Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2607.21663

Identifying the Sign of Coherent Over-Rotations with Logarithmically Many Pauli Settings

Yi Pan, Meng Hsiu Tsai, Weihang You, Hanqi Jiang, Junhao Chen, Wei Zhang, Isaac Lyngaas, Yingfeng Wang, Tianming Liu

quant-phSubmitted Jul 23, 2026• Announced Jul 24, 2026• 1 citation• Revised Sep 24, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Jul 23, 2026v2 · Sep 24, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Calibrating a quantum processor means estimating gate-error parameters from data, and a hard-to-estimate parameter is usually assumed to leave a weak signature more repetitions will resolve. Coherent over-rotations break that premise. For commuting single- and two-qubit transverse over-rotations with known support on a computational-basis input, the passive histogram is exactly invariant under a sign group acting on the coherent angles, of order $2^{n+1}$ for the complete family with $n\ge2$, so no estimator resolves the signs uniformly at any sample size. A calibration correction applied with the wrong sign doubles the rotation error it should remove. At zero angle the obstruction turns continuous, with a Fisher information singular along every coherent direction and an infinite Cramér-Rao bound. At generic angles the continuous defect clears for $5\le n\le8$, the range we compute, while the sign degeneracy persists. Covering the support removes both, and a design resolves the signed angles uniformly exactly when it covers. On $|η_R|<π/2$, $0\le p_R<1/2$ coverage is constructive, returning each angle in closed form from a ratio of two measured expectations without knowing the rates. A twirl-free code of $\lceil\log_2(n+1)\rceil$ added product-Pauli settings covers, and for the complete family none uses fewer. Conditioning then sets the Cramér-Rao cost, and we give its floor explicitly. Exact computation matches the theory, the passive fit stays at chance on the signs at every budget while the closed-form inverse recovers them, and angle magnitudes on two IBM Heron processors follow the conditioning ordering.

Related papers

Probing Coherent Noise with Stabilizer Codes: Identifiability, Ambiguity, and Decoder Priors

Long Huang

Coherent noise calls for a reusable physical model, but Pauli twirling erases it and full process tomography scales exponentially. We turn measurement-free quantum error correction into a probe: bit-flip and phase-flip codes polarize few-qubit coherent noise into single-logical-qubit channels, and the resulting fingerprint identifies an 11-parameter three-qubit family. An exact rational-arithmetic rank certificate, evaluated at a rational point in the interior of the parameter domain, proves local injectivity on a dense open subset of that domain. The map is nevertheless not globally injective: a compensating rotation combined with a site exchange yields exact collisions, which we classify and then remove by adding one two-qubit marginal channel. The site exchange is the only nontrivial permutation symmetry of the $n$-qubit chain generator at any $n$, so the classification is structural rather than a three-qubit accident. A Cramér--Rao analysis, checked at the level of individual measurement settings, reaches $0.01$~rad per parameter at a representative point, and decoder priors rebuilt from such an estimate retain most of their correlation gain. Propagating the generator into a distance-three surface code gives a $14.8$-fold encoding gain when the generator is known exactly, and $1.21$-fold of the correlation gain survives when the prior is rebuilt from an estimate at the stated precision, closing the loop from characterization to decoding.

quant-pharXiv:2610.19779•Oct 15, 2026•4 citations

Beyond Orbital Rotations: Correlation-Rank Limits and Clifford-Accessible Measurement, from Algebra and Global Optimization

