Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2607.11393

Symmetry tests for cyclic groups with quantum linear optics

Carlos Navas-Merlo, Juan Carlos García Escartín

quant-phSubmitted Jul 13, 2026• Announced Jul 14, 2026• 0 citations• Revised Sep 29, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Jul 13, 2026v2 · Sep 29, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Testing quantum states for symmetries has multiple applications in quantum state comparison or as a primitive in more complex quantum algorithms. We present a method that determines whether an input photonic state is invariant under the action of a cyclic group defined by an operator $\hat{S}$ with eigenvalues which are roots of unity. The results generalize previously known circle and SWAP tests related to suppression laws in Fourier interferometers and offer a new test for permutations defined by a binary shift and a way to search for eigenstates in multiphoton states. Finally, we discuss the scenarios where this measurement can be used to perform Hadamard test, a fundamental primitive in variational and quantum machine-learning algorithms.

Related papers

A Menagerie of Symmetry Testing Quantum Algorithms

Margarite L. LaBorde

In Chapter 1, we establish the mathematical background used throughout this thesis. We review concepts from group and representation theory. We further establish fundamental concepts from quantum information. This will allow us to then define the different notions of symmetry necessary in the following chapters. In Chapter 2, we investigate Hamiltonian symmetries. We propose quantum algorithms capable of testing whether a Hamiltonian exhibits symmetry with respect to a group. Furthermore, we show that this algorithm is that this algorithm is DQC1-Complete. Finally, we execute one of our symmetry-testing algorithms on existing quantum computers for simple examples. In Chapter 3, we discuss tests of symmetry for quantum states. For the case of testing Bose symmetry of a state, there is a simple and efficient quantum algorithm, while the tests for other kinds of symmetry rely on the aid of a quantum prover. We prove that the acceptance probability of each algorithm is equal to the maximum symmetric fidelity of the state being tested Finally, we establish various generalizations of the resource theory of asymmetry, with the upshot being that the acceptance probabilities of the algorithms are resource monotones. In Chapter 4, we begin by showing that the analytical form of the acceptance probability of such a test is given by the cycle index polynomial of the symmetric group ���� . We derive a family of quantum separability tests, each of which is generated by a finite group; for all such algorithms, we show that the acceptance probability is determined by the cycle index polynomial of the group. Finally, we produce and analyze explicit circuit constructions for these tests, showing that the tests corresponding to the symmetric and cyclic groups can be executed with ��(��2) and ��(�� log(��)) controlled-SWAP gates, respectively, where �� is the number of copies of the state In Chapter 5, we include additional results not previously published; in particular, we give a test for symmetry of a quantum state using density matrix exponentiation, a further result of Hamiltonian symmetry measurements when using Abelian groups, and an alternate Hamiltonian symmetry test construction for a block-encoded Hamiltonian.

arXiv:2305.14560•Civil War Book Review•Mar 7, 2023•1 citation

Native linear-optical protocol for efficient multivariate trace estimation

Leonardo Novo, Marco Robbio, Ernesto F. Galvão +1 more

The Hong-Ou-Mandel test estimates the overlap between spectral functions characterizing the internal degrees of freedom of two single photons. It can be viewed as a photon-native protocol that implements the well-known quantum SWAP test. Here, we propose a native linear-optical protocol that efficiently estimates multivariate traces of quantum states called Bargmann invariants, which are ubiquitous in quantum mechanics. Our protocol may be understood as a photon-native version of the cycle test in the circuit model, which encompasses many-photon multimode quantum states. We show the protocol is sample-efficient and discuss applications, such as generalized suppression laws, efficient quantum kernel estimation for quantum machine learning, eigenspectrum estimation, and the characterization of multiphoton indistinguishability.

