Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2403.04025 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Worldsheet patching, 1-form symmetries, and Landau * phase transitions

Pablo Serna, A. M. Somoza, Adam Nahum

Published Sep 3, 2024• 17 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The analysis of phase transitions of gauge theories has relied heavily on simplifications that arise at the boundaries of phase diagrams, where certain excitations are forbidden. Taking $2+1$-dimensional ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ gauge theory as an example, the simplification can be visualized geometrically: on the phase diagram boundaries the partition function is an ensemble of closed membranes. More generally, however, the membranes have ``holes'' in them, representing worldlines of virtual anyon excitations. If the holes are of a finite size, then typically they do not affect the universality class, but they destroy microscopic (higher-form) symmetries and microscopic (string) observables. We demonstrate how these symmetries and observables can be restored using a ``membrane patching'' procedure, which maps the ensemble of membranes back to an ensemble of closed membranes. (This is closely related to the idea of gauge fixing in the ``minimal gauge,'' though not equivalent.) Membrane patching makes the emergence of higher symmetry concrete. Performing patching in a Monte Carlo simulation with an appropriate algorithm, we show that it gives access to numerically useful observables. For example, the confinement transition can be analyzed using a correlation function that is a power law at the critical point. We analyze the quasi-locality of the patching procedure and discuss what happens at a self-dual multicritical point in the gauge-Higgs model, where the lengthscale $\ensuremath{\ell}$ characterizing the holes diverges. The patching approach described here generalizes to many other statistical ensembles with a representation in terms of fluctuating membranes or loops, in various dimensions, and related constructions could be implemented in experiments on quantum devices.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.110.115102

Related papers

Loop models with crossings

Adam Nahum, Pablo Serna, A. M. Somoza +1 more

The universal behavior of two-dimensional loop models can change dramatically when loops are allowed to cross. We study models with crossings both analytically and with extensive Monte Carlo simulations. Our main focus (the ``completely packed loop model with crossings'') is a simple generalization of well-known models that shows an interesting phase diagram with continuous phase transitions of a new kind. These separate the unusual ``Goldstone'' phase observed previously from phases with short loops. Using mappings to ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ lattice gauge theory, we show that the continuum description of the model is a replica limit of the $\ensuremath{\sigma}$ model on real projective space (${\mathbb{RP}}^{n\ensuremath{-}1}$). This field theory sustains ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ point defects, which proliferate at the transition. In addition to studying the new critical points, we characterize the universal properties of the Goldstone phase in detail, comparing renormalization group (RG) calculations with numerical data on systems of linear size up to $L={10}^{6}$ at loop fugacity $n=1$. (Very large sizes are necessary because of the logarithmic form of correlation functions and other observables.) The model is relevant to polymers on the verge of collapse, and a particular point in parameter space maps to self-avoiding trails at their $\ensuremath{\Theta}$ point; we use the RG treatment of a perturbed $\ensuremath{\sigma}$ model to resolve some perplexing features in the previous literature on trails. Finally, one of the phase transitions considered here is a close analog of those in disordered electronic systems---specifically, Anderson metal-insulator transitions---and provides a simpler context in which to study the properties of these poorly understood (central-charge-zero) critical points.

arXiv:1303.2342•Physical Review B•May 28, 2013•61 citations

Self-dual $S_3$ gauge theory in 2+1d: lattice model and topological phase transitions

