Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2608.14030

Periodicity-driven revision of the phase diagram of the generalized Baxter-Wu model with asymmetric complex couplings

Yuting Wang, Ye Ling, Haihong Li, Yuhai Liu

Published Aug 14, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The conventional self-dual lines of the generalized Baxter-Wu (GBW) model with asymmetric complex couplings are known to be $\sinh(2K)=\pm \cos(2ϕ)$, where $K$ and $ϕ$ are the real and imaginary parts of the coupling. We demonstrate that these lines are incomplete: the periodicity of the partition function, encoded in the cosine factor of the bundled Boltzmann weight, generates additional self-dual lines $\sinh(2K)=\pm \sin(2ϕ)$. Guided by the complete set of self-dual candidates, we perform Monte Carlo simulations using brute-force reweighting (Metropolis) and the Wang-Landau methods. Simulations indicate that the self-dual lines at the partition-function minima $ϕ_{\mathcal{Z}_{\min}}=(2n+1)π/8$ constitute a critical threshold. They are genuine critical boundaries for $|K| \ge \frac{1}{2}\operatorname{arsinh}(\cos(π/4)) \approx 0.32924$, while for smaller $|K|$ they are not. At $ϕ_{\mathcal{Z}_{\min}}$, the sign problem is most severe and finite-size scaling corrections are largest; the local peak observed below the phase boundary in the temperature scan is thus a finite-size artifact, not a genuine new phase. We further clarify the capability and limitations of the average sign and its derivatives for detecting phase transitions. In particular, the negative peak of the average sign at $ϕ_{\mathcal{Z}_{\min}}$ does not correspond to a genuine phase transition. We also evaluate the Wang-Landau method, which, despite formally circumventing the sign problem, still faces the exponential barrier.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2608.14030

Related papers

Probing the critical behavior of a sign-problematic model with Monte Carlo simulations

Ye Ling, Yuting Wang, Wenan Guo +1 more

The sign-problematic generalized Baxter-Wu (GBW) model with asymmetric complex couplings is mapped onto a one-dimensional quantum model. Utilizing the model's exactly known critical properties, we study the relation between the conventional and the modified average signs and the phase transitions in the GBW model. We find that the average sign develops a negative peak near the critical point, but it is not a unique indicator of phase transition, as similar features can appear in non-critical regions. While the average modified sign provides a viable probe for the phase transition, the practical effectiveness of this method is limited by the exponential scaling of computational cost with the system's volume. We propose that the universal properties of the original model can be investigated through simulating the related reference model, based on the universality assumption. Using finite-size scaling analysis based on Monte Carlo simulations, we confirm the validity of this method, which thereby provides a novel framework for investigating phase transitions in systems plagued by the sign problem.

arXiv:2511.09356•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Feb 19, 2026•0 citations

Monte Carlo study of the pure and dilute Baxter–Wu model

Nir Schreiber, Joan Adler

We studied the pure and dilute Baxter–Wu (BW) models using the Wang–Landau (WL) sampling method to calculate the density-of-states (DOS). We first used the exact result for the DOS of the Ising model to test our code. Then we calculated the DOS of the dilute Ising model to obtain a phase diagram, in good agreement with previous studies. We calculated the energy distribution, together with its first, second and fourth moments, to give the specific heat and the energy fourth order cumulant, better known as the Binder parameter, for the pure BW model. For small samples, the energy distribution displayed a doubly peaked shape, and finite size scaling analysis showed the expected reciprocal scaling of the positions of the peaks with L . The energy distribution yielded the expected BW α = 2/3 critical exponent for the specific heat. The Binder parameter minimum appeared to scale with lattice size L with an exponent θ B equal to the specific heat exponent. Its location (temperature) showed a large correction-to-scaling term θ 1 = 0.248 ± 0.025. For the dilute BW model we found a clear crossover to a single peak in the energy distribution even for small sizes and the expected α = 0 was recovered.

arXiv:cond-mat/0507394•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Aug 3, 2005•26 citations

Sign problem and criticality in world-line quantum Monte Carlo methods

Rubem Mondaini, Richard T. Scalettar

Discussions of the sign problem usually focus on its role as the primary limitation of the applicability of quantum Monte Carlo methods for reliably solving quantum many-body models. Its behavior as a function of spatial lattice size, doping, temperature, and interaction strengths has been carefully characterized within the determinant quantum Monte Carlo algorithm. Here, we consider the much less well-explored question of the temperature- and size-dependence of the sign problem in the world-line quantum Monte Carlo method. We review how, in this algorithm, even sampling the partition function of free fermions yields a sign problem, which we connect to non-analytic behavior in the corresponding reference model, hard-core bosons on a lattice. The latter exhibits a finite-temperature Kosterlitz-Thouless phase transition in 2D, and we show how this non-analytic behavior is imprinted on the average sign of the weights for the corresponding free fermion 2D tight-binding model. Our results thus show how phase-transition information can remain encoded in the sign problem even after direct sign sampling becomes impractical.

