Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2608.10695

Helium-like ions $(Z,e,e)$ in Lagrange Mesh method, interpolating the highly-accurate energy spectra vs. Z

H Olivares-Pilon, JC Lopez-Vieyra, AV Turbiner

quant-phmath-phphysics.atom-phSubmitted Aug 11, 2026• Announced Aug 12, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Two alternative approaches for studying Helium-like atomic ions in non-relativistic quantum mechanics are proposed: (I) a numerical approach, based on the Lagrange-mesh method which can easily reach up to 14-15 significant digits in the energy spectrum for any nuclear charge $Z$ with modest CPU time in single processor mode and (II) a highly-accurate, few-parametric interpolation formula for the energies {\it vs.} $Z$. The interpolation formula of general nature is proposed, it can be applied to the energies of any excited state of the helium-like sequence. It is based on matching the $1/Z$-expansion at large $Z$ and the Puiseux expansion with integer and half-integer powers around the so-called second critical charge $Z_B$, introduced by F and D Stillinger (1969, 1974), confirmed by the present authors in 2019 for the ground state $1^1 S$, then revisited here, and extended to the excited states in the present work. For example for the first two spin-singlet $1^1 S$, $2^1 S$ and the first two spin-triplet $2^3 S$, $3^3 S$ states this interpolation formula with nine free parameters can reach an accuracy of 10-14 significant digits (s.d.) in the energies for any physically-relevant nuclear charge $Z$, giving absolute accuracy at large $Z$. Many results are obtained for the first time.

Comments
23 pages, 1 figure, 6 tables

Related papers

Applications of B-spline method in precise calculation of structure of few-electron atoms

Yong-Hui Zhang, Ting-Yun Shi, Liyan TANG

The precise spectra of few-electron atoms plays a pivotal role in advancing fundamental physics, including the verification of quantum electrodynamics (QED) theory, the determination of the fine-structure constants, and the exploration of nuclear properties. With the rapid development of precision measurement techniques, the demand for atomic structure data has evolved from simply confirming existence to pursuing unprecedented accuracy. To meet the growing needs for precision spectroscopy experiments, we develop a series of high-precision theoretical methods based on B-spline basis sets, such as the non-relativistic configuration interaction (B-NRCI) method, the correlated B-spline basis functions (C-BSBFs) method, and the relativistic configuration interaction (B-RCI) method. These methods use the unique properties of B-spline functions, such as locality, completeness, and numerical stability, to accurately solve the Schrödinger and Dirac equations for few-electron atoms. Our methods yield significant results, particularly for helium and helium-like ions. Using these methods, we obtain accurate energies, polarizabilities, tune-out wavelengths, and magic wavelengths. Specifically, we achieve high-precision measurements of the energy spectra of helium, providing vital theoretical support for conducting related experimental researches. Additionally, we make high-precision theoretical predictions of tune-out wavelengths, paving the way for new tests of QED theory. Furthermore, we propose effective theoretical schemes to suppress Stark shifts, thereby facilitating high-precision spectroscopy experiments of helium The B-spline-basis methods reviewed in this paper prove exceptionally effective in high-precision calculations for few-electron atoms. These methods not only provide crucial theoretical support for precision spectroscopy experiments but also pave the new way for testing QED. Their ability to handle large-scale configuration interactions and incorporate relativistic and QED corrections makes them versatile tools for advancing atomic physics research. In the future, the high-precision theoretical methods based on B-spline basis sets are expected to be extended to cutting-edge fields, such as quantum state manipulation, determination of nuclear structure properties, formation of ultracold molecules, and exploration of new physics, thus continuously promoting the progress of precision measurement physics.

Acta Physica Sinica•Jan 1, 2025•1 citation

Ground states of H, He,…, Ne, and their singly positive ions in strong magnetic fields: The high-field regime