Federico Zahariev, Vanda Glezakou

One should not assume that reconstructing an electronic observable with a smaller set of measurement settings will cut the number of repetitions in proportion. Each setting is simply a basis change and qubit readout, but the savings are not guaranteed to be commensurate. Take two electrons of opposite spin in two spatial orbitals: the orbital degree of freedom of each electron acts as a logical qubit and rotations are independent in the spin sectors. From the observable's one- and two-qubit coefficients we derive an exact floor for the setting count and a decomposition to meet it in no more than three settings. With fewer settings, the minimum error in the two-qubit correlation coefficients is set by the singular values left out. A case in point is an exchange with equal nonzero couplings on the three Pauli axes. This demands three orbital settings yet only one joint measurement. We offer a Clifford circuit for four physical qubits to effect the necessary mapping of Pauli products under conjugation. In the case of a one-parameter family of logical singlet-triplet mixtures, the orbital-to-Clifford shot cost ratio is three at maximum mixing and trends toward 3/2 near the logical singlet. Where spin sectors may be mixed, isotropic exchange needs one orbital setting. For spin-conserving Hamiltonians with $N$ spatial orbitals encoded via Jordan-Wigner, the $X$-rank, the binary rank of the $X$ parts of its strings, of any commuting Pauli string family is no more than $2(N-1)$. Searches with the Robust Adaptive Nature-inspired Global Explorer (RANGE) reach this limit for CH$_4$, with the rank of the Hamiltonian support vouching for the maximality of the search values. And for all nonidentity Pauli strings on $n$ qubits, semidefinite witnesses from the Lovász theta number give a lower bound on the Clifford setting count that agrees with the integer cover and counting bounds at $2^n+1$.

quant-pharXiv:2607.16869•Jul 21, 2026•0 citations

Symmetry-Aware Independent Bit-Flip: Identifiability-Guided Distribution Learning for Quantum Noise Simulation

Yi Pan, Meng Hsiu Tsai, Hanqi Jiang +7 more

Abstract Quantum and hybrid quantum-classical workflows repeatedly need to predict how ideal circuit distributions appear as finite-shot noisy hardware histograms, but refitting high-dimensional noise simulators at each calibration point can be costly. We cast this task as finite-shot distribution learning for structured quantum outputs: given ideal distributions and noisy counts, learn a low-dimensional Markov surrogate and evaluate held-out distributional risk. Existing fast closed-form kernels lack identifiability guarantees, while richer physics-motivated simulators fit approximately 20 BO-tuned noise parameters without parameter-identifiability guarantees. We instantiate this middle ground with SA-IBF, a two-parameter closed-form kernel mixing independent bit-flip noise with a Hamming-sector-preserving component. For the support-face regimes induced by symmetry-preserving circuits, we show a support-face bridge and a rank-conditioned local guarantee at fitted operating points; open-interior genericity establishes non-degeneracy of the full-simplex model. We also show a small-q Fisher upper bound in which the Fisher information for alpha conditional on q scales on the order of N times q squared for N shots and per-qubit flip rate q, certified for 2 to 8 qubits, yielding Cramer-Rao divergence as q approaches zero; analytic-Jacobian diagnostics verify the fitted-point rank premise at all seven representative operating points and all 230 panel fits. On an 890-execution IBM Heron hardware dataset spanning four backends, SA-IBF gives a diagnosable accuracy-cost Pareto point: in matched fitted-physics comparisons, it meets the sector-aware 21-parameter Ji-BO Hellinger accuracy budget on three of four molecular qubit settings while reducing refit cost by 231-447 times under matched implementations. The remaining setting flags a uniform-flip-rate boundary where the tested Ji-BO comparator's heterogeneous parameters lower risk. Supporting calibration evidence shows lower held-out Hellinger distance than plain bit-flip noise on all seven primary configurations and throughout a 400-execution cross-backend molecular panel. These results make SA-IBF a lightweight, identifiability-guided learned distribution-level surrogate for repeated quantum noise simulation in symmetry-structured quantum and hybrid quantum-classical workloads, including symmetry-preserving quantum-machine-learning settings.

•May 19, 2026•0 citations

Krylov geometry and optimal recovery under uncertain coherent noise

Abhishek Chowdhury

Recovery from a coherent rotation with an unobserved angle depends on both the encoding and what calibration reveals about the noise. We determine their combined limit for a known finite-dimensional generator and one final recovery. Two polynomial projections organize the answer. A physical Krylov chain separates correctable error amplitudes from their first state-dependent distortion; projection onto lower-angle powers identifies the part that a coherent decoder can cancel. Under explicit rank and moment conditions, their combination gives the exact leading optimal entanglement infidelity at weak noise and a recovery attaining it for any finite logical dimension. The optimal worst-input error lies between one and $d$ times that infidelity at leading order, for logical dimension $d$. When the angle distribution is unknown, we optimize one decoder for every distribution compatible with the calibration. When spectral and calibration frequencies are integer multiples of a common frequency, moment positivity turns this into an exact finite optimization. Small measured means can still allow rare finite rotations. If the sole calibration datum is $β_r=\mathbb E[\sin^{2r}(θ/2)]$, with $θ$ the wrapped rotation phase at that common frequency, the optimal worst-prior infidelity is $O(β_r)$ exactly when generator powers through degree $r-1$ are correctable. When the first uncorrectable power has degree $m<r$, the optimal loss scales as $β_r^{m/r}$, with a sharp coefficient fixed by a universal moment problem. In a loss-free four-photon memory, population measurements at two calibration durations retain the fully informed quartic error coefficient for a fixed symmetric narrow-noise family with positive variance and finite fourth moment; a single duration permits loss quadratic in the noise width.

