Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2606.13504

A thermodynamic analysis of nonsecular master equations, beyond strict energy conservation and Gibbs equilibrium state

Mohamed Boubakour, Talia Szikman, Cyril Elouard

quant-phcond-mat.stat-mechSubmitted Jun 11, 2026• Announced Jun 12, 2026• 1 citation• Revised Oct 13, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Jun 11, 2026v2 · Oct 13, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We present a systematic thermodynamic analysis of nonsecular GKLS master equations. When some energy transitions in the system are comparable with the dissipative rate, the secular approximation is not valid, and the positivity of the dynamics must be ensured via other approximations. The dynamics then presents features reminiscent from strong coupling to the environment: e.g. the equilibrium state with an environment at thermal equilibrium is not a Gibbs state of the local system Hamiltonian and the dynamics couples energy coherences and populations. Nonetheless, we build a unified, consistent thermodynamic framework for those dynamics. We focus on two approximations beyond the full secular approximation (the local and the more accurate geometric-arithmetic approximations), and then employ systematic perturbation theory on microscopic expressions for the first and second law of thermodynamics which relate irreversibility to the increase of system-environment correlations. We show that, in spite of the weak system-bath coupling, the system-bath interaction energy participates to the energy balance, and is directly linked to the Lamb-shift Hamiltonian. We compare this microscopic entropy production with the definition based on the contractivity of the reduced system dynamics (Spohn inequality). We show that, unlike for secular master equations, the two entropy production rates differ because of the presence of non-vanishing stationary coherences in the energy eigenbasis. However, in the case of a single thermal bath, the difference is purely transient, and no work can be cyclically extracted from the steady-state despite its non-Gibbs form. Finally, we illustrate our results with simple examples, clarifying and completing the thermodynamic picture of Markovian dynamics in the quantum regime.

Comments
18 pages for main text, 9 pages for the appendix and 4 figures

Related papers

Open system dynamics from thermodynamic compatibility

Roie Dann, Ronnie Kosloff

Thermodynamics entails a set of mathematical conditions on quantum Markovian dynamics.In particular, strict energy conservation between the system and environment implies that the dissipative dynamical map commutes with the map of the system's unitary evolution.Employing spectral analysis, we prove the general form of the ensuing master equation.The obtained structure extends thermodynamical considerations to dynamical processes.Comparing this form with master equations obtained from microscopic derivations allows validating their compatibility with thermodynamics.It predicts that coherence is not generated spontaneously under steady-state transport.Moreover, for a bipartite system-environment it singles out the global master equation as the thermodynamically compatible choice for nondriven systems, as well as supplying insight into the validity of the secular approximation.

arXiv:2011.03504•Physical Review Research•Apr 1, 2021•35 citations

Entropy production and non-Markovian dynamical maps

Stefano Marcantoni, S. Alipour, F. Benatti +2 more

In the weak-coupling limit approach to open quantum systems, the presence of the bath is eliminated and accounted for by a master equation that introduces dissipative contributions to the system reduced dynamics: within this framework, there are no bath entropy contributions to the entropy balance. We show that, as a consequence, the entropy production fails to be positive for a class of physically legitimate, that is completely positive and trace preserving, non-Markovian dynamical maps. Moreover, in absence of the semigroup property, if the reduced dynamics has a thermal asymptotic state, this need not be stationary. Then even the integrated entropy production becomes negative. These observations imply that, when the conditions leading to reduced dynamics of semigroup type are relaxed, a consistent formulation of the second law of thermodynamics requires that the environment contribution to the entropy balance be explicitly taken into account.

arXiv:1709.02174•Scientific Reports•Sep 25, 2017•59 citations

Dissipation in Periodically Driven Quantum Systems: Partial Secularization and Thermodynamic Consistency