Mikhail Ivanov, Peter Schmelcher

The electronic structure of the ground state and some excited states of neutral atoms with the nuclear charge numbers $1<~Z<~10$ and their singly positive ions are investigated by means of our two-dimensional mesh Hartree-Fock method for strong magnetic fields $0.5<~\ensuremath{\gamma}<~10000.$ For $\ensuremath{\gamma}=10000$ the ground-state configurations of all the atoms and ions considered are given by fully spin-polarized configurations of single-electron orbitals with magnetic quantum numbers ranging from $m=0$ to $m=\ensuremath{-}N+1,$ where N is the number of the electrons. Focusing on the fully spin-polarized situation, we provide critical values of the magnetic-field strength for which crossovers with respect to the spatial symmetries of the ground state take place. It is found that the neutral atoms and singly charged positive ions with $2<~Z<~5$ have one fully spin-polarized ground-state configuration, whereas for $6<~Z<~10$ one intermediate fully spin-polarized configuration with an orbital of ${2p}_{0}$ type occurs.

arXiv:physics/9910017•Physical Review A•Jan 11, 2000•59 citations

Two-electron atoms, ions, and molecules

Hallstein Høgaasen, Jean-Marc Richard, P. Sorba

The quantum mechanics of two-electron systems is reviewed, starting with the ground state of the helium atom and heliumlike ions with central charge Z. The case of Z≥2 is rather straightforward. In contrast, for negative hydrogen ion with Z=1, the stability of H− cannot be achieved using a product of individual electron wavefunctions and requires explicit account of the anticorrelation among the two electrons. The wavefunction proposed by Chandrasekhar is revisited, where the permutation symmetry is first broken and then restored by a counterterm. More difficult problems can be studied using the same strategy such as the stability of hydrogenlike ions for any value of the proton-to-electron mass ratio M/m, the energy of the lowest spin-triplet state of helium and heliumlike ions, and the stability of the doubly excited hydrogen ion with unnatural parity. The positronium molecule, which was predicted years ago and discovered recently, can also be shown to be stable against spontaneous dissociation. Emphasis is placed on symmetry breaking, which can either spoil or improve the stability.

arXiv:0907.2614•American Journal of Physics•Dec 14, 2009•28 citations

Ground-State Energy Solutions of the Lithium Atom: Zeroth-, First-, and Second-Order Perturbation Theory and the Variational Method

Afraa Mahboubi, Büşra Gökçe Zolmaz, Devrim Karayer +3 more

In this work, the ground-state energy of the lithium atom is systematically investigated using both time-independent perturbation theory and the variational method to provide a comprehensive pedagogical analysis of many-body atomic systems. The unperturbed Hamiltonian is initially constructed by neglecting electron-electron interactions, treating the system as three independent hydrogen-like electrons to yield a zeroth-order energy baseline of -275.51 eV. The antisymmetric fermionic nature of the exact wave function is rigorously enforced through the Slater determinant formalism. First-order perturbation theory is applied to evaluate static inter-electronic repulsion using exact Coulomb and exchange integrals, refining the energy state to -192.01 eV. To account for dynamical electronic correlation, second-order perturbation theory is computed numerically for virtual single-electron s-orbital transitions, leading to a total perturbative energy of -196.36 eV. A brief discussion of two-electron excitations is also included to encapsulate further physical realism within the framework. Furthermore, a non-orthogonal two-parameter variational approach is employed to model the shell-specific shielding effect. By optimizing the effective nuclear charges, the variational method establishes a superior upper bound energy of -201.187 eV. The results of both methods are comprehensively contrasted against each other and the reference baseline to provide critical insights into the nature of electron correlation and screening in multi-electron atoms.

quant-pharXiv:2606.24238•Jun 24, 2026

Calculation of the wave functions of the ground and weakly excited states of helium II

Maksim Tomchenko

The wave functions of the ground (Ψ 0 ) and the first excited (Ψ k ) states of He II in the second-order approximation, i.e., up to the first two corrections to the corresponding solutions for a weakly nonideal Bose gas, are determined by the collective variable method, which was proposed by Bogolyubov and Zubarev and developed in the studies by Yukhnovskii and Vakarchuk. The functions Ψ 0 and Ψ k = ψ k Ψ 0 are determined as the eigenfunctions of the N -particle Schrödinger equation from a system of coupled equations for Ψ 0 , Ψ k , and the quasiparticle spectrum E ( k ) of helium II. The results consist in the following: (1) these equations are solved numerically for a higher order approximation compared with those investigated earlier (the first-order approximation), and (2) Ψ 0 and ψ k are derived from a model potential of interaction between He 4 atoms (rather than from the structure factor as earlier) in which the potential barrier is joined with the attractive potential found from experiment. The height V 0 of the potential barrier is a free parameter. Except for V 0 , the model does not have any free parameters or functions. The calculated values of the structure factor, the ground-state energy E 0 , and the quasiparticle spectrum E ( k ) of He II are in agreement with the experimental values for V 0 ≈ 100 K. The second-order correction to the logarithm of Ψ 0 significantly affects the value of E 0 and provides the asymptotics E ( k → 0) = ck , while the second-order correction to ψ k slightly affects the E ( k ). The second-order corrections to Ψ 0 and ψ k have a smaller effect on the results compared with the first-order corrections, whereby the theory is in agreement with experiment; therefore, one may assume that the truncated Ψ 0 and ψ k well describe the microstructure of He II. Thus, the series for Ψ 0 and Ψ k can be truncated in spite of the fact that the expansion parameter is not very small (∼1/2).

Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics•Jan 1, 2006•3 citations

Rigorous Lower Bounds for Atomic and Ionic Ground-State Energies

Michael Hofacker

We establish a new iterative method for computing rigorous lower bounds for the ground-state energies of all atoms and ions. The accuracy of the resulting bounds depends on two ingredients: the quality of the initial energy estimate and the quality of the used upper bound for the maximum number of bound electrons, $N_c(Z)$, as a function of the nuclear charge $Z>0$. In particular, this new method allows us to establish the explicit lower bound $E(N,Z) \geq -0.8710\,N^{1/3}Z^2$ for the ground-state energy $E(N,Z)$ of the atom/ion with $N \in \mathbb{N}$ electrons and nuclear charge $Z \in (0,N]$, thereby considerably improving the best known constant $A=(3/2)^{1/3} \approx 1.1447$ in the estimate $E(N,Z) \geq -A\,N^{1/3}Z^2$ for $0 < Z \leq N$ and coming much closer to the best possible constant given by the Thomas-Fermi asymptotics $\lim_{N \to \infty} |E(N,N)|N^{-7/3}= -E_{\text{TF}}(1)\approx 0.7687$ derived in Adv. Math., 23(1) by Lieb and Simon. To demonstrate the potential and the limits of our method, we also compute explicit lower bounds for the ground-state energies $E(N,N)$ of all atoms with $2 \leq N \leq 86$ and we compare them with the bounds obtained in J. Chem. Phys., 62(8) by Hertel, Lieb, Thirring and the bounds obtained by Seco in his dissertation. Finally, we also provide a uniqueness result for the expectation values of the kinetic, potential and interaction energies on the ground-state space.