quant-pharXiv:2610.33607•Oct 27, 2026•0 citations

Experimental supplement: three-qubit, three-gate repetition-code noise tomography

Long Huang

Experimental supplement to arXiv:2611.08310, a companion manuscript on gate-optimal recovery designs (2026). This supplement specifies a concrete experiment for measuring the eleven-parameter small-angle coherent noise of a three-qubit register with three single-qubit Pauli gates, using a distance-three repetition code in both orientations. It gives the branch structure, the syndrome-to-Pauli look-up table for the three-gate design, the fixed sixteen-setting measurement table, shot and wall-clock budgets for three platform classes, a calibration and systematics checklist, an analysis pipeline, and a symptom-to-cause table. Two sections price the alternatives: a fixed recovery that does not resolve the syndrome saves a factor three in circuits and loses a factor five in precision floor, and a coherent unitary recovery keeps the circuit saving but replaces each single-qubit Pauli by a multi-controlled gate that every branch must compile. At three qubits no design in the scanned budget loses rank, so identifiability does not separate the gate counts; what depends on the working point is which three gates to use, not how many. The organising point is that the recovery gate count is a resource: three gates attain the lowest precision floor, the standard six-gate decoder is 22 times worse at a small-angle operating point and 2.3 times worse at the well-conditioned point of arXiv:2610.19779, and the ordering is stable over forty sampled working points while the size of the factor is not. The ordering survives when the look-up is compiled rather than measured, and the margin then widens from 5.6 to 7.7 in wall clock, because a compiled table charges every entry in every branch. A section added in version 1.5 asks whether that answer depends on the platform. A second device archetype -- a tunable coupler or iSWAP-style gate, whose always-on term is the exchange J(XX+YY)/2 -- carries one more parameter per bond, thirteen in all, and the two clusters are not nested: XX and YY commute, and ZZ is orthogonal to their plane. Enumerating all 64 design pairs at n=3 and all 3969 at n=5 gives the same gate budget for both archetypes, zero gates to reach full rank at n=3 and one at n=5; that count is a lower bound on the budget, not a recommended design, since the precision optimum is the three gates of the main text, where zero gates is 18 times worse at the median and 379 times worse at the certified point. At matched per-layer coherent infidelity the thirteen-parameter cluster is not worse (101.0 against 88.9 mrad on the local angles at 10^5 shots), and at the three-gate optimum the comparison widens (41.7 against 32.2 mrad). Choosing the wrong cluster is a bias, not a variance: the correct family leaves a residual of exactly zero, the wrong one leaves 0.4-0.6% in the fingerprint and moves the nine local angles by a quarter to a half, while its Cramer-Rao bound looks better. The decoded logical error cannot arbitrate at that bias level -- 200 random perturbations of the same total variation spread it over a factor 43 -- so the model family must be chosen by the residual. The same section closes with a composition law: a per-gate composition of Pauli probabilities is elementwise in the Walsh eigenvalues and therefore under-counts the coherent part of the depth-L noise by exactly L (measured slopes 1.98 for the generator against 0.99 for the per-gate rule). A closing section fixes the size of the gain and asks how far it extends. An exact prior removes 19.3% of the logical error at d=3, which is 4.3e-5 errors per code cycle; a three-gate fit captures 83, 96.5 and 99.5% of that share on the three platform classes. That share, not the accuracy of the estimate, is where every prior-based protocol stops, because 94% of the residual is weight-two aliasing. It is not a limit set by using Pauli probabilities: the same prior decodes both the coherent channel and its twirled version, so the drop from 19.3% to 11.6% under twirling prices the device rather than the estimate, and composing per-gate twirls changes at most two of the 256 decoder decisions. A generator rather than a channel is what additionally allows the coherent part to be inverted and the prior to be extrapolated to unmeasured working points. Carrying the same three-qubit fit to d=5 or d=7 obeys a closed form, G_d = G_3^((d+1)/4), so no extra precision is needed at larger distance: a 6.4 mrad rms on the eleven parameters moves the d=7 gain by 8.5%. What does not transport is the truncated part of the model---the 2(d-1)^2 three-body positions a d x d patch adds, none of which a chain fit covers---which costs 5% of the gain at d=5 and 10% at d=7; site-to-site spread costs another 3%. The law itself is a property of the decoder and applies to any prior, so this is a bound on what a three-qubit run can claim, not an advantage over Pauli-statistics protocols. Measuring at the target size instead of transporting avoids the truncation count but pays conditioning: a factor 68 from three to seven qubits. All numbers are model-level: no device data are reported, and the floors assume a calibration residual of 1e-3. Contents (v1.5): 1 What the experiment measures · 2 The three branches · 3 Syndrome decoding · 4 Settings and shot arithmetic · 5 Budget on three platforms · 6 Why the syndromes must be resolved · 7 What does and does not depend on the gate count · 8 Does the platform change the answer? · 9 How large the gain is, and how far it extends · 10 Calibration and systematics · 11 Analysis pipeline · 12 Diagnostics · 13 Checklist.

