Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.34480

Rigorous Lower Bounds for Atomic and Ionic Ground-State Energies

Michael Hofacker

math-phquant-phSubmitted Oct 25, 2026• Announced Oct 27, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We establish a new iterative method for computing rigorous lower bounds for the ground-state energies of all atoms and ions. The accuracy of the resulting bounds depends on two ingredients: the quality of the initial energy estimate and the quality of the used upper bound for the maximum number of bound electrons, $N_c(Z)$, as a function of the nuclear charge $Z>0$. In particular, this new method allows us to establish the explicit lower bound $E(N,Z) \geq -0.8710\,N^{1/3}Z^2$ for the ground-state energy $E(N,Z)$ of the atom/ion with $N \in \mathbb{N}$ electrons and nuclear charge $Z \in (0,N]$, thereby considerably improving the best known constant $A=(3/2)^{1/3} \approx 1.1447$ in the estimate $E(N,Z) \geq -A\,N^{1/3}Z^2$ for $0 < Z \leq N$ and coming much closer to the best possible constant given by the Thomas-Fermi asymptotics $\lim_{N \to \infty} |E(N,N)|N^{-7/3}= -E_{\text{TF}}(1)\approx 0.7687$ derived in Adv. Math., 23(1) by Lieb and Simon. To demonstrate the potential and the limits of our method, we also compute explicit lower bounds for the ground-state energies $E(N,N)$ of all atoms with $2 \leq N \leq 86$ and we compare them with the bounds obtained in J. Chem. Phys., 62(8) by Hertel, Lieb, Thirring and the bounds obtained by Seco in his dissertation. Finally, we also provide a uniqueness result for the expectation values of the kinetic, potential and interaction energies on the ground-state space.

AI Summary

The paper addresses rigorous lower bounds for nonrelativistic atomic and ionic ground-state energies $E(N,Z)$ with a fixed nucleus. It develops a recursive construction that propagates an initial lower bound using an upper bound $N_c(Z)<f(Z)$ on the maximum number of bound electrons. The construction applies to fermionic and bosonic/full-space Hamiltonians, with statistics entering through the noninteracting hydrogenic energy sum $\sigma_N$. The central estimate is $\sqrt{|E(N,Z_1)|}\leq\sqrt{|E(N,Z_0)|}+\sqrt{\sigma_N}(Z_1-Z_0)$ for $Z_1\geq Z_0$. It follows from the virial theorem, variational estimates and concavity in nuclear charge. Combining it with $E(N,Z)=E(N-1,Z)$ beyond the binding limit gives piecewise-linear upper bounds on $\sqrt{|E|}$. For spin-$1/2$ fermions, existing ionization bounds yield $E(N,Z)\geq-0.8710N^{1/3}Z^2$ for $0<Z\leq N$, improving the stated previous constant $1.1447$. The neutral-atom Thomas–Fermi asymptotic coefficient is approximately $0.7687$. Establishing the uniform bound combines analytical estimates with computer verification for $N\leq3600$. Comparisons for neutral atoms through $N=86$ show that the recursive bounds generally remain weaker than existing numerically obtained lower bounds, exceeding their magnitudes by over $20\%$ at $N=86$. Accuracy depends on the initial estimate and binding-number bound; improved comparisons assuming $N_c(Z)<Z+1$ and a numerical critical-charge estimate are explicitly conditional. The paper also establishes equality of kinetic, nuclear-attraction and interaction expectations across degenerate ground states wherever $E(N,Z)$ is differentiable in $Z$.

No sign of AI-generated textOverclaims

Error found: The Thomas–Fermi asymptotic limit establishes a necessary lower limit on the universal coefficient, not the paper's assertion that 0.7687 is the optimal coefficient for all finite atoms. Theorem 2 relies on an undocumented finite computer verification through N = 3600, leaving a reproducibility and certification gap despite the paper's claims of avoiding numerical computations. Appendix Lemma A2 contains an incorrect inequality and completed-square equality that are both repaired by replacing (κ/4)^2 with (κ/2)^2.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Related papers

A rigorous lower bound for the ground-state energy of the hydrogen atom

Yue Zhang

Proving the existence of a lower bound on the energy of atoms is an important and noteworthy problem. Generally, people use the Heisenberg uncertainty relation to make their estimates. This article discusses the hydrogen atom and presents a new rigorous method for deriving the lower bound on the ground-state energy.