math-phCross-listedarXiv:2610.34480•Oct 27, 2026
Helium-like ions (Z,e,e)(Z,e,e)(Z,e,e) in Lagrange Mesh method, interpolating the highly-accurate energy spectra vs. Z
Two alternative approaches for studying Helium-like atomic ions in non-relativistic quantum mechanics are proposed: (I) a numerical approach, based on the Lagrange-mesh method which can easily reach up to 14-15 significant digits in the energy spectrum for any nuclear charge ZZZ with modest CPU time in single processor mode and (II) a highly-accurate, few-parametric interpolation formula for the energies {\it vs.} ZZZ. The interpolation formula of general nature is proposed, it can be applied to the energies of any excited state of the helium-like sequence. It is based on matching the 1/Z1/Z1/Z-expansion at large ZZZ and the Puiseux expansion with integer and half-integer powers around the so-called second critical charge ZBZ_BZB​, introduced by F and D Stillinger (1969, 1974), confirmed by the present authors in 2019 for the ground state 11S1^1 S11S, then revisited here, and extended to the excited states in the present work. For example for the first two spin-singlet 11S1^1 S11S, 21S2^1 S21S and the first two spin-triplet 23S2^3 S23S, 33S3^3 S33S states this interpolation formula with nine free parameters can reach an accuracy of 10-14 significant digits (s.d.) in the energies for any physically-relevant nuclear charge ZZZ, giving absolute accuracy at large ZZZ. Many results are obtained for the first time.
The precise spectra of few-electron atoms plays a pivotal role in advancing fundamental physics, including the verification of quantum electrodynamics (QED) theory, the determination of the fine-structure constants, and the exploration of nuclear properties. With the rapid development of precision measurement techniques, the demand for atomic structure data has evolved from simply confirming existence to pursuing unprecedented accuracy. To meet the growing needs for precision spectroscopy experiments, we develop a series of high-precision theoretical methods based on B-spline basis sets, such as the non-relativistic configuration interaction (B-NRCI) method, the correlated B-spline basis functions (C-BSBFs) method, and the relativistic configuration interaction (B-RCI) method. These methods use the unique properties of B-spline functions, such as locality, completeness, and numerical stability, to accurately solve the Schrödinger and Dirac equations for few-electron atoms. Our methods yield significant results, particularly for helium and helium-like ions. Using these methods, we obtain accurate energies, polarizabilities, tune-out wavelengths, and magic wavelengths. Specifically, we achieve high-precision measurements of the energy spectra of helium, providing vital theoretical support for conducting related experimental researches. Additionally, we make high-precision theoretical predictions of tune-out wavelengths, paving the way for new tests of QED theory. Furthermore, we propose effective theoretical schemes to suppress Stark shifts, thereby facilitating high-precision spectroscopy experiments of helium The B-spline-basis methods reviewed in this paper prove exceptionally effective in high-precision calculations for few-electron atoms. These methods not only provide crucial theoretical support for precision spectroscopy experiments but also pave the new way for testing QED. Their ability to handle large-scale configuration interactions and incorporate relativistic and QED corrections makes them versatile tools for advancing atomic physics research. In the future, the high-precision theoretical methods based on B-spline basis sets are expected to be extended to cutting-edge fields, such as quantum state manipulation, determination of nuclear structure properties, formation of ultracold molecules, and exploration of new physics, thus continuously promoting the progress of precision measurement physics.
The electronic structure of the ground state and some excited states of neutral atoms with the nuclear charge numbers 1< Z< 101<~Z<~101< Z< 10 and their singly positive ions are investigated by means of our two-dimensional mesh Hartree-Fock method for strong magnetic fields $0.5<~\ensuremath{\gamma}<~10000.$ For $\ensuremath{\gamma}=10000$ the ground-state configurations of all the atoms and ions considered are given by fully spin-polarized configurations of single-electron orbitals with magnetic quantum numbers ranging from m=0m=0m=0 to $m=\ensuremath{-}N+1,$ where N is the number of the electrons. Focusing on the fully spin-polarized situation, we provide critical values of the magnetic-field strength for which crossovers with respect to the spatial symmetries of the ground state take place. It is found that the neutral atoms and singly charged positive ions with 2< Z< 52<~Z<~52< Z< 5 have one fully spin-polarized ground-state configuration, whereas for 6< Z< 106<~Z<~106< Z< 10 one intermediate fully spin-polarized configuration with an orbital of 2p0{2p}_{0}2p0​ type occurs.
The quantum mechanics of two-electron systems is reviewed, starting with the ground state of the helium atom and heliumlike ions with central charge Z. The case of Z≥2 is rather straightforward. In contrast, for negative hydrogen ion with Z=1, the stability of H− cannot be achieved using a product of individual electron wavefunctions and requires explicit account of the anticorrelation among the two electrons. The wavefunction proposed by Chandrasekhar is revisited, where the permutation symmetry is first broken and then restored by a counterterm. More difficult problems can be studied using the same strategy such as the stability of hydrogenlike ions for any value of the proton-to-electron mass ratio M/m, the energy of the lowest spin-triplet state of helium and heliumlike ions, and the stability of the doubly excited hydrogen ion with unnatural parity. The positronium molecule, which was predicted years ago and discovered recently, can also be shown to be stable against spontaneous dissociation. Emphasis is placed on symmetry breaking, which can either spoil or improve the stability.