Da-Chuan Lu, Chong Wang, Ashvin Vishwanath

Electric-magnetic self-duality of the $\mathbb{Z}_2$ gauge theory, realized microscopically as a half-lattice-translation exchanging electric charge and magnetic flux, has been an influential example of a duality symmetry with an exact lattice realization. We construct the first non-Abelian generalization of this construction: a lattice model of the $S_3$ quantum double $\mathcal{D}(S_3)$ on a tensor product Hilbert space in which the $\mathbb{Z}^{\mathrm{em}}_2$ anyon-permutation symmetry, exchanging the non-Abelian chargeon $C$ and fluxon $F$, is realized via lattice translation. Consequently we find that the zigzag boundary termination of the model realizes, without fine-tuning, a gapless critical edge state described by the tetracritical Ising CFT. The bulk admits three independent $\mathbb{Z}_2^{\mathrm{em}}$-preserving bosonic perturbations, driving $\mathcal{D}(S_3)$ into distinct gapped phases. We analyze these transitions by three independent methods: category-theoretic anyon condensation, microscopic lattice Hamiltonians, and Chern-Simons-Higgs theory, which all agree, yielding a unified picture. These examples motivate a minimal-condensation principle: proliferating a bosonic anyon generically drives condensation of a minimal condensable algebra containing it, with symmetry-related condensates appearing as degenerate vacua that spontaneously break the anyon-permutation symmetry. Our model construction extends to an infinite family of self-dual dihedral quantum doubles $\mathcal{D}(D_{2n})$. Notably, each model is sign-problem-free, opening the door to large-scale numerical exploration of the phases of non-Abelian Chern-Simons-Higgs theories.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2608.05294•Aug 7, 2026•7 citations

Boundary criticality via gauging finite subgroups: a case study on the clock model

Su, Lei

Gauging a finite Abelian normal subgroup $Γ$ of a nonanomalous 0-form symmetry $G$ of a theory in $(d+1)$D spacetime can yield an unconventional critical point if the original theory has a continuous transition where $Γ$ is completely spontaneously broken and if $G$ is a nontrivial extension of $G/Γ$ by $Γ$. The gauged theory has symmetry $G/Γ\times \hatΓ^{(d-1)}$, where $\hatΓ^{(d-1)}$ is the $(d-1)$-form dual symmetry of $Γ$, and a 't Hooft anomaly between them. Thus it can be viewed as a boundary of a topological phase protected by $G/Γ\times \hatΓ^{(d-1)}$. The ordinary critical point, upon gauging, is mapped to a deconfined quantum critical point between two ordinary symmetry-breaking phases ($d =1$) or an unconventional quantum critical point between an ordinary symmetry-breaking phase and a topologically ordered phase ($d\ge 2$) associated with $G/Γ$ and $\hatΓ^{(d-1)}$, respectively. Order parameters and disorder parameters, before and after gauging, can be directly related. As a concrete example, we gauge the $\mathbb{Z}_2$ subgroup of $\mathbb{Z}_4$ symmetry of a 4-state clock model on a 1D lattice and a 2D square lattice. Since the symmetry of the clock model contains $D_8$, the dihedral group of order 8, we also analyze the anomaly structure which is similar to that in the compactified $SU(2)$ gauge theory with $θ=π$ in $(3+1)$D and its mixed gauge theory. The general case is also discussed.

arXiv:2306.02976•Jun 5, 2023•13 citations

Topological holography: Towards a unification of Landau and beyond-Landau physics

Heidar Moradi, Seyed Faroogh Moosavian, Apoorv Tiwari

We outline a holographic framework that attempts to unify Landau and beyond-Landau paradigms of quantum phases and phase transitions. Leveraging a modern understanding of symmetries as topological defects/operators, the framework uses a topological order to organize the space of quantum systems with a global symmetry in one lower dimension. The global symmetry naturally serves as an input for the topological order. In particular, we holographically construct a String Operator Algebra (SOA) which is the building block of symmetric quantum systems with a given symmetry G in one lower dimension. This exposes a vast web of dualities which act on the space of G-symmetric quantum systems. The SOA facilitates the classification of gapped phases as well as their corresponding order parameters and fundamental excitations, while dualities help to navigate and predict various corners of phase diagrams and analytically compute universality classes of phase transitions. A novelty of the approach is that it treats conventional Landau and unconventional topological phase transitions on an equal footing, thereby providing a holographic unification of these seemingly-disparate domains of understanding. We uncover a new feature of gapped phases and their multi-critical points, which we dub fusion structure, that encodes information about which phases and transitions can be dual to each other. Furthermore, we discover that self-dual systems typically posses emergent non-invertible, i.e., beyond group-like symmetries. We apply these ideas to 1+1d 1 + 1 d quantum spin chains with finite Abelian group symmetry, using topologically-ordered systems in 2+1d 2 + 1 d . We predict the phase diagrams of various concrete spin models, and analytically compute the full conformal spectra of non-trivial quantum phase transitions, which we then verify numerically.

