Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2606.16451

Detecting basis-dependent hardware errors through spatio-temporal quantum steering

Hsiang-Wei Huang, Kuo-Feng Chiu, Yi-Te Huang, Jhen-Dong Lin, Tse-Ming Chen, Yueh-Nan Chen

quant-phSubmitted Jun 15, 2026• Announced Jun 16, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Spatio-temporal quantum steering provides a framework for benchmarking the nonclassicality of general quantum state transfer processes. A central diagnostic is the no-signaling-in-time (NSIT) condition, whose violation can indicate basis-dependent hardware errors. However, finite measurement statistics may also yield apparent violations, thereby obscuring the detection of basis-dependent hardware errors. To address this, we construct a statistical hypothesis test under the null hypothesis that NSIT violations arise solely from statistical fluctuations. Combining the statistical properties of NSIT violation under the null hypothesis with Chebyshev's inequality, we obtain a distribution-free upper bound on the $p$-value without parametric assumptions. We apply this method to two examples. For a single-qubit state-transfer experiment on a superconducting processor, we observe several instances that the NSIT violation is observed and the null hypothesis is simultaneously rejected by a small $p$-value, providing statistical evidence of basis-dependent hardware errors. For a seven-qubit Hayden-Preskill teleportation protocol on IonQ devices, the null hypothesis is also rejected even when the average fidelity exceeds the classical threshold, while the associated nonclassicality measure vanishes. Our results highlight the necessity of statistical hypothesis testing for detecting basis-dependent errors in near-term quantum devices.

Related papers

Bell and EPR experiments with signalling data

Lucas Maquedano, Sophie Egelhaaf, Amro Abou-Hachem +4 more

The no-signalling principle is a fundamental assumption in Bell-inequality and quantum-steering experiments. Nonetheless, experimental imperfections can lead to apparent violations beyond those expected from finite-sample statistics. Here, we propose extensions of local hidden variable and local hidden state theories that allow for bounded, operationally quantifiable, amounts of signalling. We show how non-classicality tests can be developed for these models, both through exact methods based on the full set of observed statistics and through corrections to the standard Bell and steering inequalities. We demonstrate the applicability of these methods via two scenarios that feature apparent signalling: an IBM quantum processor and post-selected data from inefficient detectors.

quant-pharXiv:2602.05507•Quantum Science and Technology•Feb 6, 2026•1 citation

Benchmarking quantum state transfer on quantum devices

Yi-Te Huang, Jhen-Dong Lin, Huan-Yu Ku +1 more

Quantum state transfer (QST) provides a method to send arbitrary quantum states from one system to another.Such a concept is crucial for transmitting quantum information into the quantum memory, quantum processor, and quantum network.The standard benchmark of QST is the average fidelity between the prepared and received states.In this work we provide a new benchmark which reveals the nonclassicality of QST based on spatiotemporal steering (STS).More specifically, we show that the local-hidden-state (LHS) model in STS can be viewed as the classical strategy of state transfer.Therefore, we can quantify the nonclassicality of the QST process by measuring the spatiotemporal steerability.We then apply the spatiotemporal steerability measurement technique to benchmark quantum devices including the IBM quantum experience and QuTech quantum inspire under QST tasks.The experimental results show that the spatiotemporal steerability decreases as the circuit depth increases, and the reduction agrees with the noise model, which refers to the accumulation of errors during the QST process.Moreover, we provide a quantity to estimate the signaling effect which could result from gate errors or intrinsic non-Markovian effect of the devices.

arXiv:2009.07425•Physical Review Research•Apr 12, 2021•13 citations

Certification of two-qubit quantum systems with temporal inequality

Chellasamy Jebarathinam, Gautam Sharma, Sk Sazim +1 more

Self-testing of quantum devices based on observed measurement statistics is a method to certify quantum systems using minimal resources. In Irfan et al. [A. A. M. Irfan, K. Mayer, G. Ortiz, and E. Knill, Phys. Rev. A 101, 032106 (2020)] a scheme based on observing measurement statistics that demonstrate Kochen-Specker contextuality has been shown to certify two-qubit entangled states and measurements without the requirement of spatial separation between the subsystems. However, this scheme assumes a set of compatibility conditions on the measurements which are crucial to demonstrating Kochen-Specker contextuality. In this paper, we propose a self-testing protocol to certify the above two-qubit states and measurements without the assumption of the compatibility conditions, and at the same time without requiring the spatial separation between the subsystems. Our protocol is based on the observation of sequential correlations leading to the maximal violation of a temporal inequality derived from noncontextuality inequality. Moreover, our protocol is robust to small experimental errors or noise.