American Journal of Physics•Jun 1, 1990•2 citations

Rigorous Lower Bounds for the Ground State Energy of Molecules by Employing Necessary N-Representability Conditions

Denis Chaykin, Christian Jansson, Frerich Johannes Keil +3 more

Electronic structure calculations, in particular the computation of the ground state energy, lead to challenging problems in optimization. These problems are of enormous importance in quantum chemistry for calculations of properties of solids and molecules. Minimization methods for computing the ground state energy can be developed by employing a variational approach, where the second-order reduced density matrix defines the variable. This concept leads to large-scale semidefinite programming problems that provide a lower bound for the ground state energy. Upper bounds of the ground state energy can be calculated for example with the Hartree–Fock method or numerically more exact for a given basis set by full CI. However, Nakata et al. ( J. Chem. Phys. 2001 114 82828292) observed that due to numerical errors the semidefinite solver produced erroneous results with a lower bound significantly larger than the full CI energy. For the LiH, CH –, NH –, OH, OH –, and HF molecules violations within one mhartree were observed. We applied the software VSDP which takes all numerical errors due to floating-point arithmetic operations into consideration. For two test libraries VSDP provides tight rigorous error bounds lower than full CI energies reported with an accuracy of 0.1 to 0.01 mhartree. Only little computation work must be spent in order to compute close rigorous error bounds for the ground state energy.

Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation•Nov 13, 2020•0 citations

Lower bound estimates on the energy of many-body quantum system

E. B. Balbutsev, B G Irgasiev, I.N. Mikhailov +1 more

Two methods which give the lower bound for the ground-state energy of a system with N interacting particles are described. The methods exploit the solution of the Schrodinger equation for the comparison system with K<N particles. An illustrative example of fermions interacting with the harmonic force is discussed. More realistic interactions used in nuclear physics are treated numerically with K=2, 3 and 4, showing that the lower bound tends to the exact value of the energy when K increases. The lower bound is strongly dependent on the choice of the interaction.

Journal of Physics G Nuclear Physics•Sep 1, 1976•3 citations

Simple Upper Bound to the Ground-State Energy of a Many-Body System and Condition on the Two-Body Potential Necessary for Its Stability

Francesco Calogero, Yu. A. Simonov

A simple upper bound to the ground-state energy of a quantal system composed of $N$ equal particles obeying Boltzmann or Bose statistics and interacting through the interparticle potential $V(r)$ is established. This bound applies in the limit of large $N$; different expressions obtain depending on whether the potential is or is not singularly attractive at the origin. In the former case, the bound reads - $C{N}^{\frac{(4\ensuremath{-}q)}{(2\ensuremath{-}q)}}$, - $q$ being the (negative) exponent characterizing the behavior of the pair potential at the origin through ${\mathrm{lim}}_{r\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0}[{r}^{q}V(r)]={V}_{0}$, $\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\infty}<{V}_{0}<0$ (of course, $q<2$ to prevent two-body collapse); in the latter case, it reads $\ensuremath{-}B{N}^{2}$. Explicit expressions for the constants $C$ and $B$ in terms of the pair potential $V(r)$ are obtained; it is expected (and, in some cases, demonstrated) that the associated upper bound to the ground-state energy of the system approximates closely the actual value. It is also noted that, if for some non-negative value of $p$ the quantity $\ensuremath{\int}{0}^{\ensuremath{\infty}}\mathrm{dr}{r}^{2} \mathrm{exp}(\ensuremath{-}{p}^{2}{r}^{2})V(r)$ is negative, the $N$-body system is unstable in the sense that, at large $N$, its total energy is negative and increases in modulus at least as ${N}^{2}$ (so that the binding energy per particle increases in modulus at least as $N$). Examples illustrating the nontrivial nature of this conclusion are displayed.