arXiv:2207.10712•SciPost Physics Core•Oct 16, 2023•154 citations

Codimension-2 defects and higher symmetries in (3+1)D topological phases

Maissam Barkeshli, Yu-An Chen, Sheng-Jie Huang +3 more

(3+1)D topological phases of matter can host a broad class of non-trivial topological defects of codimension-1, 2, and 3, of which the well-known point charges and flux loops are special cases. The complete algebraic structure of these defects defines a higher category, and can be viewed as an emergent higher symmetry. This plays a crucial role both in the classification of phases of matter and the possible fault-tolerant logical operations in topological quantum error-correcting codes. In this paper, we study several examples of such higher codimension defects from distinct perspectives. We mainly study a class of invertible codimension-2 topological defects, which we refer to as twist strings. We provide a number of general constructions for twist strings, in terms of gauging lower dimensional invertible phases, layer constructions, and condensation defects. We study some special examples in the context of \mathbb{Z}_2 ℤ 2 gauge theory with fermionic charges, in \mathbb{Z}_2 \times \mathbb{Z}_2 ℤ 2 × ℤ 2 gauge theory with bosonic charges, and also in non-Abelian discrete gauge theories based on dihedral ( D_n D n ) and alternating ( A_6 A 6 ) groups. The intersection between twist strings and Abelian flux loops sources Abelian point charges, which defines an H^4 H 4 cohomology class that characterizes part of an underlying 3-group symmetry of the topological order. The equations involving background gauge fields for the 3-group symmetry have been explicitly written down for various cases. We also study examples of twist strings interacting with non-Abelian flux loops (defining part of a non-invertible higher symmetry), examples of non-invertible codimension-2 defects, and examples of the interplay of codimension-2 defects with codimension-1 defects. We also find an example of geometric, not fully topological, twist strings in (3+1)D A_6 A 6 gauge theory.

arXiv:2208.07367•SciPost Physics•Apr 11, 2023•83 citations

Higher-form symmetry breaking at Ising transitions

Jiarui Zhao, Zheng Yan, Meng Cheng +1 more

In recent years, new phases of matter that are beyond the Landau paradigm of symmetry breaking have been accumulating, and to catch up with this fast development, new notions of global symmetry are introduced. Among them, the higher-form symmetry, whose symmetry charges are spatially extended, can be used to describe topologically ordered phases as the spontaneous breaking of the symmetry, and consequently unify the unconventional and conventional phases under the same conceptual framework. However, such conceptual tools have not been put into quantitative tests except for certain solvable models, therefore limiting their usage in the more generic quantum many-body systems. In this work, we study ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ higher-form symmetry in a quantum Ising model, which is dual to the global (zero-form) Ising symmetry. We compute the expectation value of the Ising disorder operator, which is a nonlocal order parameter for the higher-form symmetry, analytically in free scalar theories and through unbiased quantum Monte Carlo simulations for the interacting fixed point in $(2+1)d$. From the scaling form of this extended object, we confirm that the higher-form symmetry is indeed spontaneously broken inside the paramagnetic, or quantum disordered phase (in the Landau sense), but remains symmetric in the ferromagnetic or ordered phase. At the Ising critical point, we find that the disorder operator also obeys a ``perimeter'' law scaling with possibly multiplicative power-law corrections. We discuss examples where both the global zero-form symmetry and the dual higher-form symmetry are preserved, in systems with a codimension-1 manifold of gapless points in momentum space. These results provide nontrivial working examples of higher-form symmetry operators, including the direct computation of one-form order parameter in an interacting conformal field theory, and open the avenue for their generic implementation in quantum many-body systems.

