives. The paper separates three layers: standard harmonic analysis, its observer-equivariance interpretation, and the additional physical calibration required to identify the dual spectral variable with momentum. Using a strongly continuous unitary representation of a locally compact abelian shift group, the note recalls the spectral description given by Pontryagin duality, Plancherel--Parseval, and, in the Euclidean case, the Heisenberg--Kennard uncertainty relation. The main interpretive point is that localization in perspective space and localization in the dual structural variable are subject to the usual Fourier trade-off. In this sense, uncertainty is read not merely as a feature of physical position and momentum, but as a structural constraint on perspective localization and the resolution of invariant modes. This version is a technical building block in a broader series of notes on observer equivariance, epistemic structural realism, and structural objectivity. The mathematical content is standard; the contribution is the reinterpretation of translational invariance as invariance under shifts of observer perspective.
Position and momentum of a particle can take any value in a continuous spectrum; these values are independent but their indeterminacies are correlated; momentum and position are mutually the generators of the transformations in each other. It is shown in a concise way, how all these features arise solely from their commutation relation [X,P]=iℏ[X,P]=i\hbar[X,P]=iℏ. The article is complete and self contained, adequate for didactic use.
Starting from square-integrable wave functions on a Lie group, we build an invertible Fourier transform mapping them on wave functions on the dual of the Lie algebra. This is a group-theoretic version of the map from position space to momentum space, with generally noncommuting momenta owing to the group structure. As a result, the multiplication of momentum-dependent functions involves star products, which makes the construction of noncommutative Fourier series much more involved than that of their commutative cousin. This is especially true when compact subgroups are present, in which case we carefully take into account quotients of the operator algebra, and the resulting normalization issues. We show that our formalism provides an isometry of Hilbert spaces, and use it to derive a noncommutative Poisson summation formula for any compact Lie group. This is a key preliminary for the computation of Wigner functions and path integrals for quantum systems on group manifolds.
Position and momentum of a particle can take any value in a continuous spectrum; these values are independent but their indeterminacies are correlated; momentum and position are mutually the generators of the transformations in each other. It is shown in a concise way, how all these features arise solely from their commutation relation [X,P]=ihbar[X,P]=i\\hbar[X,P]=ihbar. The article is complete and self contained, adequate for didactic use.