Luísa T. Tude, Carlos Ortega-Taberner, Roberta Zambrini +1 more

Periodically driven open quantum systems are central to quantum thermodynamics and quantum control. These systems are typically described using Floquet-Born-Markov master equations, derived with the use of a full secular approximation, and whose thermodynamic implications are often overlooked. In this context, we show that such a strong secular approximation may lead to unphysical predictions for steady state energy currents. We then demonstrate that a coarse-grained formulation of the master equation can regularize these issues while yielding completely positive dynamics and consistent energy currents. The coarse-graining time has a clear physical interpretation, as it defines the temporal resolution at which a Markovian master equation can describe the evolution of the periodically driven system. We show the consistency and validity of our approach by comparing to an exact non-Markovian simulation in paradigmatic examples: a driven two-level system and a three-level maser coupled to hot and cold thermal reservoirs. Our work provides a practical framework for correctly applying the secular approximation in periodically driven-dissipative systems and for assessing the accuracy of master equations of the GKSL form.

quant-pharXiv:2608.00225•Aug 4, 2026•1 citation

Thermodynamic consistency of quantum master equations

Ariane Soret, Vasco Cavina, Massimiliano Esposito

Starting from a microscopic system-baths description, we derive the general conditions for a time-local quantum master equation (QME) to satisfy the first and second laws of thermodynamics at the fluctuating level. Using counting statistics, we show that the fluctuating second law can be rephrased as a generalized quantum detailed balance condition (GQDB), i.e., a symmetry of the time-local generators which ensures the validity of the fluctuation theorem. When requiring in addition a strict system-bath energy conservation, the GQDB reduces to the usual notion of detailed balance which characterizes QMEs with Gibbsian steady states. However, if energy conservation is only required on average, QMEs with non-Gibbsian steady states can still maintain a certain level of thermodynamic consistency. Applying our theory to commonly used QMEs, we show that the Redfield equation breaks the GQDB, and that some recently derived approximation schemes based on the Redfield equation (which hold beyond the secular approximation and allow one to derive a QME of Lindblad form) satisfy the GQDB and the average first law. We find that performing the secular approximation is the only way to ensure the first and second laws at the fluctuating level.

arXiv:2207.05719•Physical Review A•Dec 15, 2022•49 citations

Thermodynamics Beyond Equilibrium in Coherent Quantum Systems

Md Manirul Ali, Po-Wen Chen

A central open question in quantum thermodynamics is the identification of thermodynamic entropy away from equilibrium. Although thermodynamic entropy coincides with the von Neumann entropy for a Gibbs state at equilibrium, the thermodynamic role of quantum coherence generated during nonequilibrium evolution remains unclear. Here, we show that von Neumann entropy does not, in general, represent the thermodynamic entropy governing heat exchange in coherent nonequilibrium quantum systems. By integrating the resource theory of quantum coherence with thermodynamic principles, we develop a general framework for nonequilibrium quantum thermodynamics. We identify thermodynamic entropy with the energy entropy derived from energy-measurement statistics and introduce a dynamical temperature extending the equilibrium concept to nonequilibrium states. Consequently, we obtain an exact entropy-balance relation separating the entropy flux associated with heat exchange from the coherence-loss contribution to entropy production, establishing an operational connection between quantum coherence, heat flow, and total entropy change. Unlike approaches relying on equilibrium reference states or stationary Gibbs ensembles, our framework uses instantaneous dynamical quantities and remains valid throughout transient nonequilibrium evolution. It provides consistent dynamical definitions of temperature, work, heat, and free energy. Applying the formalism to an exactly solvable open quantum system, we show that the first and second laws hold throughout transient evolution and that equilibrium thermodynamics emerges dynamically in the weak-coupling long-time limit. Our results establish a unified framework for coherent nonequilibrium quantum thermodynamics and suggest opportunities for controlling heat dissipation through coherence engineering in quantum thermal technologies.