arXiv:2011.12543•Physical Review Research•Jul 6, 2021•69 citations
The analysis of phase transitions of gauge theories has relied heavily on simplifications that arise at the boundaries of phase diagrams, where certain excitations are forbidden. Taking 2+12+12+1-dimensional Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ gauge theory as an example, the simplification can be visualized geometrically: on the phase diagram boundaries the partition function is an ensemble of closed membranes. More generally, however, the membranes have holes'' in them, representing worldlines of virtual anyon excitations. If the holes are of a finite size, then typically they do not affect the universality class, but they destroy microscopic (higher-form) symmetries and microscopic (string) observables. We demonstrate how these symmetries and observables can be restored using a membrane patching'' procedure, which maps the ensemble of membranes back to an ensemble of closed membranes. (This is closely related to the idea of gauge fixing in the ``minimal gauge,'' though not equivalent.) Membrane patching makes the emergence of higher symmetry concrete. Performing patching in a Monte Carlo simulation with an appropriate algorithm, we show that it gives access to numerically useful observables. For example, the confinement transition can be analyzed using a correlation function that is a power law at the critical point. We analyze the quasi-locality of the patching procedure and discuss what happens at a self-dual multicritical point in the gauge-Higgs model, where the lengthscale \ensuremathℓ\ensuremath{\ell}\ensuremathℓ characterizing the holes diverges. The patching approach described here generalizes to many other statistical ensembles with a representation in terms of fluctuating membranes or loops, in various dimensions, and related constructions could be implemented in experiments on quantum devices.
The universal behavior of two-dimensional loop models can change dramatically when loops are allowed to cross. We study models with crossings both analytically and with extensive Monte Carlo simulations. Our main focus (the ``completely packed loop model with crossings'') is a simple generalization of well-known models that shows an interesting phase diagram with continuous phase transitions of a new kind. These separate the unusual ``Goldstone'' phase observed previously from phases with short loops. Using mappings to Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ lattice gauge theory, we show that the continuum description of the model is a replica limit of the $\ensuremath{\sigma}$ model on real projective space (${\mathbb{RP}}^{n\ensuremath{-}1}$). This field theory sustains Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ point defects, which proliferate at the transition. In addition to studying the new critical points, we characterize the universal properties of the Goldstone phase in detail, comparing renormalization group (RG) calculations with numerical data on systems of linear size up to L=106L={10}^{6}L=106 at loop fugacity n=1n=1n=1. (Very large sizes are necessary because of the logarithmic form of correlation functions and other observables.) The model is relevant to polymers on the verge of collapse, and a particular point in parameter space maps to self-avoiding trails at their $\ensuremath{\Theta}$ point; we use the RG treatment of a perturbed $\ensuremath{\sigma}$ model to resolve some perplexing features in the previous literature on trails. Finally, one of the phase transitions considered here is a close analog of those in disordered electronic systems---specifically, Anderson metal-insulator transitions---and provides a simpler context in which to study the properties of these poorly understood (central-charge-zero) critical points.
Self-dual S3S_3S3​ gauge theory in 2+1d: lattice model and topological phase transitions