quant-pharXiv:2601.14204•Jan 21, 2026•9 citations

The efficiency of quantum identity testing of multiple states

Masaru Kada, Harumichi Nishimura, Tomoyuki Yamakami

We examine two quantum operations, the permutation test and the circle test, which test the identity of n quantum states. These operations naturally extend the well-studied swap test on two quantum states. We first show the optimality of the permutation test for any input size n as well as the optimality of the circle test for three input states. In particular, when n = 3, we present a semi-classical protocol, incorporated with the swap test, which approximates the circle test efficiently. Furthermore, we show that, with the help of classical preprocessing, a single use of the circle test can approximate the permutation test efficiently for an arbitrary input size n .

arXiv:0809.2037•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Sep 8, 2008•25 citations

Learning quantum symmetries

Isaac Holt, Sathyawageeswar Subramanian

Quantum algorithms are powerful tools for finding symmetries of classical objects, most famously through Shor's algorithm and the Hidden Subgroup Problem (HSP). In this work, we study quantum algorithms for learning symmetries of \emph{quantum} objects. Existing work in this area centres on the recently introduced State Hidden Subgroup Problem (StateHSP), a quantum generalisation of HSP in which the task is to learn the symmetry subgroup of a quantum state. We develop efficient quantum algorithms for non-abelian StateHSP when the hidden subgroup is normal and the ambient group belongs to a broad class of non-abelian groups, extending the previous general theory beyond the abelian setting. StateHSP learns \emph{Bose} symmetries, under which a state must be invariant exactly under the action of the symmetry group. In quantum mechanics, however, physically equivalent pure states are defined only up to global phase. Motivated by this, we introduce a natural notion of \emph{Anyonic} state symmetry learning, based on invariance up to global phase. We give an efficient quantum algorithm by reducing the problem to StateHSP, where the reduction rests on a new correspondence between linearisations of projective representations and linear error-correcting codes. As an application, we obtain an improved algorithm for learning stabiliser groups of mixed qudit states of arbitrary local dimension. Finally, we introduce symmetry learning problems for other quantum objects, including unitaries, Hamiltonians, and finite collections of states, and give efficient algorithms for them by reduction to state symmetry learning. Together, these results broaden the scope of state symmetry learning as a common algorithmic primitive for learning quantum symmetries.

quant-pharXiv:2609.38085•Sep 30, 2026•0 citations

Permutation tests for quantum state identity

Harry Buhrman, Dmitry Grinko, Philip Verduyn Lunel +1 more

The quantum analogue of the equality function, known as the quantum state identity problem, is the task of deciding whether $n$ unknown quantum states are equal or unequal, given the promise that all states are either pairwise orthogonal or identical. Under the one-sided error requirement, it is known that the permutation test is optimal for this task, and for two input states this coincides with the well-known Swap test. Until now, the optimal measurement in the general two-sided error regime was unknown. Under more specific promises, the problem can be solved approximately or even optimally with simpler tests, such as the circle test. This work attempts to capture the underlying structure of the quantum state identity problem. Using tools from semidefinite programming and representation theory, we (i) give an optimal test for any input distribution without the one-sided error requirement by writing the problem as an SDP, giving the exact solutions to the primal and dual programs and showing that the two values coincide; (ii) propose a general $G$-test which uses an arbitrary subgroup $G$ of $\text{S}_n$, giving an analytic expression of the performance of the specific test, and (iii) give an approximation of the permutation test using only a classical permutation and $n-1$ Swap tests.

arXiv:2405.09626•May 15, 2024•12 citations

Quantum search processes in the cyclic group state spaces

Xijia Miao

The hardness to solve an unstructured quantum search problem by a standard quantum search algorithm mainly originates from the low efficiency to amplify the amplitude of the marked state by the oracle unitary operation associated with other known quantum operations. In order to bypass the square speedup limitation of a standard quantum search algorithm it is necessary to develop other type of quantum search algorithms. It is described in detail in the paper for a quantum dynamical method to solve the quantum search problems in the cyclic group state space. The binary dynamical representation for a quantum state in the Hilbert space of the n-qubit quantum system is generalized to the multi-base dynamical representation for a quantum state in the cyclic group state space. Thus, any quantum state in the cyclic group state space may be described completely in terms of a set of dynamical parameters that are closely related to the symmetric property and structure of the cyclic group. The quantum search problem therefore could be solved by determining the set of dynamical parameters that describe completely the unknown marked state of the search problem instead by directly measuring the marked state which is a necessary step in the standard quantum search algorithm. An unstructured quantum search problem in the Hilbert space is inevitably affected greatly by the symmetric property and structure of a group. The main attempt of the paper is to make use of the symmetric properties and structures of groups to help solving the quantum search problems in the group state spaces. It is shown how the quantum search process could be reduced from the cyclic group state space to these cyclic group state subspaces with the help of the symmetric property and structure of the cyclic group on a universal quantum computer.