arXiv:2609.38740•Sep 30, 2026•1 citation

Worldsheet patching, 1-form symmetries, and Landau * phase transitions

Pablo Serna, A. M. Somoza, Adam Nahum

The analysis of phase transitions of gauge theories has relied heavily on simplifications that arise at the boundaries of phase diagrams, where certain excitations are forbidden. Taking $2+1$-dimensional ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ gauge theory as an example, the simplification can be visualized geometrically: on the phase diagram boundaries the partition function is an ensemble of closed membranes. More generally, however, the membranes have ``holes'' in them, representing worldlines of virtual anyon excitations. If the holes are of a finite size, then typically they do not affect the universality class, but they destroy microscopic (higher-form) symmetries and microscopic (string) observables. We demonstrate how these symmetries and observables can be restored using a ``membrane patching'' procedure, which maps the ensemble of membranes back to an ensemble of closed membranes. (This is closely related to the idea of gauge fixing in the ``minimal gauge,'' though not equivalent.) Membrane patching makes the emergence of higher symmetry concrete. Performing patching in a Monte Carlo simulation with an appropriate algorithm, we show that it gives access to numerically useful observables. For example, the confinement transition can be analyzed using a correlation function that is a power law at the critical point. We analyze the quasi-locality of the patching procedure and discuss what happens at a self-dual multicritical point in the gauge-Higgs model, where the lengthscale $\ensuremath{\ell}$ characterizing the holes diverges. The patching approach described here generalizes to many other statistical ensembles with a representation in terms of fluctuating membranes or loops, in various dimensions, and related constructions could be implemented in experiments on quantum devices.

arXiv:2403.04025•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 3, 2024•17 citations

Finite-size scaling and Monte Carlo simulations of first-order phase transitions

Jooyoung Lee, J. Michael Kosterlitz

We develop a detailed finite-size-scaling theory at a general, asymmetric, temperature-driven, strongly first-order phase transition in a system with periodic boundary conditions. We compute scaling functions for various cumulants of energy in the form U(L,t)=${\mathit{U}}_{0}$(${\mathit{tL}}^{\mathit{d}}$)+${\mathit{L}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}\mathit{d}}$${\mathit{U}}_{1}$(${\mathit{tL}}^{\mathit{d}}$) with t=1-${\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}$/T. In particular, we consider the specific heat and Binder's fourth cumulant and show this has a minimum value of 2/3-(${\mathit{e}}_{1}$/${\mathit{e}}_{2}$-${\mathit{e}}_{2}$/${\mathit{e}}_{1}$${)}^{2}$/12+O(${\mathit{L}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}\mathit{d}}$) at a temperature ${\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}^{(2)}$(L)-${\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}$=O(${\mathit{L}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}\mathit{d}}$). Various other pseudocritical temperatures corresponding to extrema of other cumulants are evaluated. We compare these theoretical predictions with extensive Monte Carlo simulations of the nominally strong first-order transitions in the eight- and ten-state Potts models in two dimensions for system sizes L\ensuremath{\le}50. The ten-state simulations agree with theory in all details in contrast to the eight-state data, and we give estimates for the bulk specific heats at ${\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}$ using all exactly known analytic results. A criterion is developed to estimate numerically whether or not system sizes used in a simulation of a first-order transition are in the finite-size-scaling regime.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Feb 1, 1991•315 citations