Physical Review•Jul 20, 1969•8 citations

Quantum approximation algorithms for many-body and electronic structure problems

Karen J. Morenz, Kenny Choo, Antonio Mezzacapo

Computing many-body ground state energies and resolving electronic structure calculations are fundamental problems for fields such as quantum chemistry or condensed matter. Several quantum computing algorithms that address these problems exist, although it is often challenging to establish rigorous bounds on their performances. Here we detail three algorithms that produce approximate ground states for many-body and electronic structure problems, generalizing some previously known results for 2-local Hamiltonians. Each method comes with asymptotic bounds on the energies produced. The first one produces a separable state which improves on random product states. We test it on a spinless Hubbard model, validating numerically the theoretical result. The other two algorithms produce entangled states via shallow or deep circuits, improving on the energies of given initial states. We demonstrate their performance via numerical experiments on a 2-dimensional Hubbard model, starting from a checkerboard product state, as well as on some chemistry Hamiltonians, using the Hartree-Fock state as reference. In both cases, we show that the approximate energies produced are close to the exact ones. These algorithms provide a way to systematically improve the estimation of ground state energies and can be used stand-alone or in conjunction with existing quantum algorithms for ground states.

arXiv:2111.08090•Nov 15, 2021•3 citations

A sharp gradient-corrected Lieb--Thirring inequality in one dimension with applications to density functional theory

Thiago Carvalho Corso, Louis Garrigue

We first prove a sharp Lieb-Thirring inequality with semi-classical constant and gradient correction in one dimension. In the periodic setting, the corresponding inequality also includes a parity dependent shell-correction term, which appears to be new. Moreover, we also characterize the optimizers of these inequalities. In particular, the optimizing density profiles form a two-dimensional manifold, which we call here the Poincaré density manifold. We then apply these results to study the Thomas--Fermi--von Weizsäcker (TFW) approximation of the kinetic energy in Density Functional Theory. More precisely, we first obtain an explicit and non-asymptotic bound on the global and local error made by the TFW approximation. These bounds are controlled by the distance of the normalized density profile from the Poincaré density manifold times the number of particles. In particular, these bounds show that the TFW approximation is exact on the Poincaré manifold. We then show that, in the periodic setting, the distance between the Kohn-Sham potential and the inverse TFW potential in the natural dual Sobolev space can also be controlled by explicit density dependent constants times the distance to the Poincaré manifold. As a corollary, we prove that for a fixed density profile, the Kohn-Sham potential converges towards the inverse Thomas--Fermi potential in the high-density limit $N \rightarrow \infty$ with asymptotic rate of order $N^{-2}$. This rate is shown to be optimal.