arXiv:quant-ph/0507236•Jul 25, 2005•5 citations
Testing quantum states for symmetries has multiple applications in quantum state comparison or as a primitive in more complex quantum algorithms. We present a method that determines whether an input photonic state is invariant under the action of a cyclic group defined by an operator S^\hat{S}S^ with eigenvalues which are roots of unity. The results generalize previously known circle and SWAP tests related to suppression laws in Fourier interferometers and offer a new test for permutations defined by a binary shift and a way to search for eigenstates in multiphoton states. Finally, we discuss the scenarios where this measurement can be used to perform Hadamard test, a fundamental primitive in variational and quantum machine-learning algorithms.
In Chapter 1, we establish the mathematical background used throughout this thesis. We review concepts from group and representation theory. We further establish fundamental concepts from quantum information. This will allow us to then define the different notions of symmetry necessary in the following chapters. In Chapter 2, we investigate Hamiltonian symmetries. We propose quantum algorithms capable of testing whether a Hamiltonian exhibits symmetry with respect to a group. Furthermore, we show that this algorithm is that this algorithm is DQC1-Complete. Finally, we execute one of our symmetry-testing algorithms on existing quantum computers for simple examples. In Chapter 3, we discuss tests of symmetry for quantum states. For the case of testing Bose symmetry of a state, there is a simple and efficient quantum algorithm, while the tests for other kinds of symmetry rely on the aid of a quantum prover. We prove that the acceptance probability of each algorithm is equal to the maximum symmetric fidelity of the state being tested Finally, we establish various generalizations of the resource theory of asymmetry, with the upshot being that the acceptance probabilities of the algorithms are resource monotones. In Chapter 4, we begin by showing that the analytical form of the acceptance probability of such a test is given by the cycle index polynomial of the symmetric group ���� . We derive a family of quantum separability tests, each of which is generated by a finite group; for all such algorithms, we show that the acceptance probability is determined by the cycle index polynomial of the group. Finally, we produce and analyze explicit circuit constructions for these tests, showing that the tests corresponding to the symmetric and cyclic groups can be executed with ��(��2) and ��(�� log(��)) controlled-SWAP gates, respectively, where �� is the number of copies of the state In Chapter 5, we include additional results not previously published; in particular, we give a test for symmetry of a quantum state using density matrix exponentiation, a further result of Hamiltonian symmetry measurements when using Abelian groups, and an alternate Hamiltonian symmetry test construction for a block-encoded Hamiltonian.
The Hong-Ou-Mandel test estimates the overlap between spectral functions characterizing the internal degrees of freedom of two single photons. It can be viewed as a photon-native protocol that implements the well-known quantum SWAP test. Here, we propose a native linear-optical protocol that efficiently estimates multivariate traces of quantum states called Bargmann invariants, which are ubiquitous in quantum mechanics. Our protocol may be understood as a photon-native version of the cycle test in the circuit model, which encompasses many-photon multimode quantum states. We show the protocol is sample-efficient and discuss applications, such as generalized suppression laws, efficient quantum kernel estimation for quantum machine learning, eigenspectrum estimation, and the characterization of multiphoton indistinguishability.
We examine two quantum operations, the permutation test and the circle test, which test the identity of n quantum states. These operations naturally extend the well-studied swap test on two quantum states. We first show the optimality of the permutation test for any input size n as well as the optimality of the circle test for three input states. In particular, when n = 3, we present a semi-classical protocol, incorporated with the swap test, which approximates the circle test efficiently. Furthermore, we show that, with the help of classical preprocessing, a single use of the circle test can approximate the permutation test efficiently for an arbitrary input size n .