•Nov 6, 2026•3 citations

Algebraic structure of the CHSH failure mode: a Bell-state-selective diagnostic for coherent Ry errors

E. F. Perez-Eugenio

The textbook CHSH measurement configuration {a, a', b, b'} = {0, pi/2, pi/4, -pi/4} with Form I evaluates to S = 0 on all four Bell states in the spin-1/2 convention used by gate-based quantum processors. This "failure mode", documented as a state-formula-angle mismatch in a companion pedagogical note (doi:10.5281/zenodo.20146219), is shown here to have a clean algebraic origin: the corresponding Bell operator reduces to sqrt(2) * (sigma_z (x) sigma_x + sigma_x (x) sigma_z), whose spectrum is {-2*sqrt(2), 0, 0, +2*sqrt(2)}, with the kernel spanned by {|Phi+>, |Psi->} and the non-kernel pair {|Phi->, |Psi+>} mapped to each other. Main results. The note establishes three properties of the failure-mode configuration: (1) The CHSH value S is preserved at exactly zero under arbitrary symmetric local Pauli channels (depolarizing, dephasing, bit-flip) and under local Rx and Rz rotations on either qubit, for every Bell state. Verified numerically with 1000 random Pauli channels per state and across the full range of standard noise channels. (2) Local Ry(theta) rotations break S = 0 only for the pair {|Phi->, |Psi+>}, with closed form S = 2*sqrt(2)*|sin(theta)|, reaching the Tsirelson bound at theta = pi/2. (3) The asymmetry has a direct algebraic origin in the correlation tensor: the kernel pair has equal XX and ZZ moments (t_1 = t_3), while the broken pair has opposite signs (t_1 = -t_3). This connects to and gives algebraic meaning to the Bell-state taxonomy of the companion paper. Diagnostic interpretation. The same CHSH measurement that fails in textbook form becomes a no-extra-resource diagnostic for coherent Ry-type errors restricted to a specific Bell-state family. If S > 0 in this configuration, then (i) the state is in the {|Phi->, |Psi+>} family, and (ii) a coherent Ry error of magnitude theta_err = arcsin(S/(2*sqrt(2))) is present. Incoherent Pauli noise alone cannot produce this signal. Calibration of novelty. The note explicitly searches the self-testing literature (Supic-Bowles 2020 review) and the CHSH-under-noise literature (Kofman 2012, Kofman-Korotkov 2008) and reports that this specific asymmetric breaking pattern was not located in those communities. Priority is explicitly disclaimed with respect to gate-set-tomography and randomized-benchmarking literatures, which were not exhaustively surveyed. The result is presented as either a novel observation or, if previously catalogued elsewhere, an independent algebraic rederivation with closed-form expression in terms of the correlation tensor. Reproducibility. The repository contains the LaTeX source, the bibliography, both figures, and seven Python scripts that reproduce every numerical claim from scratch using only NumPy and Matplotlib. Each script is self-contained and runs in seconds. Companion paper. This work extends the pedagogical note "State-dependent CHSH inequality on gate-based quantum processors" (Perez-Eugenio 2026, doi:10.5281/zenodo.20146219), which documents the original state-formula-angle compatibility issue and the corrected configurations. The present note can be read independently.