Electric-magnetic self-duality of the Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​ gauge theory, realized microscopically as a half-lattice-translation exchanging electric charge and magnetic flux, has been an influential example of a duality symmetry with an exact lattice realization. We construct the first non-Abelian generalization of this construction: a lattice model of the S3S_3S3​ quantum double D(S3)\mathcal{D}(S_3)D(S3​) on a tensor product Hilbert space in which the Z2em\mathbb{Z}^{\mathrm{em}}_2Z2em​ anyon-permutation symmetry, exchanging the non-Abelian chargeon CCC and fluxon FFF, is realized via lattice translation. Consequently we find that the zigzag boundary termination of the model realizes, without fine-tuning, a gapless critical edge state described by the tetracritical Ising CFT. The bulk admits three independent Z2em\mathbb{Z}_2^{\mathrm{em}}Z2em​-preserving bosonic perturbations, driving D(S3)\mathcal{D}(S_3)D(S3​) into distinct gapped phases. We analyze these transitions by three independent methods: category-theoretic anyon condensation, microscopic lattice Hamiltonians, and Chern-Simons-Higgs theory, which all agree, yielding a unified picture. These examples motivate a minimal-condensation principle: proliferating a bosonic anyon generically drives condensation of a minimal condensable algebra containing it, with symmetry-related condensates appearing as degenerate vacua that spontaneously break the anyon-permutation symmetry. Our model construction extends to an infinite family of self-dual dihedral quantum doubles D(D2n)\mathcal{D}(D_{2n})D(D2n​). Notably, each model is sign-problem-free, opening the door to large-scale numerical exploration of the phases of non-Abelian Chern-Simons-Higgs theories.
Gauging a finite Abelian normal subgroup ΓΓΓ of a nonanomalous 0-form symmetry GGG of a theory in (d+1)(d+1)(d+1)D spacetime can yield an unconventional critical point if the original theory has a continuous transition where ΓΓΓ is completely spontaneously broken and if GGG is a nontrivial extension of G/ΓG/ΓG/Γ by ΓΓΓ. The gauged theory has symmetry G/Γ×Γ^(d−1)G/Γ\times \hatΓ^{(d-1)}G/Γ×Γ^(d−1), where Γ^(d−1)\hatΓ^{(d-1)}Γ^(d−1) is the (d−1)(d-1)(d−1)-form dual symmetry of ΓΓΓ, and a 't Hooft anomaly between them. Thus it can be viewed as a boundary of a topological phase protected by G/Γ×Γ^(d−1)G/Γ\times \hatΓ^{(d-1)}G/Γ×Γ^(d−1). The ordinary critical point, upon gauging, is mapped to a deconfined quantum critical point between two ordinary symmetry-breaking phases (d=1d =1d=1) or an unconventional quantum critical point between an ordinary symmetry-breaking phase and a topologically ordered phase (d≥2d\ge 2d≥2) associated with G/ΓG/ΓG/Γ and Γ^(d−1)\hatΓ^{(d-1)}Γ^(d−1), respectively. Order parameters and disorder parameters, before and after gauging, can be directly related. As a concrete example, we gauge the Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​ subgroup of Z4\mathbb{Z}_4Z4​ symmetry of a 4-state clock model on a 1D lattice and a 2D square lattice. Since the symmetry of the clock model contains D8D_8D8​, the dihedral group of order 8, we also analyze the anomaly structure which is similar to that in the compactified SU(2)SU(2)SU(2) gauge theory with θ=πθ=πθ=π in (3+1)(3+1)(3+1)D and its mixed gauge theory. The general case is also discussed.
We outline a holographic framework that attempts to unify Landau and beyond-Landau paradigms of quantum phases and phase transitions. Leveraging a modern understanding of symmetries as topological defects/operators, the framework uses a topological order to organize the space of quantum systems with a global symmetry in one lower dimension. The global symmetry naturally serves as an input for the topological order. In particular, we holographically construct a String Operator Algebra (SOA) which is the building block of symmetric quantum systems with a given symmetry G in one lower dimension. This exposes a vast web of dualities which act on the space of G-symmetric quantum systems. The SOA facilitates the classification of gapped phases as well as their corresponding order parameters and fundamental excitations, while dualities help to navigate and predict various corners of phase diagrams and analytically compute universality classes of phase transitions. A novelty of the approach is that it treats conventional Landau and unconventional topological phase transitions on an equal footing, thereby providing a holographic unification of these seemingly-disparate domains of understanding. We uncover a new feature of gapped phases and their multi-critical points, which we dub fusion structure, that encodes information about which phases and transitions can be dual to each other. Furthermore, we discover that self-dual systems typically posses emergent non-invertible, i.e., beyond group-like symmetries. We apply these ideas to 1+1d 1 + 1 d quantum spin chains with finite Abelian group symmetry, using topologically-ordered systems in 2+1d 2 + 1 d . We predict the phase diagrams of various concrete spin models, and analytically compute the full conformal spectra of non-trivial quantum phase transitions, which we then verify numerically.