Critical behavior of the Baxter-Wu model with quenched impurities

M. A. Novotny, David Paul Landau

We have used an importance-sampling Monte Carlo technique to study the Baxter-Wu model with various fractions of the lattice sites occupied by random, quenched, nonmagnetic, site impurities. We found the system had long-time fluctuations which were caused by the creation and motion of domain boundaries. For this reason our study required the use of a large number of Monte Carlo steps per spin. The data were analyzed using finite-size scaling to extract the infinite-lattice critical exponents and critical amplitudes from the Monte Carlo simulation of finite lattices. This analysis of the data for the pure Baxter-Wu model yielded results which agreed well with exact results and series-expansion predictions. The addition of quenched site impurities caused a dramatic change in the critical behavior. The pure-lattice critical exponents ($\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{2}{3}$, $\ensuremath{\alpha}=\frac{2}{3}$, ${\ensuremath{\gamma}}_{m}\ensuremath{\simeq}1.17$) change upon the addition of only a few percent impurities to $\ensuremath{\nu}=1.00\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.07$, $\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\lesssim}0.0$, and ${\ensuremath{\gamma}}_{m}=1.95\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.08$. The phase diagram as a function of impurity concentration and an estimate for the infinite-lattice percolation limit are also given.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Aug 1, 1981•72 citations
The conventional self-dual lines of the generalized Baxter-Wu (GBW) model with asymmetric complex couplings are known to be sinh⁡(2K)=±cos⁡(2ϕ)\sinh(2K)=\pm \cos(2ϕ)sinh(2K)=±cos(2ϕ), where KKK and ϕϕϕ are the real and imaginary parts of the coupling. We demonstrate that these lines are incomplete: the periodicity of the partition function, encoded in the cosine factor of the bundled Boltzmann weight, generates additional self-dual lines sinh⁡(2K)=±sin⁡(2ϕ)\sinh(2K)=\pm \sin(2ϕ)sinh(2K)=±sin(2ϕ). Guided by the complete set of self-dual candidates, we perform Monte Carlo simulations using brute-force reweighting (Metropolis) and the Wang-Landau methods. Simulations indicate that the self-dual lines at the partition-function minima ϕZmin⁡=(2n+1)π/8ϕ_{\mathcal{Z}_{\min}}=(2n+1)π/8ϕZmin​​=(2n+1)π/8 constitute a critical threshold. They are genuine critical boundaries for ∣K∣≥12arsinh⁡(cos⁡(π/4))≈0.32924|K| \ge \frac{1}{2}\operatorname{arsinh}(\cos(π/4)) \approx 0.32924∣K∣≥21​arsinh(cos(π/4))≈0.32924, while for smaller ∣K∣|K|∣K∣ they are not. At ϕZmin⁡ϕ_{\mathcal{Z}_{\min}}ϕZmin​​, the sign problem is most severe and finite-size scaling corrections are largest; the local peak observed below the phase boundary in the temperature scan is thus a finite-size artifact, not a genuine new phase. We further clarify the capability and limitations of the average sign and its derivatives for detecting phase transitions. In particular, the negative peak of the average sign at ϕZmin⁡ϕ_{\mathcal{Z}_{\min}}ϕZmin​​ does not correspond to a genuine phase transition. We also evaluate the Wang-Landau method, which, despite formally circumventing the sign problem, still faces the exponential barrier.
The sign-problematic generalized Baxter-Wu (GBW) model with asymmetric complex couplings is mapped onto a one-dimensional quantum model. Utilizing the model's exactly known critical properties, we study the relation between the conventional and the modified average signs and the phase transitions in the GBW model. We find that the average sign develops a negative peak near the critical point, but it is not a unique indicator of phase transition, as similar features can appear in non-critical regions. While the average modified sign provides a viable probe for the phase transition, the practical effectiveness of this method is limited by the exponential scaling of computational cost with the system's volume. We propose that the universal properties of the original model can be investigated through simulating the related reference model, based on the universality assumption. Using finite-size scaling analysis based on Monte Carlo simulations, we confirm the validity of this method, which thereby provides a novel framework for investigating phase transitions in systems plagued by the sign problem.
We studied the pure and dilute Baxter–Wu (BW) models using the Wang–Landau (WL) sampling method to calculate the density-of-states (DOS). We first used the exact result for the DOS of the Ising model to test our code. Then we calculated the DOS of the dilute Ising model to obtain a phase diagram, in good agreement with previous studies. We calculated the energy distribution, together with its first, second and fourth moments, to give the specific heat and the energy fourth order cumulant, better known as the Binder parameter, for the pure BW model. For small samples, the energy distribution displayed a doubly peaked shape, and finite size scaling analysis showed the expected reciprocal scaling of the positions of the peaks with L . The energy distribution yielded the expected BW α = 2/3 critical exponent for the specific heat. The Binder parameter minimum appeared to scale with lattice size L with an exponent θ B equal to the specific heat exponent. Its location (temperature) showed a large correction-to-scaling term θ 1 = 0.248 ± 0.025. For the dilute BW model we found a clear crossover to a single peak in the energy distribution even for small sizes and the expected α = 0 was recovered.