quant-pharXiv:2602.09074•APL Quantum•Feb 10, 2026•0 citations

On the non-equilibrium thermodynamics of quantum systems

Stefano Marcantoni

A consistent theory of non-equilibrium thermodynamics for Markovian open quantum systems has been developed in the late seventies in analogy with Classical Irreversible Thermodynamics. The time-evolution of these open systems is usually described by means of effective master equations in Lindblad form, that turn out to be reliable when there is a separation of time-scales between system and environment, such that memory effects are negligible and the so-called Markovian approximation is justified. In this framework, the variations of energy and entropy in the system are consistently described, distinguishing between heat and work contributions and providing a statement of the second law of thermodynamics as positivity of the entropy production.\nHowever, there is empirical evidence that many physical systems like photosynthetic complexes,\nopto-mechanical resonators and superconducting qubits, just to mention a few, experience more general non-Markovian dynamics. The formulation of the laws of thermodynamics in a non-Markovian setting is matter of current research and represents the main topic of the present work. As a first step, we show that the entropy production defined as in the Markovian case can be negative for a class of non-Markovian dynamics. We argue that this outcome should not be interpreted as a violation of the second law of thermodynamics because the environment must be explicitly taken into account in the balance of entropy in the non-Markovian setting. In order to justify this claim we adopt a more general point of view, studying a closed bipartite quantum system, such that each of the two subsystems plays the role of a finite environment out of equilibrium for the other one. We concentrate on the balance of energy first and construct an effective Hamiltonian for each subsystem using physically reasonable requirements; then we define heat and work as in the standard Markovian treatment, with the effective Hamiltonian replacing the free Hamiltonian. It turns out that, in our framework, the work power is perfectly balanced between subsystems, while the correlations can store a part of energy locally inaccessible and exchange it with both subsystems in the form of heat.\nConcerning the balance of entropy, a quite general formulation of the second law of thermodynamics can be given as follows: under the assumption of a factorized initial state for the compound system, the sum of the total variations of the entropies in the two subsystems is always nonnegative. We show with an explicit example that this general formulation does not correspond to the statement presented in the framework of Markovian master equations, which should not be considered a priori the second law of thermodynamics.\nIn the last part of the thesis we concentrate of the so-called fluctuation relations, that are results extending the thermodynamic formalism beyond the behavior of average quantities. After reviewing the main theoretical outcomes, such as the Jarzynski equality and the Crooks fluctuation theorem, we describe a proposal to access experimentally the work performed on an ensemble of diatomic molecules by a time-dependent electric field coupled with their vibrational degree of freedom. This procedure could then be used to test the quantum Jarzynski equality. With respect to the results so far appeared in the literature, in which the left-hand side of the equality is inferred from an experiment and the right-hand side is computed according to a model, in our proposed setting we should be able to estimate from the experiment both the left-hand side and the right-hand side of the equality, independently.

