Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2601.08290 · Physical Review A

A Preparation Nonstationarity Loophole in Superconducting-Qubit Bell Tests

Prosanta Pal, Shubhanshu Karoliya, Gargee Sharma, Ramakrishna Podila

quant-phcond-mat.mes-hallcond-mat.supr-conSubmitted Jan 13, 2026• Announced Jan 14, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Bell or Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) tests on superconducting quantum processors are commonly interpreted under the assumption that repeated circuit executions sample a single, stationary preparation ensemble. Here we show that this assumption can be violated on contemporary hardware, with direct implications for the interpretation of observed Bell violations. We introduce an ensemble-divergence framework in which slow temporal drift of the preparation process induces context-dependent effective ensembles, even when measurement independence and locality are preserved. This leads to a relaxed Bell bound $|S| \le 2 + 6δ_{\mathrm{ens}}$, where $δ_{\mathrm{ens}}$ quantifies preparation nonstationarity. Because $δ_{\mathrm{ens}}$ is not directly observable, we develop an operational witness $δ_{\mathrm{op}}$ based on bin-resolved outcome statistics for fixed measurement channels. Using Pauli-axis measurements on IBM superconducting processors, we observe statistically significant operational drift that persists after full two-qubit readout mitigation, ruling out measurement artifacts. In contrast, drift extracted from CHSH-optimal measurements is eliminated by mitigation, demonstrating that such settings are unsuitable for diagnosing preparation nonstationarity. We further show that the observed Bell violations imply only modest ensemble divergences, comparable in scale to those required in Hall-type measurement-dependence models, but arising here solely from preparation drift combined with experimental scheduling. Our results identify a preparation-dependent loophole relevant to Bell tests on noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices and highlight the necessity of drift-aware protocols for reliable quantum certification.

Comments
10+pages, 4 figures

Related papers

CHSH Violations Using Dynamic Circuits

Jean-Baptiste Waring, Christophe Père, Sébastien Le Beux

Scalable quantum computing relies on high-quality, long-range entanglement, a challenge on noisy, near-term devices. The need for practical insights for near-term algorithm design calls for trade-offs exploration in implementing dynamic circuits on current hardware. In this work, we experimentally compare three CNOT implementations for generating Bell states across varying qubit separations on a 127 -qubit IBM Quantum Eagle processor (ibm_quebec): a unitary (SWAP-based) approach, a dynamic approach with mid-circuit measurements and classical feedforward, and a post-processed approach. We use Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality violations to quantify entanglement quality. We observe that, beyond 10 qubits, dynamic circuits lead to higher$\vert S \vert$values than the unitary approach, demonstrating improved distance-dependent entanglement preservation. The post-processed approach yields the highest CHSH values, reaching$\vert S \vert >2$up to 13 qubits. Our results underscore the critical need for faster classical feedforward and higher readout fidelity.

arXiv:2504.18429•IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)•Aug 30, 2025•2 citations

Quantum nonlocality, Bell inequalities, and the memory loophole

Jonathan Barrett, Daniel Collins, Lucién Hardy +2 more

In the analysis of experiments designed to reveal violation of Bell-type inequalities, it is usually assumed that any hidden variables associated with the $n\mathrm{th}$ particle pair would be independent of measurement choices and outcomes for the first $(n\ensuremath{-}1)$ pairs. Models which violate this assumption exploit what we call the memory loophole. We focus on the strongest type of violation, which uses the two-sided memory loophole, in which the hidden variables for pair n can depend on the previous measurement choices and outcomes in both wings of the experiment. We show that the two-sided memory loophole allows a systematic violation of the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality when the data are analyzed in the standard way, but cannot produce a violation if a CHSH expression depending linearly on the data is used. In the first case, the maximal CHSH violation becomes small as the number of particle pairs tested becomes large. Hence, although in principle the memory loophole implies a slight flaw in the existing analyses of Bell experiments, the data still strongly confirm quantum mechanics against local hidden variables. We consider also a related loophole, the simultaneous measurement loophole, which applies if all measurements on each side are carried out simultaneously. We show that this can increase the probability of violating the linearized CHSH inequality as well as other Bell-type inequalities.

arXiv:quant-ph/0205016•Physical Review A•Oct 21, 2002•135 citations

Complete Self-Testing of a System of Remote Superconducting Qubits

Simon Storz, Anatoly Kulikov, Josua Schär +6 more

Self-testing protocols enable the certification of quantum systems in a device-independent manner, i.e., without knowledge of the inner workings of the quantum devices under test. Here, we demonstrate this high standard for characterization routines with superconducting circuits, a prime platform for building large-scale quantum computing systems. We first develop the missing theory allowing for the self-testing of Pauli measurements. We then self-test Bell pair generation and measurements at the same time, performing a complete self-test in a system composed of two entangled superconducting circuits operated at a separation of 30 m. In an experiment based on 17 million trials, we measure an average CHSH (Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt) S value of 2.236. Without relying on additional assumptions on the experimental setup, we certify an average Bell state fidelity of at least 58.9% and an average measurement fidelity of at least 89.5% in a device-independent manner, both with 99% confidence. This enables applications in the field of distributed quantum computing and communication with superconducting circuits, such as delegated quantum computing.