math-phCross-listedarXiv:2610.30887•Oct 23, 2026
We establish a new iterative method for computing rigorous lower bounds for the ground-state energies of all atoms and ions. The accuracy of the resulting bounds depends on two ingredients: the quality of the initial energy estimate and the quality of the used upper bound for the maximum number of bound electrons, Nc(Z)N_c(Z)Nc​(Z), as a function of the nuclear charge Z>0Z>0Z>0. In particular, this new method allows us to establish the explicit lower bound E(N,Z)≥−0.8710 N1/3Z2E(N,Z) \geq -0.8710\,N^{1/3}Z^2E(N,Z)≥−0.8710N1/3Z2 for the ground-state energy E(N,Z)E(N,Z)E(N,Z) of the atom/ion with N∈NN \in \mathbb{N}N∈N electrons and nuclear charge Z∈(0,N]Z \in (0,N]Z∈(0,N], thereby considerably improving the best known constant A=(3/2)1/3≈1.1447A=(3/2)^{1/3} \approx 1.1447A=(3/2)1/3≈1.1447 in the estimate E(N,Z)≥−A N1/3Z2E(N,Z) \geq -A\,N^{1/3}Z^2E(N,Z)≥−AN1/3Z2 for 0<Z≤N0 < Z \leq N0<Z≤N and coming much closer to the best possible constant given by the Thomas-Fermi asymptotics lim⁡N→∞∣E(N,N)∣N−7/3=−ETF(1)≈0.7687\lim_{N \to \infty} |E(N,N)|N^{-7/3}= -E_{\text{TF}}(1)\approx 0.7687limN→∞​∣E(N,N)∣N−7/3=−ETF​(1)≈0.7687 derived in Adv. Math., 23(1) by Lieb and Simon. To demonstrate the potential and the limits of our method, we also compute explicit lower bounds for the ground-state energies E(N,N)E(N,N)E(N,N) of all atoms with 2≤N≤862 \leq N \leq 862≤N≤86 and we compare them with the bounds obtained in J. Chem. Phys., 62(8) by Hertel, Lieb, Thirring and the bounds obtained by Seco in his dissertation. Finally, we also provide a uniqueness result for the expectation values of the kinetic, potential and interaction energies on the ground-state space.
The paper addresses rigorous lower bounds for nonrelativistic atomic and ionic ground-state energies E(N,Z)E(N,Z)E(N,Z) with a fixed nucleus. It develops a recursive construction that propagates an initial lower bound using an upper bound Nc(Z)<f(Z)N_c(Z)<f(Z)Nc​(Z)<f(Z) on the maximum number of bound electrons. The construction applies to fermionic and bosonic/full-space Hamiltonians, with statistics entering through the noninteracting hydrogenic energy sum σN\sigma_NσN​.
The central estimate is ∣E(N,Z1)∣≤∣E(N,Z0)∣+σN(Z1−Z0)\sqrt{|E(N,Z_1)|}\leq\sqrt{|E(N,Z_0)|}+\sqrt{\sigma_N}(Z_1-Z_0)∣E(N,Z1​)∣​≤∣E(N,Z0​)∣​+σN​​(Z1​−Z0​) for Z1≥Z0Z_1\geq Z_0Z1​≥Z0​. It follows from the virial theorem, variational estimates and concavity in nuclear charge. Combining it with E(N,Z)=E(N−1,Z)E(N,Z)=E(N-1,Z)E(N,Z)=E(N−1,Z) beyond the binding limit gives piecewise-linear upper bounds on ∣E∣\sqrt{|E|}∣E∣​. For spin-1/21/21/2 fermions, existing ionization bounds yield E(N,Z)≥−0.8710N1/3Z2E(N,Z)\geq-0.8710N^{1/3}Z^2E(N,Z)≥−0.8710N1/3Z2 for 0<Z≤N0<Z\leq N0<Z≤N, improving the stated previous constant 1.14471.14471.1447. The neutral-atom Thomas–Fermi asymptotic coefficient is approximately 0.76870.76870.7687. Establishing the uniform bound combines analytical estimates with computer verification for N≤3600N\leq3600N≤3600.
Comparisons for neutral atoms through N=86N=86N=86 show that the recursive bounds generally remain weaker than existing numerically obtained lower bounds, exceeding their magnitudes by over 20%20\%20% at N=86N=86N=86. Accuracy depends on the initial estimate and binding-number bound; improved comparisons assuming Nc(Z)<Z+1N_c(Z)<Z+1Nc​(Z)<Z+1 and a numerical critical-charge estimate are explicitly conditional. The paper also establishes equality of kinetic, nuclear-attraction and interaction expectations across degenerate ground states wherever E(N,Z)E(N,Z)E(N,Z) is differentiable in ZZZ.
Electronic structure calculations, in particular the computation of the ground state energy, lead to challenging problems in optimization. These problems are of enormous importance in quantum chemistry for calculations of properties of solids and molecules. Minimization methods for computing the ground state energy can be developed by employing a variational approach, where the second-order reduced density matrix defines the variable. This concept leads to large-scale semidefinite programming problems that provide a lower bound for the ground state energy. Upper bounds of the ground state energy can be calculated for example with the Hartree–Fock method or numerically more exact for a given basis set by full CI. However, Nakata et al. ( J. Chem. Phys. 2001 114 82828292) observed that due to numerical errors the semidefinite solver produced erroneous results with a lower bound significantly larger than the full CI energy. For the LiH, CH –, NH –, OH, OH –, and HF molecules violations within one mhartree were observed. We applied the software VSDP which takes all numerical errors due to floating-point arithmetic operations into consideration. For two test libraries VSDP provides tight rigorous error bounds lower than full CI energies reported with an accuracy of 0.1 to 0.01 mhartree. Only little computation work must be spent in order to compute close rigorous error bounds for the ground state energy.