•Feb 6, 2018•1 citation
We present a systematic thermodynamic analysis of nonsecular GKLS master equations. When some energy transitions in the system are comparable with the dissipative rate, the secular approximation is not valid, and the positivity of the dynamics must be ensured via other approximations. The dynamics then presents features reminiscent from strong coupling to the environment: e.g. the equilibrium state with an environment at thermal equilibrium is not a Gibbs state of the local system Hamiltonian and the dynamics couples energy coherences and populations. Nonetheless, we build a unified, consistent thermodynamic framework for those dynamics. We focus on two approximations beyond the full secular approximation (the local and the more accurate geometric-arithmetic approximations), and then employ systematic perturbation theory on microscopic expressions for the first and second law of thermodynamics which relate irreversibility to the increase of system-environment correlations. We show that, in spite of the weak system-bath coupling, the system-bath interaction energy participates to the energy balance, and is directly linked to the Lamb-shift Hamiltonian. We compare this microscopic entropy production with the definition based on the contractivity of the reduced system dynamics (Spohn inequality). We show that, unlike for secular master equations, the two entropy production rates differ because of the presence of non-vanishing stationary coherences in the energy eigenbasis. However, in the case of a single thermal bath, the difference is purely transient, and no work can be cyclically extracted from the steady-state despite its non-Gibbs form. Finally, we illustrate our results with simple examples, clarifying and completing the thermodynamic picture of Markovian dynamics in the quantum regime.
Thermodynamics entails a set of mathematical conditions on quantum Markovian dynamics.In particular, strict energy conservation between the system and environment implies that the dissipative dynamical map commutes with the map of the system's unitary evolution.Employing spectral analysis, we prove the general form of the ensuing master equation.The obtained structure extends thermodynamical considerations to dynamical processes.Comparing this form with master equations obtained from microscopic derivations allows validating their compatibility with thermodynamics.It predicts that coherence is not generated spontaneously under steady-state transport.Moreover, for a bipartite system-environment it singles out the global master equation as the thermodynamically compatible choice for nondriven systems, as well as supplying insight into the validity of the secular approximation.
In the weak-coupling limit approach to open quantum systems, the presence of the bath is eliminated and accounted for by a master equation that introduces dissipative contributions to the system reduced dynamics: within this framework, there are no bath entropy contributions to the entropy balance. We show that, as a consequence, the entropy production fails to be positive for a class of physically legitimate, that is completely positive and trace preserving, non-Markovian dynamical maps. Moreover, in absence of the semigroup property, if the reduced dynamics has a thermal asymptotic state, this need not be stationary. Then even the integrated entropy production becomes negative. These observations imply that, when the conditions leading to reduced dynamics of semigroup type are relaxed, a consistent formulation of the second law of thermodynamics requires that the environment contribution to the entropy balance be explicitly taken into account.
Periodically driven open quantum systems are central to quantum thermodynamics and quantum control. These systems are typically described using Floquet-Born-Markov master equations, derived with the use of a full secular approximation, and whose thermodynamic implications are often overlooked. In this context, we show that such a strong secular approximation may lead to unphysical predictions for steady state energy currents. We then demonstrate that a coarse-grained formulation of the master equation can regularize these issues while yielding completely positive dynamics and consistent energy currents. The coarse-graining time has a clear physical interpretation, as it defines the temporal resolution at which a Markovian master equation can describe the evolution of the periodically driven system. We show the consistency and validity of our approach by comparing to an exact non-Markovian simulation in paradigmatic examples: a driven two-level system and a three-level maser coupled to hot and cold thermal reservoirs. Our work provides a practical framework for correctly applying the secular approximation in periodically driven-dissipative systems and for assessing the accuracy of master equations of the GKSL form.
Starting from a microscopic system-baths description, we derive the general conditions for a time-local quantum master equation (QME) to satisfy the first and second laws of thermodynamics at the fluctuating level. Using counting statistics, we show that the fluctuating second law can be rephrased as a generalized quantum detailed balance condition (GQDB), i.e., a symmetry of the time-local generators which ensures the validity of the fluctuation theorem. When requiring in addition a strict system-bath energy conservation, the GQDB reduces to the usual notion of detailed balance which characterizes QMEs with Gibbsian steady states. However, if energy conservation is only required on average, QMEs with non-Gibbsian steady states can still maintain a certain level of thermodynamic consistency. Applying our theory to commonly used QMEs, we show that the Redfield equation breaks the GQDB, and that some recently derived approximation schemes based on the Redfield equation (which hold beyond the secular approximation and allow one to derive a QME of Lindblad form) satisfy the GQDB and the average first law. We find that performing the secular approximation is the only way to ensure the first and second laws at the fluctuating level.
