Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2607.01712

Quantum Noncommutativity Uniquely Determines Relative Entropy

Gilad Gour

quant-phmath-phSubmitted Jul 2, 2026• Announced Jul 3, 2026• 4 citations• Revised Jul 30, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Jul 2, 2026v2 · Jul 30, 2026v3 · Oct 31, 2026v4 · Nov 3, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum relative entropy is a core concept in physics, governing the limits of communication, thermodynamic irreversibility and quantum resource conversion. However, the requirement that physical processes cannot increase state distinguishability, the data-processing inequality, permits an infinite family of alternative divergence measures. Here we show that quantum relative entropy is uniquely selected by a sharper operational principle. We evaluate distinguishability through binary guessing games, in which an observer discriminates between pairs of quantum states using the optimal measurement. We prove that any additive measure that respects the odds revealed by these optimal measurements must coincide with the Umegaki relative entropy. This rigidity is a purely quantum phenomenon. Whereas classical theory permits a continuous family of valid divergence measures, including Rényi divergences, quantum noncommutativity. collapses this mathematical freedom. The result is exact, requiring neither a thermodynamic limit of infinitely many copies nor super-additivity assumptions for correlated states. It establishes quantum relative entropy not merely as an asymptotic quantity, but as the unique additive distinguishability measure compatible with single-shot quantum discrimination.

Comments
Revised version: added an operational interpretation of Frenkel's integral formula in terms of binary guessing probabilities, together with a new figure and an appendix proof; also improved the terminology and historical attribution

Related papers

Quantum Relative-alpha-Entropies: A Structural and Geometric Perspective

Sayantan Roy, Atin Gayen, Aditi Kar Gangopadhyay +1 more

Most quantum divergences derive their structure from classical f-divergences or Renyi-type constructions, a dependence that obscures several quantum geometric effects. We introduce a quantum relative-alpha-entropy that extends Umegaki's relative entropy while falling outside the f-divergence class. The proposed divergence exhibits a nonlinear convexity property, which yields a generalized convexity result for the Petz-Renyi divergence for alpha greater than one, complementing the known convexity for alpha less than one. It is additive under tensor products, invariant under unitary transformations, and depends only on the relative geometry of quantum states rather than their absolute magnitudes. Using Nussbaum-Szkola-type distributions, we also establish an exact correspondence of this divergence with classical relative-alpha-entropy. This reveals relative-alpha-entropy as a fundamentally geometric notion of quantum distinguishability not captured by existing divergence frameworks.

quant-pharXiv:2604.06908•Apr 9, 2026•0 citations

Relative entropy and catalytic relative majorization

Soorya Rethinasamy, Mark M. Wilde

Given two pairs of quantum states, a fundamental question in the resource theory of asymmetric distinguishability is whether there exists a quantum channel converting one pair to the other.In this work, we reframe this question in such a way that a catalyst can be used to help perform the transformation, with the only constraint on the catalyst being that its reduced state is returned unchanged, so that it can be used again to assist a future transformation.What we find here, for the special case in which the states in a given pair are commuting, and thus quasiclassical, is that this catalytic transformation can be performed if and only if the relative entropy of one pair of states is larger than that of the other pair.This result endows the relative entropy with a fundamental operational meaning that goes beyond its traditional interpretation in the setting of independent and identical resources.Our finding thus has an immediate application and interpretation in the resource theory of asymmetric distinguishability, and we expect it to find application in other domains.

arXiv:1912.04254•Physical Review Research•Sep 21, 2020•31 citations

Maximal Rényi Relative Entropy for $α>2$

Roberto Rubboli

Quantum relative entropies play a fundamental role in quantum information theory. In the classical setting, Rényi relative entropies constitute, up to linear combinations, the most general class of relative entropies, naturally motivating the search for their minimal and maximal quantum extensions. The minimal extension is known to be the reverse sandwiched Rényi relative entropy for $α\in[0,1/2)$ and the sandwiched Rényi relative entropy for $α\geq 1/2$. In contrast, the maximal extension had previously been identified only for $α\in[0,2]$, where it is given by the geometric Rényi relative entropy. In this work, we complete this characterization by proving that for $α>2$, the maximal extension is given by the $α$-$z$ Rényi relative entropy with $z=α-1$. As an application, we determine when an energy-incoherent state can be transformed into an energy-coherent state by a Gibbs-preserving operation assisted by an uncorrelated catalyst, thereby fully characterizing the coherence-generating power of this class of operations in the catalytic setting.