In this work, the ground-state energy of the lithium atom is systematically investigated using both time-independent perturbation theory and the variational method to provide a comprehensive pedagogical analysis of many-body atomic systems. The unperturbed Hamiltonian is initially constructed by neglecting electron-electron interactions, treating the system as three independent hydrogen-like electrons to yield a zeroth-order energy baseline of -275.51 eV. The antisymmetric fermionic nature of the exact wave function is rigorously enforced through the Slater determinant formalism. First-order perturbation theory is applied to evaluate static inter-electronic repulsion using exact Coulomb and exchange integrals, refining the energy state to -192.01 eV. To account for dynamical electronic correlation, second-order perturbation theory is computed numerically for virtual single-electron s-orbital transitions, leading to a total perturbative energy of -196.36 eV. A brief discussion of two-electron excitations is also included to encapsulate further physical realism within the framework. Furthermore, a non-orthogonal two-parameter variational approach is employed to model the shell-specific shielding effect. By optimizing the effective nuclear charges, the variational method establishes a superior upper bound energy of -201.187 eV. The results of both methods are comprehensively contrasted against each other and the reference baseline to provide critical insights into the nature of electron correlation and screening in multi-electron atoms.
The wave functions of the ground (Ψ 0 ) and the first excited (Ψ k ) states of He II in the second-order approximation, i.e., up to the first two corrections to the corresponding solutions for a weakly nonideal Bose gas, are determined by the collective variable method, which was proposed by Bogolyubov and Zubarev and developed in the studies by Yukhnovskii and Vakarchuk. The functions Ψ 0 and Ψ k = ψ k Ψ 0 are determined as the eigenfunctions of the N -particle Schrödinger equation from a system of coupled equations for Ψ 0 , Ψ k , and the quasiparticle spectrum E ( k ) of helium II. The results consist in the following: (1) these equations are solved numerically for a higher order approximation compared with those investigated earlier (the first-order approximation), and (2) Ψ 0 and ψ k are derived from a model potential of interaction between He 4 atoms (rather than from the structure factor as earlier) in which the potential barrier is joined with the attractive potential found from experiment. The height V 0 of the potential barrier is a free parameter. Except for V 0 , the model does not have any free parameters or functions. The calculated values of the structure factor, the ground-state energy E 0 , and the quasiparticle spectrum E ( k ) of He II are in agreement with the experimental values for V 0 ≈ 100 K. The second-order correction to the logarithm of Ψ 0 significantly affects the value of E 0 and provides the asymptotics E ( k → 0) = ck , while the second-order correction to ψ k slightly affects the E ( k ). The second-order corrections to Ψ 0 and ψ k have a smaller effect on the results compared with the first-order corrections, whereby the theory is in agreement with experiment; therefore, one may assume that the truncated Ψ 0 and ψ k well describe the microstructure of He II. Thus, the series for Ψ 0 and Ψ k can be truncated in spite of the fact that the expansion parameter is not very small (∼1/2).
We establish a new iterative method for computing rigorous lower bounds for the ground-state energies of all atoms and ions. The accuracy of the resulting bounds depends on two ingredients: the quality of the initial energy estimate and the quality of the used upper bound for the maximum number of bound electrons, Nc(Z)N_c(Z)Nc​(Z), as a function of the nuclear charge Z>0Z>0Z>0. In particular, this new method allows us to establish the explicit lower bound E(N,Z)≥−0.8710 N1/3Z2E(N,Z) \geq -0.8710\,N^{1/3}Z^2E(N,Z)≥−0.8710N1/3Z2 for the ground-state energy E(N,Z)E(N,Z)E(N,Z) of the atom/ion with N∈NN \in \mathbb{N}N∈N electrons and nuclear charge Z∈(0,N]Z \in (0,N]Z∈(0,N], thereby considerably improving the best known constant A=(3/2)1/3≈1.1447A=(3/2)^{1/3} \approx 1.1447A=(3/2)1/3≈1.1447 in the estimate E(N,Z)≥−A N1/3Z2E(N,Z) \geq -A\,N^{1/3}Z^2E(N,Z)≥−AN1/3Z2 for 0<Z≤N0 < Z \leq N0<Z≤N and coming much closer to the best possible constant given by the Thomas-Fermi asymptotics lim⁡N→∞∣E(N,N)∣N−7/3=−ETF(1)≈0.7687\lim_{N \to \infty} |E(N,N)|N^{-7/3}= -E_{\text{TF}}(1)\approx 0.7687limN→∞​∣E(N,N)∣N−7/3=−ETF​(1)≈0.7687 derived in Adv. Math., 23(1) by Lieb and Simon. To demonstrate the potential and the limits of our method, we also compute explicit lower bounds for the ground-state energies E(N,N)E(N,N)E(N,N) of all atoms with 2≤N≤862 \leq N \leq 862≤N≤86 and we compare them with the bounds obtained in J. Chem. Phys., 62(8) by Hertel, Lieb, Thirring and the bounds obtained by Seco in his dissertation. Finally, we also provide a uniqueness result for the expectation values of the kinetic, potential and interaction energies on the ground-state space.