Two methods which give the lower bound for the ground-state energy of a system with N interacting particles are described. The methods exploit the solution of the Schrodinger equation for the comparison system with K<N particles. An illustrative example of fermions interacting with the harmonic force is discussed. More realistic interactions used in nuclear physics are treated numerically with K=2, 3 and 4, showing that the lower bound tends to the exact value of the energy when K increases. The lower bound is strongly dependent on the choice of the interaction.
A simple upper bound to the ground-state energy of a quantal system composed of NNN equal particles obeying Boltzmann or Bose statistics and interacting through the interparticle potential V(r)V(r)V(r) is established. This bound applies in the limit of large NNN; different expressions obtain depending on whether the potential is or is not singularly attractive at the origin. In the former case, the bound reads - $C{N}^{\frac{(4\ensuremath{-}q)}{(2\ensuremath{-}q)}}$, - qqq being the (negative) exponent characterizing the behavior of the pair potential at the origin through ${\mathrm{lim}}_{r\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0}[{r}^{q}V(r)]={V}_{0}$, $\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\infty}<{V}_{0}<0$ (of course, q<2q<2q<2 to prevent two-body collapse); in the latter case, it reads $\ensuremath{-}B{N}^{2}$. Explicit expressions for the constants CCC and BBB in terms of the pair potential V(r)V(r)V(r) are obtained; it is expected (and, in some cases, demonstrated) that the associated upper bound to the ground-state energy of the system approximates closely the actual value. It is also noted that, if for some non-negative value of ppp the quantity $\ensuremath{\int}{0}^{\ensuremath{\infty}}\mathrm{dr}{r}^{2} \mathrm{exp}(\ensuremath{-}{p}^{2}{r}^{2})V(r)$ is negative, the NNN-body system is unstable in the sense that, at large NNN, its total energy is negative and increases in modulus at least as N2{N}^{2}N2 (so that the binding energy per particle increases in modulus at least as NNN). Examples illustrating the nontrivial nature of this conclusion are displayed.
Computing many-body ground state energies and resolving electronic structure calculations are fundamental problems for fields such as quantum chemistry or condensed matter. Several quantum computing algorithms that address these problems exist, although it is often challenging to establish rigorous bounds on their performances. Here we detail three algorithms that produce approximate ground states for many-body and electronic structure problems, generalizing some previously known results for 2-local Hamiltonians. Each method comes with asymptotic bounds on the energies produced. The first one produces a separable state which improves on random product states. We test it on a spinless Hubbard model, validating numerically the theoretical result. The other two algorithms produce entangled states via shallow or deep circuits, improving on the energies of given initial states. We demonstrate their performance via numerical experiments on a 2-dimensional Hubbard model, starting from a checkerboard product state, as well as on some chemistry Hamiltonians, using the Hartree-Fock state as reference. In both cases, we show that the approximate energies produced are close to the exact ones. These algorithms provide a way to systematically improve the estimation of ground state energies and can be used stand-alone or in conjunction with existing quantum algorithms for ground states.
We first prove a sharp Lieb-Thirring inequality with semi-classical constant and gradient correction in one dimension. In the periodic setting, the corresponding inequality also includes a parity dependent shell-correction term, which appears to be new. Moreover, we also characterize the optimizers of these inequalities. In particular, the optimizing density profiles form a two-dimensional manifold, which we call here the Poincaré density manifold. We then apply these results to study the Thomas--Fermi--von Weizsäcker (TFW) approximation of the kinetic energy in Density Functional Theory. More precisely, we first obtain an explicit and non-asymptotic bound on the global and local error made by the TFW approximation. These bounds are controlled by the distance of the normalized density profile from the Poincaré density manifold times the number of particles. In particular, these bounds show that the TFW approximation is exact on the Poincaré manifold. We then show that, in the periodic setting, the distance between the Kohn-Sham potential and the inverse TFW potential in the natural dual Sobolev space can also be controlled by explicit density dependent constants times the distance to the Poincaré manifold. As a corollary, we prove that for a fixed density profile, the Kohn-Sham potential converges towards the inverse Thomas--Fermi potential in the high-density limit N→∞N \rightarrow \inftyN→∞ with asymptotic rate of order N−2N^{-2}N−2. This rate is shown to be optimal.