quant-pharXiv:2608.01124•Aug 4, 2026•3 citations

Axiomatic Characterization of the Quantum Relative Entropy and Free Energy

Henrik Wilming, Rodrigo Gallego, Jens Eisert

Building upon work by Matsumoto, we show that the quantum relative entropy with full-rank second argument is determined by four simple axioms: (i) Continuity in the first argument; (ii) the validity of the data-processing inequality; (iii) additivity under tensor products; and (iv) super-additivity. This observation has immediate implications for quantum thermodynamics, which we discuss. Specifically, we demonstrate that, under reasonable restrictions, the free energy is singled out as a measure of athermality. In particular, we consider an extended class of Gibbs-preserving maps as free operations in a resource-theoretic framework, in which a catalyst is allowed to build up correlations with the system at hand. The free energy is the only extensive and continuous function that is monotonic under such free operations.

arXiv:1702.08473•Entropy•May 23, 2017•52 citations

Single-letter Chain Rule for Quantum Relative Entropy

Giulio Gasbarri, Matt Hoogsteder Riera

Relative entropy is the standard measure of distinguishability in classical and quantum information theory. In the classical case, its loss under channels admits an exact chain rule, while in the quantum case only asymptotic, regularized chain rules are known. We establish new chain rules for quantum relative entropy that apply already in the single-copy regime. The first inequality can be naturally obtained via POVM decompositions, extending the point distributions in the classical chain rule to quantum ensemble partitions. The second gives a sufficient condition for the most natural extension of the classical result, which uses projectors as an analog for the classical point distributions. We additionally find a semiclassical chain rule where the point distributions are replaced with the projectors of the initial states, and, finally, we find a relation to previous works on strengthened data processing inequalities and recoverability. These results show that meaningful chain inequalities are possible already at the single-copy level, but they also highlight that tighter bounds remain to be found.