(3+1)D topological phases of matter can host a broad class of non-trivial topological defects of codimension-1, 2, and 3, of which the well-known point charges and flux loops are special cases. The complete algebraic structure of these defects defines a higher category, and can be viewed as an emergent higher symmetry. This plays a crucial role both in the classification of phases of matter and the possible fault-tolerant logical operations in topological quantum error-correcting codes. In this paper, we study several examples of such higher codimension defects from distinct perspectives. We mainly study a class of invertible codimension-2 topological defects, which we refer to as twist strings. We provide a number of general constructions for twist strings, in terms of gauging lower dimensional invertible phases, layer constructions, and condensation defects. We study some special examples in the context of \mathbb{Z}_2 ℤ 2 gauge theory with fermionic charges, in \mathbb{Z}_2 \times \mathbb{Z}_2 ℤ 2 × ℤ 2 gauge theory with bosonic charges, and also in non-Abelian discrete gauge theories based on dihedral ( D_n D n ) and alternating ( A_6 A 6 ) groups. The intersection between twist strings and Abelian flux loops sources Abelian point charges, which defines an H^4 H 4 cohomology class that characterizes part of an underlying 3-group symmetry of the topological order. The equations involving background gauge fields for the 3-group symmetry have been explicitly written down for various cases. We also study examples of twist strings interacting with non-Abelian flux loops (defining part of a non-invertible higher symmetry), examples of non-invertible codimension-2 defects, and examples of the interplay of codimension-2 defects with codimension-1 defects. We also find an example of geometric, not fully topological, twist strings in (3+1)D A_6 A 6 gauge theory.
In recent years, new phases of matter that are beyond the Landau paradigm of symmetry breaking have been accumulating, and to catch up with this fast development, new notions of global symmetry are introduced. Among them, the higher-form symmetry, whose symmetry charges are spatially extended, can be used to describe topologically ordered phases as the spontaneous breaking of the symmetry, and consequently unify the unconventional and conventional phases under the same conceptual framework. However, such conceptual tools have not been put into quantitative tests except for certain solvable models, therefore limiting their usage in the more generic quantum many-body systems. In this work, we study Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ higher-form symmetry in a quantum Ising model, which is dual to the global (zero-form) Ising symmetry. We compute the expectation value of the Ising disorder operator, which is a nonlocal order parameter for the higher-form symmetry, analytically in free scalar theories and through unbiased quantum Monte Carlo simulations for the interacting fixed point in (2+1)d(2+1)d(2+1)d. From the scaling form of this extended object, we confirm that the higher-form symmetry is indeed spontaneously broken inside the paramagnetic, or quantum disordered phase (in the Landau sense), but remains symmetric in the ferromagnetic or ordered phase. At the Ising critical point, we find that the disorder operator also obeys a ``perimeter'' law scaling with possibly multiplicative power-law corrections. We discuss examples where both the global zero-form symmetry and the dual higher-form symmetry are preserved, in systems with a codimension-1 manifold of gapless points in momentum space. These results provide nontrivial working examples of higher-form symmetry operators, including the direct computation of one-form order parameter in an interacting conformal field theory, and open the avenue for their generic implementation in quantum many-body systems.