Quantum algorithms are powerful tools for finding symmetries of classical objects, most famously through Shor's algorithm and the Hidden Subgroup Problem (HSP). In this work, we study quantum algorithms for learning symmetries of \emph{quantum} objects. Existing work in this area centres on the recently introduced State Hidden Subgroup Problem (StateHSP), a quantum generalisation of HSP in which the task is to learn the symmetry subgroup of a quantum state. We develop efficient quantum algorithms for non-abelian StateHSP when the hidden subgroup is normal and the ambient group belongs to a broad class of non-abelian groups, extending the previous general theory beyond the abelian setting. StateHSP learns \emph{Bose} symmetries, under which a state must be invariant exactly under the action of the symmetry group. In quantum mechanics, however, physically equivalent pure states are defined only up to global phase. Motivated by this, we introduce a natural notion of \emph{Anyonic} state symmetry learning, based on invariance up to global phase. We give an efficient quantum algorithm by reducing the problem to StateHSP, where the reduction rests on a new correspondence between linearisations of projective representations and linear error-correcting codes. As an application, we obtain an improved algorithm for learning stabiliser groups of mixed qudit states of arbitrary local dimension. Finally, we introduce symmetry learning problems for other quantum objects, including unitaries, Hamiltonians, and finite collections of states, and give efficient algorithms for them by reduction to state symmetry learning. Together, these results broaden the scope of state symmetry learning as a common algorithmic primitive for learning quantum symmetries.
The quantum analogue of the equality function, known as the quantum state identity problem, is the task of deciding whether nnn unknown quantum states are equal or unequal, given the promise that all states are either pairwise orthogonal or identical. Under the one-sided error requirement, it is known that the permutation test is optimal for this task, and for two input states this coincides with the well-known Swap test. Until now, the optimal measurement in the general two-sided error regime was unknown. Under more specific promises, the problem can be solved approximately or even optimally with simpler tests, such as the circle test. This work attempts to capture the underlying structure of the quantum state identity problem. Using tools from semidefinite programming and representation theory, we (i) give an optimal test for any input distribution without the one-sided error requirement by writing the problem as an SDP, giving the exact solutions to the primal and dual programs and showing that the two values coincide; (ii) propose a general GGG-test which uses an arbitrary subgroup GGG of Sn\text{S}_nSn​, giving an analytic expression of the performance of the specific test, and (iii) give an approximation of the permutation test using only a classical permutation and n−1n-1n−1 Swap tests.
The hardness to solve an unstructured quantum search problem by a standard quantum search algorithm mainly originates from the low efficiency to amplify the amplitude of the marked state by the oracle unitary operation associated with other known quantum operations. In order to bypass the square speedup limitation of a standard quantum search algorithm it is necessary to develop other type of quantum search algorithms. It is described in detail in the paper for a quantum dynamical method to solve the quantum search problems in the cyclic group state space. The binary dynamical representation for a quantum state in the Hilbert space of the n-qubit quantum system is generalized to the multi-base dynamical representation for a quantum state in the cyclic group state space. Thus, any quantum state in the cyclic group state space may be described completely in terms of a set of dynamical parameters that are closely related to the symmetric property and structure of the cyclic group. The quantum search problem therefore could be solved by determining the set of dynamical parameters that describe completely the unknown marked state of the search problem instead by directly measuring the marked state which is a necessary step in the standard quantum search algorithm. An unstructured quantum search problem in the Hilbert space is inevitably affected greatly by the symmetric property and structure of a group. The main attempt of the paper is to make use of the symmetric properties and structures of groups to help solving the quantum search problems in the group state spaces. It is shown how the quantum search process could be reduced from the cyclic group state space to these cyclic group state subspaces with the help of the symmetric property and structure of the cyclic group on a universal quantum computer.