arXiv:2510.16918•Oct 19, 2025•0 citations

Entropies and Relative Entropies

Gilad Gour

Chapter 6 builds upon the foundation of divergences from Chapter 5, advancing into entropies and relative entropies with an axiomatic approach, and the inclusion of the additivity axiom. The chapter delves into the classical and quantum relative entropies, establishing their core properties and revealing the significance of the KL-divergence introduced in Chapter 5, notably characterized by asymptotic continuity. Quantum relative entropies are addressed as generalizations of classical ones, with a focus on the conditions necessary for these measures in the quantum framework. Several variants of relative entropies are discussed, including Renyi relative entropies and their extensions to quantum domain such as the Petz quantum Renyi divergence, minimal quantum Renyi divergence, and the maximal quantum Renyi divergence. This discourse underlines the relevance of continuity and its relation to faithfulness in relative entropies. The concept of entropy is portrayed as a measure with a broad spectrum of interpretations and applications across fields, from thermodynamics and information theory to cosmology and economics.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 10, 2025•0 citations
Quantum relative entropy is a core concept in physics, governing the limits of communication, thermodynamic irreversibility and quantum resource conversion. However, the requirement that physical processes cannot increase state distinguishability, the data-processing inequality, permits an infinite family of alternative divergence measures. Here we show that quantum relative entropy is uniquely selected by a sharper operational principle. We evaluate distinguishability through binary guessing games, in which an observer discriminates between pairs of quantum states using the optimal measurement. We prove that any additive measure that respects the odds revealed by these optimal measurements must coincide with the Umegaki relative entropy. This rigidity is a purely quantum phenomenon. Whereas classical theory permits a continuous family of valid divergence measures, including Rényi divergences, quantum noncommutativity. collapses this mathematical freedom. The result is exact, requiring neither a thermodynamic limit of infinitely many copies nor super-additivity assumptions for correlated states. It establishes quantum relative entropy not merely as an asymptotic quantity, but as the unique additive distinguishability measure compatible with single-shot quantum discrimination.
Most quantum divergences derive their structure from classical f-divergences or Renyi-type constructions, a dependence that obscures several quantum geometric effects. We introduce a quantum relative-alpha-entropy that extends Umegaki's relative entropy while falling outside the f-divergence class. The proposed divergence exhibits a nonlinear convexity property, which yields a generalized convexity result for the Petz-Renyi divergence for alpha greater than one, complementing the known convexity for alpha less than one. It is additive under tensor products, invariant under unitary transformations, and depends only on the relative geometry of quantum states rather than their absolute magnitudes. Using Nussbaum-Szkola-type distributions, we also establish an exact correspondence of this divergence with classical relative-alpha-entropy. This reveals relative-alpha-entropy as a fundamentally geometric notion of quantum distinguishability not captured by existing divergence frameworks.
Given two pairs of quantum states, a fundamental question in the resource theory of asymmetric distinguishability is whether there exists a quantum channel converting one pair to the other.In this work, we reframe this question in such a way that a catalyst can be used to help perform the transformation, with the only constraint on the catalyst being that its reduced state is returned unchanged, so that it can be used again to assist a future transformation.What we find here, for the special case in which the states in a given pair are commuting, and thus quasiclassical, is that this catalytic transformation can be performed if and only if the relative entropy of one pair of states is larger than that of the other pair.This result endows the relative entropy with a fundamental operational meaning that goes beyond its traditional interpretation in the setting of independent and identical resources.Our finding thus has an immediate application and interpretation in the resource theory of asymmetric distinguishability, and we expect it to find application in other domains.
Maximal Rényi Relative Entropy for α>2α>2α>2
Quantum relative entropies play a fundamental role in quantum information theory. In the classical setting, Rényi relative entropies constitute, up to linear combinations, the most general class of relative entropies, naturally motivating the search for their minimal and maximal quantum extensions. The minimal extension is known to be the reverse sandwiched Rényi relative entropy for α∈[0,1/2)α\in[0,1/2)α∈[0,1/2) and the sandwiched Rényi relative entropy for α≥1/2α\geq 1/2α≥1/2. In contrast, the maximal extension had previously been identified only for α∈[0,2]α\in[0,2]α∈[0,2], where it is given by the geometric Rényi relative entropy. In this work, we complete this characterization by proving that for α>2α>2α>2, the maximal extension is given by the ααα-zzz Rényi relative entropy with z=α−1z=α-1z=α−1. As an application, we determine when an energy-incoherent state can be transformed into an energy-coherent state by a Gibbs-preserving operation assisted by an uncorrelated catalyst, thereby fully characterizing the coherence-generating power of this class of operations in the catalytic setting.
Building upon work by Matsumoto, we show that the quantum relative entropy with full-rank second argument is determined by four simple axioms: (i) Continuity in the first argument; (ii) the validity of the data-processing inequality; (iii) additivity under tensor products; and (iv) super-additivity. This observation has immediate implications for quantum thermodynamics, which we discuss. Specifically, we demonstrate that, under reasonable restrictions, the free energy is singled out as a measure of athermality. In particular, we consider an extended class of Gibbs-preserving maps as free operations in a resource-theoretic framework, in which a catalyst is allowed to build up correlations with the system at hand. The free energy is the only extensive and continuous function that is monotonic under such free operations.
Relative entropy is the standard measure of distinguishability in classical and quantum information theory. In the classical case, its loss under channels admits an exact chain rule, while in the quantum case only asymptotic, regularized chain rules are known. We establish new chain rules for quantum relative entropy that apply already in the single-copy regime. The first inequality can be naturally obtained via POVM decompositions, extending the point distributions in the classical chain rule to quantum ensemble partitions. The second gives a sufficient condition for the most natural extension of the classical result, which uses projectors as an analog for the classical point distributions. We additionally find a semiclassical chain rule where the point distributions are replaced with the projectors of the initial states, and, finally, we find a relation to previous works on strengthened data processing inequalities and recoverability. These results show that meaningful chain inequalities are possible already at the single-copy level, but they also highlight that tighter bounds remain to be found.
Chapter 6 builds upon the foundation of divergences from Chapter 5, advancing into entropies and relative entropies with an axiomatic approach, and the inclusion of the additivity axiom. The chapter delves into the classical and quantum relative entropies, establishing their core properties and revealing the significance of the KL-divergence introduced in Chapter 5, notably characterized by asymptotic continuity. Quantum relative entropies are addressed as generalizations of classical ones, with a focus on the conditions necessary for these measures in the quantum framework. Several variants of relative entropies are discussed, including Renyi relative entropies and their extensions to quantum domain such as the Petz quantum Renyi divergence, minimal quantum Renyi divergence, and the maximal quantum Renyi divergence. This discourse underlines the relevance of continuity and its relation to faithfulness in relative entropies. The concept of entropy is portrayed as a measure with a broad spectrum of interpretations and applications across fields, from thermodynamics and information theory to cosmology and economics.