A central open question in quantum thermodynamics is the identification of thermodynamic entropy away from equilibrium. Although thermodynamic entropy coincides with the von Neumann entropy for a Gibbs state at equilibrium, the thermodynamic role of quantum coherence generated during nonequilibrium evolution remains unclear. Here, we show that von Neumann entropy does not, in general, represent the thermodynamic entropy governing heat exchange in coherent nonequilibrium quantum systems. By integrating the resource theory of quantum coherence with thermodynamic principles, we develop a general framework for nonequilibrium quantum thermodynamics. We identify thermodynamic entropy with the energy entropy derived from energy-measurement statistics and introduce a dynamical temperature extending the equilibrium concept to nonequilibrium states. Consequently, we obtain an exact entropy-balance relation separating the entropy flux associated with heat exchange from the coherence-loss contribution to entropy production, establishing an operational connection between quantum coherence, heat flow, and total entropy change. Unlike approaches relying on equilibrium reference states or stationary Gibbs ensembles, our framework uses instantaneous dynamical quantities and remains valid throughout transient nonequilibrium evolution. It provides consistent dynamical definitions of temperature, work, heat, and free energy. Applying the formalism to an exactly solvable open quantum system, we show that the first and second laws hold throughout transient evolution and that equilibrium thermodynamics emerges dynamically in the weak-coupling long-time limit. Our results establish a unified framework for coherent nonequilibrium quantum thermodynamics and suggest opportunities for controlling heat dissipation through coherence engineering in quantum thermal technologies.
A consistent theory of non-equilibrium thermodynamics for Markovian open quantum systems has been developed in the late seventies in analogy with Classical Irreversible Thermodynamics. The time-evolution of these open systems is usually described by means of effective master equations in Lindblad form, that turn out to be reliable when there is a separation of time-scales between system and environment, such that memory effects are negligible and the so-called Markovian approximation is justified. In this framework, the variations of energy and entropy in the system are consistently described, distinguishing between heat and work contributions and providing a statement of the second law of thermodynamics as positivity of the entropy production.\nHowever, there is empirical evidence that many physical systems like photosynthetic complexes,\nopto-mechanical resonators and superconducting qubits, just to mention a few, experience more general non-Markovian dynamics. The formulation of the laws of thermodynamics in a non-Markovian setting is matter of current research and represents the main topic of the present work. As a first step, we show that the entropy production defined as in the Markovian case can be negative for a class of non-Markovian dynamics. We argue that this outcome should not be interpreted as a violation of the second law of thermodynamics because the environment must be explicitly taken into account in the balance of entropy in the non-Markovian setting. In order to justify this claim we adopt a more general point of view, studying a closed bipartite quantum system, such that each of the two subsystems plays the role of a finite environment out of equilibrium for the other one. We concentrate on the balance of energy first and construct an effective Hamiltonian for each subsystem using physically reasonable requirements; then we define heat and work as in the standard Markovian treatment, with the effective Hamiltonian replacing the free Hamiltonian. It turns out that, in our framework, the work power is perfectly balanced between subsystems, while the correlations can store a part of energy locally inaccessible and exchange it with both subsystems in the form of heat.\nConcerning the balance of entropy, a quite general formulation of the second law of thermodynamics can be given as follows: under the assumption of a factorized initial state for the compound system, the sum of the total variations of the entropies in the two subsystems is always nonnegative. We show with an explicit example that this general formulation does not correspond to the statement presented in the framework of Markovian master equations, which should not be considered a priori the second law of thermodynamics.\nIn the last part of the thesis we concentrate of the so-called fluctuation relations, that are results extending the thermodynamic formalism beyond the behavior of average quantities. After reviewing the main theoretical outcomes, such as the Jarzynski equality and the Crooks fluctuation theorem, we describe a proposal to access experimentally the work performed on an ensemble of diatomic molecules by a time-dependent electric field coupled with their vibrational degree of freedom. This procedure could then be used to test the quantum Jarzynski equality. With respect to the results so far appeared in the literature, in which the left-hand side of the equality is inferred from an experiment and the right-hand side is computed according to a model, in our proposed setting we should be able to estimate from the experiment both the left-hand side and the right-hand side of the equality, independently.