arXiv:2408.01299•Physical Review Letters•Jun 12, 2025•18 citations

Hardware-Efficient Error Mitigation and Shot-Efficient Sampling on IBM Quantum Hardware

Sumit Chongder

We experimentally study error mitigation and finite-shot sampling on superconducting quantum hardware under a constrained execution budget. The study combines calibration-aware qubit selection, circuit-depth scaling, zero-noise extrapolation, dynamical decoupling, readout-error mitigation, and repeated-shot estimation on an IBM Quantum processor. Experiments are organized across ideal simulation, noise-model simulation, and physical-device execution to separate sampling uncertainty from device-induced error. We investigate how mitigation performance changes with circuit depth, effective noise scale, qubit connectivity, and measurement budget, and quantify accuracy using expectation-value error, mean-squared error, statistical uncertainty, and mitigation gain. A fixed hardware-execution budget is used to evaluate shot allocation strategies and repeated measurements without relying on unlimited sampling. The resulting analysis provides a hardware-aware characterization of when mitigation improves expectation-value estimation and when finite-shot fluctuations offset the benefit of additional mitigation overhead. The implementation uses contemporary Qiskit and IBM Quantum Runtime workflows and is designed to provide reproducible experimental evidence for error-mitigation studies on current quantum processors.

quant-pharXiv:2608.28535•Aug 31, 2026•0 citations

Temporal Noise Analysis and Filtering for Superconducting Quantum Circuits

Mohammadreza Saghafi

Quantum computing holds the promise of transforming computational paradigms across science and engineering. But realizing potential on near term hardware demands on understanding of the noise processes that corrupt quantum circuit outputs. On superconducting processors, fragile qubits are continuously subjected to environmental disturbances including $T_1$ relaxation, charge noise, and magnetic flux drift that cause measurement statistics to evolve in a nonstationary manner across repeated circuit executions, undermining the reliability of any result aggregated over a long experimental session. In this work, we treat the sequence of bitstring count outcomes from repeated executions of a fixed quantum circuit as a time series and conduct a systematic statistical investigation of its structure. The first contribution is constructing a predictive model of circuit output, demonstrating that future measurement outcomes can be forecast by exploiting temporal correlations in the execution record. We then extend the analysis to two circuits sharing the same physical qubit, examining cross-series dependencies and evaluating whether the drift behavior of one circuit can inform predictions about the other. The temporal structure of the signals is characterized in depth. The other contribution of this dissertation is to perform Wavelet-based multifractal analysis to reveal that quantum circuit outputs exhibit genuine multifractality. This is a hallmark of long range correlated, scale free processes rather than the simple Gaussian white noise assumed by standard error models. Complementary frequency-domain analysis identifies a residual $1/f$ noise component that persists after linear detrending, consistent with charge and flux noise mechanisms well documented in superconducting qubit literature. Motivated by these findings, The other contribution is to design and evaluate a suite of drift-mitigation filters including piecewise Huber regression, rolling median, smoothing spline, and Savitzky–Golay approaches under a rigorous chronological train/test protocol that mimics real operational deployment. The smoothing spline and median filter achieve near-zero corrected bias, while the rolling median emerges as the preferred solution for online, shot-by-shot correction due to its causal update structure and maximal robustness to impulsive hardware events. Taken together, our results characterize quantum circuit outputs as non-stationary, multifractal processes exhibiting long memory, seasonality, and inter-circuit causality, and establish a principled filtering framework for mitigating temporal bias drift in NISQ era quantum hardware.

•Jun 10, 2026•0 citations

Practical Guide to Using a Quantum Computer (Based on Materials from the International Quantum Center at CERN, Switzerland) # 4

Mikhail Pavlov

Abstract This laboratory work presents a practical implementation of the CHSH game using the Qiskit framework and IBM quantum hardware. The material is based on educational resources developed by the International Quantum Center at CERN (Switzerland) and aims to provide an experimental demonstration of quantum nonlocality and Bell inequality violation. In Laboratory Work No. 4, participants implement a simplified version of the Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt (CHSH) game to test whether IBM quantum processors exhibit genuinely quantum behavior. The CHSH game is a fundamental protocol in quantum information theory that distinguishes classical correlations from quantum correlations through statistical violation of Bell inequalities. Using Qiskit, a two-qubit entangled state is prepared and measurement settings corresponding to different basis choices are applied. By executing the circuit multiple times on a simulator and real quantum hardware, participants collect measurement statistics and compute the CHSH correlation parameter. If the experimentally obtained value exceeds the classical bound, the results provide empirical evidence of quantum entanglement and nonlocal correlations. This laboratory exercise demonstrates how foundational concepts of quantum mechanics—entanglement, superposition, and measurement basis dependence—can be directly tested using cloud-accessible quantum processors. The experiment not only reinforces theoretical understanding of Bell inequalities but also introduces practical skills in circuit construction, parameterized measurements, statistical analysis, and noise considerations in real quantum devices.