Discussions of the sign problem usually focus on its role as the primary limitation of the applicability of quantum Monte Carlo methods for reliably solving quantum many-body models. Its behavior as a function of spatial lattice size, doping, temperature, and interaction strengths has been carefully characterized within the determinant quantum Monte Carlo algorithm. Here, we consider the much less well-explored question of the temperature- and size-dependence of the sign problem in the world-line quantum Monte Carlo method. We review how, in this algorithm, even sampling the partition function of free fermions yields a sign problem, which we connect to non-analytic behavior in the corresponding reference model, hard-core bosons on a lattice. The latter exhibits a finite-temperature Kosterlitz-Thouless phase transition in 2D, and we show how this non-analytic behavior is imprinted on the average sign of the weights for the corresponding free fermion 2D tight-binding model. Our results thus show how phase-transition information can remain encoded in the sign problem even after direct sign sampling becomes impractical.
The analysis of phase transitions of gauge theories has relied heavily on simplifications that arise at the boundaries of phase diagrams, where certain excitations are forbidden. Taking 2+12+12+1-dimensional Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ gauge theory as an example, the simplification can be visualized geometrically: on the phase diagram boundaries the partition function is an ensemble of closed membranes. More generally, however, the membranes have ``holes'' in them, representing worldlines of virtual anyon excitations. If the holes are of a finite size, then typically they do not affect the universality class, but they destroy microscopic (higher-form) symmetries and microscopic (string) observables. We demonstrate how these symmetries and observables can be restored using a ``membrane patching'' procedure, which maps the ensemble of membranes back to an ensemble of closed membranes. (This is closely related to the idea of gauge fixing in the ``minimal gauge,'' though not equivalent.) Membrane patching makes the emergence of higher symmetry concrete. Performing patching in a Monte Carlo simulation with an appropriate algorithm, we show that it gives access to numerically useful observables. For example, the confinement transition can be analyzed using a correlation function that is a power law at the critical point. We analyze the quasi-locality of the patching procedure and discuss what happens at a self-dual multicritical point in the gauge-Higgs model, where the lengthscale $\ensuremath{\ell}$ characterizing the holes diverges. The patching approach described here generalizes to many other statistical ensembles with a representation in terms of fluctuating membranes or loops, in various dimensions, and related constructions could be implemented in experiments on quantum devices.
We develop a detailed finite-size-scaling theory at a general, asymmetric, temperature-driven, strongly first-order phase transition in a system with periodic boundary conditions. We compute scaling functions for various cumulants of energy in the form U(L,t)=U0{\mathit{U}}_{0}U0​(tLd{\mathit{tL}}^{\mathit{d}}tLd)+${\mathit{L}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}\mathit{d}}$U1{\mathit{U}}_{1}U1​(tLd{\mathit{tL}}^{\mathit{d}}tLd) with t=1-Tc{\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}Tc​/T. In particular, we consider the specific heat and Binder's fourth cumulant and show this has a minimum value of 2/3-(e1{\mathit{e}}_{1}e1​/e2{\mathit{e}}_{2}e2​-e2{\mathit{e}}_{2}e2​/e1{\mathit{e}}_{1}e1​)2{)}^{2})2/12+O(${\mathit{L}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}\mathit{d}}$) at a temperature Tc(2){\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}^{(2)}Tc(2)​(L)-Tc{\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}Tc​=O(${\mathit{L}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}\mathit{d}}$). Various other pseudocritical temperatures corresponding to extrema of other cumulants are evaluated. We compare these theoretical predictions with extensive Monte Carlo simulations of the nominally strong first-order transitions in the eight- and ten-state Potts models in two dimensions for system sizes L\ensuremath{\le}50. The ten-state simulations agree with theory in all details in contrast to the eight-state data, and we give estimates for the bulk specific heats at Tc{\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}Tc​ using all exactly known analytic results. A criterion is developed to estimate numerically whether or not system sizes used in a simulation of a first-order transition are in the finite-size-scaling regime.
We have used an importance-sampling Monte Carlo technique to study the Baxter-Wu model with various fractions of the lattice sites occupied by random, quenched, nonmagnetic, site impurities. We found the system had long-time fluctuations which were caused by the creation and motion of domain boundaries. For this reason our study required the use of a large number of Monte Carlo steps per spin. The data were analyzed using finite-size scaling to extract the infinite-lattice critical exponents and critical amplitudes from the Monte Carlo simulation of finite lattices. This analysis of the data for the pure Baxter-Wu model yielded results which agreed well with exact results and series-expansion predictions. The addition of quenched site impurities caused a dramatic change in the critical behavior. The pure-lattice critical exponents ($\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{2}{3}$, $\ensuremath{\alpha}=\frac{2}{3}$, ${\ensuremath{\gamma}}_{m}\ensuremath{\simeq}1.17$) change upon the addition of only a few percent impurities to $\ensuremath{\nu}=1.00\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.07$, $\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\lesssim}0.0$, and ${\ensuremath{\gamma}}_{m}=1.95\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.08$. The phase diagram as a function of impurity concentration and an estimate for the infinite-lattice percolation limit are also given.