•May 18, 2026•0 citations
Calibrating a quantum processor means estimating gate-error parameters from data, and a hard-to-estimate parameter is usually assumed to leave a weak signature more repetitions will resolve. Coherent over-rotations break that premise. For commuting single- and two-qubit transverse over-rotations with known support on a computational-basis input, the passive histogram is exactly invariant under a sign group acting on the coherent angles, of order 2n+12^{n+1}2n+1 for the complete family with n≥2n\ge2n≥2, so no estimator resolves the signs uniformly at any sample size. A calibration correction applied with the wrong sign doubles the rotation error it should remove. At zero angle the obstruction turns continuous, with a Fisher information singular along every coherent direction and an infinite Cramér-Rao bound. At generic angles the continuous defect clears for 5≤n≤85\le n\le85≤n≤8, the range we compute, while the sign degeneracy persists. Covering the support removes both, and a design resolves the signed angles uniformly exactly when it covers. On ∣ηR∣<π/2|η_R|<π/2∣ηR​∣<π/2, 0≤pR<1/20\le p_R<1/20≤pR​<1/2 coverage is constructive, returning each angle in closed form from a ratio of two measured expectations without knowing the rates. A twirl-free code of ⌈log⁡2(n+1)⌉\lceil\log_2(n+1)\rceil⌈log2​(n+1)⌉ added product-Pauli settings covers, and for the complete family none uses fewer. Conditioning then sets the Cramér-Rao cost, and we give its floor explicitly. Exact computation matches the theory, the passive fit stays at chance on the signs at every budget while the closed-form inverse recovers them, and angle magnitudes on two IBM Heron processors follow the conditioning ordering.
Coherent noise calls for a reusable physical model, but Pauli twirling erases it and full process tomography scales exponentially. We turn measurement-free quantum error correction into a probe: bit-flip and phase-flip codes polarize few-qubit coherent noise into single-logical-qubit channels, and the resulting fingerprint identifies an 11-parameter three-qubit family. An exact rational-arithmetic rank certificate, evaluated at a rational point in the interior of the parameter domain, proves local injectivity on a dense open subset of that domain. The map is nevertheless not globally injective: a compensating rotation combined with a site exchange yields exact collisions, which we classify and then remove by adding one two-qubit marginal channel. The site exchange is the only nontrivial permutation symmetry of the nnn-qubit chain generator at any nnn, so the classification is structural rather than a three-qubit accident. A Cramér--Rao analysis, checked at the level of individual measurement settings, reaches 0.010.010.01~rad per parameter at a representative point, and decoder priors rebuilt from such an estimate retain most of their correlation gain. Propagating the generator into a distance-three surface code gives a 14.814.814.8-fold encoding gain when the generator is known exactly, and 1.211.211.21-fold of the correlation gain survives when the prior is rebuilt from an estimate at the stated precision, closing the loop from characterization to decoding.
One should not assume that reconstructing an electronic observable with a smaller set of measurement settings will cut the number of repetitions in proportion. Each setting is simply a basis change and qubit readout, but the savings are not guaranteed to be commensurate. Take two electrons of opposite spin in two spatial orbitals: the orbital degree of freedom of each electron acts as a logical qubit and rotations are independent in the spin sectors. From the observable's one- and two-qubit coefficients we derive an exact floor for the setting count and a decomposition to meet it in no more than three settings. With fewer settings, the minimum error in the two-qubit correlation coefficients is set by the singular values left out. A case in point is an exchange with equal nonzero couplings on the three Pauli axes. This demands three orbital settings yet only one joint measurement. We offer a Clifford circuit for four physical qubits to effect the necessary mapping of Pauli products under conjugation. In the case of a one-parameter family of logical singlet-triplet mixtures, the orbital-to-Clifford shot cost ratio is three at maximum mixing and trends toward 3/2 near the logical singlet. Where spin sectors may be mixed, isotropic exchange needs one orbital setting. For spin-conserving Hamiltonians with NNN spatial orbitals encoded via Jordan-Wigner, the XXX-rank, the binary rank of the XXX parts of its strings, of any commuting Pauli string family is no more than 2(N−1)2(N-1)2(N−1). Searches with the Robust Adaptive Nature-inspired Global Explorer (RANGE) reach this limit for CH4_44​, with the rank of the Hamiltonian support vouching for the maximality of the search values. And for all nonidentity Pauli strings on nnn qubits, semidefinite witnesses from the Lovász theta number give a lower bound on the Clifford setting count that agrees with the integer cover and counting bounds at 2n+12^n+12n+1.