•Mar 3, 2026•0 citations
Bell or Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) tests on superconducting quantum processors are commonly interpreted under the assumption that repeated circuit executions sample a single, stationary preparation ensemble. Here we show that this assumption can be violated on contemporary hardware, with direct implications for the interpretation of observed Bell violations. We introduce an ensemble-divergence framework in which slow temporal drift of the preparation process induces context-dependent effective ensembles, even when measurement independence and locality are preserved. This leads to a relaxed Bell bound ∣S∣≤2+6δens|S| \le 2 + 6δ_{\mathrm{ens}}∣S∣≤2+6δens​, where δensδ_{\mathrm{ens}}δens​ quantifies preparation nonstationarity. Because δensδ_{\mathrm{ens}}δens​ is not directly observable, we develop an operational witness δopδ_{\mathrm{op}}δop​ based on bin-resolved outcome statistics for fixed measurement channels. Using Pauli-axis measurements on IBM superconducting processors, we observe statistically significant operational drift that persists after full two-qubit readout mitigation, ruling out measurement artifacts. In contrast, drift extracted from CHSH-optimal measurements is eliminated by mitigation, demonstrating that such settings are unsuitable for diagnosing preparation nonstationarity. We further show that the observed Bell violations imply only modest ensemble divergences, comparable in scale to those required in Hall-type measurement-dependence models, but arising here solely from preparation drift combined with experimental scheduling. Our results identify a preparation-dependent loophole relevant to Bell tests on noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices and highlight the necessity of drift-aware protocols for reliable quantum certification.
Scalable quantum computing relies on high-quality, long-range entanglement, a challenge on noisy, near-term devices. The need for practical insights for near-term algorithm design calls for trade-offs exploration in implementing dynamic circuits on current hardware. In this work, we experimentally compare three CNOT implementations for generating Bell states across varying qubit separations on a 127 -qubit IBM Quantum Eagle processor (ibm_quebec): a unitary (SWAP-based) approach, a dynamic approach with mid-circuit measurements and classical feedforward, and a post-processed approach. We use Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality violations to quantify entanglement quality. We observe that, beyond 10 qubits, dynamic circuits lead to higher∣S∣\vert S \vert∣S∣values than the unitary approach, demonstrating improved distance-dependent entanglement preservation. The post-processed approach yields the highest CHSH values, reaching∣S∣>2\vert S \vert >2∣S∣>2up to 13 qubits. Our results underscore the critical need for faster classical feedforward and higher readout fidelity.
In the analysis of experiments designed to reveal violation of Bell-type inequalities, it is usually assumed that any hidden variables associated with the nthn\mathrm{th}nth particle pair would be independent of measurement choices and outcomes for the first $(n\ensuremath{-}1)$ pairs. Models which violate this assumption exploit what we call the memory loophole. We focus on the strongest type of violation, which uses the two-sided memory loophole, in which the hidden variables for pair n can depend on the previous measurement choices and outcomes in both wings of the experiment. We show that the two-sided memory loophole allows a systematic violation of the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality when the data are analyzed in the standard way, but cannot produce a violation if a CHSH expression depending linearly on the data is used. In the first case, the maximal CHSH violation becomes small as the number of particle pairs tested becomes large. Hence, although in principle the memory loophole implies a slight flaw in the existing analyses of Bell experiments, the data still strongly confirm quantum mechanics against local hidden variables. We consider also a related loophole, the simultaneous measurement loophole, which applies if all measurements on each side are carried out simultaneously. We show that this can increase the probability of violating the linearized CHSH inequality as well as other Bell-type inequalities.
Self-testing protocols enable the certification of quantum systems in a device-independent manner, i.e., without knowledge of the inner workings of the quantum devices under test. Here, we demonstrate this high standard for characterization routines with superconducting circuits, a prime platform for building large-scale quantum computing systems. We first develop the missing theory allowing for the self-testing of Pauli measurements. We then self-test Bell pair generation and measurements at the same time, performing a complete self-test in a system composed of two entangled superconducting circuits operated at a separation of 30 m. In an experiment based on 17 million trials, we measure an average CHSH (Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt) S value of 2.236. Without relying on additional assumptions on the experimental setup, we certify an average Bell state fidelity of at least 58.9% and an average measurement fidelity of at least 89.5% in a device-independent manner, both with 99% confidence. This enables applications in the field of distributed quantum computing and communication with superconducting circuits, such as delegated quantum computing.