arXiv:2307.06710•Physical Review A•Aug 6, 2024•3 citations

Spatio-Temporal Steering for Testing Nonclassical Correlations in Quantum Networks

Shin-Liang Chen, Neill Lambert, Che-Ming Li +4 more

We introduce the concept of spatio-temporal steering (STS), which reduces, in special cases, to Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen steering and the recently-introduced temporal steering. We describe two measures of this effect referred to as the STS weight and robustness. We suggest that these STS measures enable a new way to assess nonclassical correlations in an open quantum network, such as quantum transport through nano-structures or excitation transfer in a complex biological system. As one of our examples, we apply STS to check nonclassical correlations among sites in a photosynthetic pigment-protein complex in the Fenna-Matthews-Olson model.

arXiv:1608.03150•Scientific Reports•Jun 12, 2017•35 citations

A Preparation Nonstationarity Loophole in Superconducting-Qubit Bell Tests

Prosanta Pal, Shubhanshu Karoliya, Gargee Sharma +1 more

Bell or Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) tests on superconducting quantum processors are commonly interpreted under the assumption that repeated circuit executions sample a single, stationary preparation ensemble. Here we show that this assumption can be violated on contemporary hardware, with direct implications for the interpretation of observed Bell violations. We introduce an ensemble-divergence framework in which slow temporal drift of the preparation process induces context-dependent effective ensembles, even when measurement independence and locality are preserved. This leads to a relaxed Bell bound $|S| \le 2 + 6δ_{\mathrm{ens}}$, where $δ_{\mathrm{ens}}$ quantifies preparation nonstationarity. Because $δ_{\mathrm{ens}}$ is not directly observable, we develop an operational witness $δ_{\mathrm{op}}$ based on bin-resolved outcome statistics for fixed measurement channels. Using Pauli-axis measurements on IBM superconducting processors, we observe statistically significant operational drift that persists after full two-qubit readout mitigation, ruling out measurement artifacts. In contrast, drift extracted from CHSH-optimal measurements is eliminated by mitigation, demonstrating that such settings are unsuitable for diagnosing preparation nonstationarity. We further show that the observed Bell violations imply only modest ensemble divergences, comparable in scale to those required in Hall-type measurement-dependence models, but arising here solely from preparation drift combined with experimental scheduling. Our results identify a preparation-dependent loophole relevant to Bell tests on noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices and highlight the necessity of drift-aware protocols for reliable quantum certification.

quant-pharXiv:2601.08290•Physical Review A•Jan 14, 2026•0 citations

Statistical Hypothesis Testing for Efficient Black-Box Quantum Program Testing

Tiancheng Jin, Bo Yang, Haibo Yu +1 more

Quantum computing offers exponential computational advantages across diverse application domains, yet the inherent probabilistic nature of quantum measurements poses challenges for program testing. Existing quantum black-box testing approaches rely on ad-hoc tolerance checks applied to empirical probability distributions estimated from large measurement samples, often requiring a large number of measurements, because of lacking formal Type I error control, power guarantees, or principled sample size determination. We present a statistical hypothesis-testing method for quantum program testing, encompassing two paradigms: marginal probability testing and joint distribution testing over the full$2^{d}$-dimensional state space. By combining exact and asymptotic tests, bootstrap procedures, sequential designs, and kernel-based two-sample testing, our method provides rigorous error control with substantially improved sample efficiency. Experiments on quantum programs with 2 to 12 qubits show measurement reductions from 97 to 99 percent over the conventional practice of ten thousand shots against strong synthetic faults. A structural mutation study separates the faults that every test detects at one hundred measurements from those that no measurement-based test can detect. The exact marginal test, the exact branch of the sequential design, and the permutation-calibrated joint tests control the Type I error rate at or below the nominal level of 0.05. The adaptive chi-square branch is mildly anticonservative on random states, with a median of 0.060, and conservative on the named benchmarks. On QFT, the sequential design rejects a faulty program with 32 to 85 percent fewer measurements than a properly powered fixed-sample test at two to twelve qubits on its adaptive branch, and with 19 to 60 percent fewer on its exact branch, which is valid under any dependence and reaches the target power from four qubits upward. Power exceeds 0.80 above a characterized fault strength, and faults that preserve the output distribution are shown to be undetectable by any measurement-based test. These results establish a principled and practical foundation for quantum program testing.