Abstract Quantum and hybrid quantum-classical workflows repeatedly need to predict how ideal circuit distributions appear as finite-shot noisy hardware histograms, but refitting high-dimensional noise simulators at each calibration point can be costly. We cast this task as finite-shot distribution learning for structured quantum outputs: given ideal distributions and noisy counts, learn a low-dimensional Markov surrogate and evaluate held-out distributional risk. Existing fast closed-form kernels lack identifiability guarantees, while richer physics-motivated simulators fit approximately 20 BO-tuned noise parameters without parameter-identifiability guarantees. We instantiate this middle ground with SA-IBF, a two-parameter closed-form kernel mixing independent bit-flip noise with a Hamming-sector-preserving component. For the support-face regimes induced by symmetry-preserving circuits, we show a support-face bridge and a rank-conditioned local guarantee at fitted operating points; open-interior genericity establishes non-degeneracy of the full-simplex model. We also show a small-q Fisher upper bound in which the Fisher information for alpha conditional on q scales on the order of N times q squared for N shots and per-qubit flip rate q, certified for 2 to 8 qubits, yielding Cramer-Rao divergence as q approaches zero; analytic-Jacobian diagnostics verify the fitted-point rank premise at all seven representative operating points and all 230 panel fits. On an 890-execution IBM Heron hardware dataset spanning four backends, SA-IBF gives a diagnosable accuracy-cost Pareto point: in matched fitted-physics comparisons, it meets the sector-aware 21-parameter Ji-BO Hellinger accuracy budget on three of four molecular qubit settings while reducing refit cost by 231-447 times under matched implementations. The remaining setting flags a uniform-flip-rate boundary where the tested Ji-BO comparator's heterogeneous parameters lower risk. Supporting calibration evidence shows lower held-out Hellinger distance than plain bit-flip noise on all seven primary configurations and throughout a 400-execution cross-backend molecular panel. These results make SA-IBF a lightweight, identifiability-guided learned distribution-level surrogate for repeated quantum noise simulation in symmetry-structured quantum and hybrid quantum-classical workloads, including symmetry-preserving quantum-machine-learning settings.
Recovery from a coherent rotation with an unobserved angle depends on both the encoding and what calibration reveals about the noise. We determine their combined limit for a known finite-dimensional generator and one final recovery. Two polynomial projections organize the answer. A physical Krylov chain separates correctable error amplitudes from their first state-dependent distortion; projection onto lower-angle powers identifies the part that a coherent decoder can cancel. Under explicit rank and moment conditions, their combination gives the exact leading optimal entanglement infidelity at weak noise and a recovery attaining it for any finite logical dimension. The optimal worst-input error lies between one and ddd times that infidelity at leading order, for logical dimension ddd. When the angle distribution is unknown, we optimize one decoder for every distribution compatible with the calibration. When spectral and calibration frequencies are integer multiples of a common frequency, moment positivity turns this into an exact finite optimization. Small measured means can still allow rare finite rotations. If the sole calibration datum is βr=E[sin⁡2r(θ/2)]β_r=\mathbb E[\sin^{2r}(θ/2)]βr​=E[sin2r(θ/2)], with θθθ the wrapped rotation phase at that common frequency, the optimal worst-prior infidelity is O(βr)O(β_r)O(βr​) exactly when generator powers through degree r−1r-1r−1 are correctable. When the first uncorrectable power has degree m<rm<rm<r, the optimal loss scales as βrm/rβ_r^{m/r}βrm/r​, with a sharp coefficient fixed by a universal moment problem. In a loss-free four-photon memory, population measurements at two calibration durations retain the fully informed quartic error coefficient for a fixed symmetric narrow-noise family with positive variance and finite fourth moment; a single duration permits loss quadratic in the noise width.