We experimentally study error mitigation and finite-shot sampling on superconducting quantum hardware under a constrained execution budget. The study combines calibration-aware qubit selection, circuit-depth scaling, zero-noise extrapolation, dynamical decoupling, readout-error mitigation, and repeated-shot estimation on an IBM Quantum processor. Experiments are organized across ideal simulation, noise-model simulation, and physical-device execution to separate sampling uncertainty from device-induced error. We investigate how mitigation performance changes with circuit depth, effective noise scale, qubit connectivity, and measurement budget, and quantify accuracy using expectation-value error, mean-squared error, statistical uncertainty, and mitigation gain. A fixed hardware-execution budget is used to evaluate shot allocation strategies and repeated measurements without relying on unlimited sampling. The resulting analysis provides a hardware-aware characterization of when mitigation improves expectation-value estimation and when finite-shot fluctuations offset the benefit of additional mitigation overhead. The implementation uses contemporary Qiskit and IBM Quantum Runtime workflows and is designed to provide reproducible experimental evidence for error-mitigation studies on current quantum processors.
Quantum computing holds the promise of transforming computational paradigms across science and engineering. But realizing potential on near term hardware demands on understanding of the noise processes that corrupt quantum circuit outputs. On superconducting processors, fragile qubits are continuously subjected to environmental disturbances including T1T_1T1​ relaxation, charge noise, and magnetic flux drift that cause measurement statistics to evolve in a nonstationary manner across repeated circuit executions, undermining the reliability of any result aggregated over a long experimental session. In this work, we treat the sequence of bitstring count outcomes from repeated executions of a fixed quantum circuit as a time series and conduct a systematic statistical investigation of its structure. The first contribution is constructing a predictive model of circuit output, demonstrating that future measurement outcomes can be forecast by exploiting temporal correlations in the execution record. We then extend the analysis to two circuits sharing the same physical qubit, examining cross-series dependencies and evaluating whether the drift behavior of one circuit can inform predictions about the other. The temporal structure of the signals is characterized in depth. The other contribution of this dissertation is to perform Wavelet-based multifractal analysis to reveal that quantum circuit outputs exhibit genuine multifractality. This is a hallmark of long range correlated, scale free processes rather than the simple Gaussian white noise assumed by standard error models. Complementary frequency-domain analysis identifies a residual 1/f1/f1/f noise component that persists after linear detrending, consistent with charge and flux noise mechanisms well documented in superconducting qubit literature. Motivated by these findings, The other contribution is to design and evaluate a suite of drift-mitigation filters including piecewise Huber regression, rolling median, smoothing spline, and Savitzky–Golay approaches under a rigorous chronological train/test protocol that mimics real operational deployment. The smoothing spline and median filter achieve near-zero corrected bias, while the rolling median emerges as the preferred solution for online, shot-by-shot correction due to its causal update structure and maximal robustness to impulsive hardware events. Taken together, our results characterize quantum circuit outputs as non-stationary, multifractal processes exhibiting long memory, seasonality, and inter-circuit causality, and establish a principled filtering framework for mitigating temporal bias drift in NISQ era quantum hardware.
Abstract This laboratory work presents a practical implementation of the CHSH game using the Qiskit framework and IBM quantum hardware. The material is based on educational resources developed by the International Quantum Center at CERN (Switzerland) and aims to provide an experimental demonstration of quantum nonlocality and Bell inequality violation. In Laboratory Work No. 4, participants implement a simplified version of the Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt (CHSH) game to test whether IBM quantum processors exhibit genuinely quantum behavior. The CHSH game is a fundamental protocol in quantum information theory that distinguishes classical correlations from quantum correlations through statistical violation of Bell inequalities. Using Qiskit, a two-qubit entangled state is prepared and measurement settings corresponding to different basis choices are applied. By executing the circuit multiple times on a simulator and real quantum hardware, participants collect measurement statistics and compute the CHSH correlation parameter. If the experimentally obtained value exceeds the classical bound, the results provide empirical evidence of quantum entanglement and nonlocal correlations. This laboratory exercise demonstrates how foundational concepts of quantum mechanics—entanglement, superposition, and measurement basis dependence—can be directly tested using cloud-accessible quantum processors. The experiment not only reinforces theoretical understanding of Bell inequalities but also introduces practical skills in circuit construction, parameterized measurements, statistical analysis, and noise considerations in real quantum devices.