IEEE Access•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations
Spatio-temporal quantum steering provides a framework for benchmarking the nonclassicality of general quantum state transfer processes. A central diagnostic is the no-signaling-in-time (NSIT) condition, whose violation can indicate basis-dependent hardware errors. However, finite measurement statistics may also yield apparent violations, thereby obscuring the detection of basis-dependent hardware errors. To address this, we construct a statistical hypothesis test under the null hypothesis that NSIT violations arise solely from statistical fluctuations. Combining the statistical properties of NSIT violation under the null hypothesis with Chebyshev's inequality, we obtain a distribution-free upper bound on the ppp-value without parametric assumptions. We apply this method to two examples. For a single-qubit state-transfer experiment on a superconducting processor, we observe several instances that the NSIT violation is observed and the null hypothesis is simultaneously rejected by a small ppp-value, providing statistical evidence of basis-dependent hardware errors. For a seven-qubit Hayden-Preskill teleportation protocol on IonQ devices, the null hypothesis is also rejected even when the average fidelity exceeds the classical threshold, while the associated nonclassicality measure vanishes. Our results highlight the necessity of statistical hypothesis testing for detecting basis-dependent errors in near-term quantum devices.
The no-signalling principle is a fundamental assumption in Bell-inequality and quantum-steering experiments. Nonetheless, experimental imperfections can lead to apparent violations beyond those expected from finite-sample statistics. Here, we propose extensions of local hidden variable and local hidden state theories that allow for bounded, operationally quantifiable, amounts of signalling. We show how non-classicality tests can be developed for these models, both through exact methods based on the full set of observed statistics and through corrections to the standard Bell and steering inequalities. We demonstrate the applicability of these methods via two scenarios that feature apparent signalling: an IBM quantum processor and post-selected data from inefficient detectors.
Quantum state transfer (QST) provides a method to send arbitrary quantum states from one system to another.Such a concept is crucial for transmitting quantum information into the quantum memory, quantum processor, and quantum network.The standard benchmark of QST is the average fidelity between the prepared and received states.In this work we provide a new benchmark which reveals the nonclassicality of QST based on spatiotemporal steering (STS).More specifically, we show that the local-hidden-state (LHS) model in STS can be viewed as the classical strategy of state transfer.Therefore, we can quantify the nonclassicality of the QST process by measuring the spatiotemporal steerability.We then apply the spatiotemporal steerability measurement technique to benchmark quantum devices including the IBM quantum experience and QuTech quantum inspire under QST tasks.The experimental results show that the spatiotemporal steerability decreases as the circuit depth increases, and the reduction agrees with the noise model, which refers to the accumulation of errors during the QST process.Moreover, we provide a quantity to estimate the signaling effect which could result from gate errors or intrinsic non-Markovian effect of the devices.
Self-testing of quantum devices based on observed measurement statistics is a method to certify quantum systems using minimal resources. In Irfan et al. [A. A. M. Irfan, K. Mayer, G. Ortiz, and E. Knill, Phys. Rev. A 101, 032106 (2020)] a scheme based on observing measurement statistics that demonstrate Kochen-Specker contextuality has been shown to certify two-qubit entangled states and measurements without the requirement of spatial separation between the subsystems. However, this scheme assumes a set of compatibility conditions on the measurements which are crucial to demonstrating Kochen-Specker contextuality. In this paper, we propose a self-testing protocol to certify the above two-qubit states and measurements without the assumption of the compatibility conditions, and at the same time without requiring the spatial separation between the subsystems. Our protocol is based on the observation of sequential correlations leading to the maximal violation of a temporal inequality derived from noncontextuality inequality. Moreover, our protocol is robust to small experimental errors or noise.