Experimental supplement to arXiv:2611.08310, a companion manuscript on gate-optimal recovery designs (2026). This supplement specifies a concrete experiment for measuring the eleven-parameter small-angle coherent noise of a three-qubit register with three single-qubit Pauli gates, using a distance-three repetition code in both orientations. It gives the branch structure, the syndrome-to-Pauli look-up table for the three-gate design, the fixed sixteen-setting measurement table, shot and wall-clock budgets for three platform classes, a calibration and systematics checklist, an analysis pipeline, and a symptom-to-cause table. Two sections price the alternatives: a fixed recovery that does not resolve the syndrome saves a factor three in circuits and loses a factor five in precision floor, and a coherent unitary recovery keeps the circuit saving but replaces each single-qubit Pauli by a multi-controlled gate that every branch must compile. At three qubits no design in the scanned budget loses rank, so identifiability does not separate the gate counts; what depends on the working point is which three gates to use, not how many. The organising point is that the recovery gate count is a resource: three gates attain the lowest precision floor, the standard six-gate decoder is 22 times worse at a small-angle operating point and 2.3 times worse at the well-conditioned point of arXiv:2610.19779, and the ordering is stable over forty sampled working points while the size of the factor is not. The ordering survives when the look-up is compiled rather than measured, and the margin then widens from 5.6 to 7.7 in wall clock, because a compiled table charges every entry in every branch. A section added in version 1.5 asks whether that answer depends on the platform. A second device archetype -- a tunable coupler or iSWAP-style gate, whose always-on term is the exchange J(XX+YY)/2 -- carries one more parameter per bond, thirteen in all, and the two clusters are not nested: XX and YY commute, and ZZ is orthogonal to their plane. Enumerating all 64 design pairs at n=3 and all 3969 at n=5 gives the same gate budget for both archetypes, zero gates to reach full rank at n=3 and one at n=5; that count is a lower bound on the budget, not a recommended design, since the precision optimum is the three gates of the main text, where zero gates is 18 times worse at the median and 379 times worse at the certified point. At matched per-layer coherent infidelity the thirteen-parameter cluster is not worse (101.0 against 88.9 mrad on the local angles at 10^5 shots), and at the three-gate optimum the comparison widens (41.7 against 32.2 mrad). Choosing the wrong cluster is a bias, not a variance: the correct family leaves a residual of exactly zero, the wrong one leaves 0.4-0.6% in the fingerprint and moves the nine local angles by a quarter to a half, while its Cramer-Rao bound looks better. The decoded logical error cannot arbitrate at that bias level -- 200 random perturbations of the same total variation spread it over a factor 43 -- so the model family must be chosen by the residual. The same section closes with a composition law: a per-gate composition of Pauli probabilities is elementwise in the Walsh eigenvalues and therefore under-counts the coherent part of the depth-L noise by exactly L (measured slopes 1.98 for the generator against 0.99 for the per-gate rule). A closing section fixes the size of the gain and asks how far it extends. An exact prior removes 19.3% of the logical error at d=3, which is 4.3e-5 errors per code cycle; a three-gate fit captures 83, 96.5 and 99.5% of that share on the three platform classes. That share, not the accuracy of the estimate, is where every prior-based protocol stops, because 94% of the residual is weight-two aliasing. It is not a limit set by using Pauli probabilities: the same prior decodes both the coherent channel and its twirled version, so the drop from 19.3% to 11.6% under twirling prices the device rather than the estimate, and composing per-gate twirls changes at most two of the 256 decoder decisions. A generator rather than a channel is what additionally allows the coherent part to be inverted and the prior to be extrapolated to unmeasured working points. Carrying the same three-qubit fit to d=5 or d=7 obeys a closed form, G_d = G_3^((d+1)/4), so no extra precision is needed at larger distance: a 6.4 mrad rms on the eleven parameters moves the d=7 gain by 8.5%. What does not transport is the truncated part of the model---the 2(d-1)^2 three-body positions a d x d patch adds, none of which a chain fit covers---which costs 5% of the gain at d=5 and 10% at d=7; site-to-site spread costs another 3%. The law itself is a property of the decoder and applies to any prior, so this is a bound on what a three-qubit run can claim, not an advantage over Pauli-statistics protocols. Measuring at the target size instead of transporting avoids the truncation count but pays conditioning: a factor 68 from three to seven qubits. All numbers are model-level: no device data are reported, and the floors assume a calibration residual of 1e-3. Contents (v1.5): 1 What the experiment measures · 2 The three branches · 3 Syndrome decoding · 4 Settings and shot arithmetic · 5 Budget on three platforms · 6 Why the syndromes must be resolved · 7 What does and does not depend on the gate count · 8 Does the platform change the answer? · 9 How large the gain is, and how far it extends · 10 Calibration and systematics · 11 Analysis pipeline · 12 Diagnostics · 13 Checklist.
The textbook CHSH measurement configuration {a, a', b, b'} = {0, pi/2, pi/4, -pi/4} with Form I evaluates to S = 0 on all four Bell states in the spin-1/2 convention used by gate-based quantum processors. This "failure mode", documented as a state-formula-angle mismatch in a companion pedagogical note (doi:10.5281/zenodo.20146219), is shown here to have a clean algebraic origin: the corresponding Bell operator reduces to sqrt(2) * (sigma_z (x) sigma_x + sigma_x (x) sigma_z), whose spectrum is {-2*sqrt(2), 0, 0, +2*sqrt(2)}, with the kernel spanned by {|Phi+>, |Psi->} and the non-kernel pair {|Phi->, |Psi+>} mapped to each other. Main results. The note establishes three properties of the failure-mode configuration: (1) The CHSH value S is preserved at exactly zero under arbitrary symmetric local Pauli channels (depolarizing, dephasing, bit-flip) and under local Rx and Rz rotations on either qubit, for every Bell state. Verified numerically with 1000 random Pauli channels per state and across the full range of standard noise channels. (2) Local Ry(theta) rotations break S = 0 only for the pair {|Phi->, |Psi+>}, with closed form S = 2*sqrt(2)*|sin(theta)|, reaching the Tsirelson bound at theta = pi/2. (3) The asymmetry has a direct algebraic origin in the correlation tensor: the kernel pair has equal XX and ZZ moments (t_1 = t_3), while the broken pair has opposite signs (t_1 = -t_3). This connects to and gives algebraic meaning to the Bell-state taxonomy of the companion paper. Diagnostic interpretation. The same CHSH measurement that fails in textbook form becomes a no-extra-resource diagnostic for coherent Ry-type errors restricted to a specific Bell-state family. If S > 0 in this configuration, then (i) the state is in the {|Phi->, |Psi+>} family, and (ii) a coherent Ry error of magnitude theta_err = arcsin(S/(2*sqrt(2))) is present. Incoherent Pauli noise alone cannot produce this signal. Calibration of novelty. The note explicitly searches the self-testing literature (Supic-Bowles 2020 review) and the CHSH-under-noise literature (Kofman 2012, Kofman-Korotkov 2008) and reports that this specific asymmetric breaking pattern was not located in those communities. Priority is explicitly disclaimed with respect to gate-set-tomography and randomized-benchmarking literatures, which were not exhaustively surveyed. The result is presented as either a novel observation or, if previously catalogued elsewhere, an independent algebraic rederivation with closed-form expression in terms of the correlation tensor. Reproducibility. The repository contains the LaTeX source, the bibliography, both figures, and seven Python scripts that reproduce every numerical claim from scratch using only NumPy and Matplotlib. Each script is self-contained and runs in seconds. Companion paper. This work extends the pedagogical note "State-dependent CHSH inequality on gate-based quantum processors" (Perez-Eugenio 2026, doi:10.5281/zenodo.20146219), which documents the original state-formula-angle compatibility issue and the corrected configurations. The present note can be read independently.