We introduce the concept of spatio-temporal steering (STS), which reduces, in special cases, to Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen steering and the recently-introduced temporal steering. We describe two measures of this effect referred to as the STS weight and robustness. We suggest that these STS measures enable a new way to assess nonclassical correlations in an open quantum network, such as quantum transport through nano-structures or excitation transfer in a complex biological system. As one of our examples, we apply STS to check nonclassical correlations among sites in a photosynthetic pigment-protein complex in the Fenna-Matthews-Olson model.
Bell or Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) tests on superconducting quantum processors are commonly interpreted under the assumption that repeated circuit executions sample a single, stationary preparation ensemble. Here we show that this assumption can be violated on contemporary hardware, with direct implications for the interpretation of observed Bell violations. We introduce an ensemble-divergence framework in which slow temporal drift of the preparation process induces context-dependent effective ensembles, even when measurement independence and locality are preserved. This leads to a relaxed Bell bound ∣S∣≤2+6δens|S| \le 2 + 6δ_{\mathrm{ens}}∣S∣≤2+6δens​, where δensδ_{\mathrm{ens}}δens​ quantifies preparation nonstationarity. Because δensδ_{\mathrm{ens}}δens​ is not directly observable, we develop an operational witness δopδ_{\mathrm{op}}δop​ based on bin-resolved outcome statistics for fixed measurement channels. Using Pauli-axis measurements on IBM superconducting processors, we observe statistically significant operational drift that persists after full two-qubit readout mitigation, ruling out measurement artifacts. In contrast, drift extracted from CHSH-optimal measurements is eliminated by mitigation, demonstrating that such settings are unsuitable for diagnosing preparation nonstationarity. We further show that the observed Bell violations imply only modest ensemble divergences, comparable in scale to those required in Hall-type measurement-dependence models, but arising here solely from preparation drift combined with experimental scheduling. Our results identify a preparation-dependent loophole relevant to Bell tests on noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices and highlight the necessity of drift-aware protocols for reliable quantum certification.
Quantum computing offers exponential computational advantages across diverse application domains, yet the inherent probabilistic nature of quantum measurements poses challenges for program testing. Existing quantum black-box testing approaches rely on ad-hoc tolerance checks applied to empirical probability distributions estimated from large measurement samples, often requiring a large number of measurements, because of lacking formal Type I error control, power guarantees, or principled sample size determination. We present a statistical hypothesis-testing method for quantum program testing, encompassing two paradigms: marginal probability testing and joint distribution testing over the full2d2^{d}2d-dimensional state space. By combining exact and asymptotic tests, bootstrap procedures, sequential designs, and kernel-based two-sample testing, our method provides rigorous error control with substantially improved sample efficiency. Experiments on quantum programs with 2 to 12 qubits show measurement reductions from 97 to 99 percent over the conventional practice of ten thousand shots against strong synthetic faults. A structural mutation study separates the faults that every test detects at one hundred measurements from those that no measurement-based test can detect. The exact marginal test, the exact branch of the sequential design, and the permutation-calibrated joint tests control the Type I error rate at or below the nominal level of 0.05. The adaptive chi-square branch is mildly anticonservative on random states, with a median of 0.060, and conservative on the named benchmarks. On QFT, the sequential design rejects a faulty program with 32 to 85 percent fewer measurements than a properly powered fixed-sample test at two to twelve qubits on its adaptive branch, and with 19 to 60 percent fewer on its exact branch, which is valid under any dependence and reaches the target power from four qubits upward. Power exceeds 0.80 above a characterized fault strength, and faults that preserve the output distribution are shown to be undetectable by any measurement-based test. These results establish a principled and practical foundation for quantum program testing.